HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

v7p1Qbt1im

375 karma · joined July 27, 2018

submissionscomments
v7p1Qbt1im··on Google just deleted my nearly 10-year-old free and open-source Android app
I don’t know. Take YouTube. For all its faults, it has enabled countless people to make a living, or helped artists get noticed. I personally feel having the option for everyone to publish content without prohibitive cost or other barriers is a massive achievement.

Sure you could go back to selfhosting. But monetization and, more importantly, discovery will not work that way.

Or we go back to the days of yesteryear with vetted and sanitized gatekeepers (also beholden to advertisers) in place.

So yeah. Until there is a empathetic, nuanced AGI/ASI in charge of policing content there’s not gonna be a good solution. That might take longer than a while.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Google just deleted my nearly 10-year-old free and open-source Android app
Ironically you are giving Google to much credit. There is no real way to improve enforcement. At this insane scale, and with the extreme level of sophistication from scammers, and the privacy expectation from users it‘s almost impossible to do more than they are. Someone else said it further up. They can‘t just let employees snoop around in personably identifying data. Nor would you want that, right?

The fact is, as bad as Google is sometimes about user privacy and „borg behavior“. Their adversaries (malvertising, spammers, clickfarms, bot-armies, state actors) are so committed to manipulating humans for money and/or influence, that they must be hindered wherever possible. It‘s the war for attention. And it‘s only going to get more intense.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Nvidia CEO says Google is the only customer building its own silicon at scale
Part of the problem is that the rest of the world moves too slowly. They were using containers and SDN at planet scale when nobody even knew what that was. App Engine has been a PAAS product for over a decade. But everyone wanted IAAS instead because of inertia. AWS has first mover advantage. MS profits because of their existing enterprise relationships. GCP is making big moves and is growing quickly.
v7p1Qbt1im··on Is Google evil? (2017)
I actually disagree here. Majority-Owner/CEO‘s like Page/Brin, Bezos and Zuckerberg absolutely might have idealogical ambitions and not just monetary gain. I kind of buy that Page/Brin want to create real AI to bring humanity forward. And that Bezos uses Amazon as a money machine to fund humanities future in space. Not sure about Zuckerberg but he‘s certainly not motivated by money I think.

I‘m not saying their motives are pure obviously. They still want to be in charge of that future. But money seems like an incredibly boring goal.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Is Google evil? (2017)
Lol, in my personal evil ranking, Rupert Murdoch is certainly Top 10.

Larry Ellison is a greedy jerk too. But at least he‘s content in being jealous of Google, Amazon and Microsoft and stops short of keeping a harmful conservative media empire alive. As far as I know.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Chrome hides www and https:// in the address bar again
Signed HTTP exchanges. It was actually the main complaint about AMP because it caused confusion among users. Technically it makes no difference wether the content is hosted by the author or any AMP CDN.

The question is more a philosophical one. If it’s wrong that the URL doesn’t point to where files are “actually” stored. Or rather that the package delivery and package creator aren’t the same party. In my mind this hasn’t been the case for a long time now anyway.

https://amp.dev/documentation/guides-and-tutorials/optimize-...

v7p1Qbt1im··on Yelp Is Replacing Restaurants’ Phone Numbers So Grubhub Can Take a Cut
I would be happy if people started using more locally sourced info on restaurants and places to sleep. Tripadvisor/yelp etc. can destroy any local restaurant scene. IMO there is nothing more soulless than picking a tripadvisor top 10 restaurant just because it‘s listed there. I usually ask people i know or random locals for tips where to eat. Or look at local blogs. Or you just pick a random place. I feel like some people just don’t do that anymore.
v7p1Qbt1im··on Google Discontinues Hangouts on Air
This. I use my own domain names with gsuite and protonmail.
v7p1Qbt1im··on Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf]
This kind of thinking leads to companies becoming irrelevant over time. I for one would much rather go for an interesting 50-year vision instead of pushing for quarterly stock gains exclusively. Ad revenue growth is slowing down across the board. FB is still showing increased growth because of Instagram which is just so perfect for ads. AMZN is a small player to begin with, so their growth will naturally be high. Also their platform is very well positioned for display ads and especially sponsored product ads because they tie in to their main business so well.

Alphabet will have ad revenue for a long time, yes. But cloud will eventually be more important. So they need to make sure they catch up to MSFT and AMZN eventually. And the moonshots are very important as well. Their very nature is risk. If successful anyone of them could potentially be worth hundreds of billions. Morgan Stanley speculates that Waymo could be worth a quarter of trillion in 10 years. DeepmMind and Google Brain/AI are two of the leading AI entities in the world. Wing could be very important for Google Shopping. And they really need to build out their shopping offerings. And then there are the healthcare/life science efforts. No one even knows what Calico is doing exactly.

What they are missing is basically a space initiative. Yes there is loon and Access but Amazon is already in the process of launching their Starlink-like satellite network. And then there is Bezos's Blue Origin.

My (amateurish) prediction is to be positioned in: AI, biotech/genetic engineering, space industries.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Google shuts down its blog management tool just 10 months after launch
> GCPs customer support is light years behind AWS’s business or enterprise support. I’ve yet to hear anyone say anything positive about any part of Google’s customer support.

I‘ve heard positive things. But yeah, that‘s not really something you can measure easily.

> And that‘s a minuscule part of the market.

Yes, for now. Eventually everything might be containers and serverless.

> But as far as I know, AWS has never outright abandoned a product. They may make it unavailable to new accounts.

Can‘t recall GCP ever abandoning something. Regardless, all the providers have the same deprecation policy I believe. Announce at least one year prior to deprecation.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Google shuts down its blog management tool just 10 months after launch
People forget that latency is actually pretty big on a console already. Many of the more casual gamers might not mind. From what I‘ve heard from the test run of AC Odyssey lag wasn‘t too bad. If anything I‘m interested to see of we‘ll see any difference in graphics quality with regards to artifacts. Also, how scalable and future proof their stack is (or how they upgrade). Especially once PS5/Scarlett come along. But most of the more casual players won‘t mind I think.
v7p1Qbt1im··on Google shuts down its blog management tool just 10 months after launch
It‘s always interesting when people like monopolies one day and call for antitrust the next.

Besides data sovereignty and user manipulation, the relationship between competition and convenience seems like the biggest issue in tech now. And there are no real solutions. It‘s obvious why tech is so consolidated. Marginal cost of growth is pretty much zero. 2 to 3 platform for a given use case might be the most „efficient“.

Chances are that quite a few of the new streaming services will disappear/consolidate soon enough.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Google shuts down its blog management tool just 10 months after launch
To be fair, AWS still has first mover advantage. And Azure has lock-in advantages because of existing enterprise relationships. From anecdotal evidence I know that that base products are largely the same, as is top tier support. If anything GCP seems to have great documentation, may be a shade cheaper and devs seem to like it.

Then everyone has their strengths. If you want to run a lot of containers or ML for example, GCP seems a save bet.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Google shuts down its blog management tool just 10 months after launch
Most of the headcount growth is cloud atm. But even so. They hire top talent exclusively pretty much. So It‘s advantageous to retain as many as possible and let them choose projects or build new ones. It doesn‘t matter. Worst case the project doesn‘t go anywhere, at best it‘s something useful or successful. Either way, the main point is to stop them running off to other FAANG‘s. Talent is the most important thing they have and it‘s important for them to stay the top employer for new hires.
v7p1Qbt1im··on The First Sony Walkman Was Released 40 Years Ago
That's pretty genius. 18-year old me would have never thought of that.
v7p1Qbt1im··on Google exec responds to Project Veritas video about bias
It could also just mean, they weren't prepared for the onslaught of bad actors like troll/bot farms. Those actors often take both sides of the argument with the simple goal to instigate hate and rage and eventually cause as much societal division as possible.
v7p1Qbt1im··on Glass discs that can store 360TB and remain intact for billions of years (2016)
In 5 billion years, humanity will either not exist anymore, or will be a Type III+ civilization. We certainly won't be impacted by anything that might happen to the sun in terms of its life cycle. A coronal mass ejection might be a problem at some point though.
v7p1Qbt1im··on Sidewalk Labs’ Plan for Toronto
Of course they would. But it‘s an Alphabet company, so it‘s automatically a distopian nightmare and basically cyberpunk. /s

Which is not to say that the actual project plan shouldn‘t be heavily scrutinized. But a lot of the comments around it are just FUD.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Google’s Rivals Gear Up to Make Antitrust Case
> I'd like to see what a self-sustaining youtube alternative looks like.

What does that even mean? Clearly another platform of similar popularity would end up heaving the exact same problems.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Google’s Rivals Gear Up to Make Antitrust Case
But Sinclair et al. preach the politics of the current administration, so they‘re safe.
v7p1Qbt1im··on Google’s Rivals Gear Up to Make Antitrust Case
I‘m probably wrong, but at this point only a real (benevolent) super intelligence can solve our biggest problems and questions (climate change, pollution, energy, deep space travel, chronic and terminal diseases, mass scale decision finding, consciousness).

Futurism aside. The only thing that will happen happen if Google is broken up, is Microsoft/Amazon/Tencent/Baidu taking over their share. The internet is not quite like other industries. The biggest possible scale will eventually assimilate almost everything.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Google’s Rivals Gear Up to Make Antitrust Case
By your logic there would be no YouTube. Or no user generated video at all. I imagine most people (including me) wouldn‘t like that.
v7p1Qbt1im··on Google clears up AMP’s confusing URLs by hiding google.com
You can‘t really, though. Many people have been fooled by fake URL‘s. Nobody checks the cert. To say nothing of the non-human-readable token URL‘s in emails.

Password managers and hardware tokens (Android phones too now) are actually a much better defense against phishing.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Berlin approves 5-year rent freeze
I was living in Berlin in 2015/2016 and believe me in no way at all are people coming here begrudgingly. Pretty much everyone between 20 and 35 wants to live here. And I can't blame them. I wanted to go and I still love the city to bits. There is nothing you can't to there. Tons of very interesting people to collaborate on projects with. Extremely good food and cultural attractions. Pretty much the most progressive place I've ever come across. Easily the best nightlife in the world.

This sounds like a love letter I suppose and I realize you were talking about cities in general. But anyway, I can understand why everyone wants go there.

v7p1Qbt1im··on YouTube’s Algorithm Incentivizes the Wrong Behavior
> Most youtube channels don't need the recommendation engine.

This is just not true. A massive part of the views originate from recommended/up next. Ask pretty much any creator. Only the core audience of a channel will have the notification bell on for a specific channel. Many users don't check the Subscription section and either link in from an external source, know beforehand what they want to search for or just watch what pops up in recommended.

v7p1Qbt1im··on YouTube’s Algorithm Incentivizes the Wrong Behavior
lol, do you even children. They will always find a way. You can restrict apps and services all you want. How about their friends at school? Are you going to restrict their phones as well? The only thing that works is actually talking to the kids about things they've seen/experienced. Not saying that is easy of course.
v7p1Qbt1im··on YouTube’s Algorithm Incentivizes the Wrong Behavior
The argument is that a hypothetical benevolent ASI can't be corrupted like literally all humans can. Those people are likely referring to AI's as they appear in Ian Banks The Culture series.
v7p1Qbt1im··on YouTube’s Algorithm Incentivizes the Wrong Behavior
Probably Neal Mohan on Recode right? The current public number is 500 hours per minute. But that number has been floating around for a while. It's probably higher now.
v7p1Qbt1im··on Facebook reveals its cryptocurrency Libra
This seems to be Facebooks WeChat play. It makes absolute sense for them to do this and there is very little friction for onboarding.

I can see them adding contracts (rental for example) to the chain at some point.

Validators are hand picked. So it‘s distributed but no really that much. Again, it makes sense from a business perspective. But it‘s certainly expanding FBs power and influence as a platform even more. I can see this getting pretty crazy in developing countries where FB might be the platform for everything at this point. Concerning.

v7p1Qbt1im··on Google Is Taking Charge of the RCS Rollout
True. Now that you mention it. I seem to remember having iMessage (the feature) be opt-in in Europe. So the feature is on by default in the US for sure? I guess that somehow negates my earlier post. But I suppose people would notice the green bubbles everywhere and remember to turn it on.

Hmm is this a defense against antitrust concerns as well?

← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →