HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ur-whale

5,464 karma · joined January 11, 2018

submissionscomments
ur-whale··on Music Theory for Programmers
> It's as if a physics student tries to derive medicine "from first principles" by starting at atoms and thinking hard. It doesn't work and won't fix your appendix.

An entire civilization (China) completely missed having a proper scientific awakening and the following industrial revolution about a 1000 year ago exactly because of that kind of dumb thinking.

Great idea!

ur-whale··on Music Theory for Programmers
> I don't think you can get good at an instrument or enjoy music if you keep trying to force it to make logical sense in your brain all the time.

I wholeheartedly agree with this.

But then, please, don't call it "theory".

There is strictly nothing theoretical or indeed, logical, about it.

ur-whale··on Music Theory for Programmers
> Which is a strange way to teach a system that essentially comes out of physics and arithmetic

Oh boy, couldn't agree more, this has been a lifelong frustration for me as well:

I've always been completely stumped by the utter lack of curiosity most musicians seem to have about that.

There's a convention, just learn it, why IHN would you want to ask questions about this?

Who cares about things like first principles anyways.

ur-whale··on What is Nueralese and Why is it Bad
What exactly prevents anyone worried about this to build an LLM that can decode the neuralese to english and use it to monitor what the model is doing?

Or is the neuralese some sort of irreversibly encrypted data set that only an LLM can "understand" and that can never be translated back to English?

ur-whale··on Iceland rejects reopening talks on EU entry
> The EU is tremendously effective

It certainly is, but unfortunately not at very many actually positive things.

When it comes to wasting money and being completely ham-fisted with regulation though, I agree with you 100%

ur-whale··on Iceland rejects reopening talks on EU entry
> Iceland rejects reopening talks on EU entry

Good for them.

Joining the EU, given the very sorry state that institution is currently in would basically be a pair of concrete shoes at the bottom of the river for Iceland.

ur-whale··on Decompiling a Nintendo 64 game in 84 days
Fantastic work, but my gut reaction: Why?

Why snowboard kids and not the ocarina of time ????

ur-whale··on Xiaomi: New CPU matches Apple cores single threaded, much faster multithreaded
2020's US geopolitical doctrine:

1) Pick a historically extremely innovative and disciplined culture which also happens to have massive human capital

2) Please arbitrary artificial ill-thought-out economic constraints on them

3) wait a while

4) get a bunch of magnificent spanking in return (AI, chips, etc...)

ur-whale··on Finger: the 1971 social network that never died
finger is the best-named utility of the Unix world.
ur-whale··on A digestion of the proof of Sendov's conjecture
Your definition of "elementary" is the one used by the other 100.0 - 99.999 %

Thank you for making my point for me.

Ivory tower much?

ur-whale··on A digestion of the proof of Sendov's conjecture
> LLMs don't understand things as human mathematicians do

You say it like it's a bad thing!

ur-whale··on A digestion of the proof of Sendov's conjecture
"The proof ends up being remarkably elementary."

Dude then proceeds to dump about 16 A4 pages worth of heavy-duty algebra which 99.999% of the humans on the surface of this planet are completely unable to read past the first two lines.

LOL, I guess language is a "remarkably" vague tool, where "elementary" means vastly different things to different people.

That doesn't diminish the achievement of course, but ... please, easy on the "remarkably elementary" next time, that's borderline insulting.

ur-whale··on The Lonely Men Who Work in Patagonia, at the End of the World
https://archive.ph/XDM2H
ur-whale··on Design 3D-printable parts by talking
> runs on your computer

Only if you have a cupertino-made toaster that is.

ur-whale··on RISC-V: They Should Have Known Better
Here's an interesting ChatGPT conversation posted in the comments of the article:

https://chatgpt.com/share/6a81dbb7-1934-83ea-8a47-6d1d1b4c0f...

ur-whale··on Yadda 3.0.0: BDD in the Age of AI Agents
> I’ll take that bet, since we ask about it in our interview questions.

You evaluate candidates based on their intimate knowledge of acronyms?

LOL.

Pray tell where you work so we all collectively never apply for a job there.

ur-whale··on Yadda 3.0.0: BDD in the Age of AI Agents
One suggestion: my bet is that close to no one knows what the acronym BDD stands for. The first comment on this post is in fact exactly about that.

I'd consider explaining what BBD is at the start of the front page of your project.

ur-whale··on Gemini 3.7 Flash
Why does Google keep announcing these subpar models?

What am I missing?

They can't seem to be able to produce a frontier model, fine.

Just be quiet about it and work hard until you manage to put one together.

[EDIT]: Come to think of it. Maybe they're trying to build the Toyota corolla of AI ... let's see if that wins them the battle long term. I personally doubt it.

ur-whale··on Gemini 3.7 Flash
> Can you help me understand how it is hard to get an API key from Google?

Using Google products in general is an effing nightmare as soon as you have to give them money.

The one thing you want in a business is to remove friction when people want to give you money, a concept Google has never been able to understand.

ur-whale··on llama.cpp
> Anything that suggests curl into bash just plain sketches me out.

Yeah, 100% and it's becoming more and more of a thing, see rust install for example.

OTOH, if you're installing llama.cpp, you're more than likely planning to run an LLM on your Linux box with an agentic harness, so a curl into bash thing might be the least of your security concerns, :-)

ur-whale··on Project Lana attempts to formalize hard to understand Mochizuki's IUT in Lean
An attempt at formalizing in Lean Mochizuki's ITU and put an end to the controversy produced by a 500 pages "proof" that no one can actually understands.

Additional information:

https://github.com/katobungen/LANA_report_202607

Mochizuki himself has also started a "skeleton" formalization attempt of his theory:

https://aitpm.github.io/slides/Mochizuki.pdf?utm_source=chat...

Surprisingly enough, no one seem to have tried to use LLM's to do the work (or parts of it).

ur-whale··on AMD acquires Taalas to boost inference performance by etching models in silicon
Yeah, so https://chatjimmy.ai/ ... the model is crap, but the speed is amazing. Worth checking out.
ur-whale··on Changes at Google DeepMind: Demis Hassabis from CEO to Chair, Jeff Dean departs
> Google loves to kick senior execs upstairs.

The Japanese corporate culture has a name for this: Madogiwa-Zoku (窓際族) or “The tribe by the window”.

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fenstergucker_(Japan)

ur-whale··on Changes at Google DeepMind: Demis Hassabis from CEO to Chair, Jeff Dean departs
> It would be stock price suicide if anything even remotely happened with Google.

aka they're dead in the water.

ur-whale··on Exact, parallel 2D Delaunay triangulation for int32 coordinates
> Neat, now do a 3D Delaunay tetrahedrization! :)

I do see the smiley, but still: show a litle more appreciation man, this is really impressive work and deserves more than a "great, can you do it on one leg now?" comment.

ur-whale··on Exact, parallel 2D Delaunay triangulation for int32 coordinates
Impressive work.

@author : I'm trying to wrap my head around the following question: are there any situations where the "int32 constraint" would be an issue?

My gut feeling says that fine a grid (4B steps) is likely to generate a good enough approximation to the exact answer for general problem (64 bit float) for most cases.

Am I wrong?

Also: can the algorithm easily be extended to int64 ?

ur-whale··on Changes at Google DeepMind: Demis Hassabis from CEO to Chair, Jeff Dean departs
Here's my bet: Demis will be gone within 6 months. A year at most.
ur-whale··on Ten advances in mathematics and theoretical computer science
> I think it might be like waveform collapse, but very high dimensional.

The waveform collapse is natively "very high dimensional", not sure why the "but" part of the sentence belongs here.

ur-whale··on Kuna: Decompiler Development in the Age of Coding Agents
> LLMs are famously inefficient, expensive and unreliable.

Maybe, but here I am suggesting an LLM specifically trained to do only machine code to high-level code reverse engineering.

I suspect this can be made both efficient and very reliable.

Especially given the fact that there is very often a path the verify if what the LLM produces is a valid answer (by testing if the high level code produced by the LLM, when compiled, behaves like the original machine code).

ur-whale··on Kuna: Decompiler Development in the Age of Coding Agents
> There is no point to have an LLM do what can be done faster and deterministically by standard algorithms

I think using the word "deterministically" in the context of decompilation is not a particularly good idea.

The code generated by a compiler can be arbitrarily complex and arbitrarily varied even before you take into account willful attempts at obfuscation to protect against reverse-engineering (for example, try futzing with compiler optimization flags to see how much the ASM changes).

The "high-level code to assembly" operator is thus not even really a function (same high level code can generate infinite variation of functionally equivalent assembly code) and any attempt at producing an inverse of this operator ... this really does not strike me as an environment where the word "deterministic" seems appropriate.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →