HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vaporstun

778 karma · joined January 29, 2009

Victor Quinn

mail [at] victorquinn.com

http://victorquinn.com @victorquinn

submissionscomments
vaporstun··on Palm loses their lead webOS designer to the Google Android team
I'll give you a few examples. I was an iPhone user for 2.5 years and switched to an Android phone a month and a half ago. (thank you Google I/O!)

First, there are 2 calendar apps and 2 email apps. One calendar app is just called "calendar" and the other is called "corporate calendar" I think the idea is to have the exchange calendar in one app and the regular one in the other. But this is unnecessarily complicated. Why not just one calendar app like the iPhone which has all calendar events? Likewise, there is an Email app for any non-Google accounts, then GMail. So when I get an email, it may open in either app which have a completely different look and feel. While that's mostly fine for a geek like myself, it is confusing to any normal users and is a UI mess.

And there are many other things throughout the interface which lack polish. The phone app, for example. When in a call, my fiancee accidentally hit the home button. She then went into the phone app to get back to the call because she had to enter things on the dialpad to continue. (she was on the phone with a 1-800 number's automated system) So she went back to the phone app to get back to the call. But that opened to the call log. So she went to the dialpad and tried entering the numbers like she was told, but that dialpad is the dialpad for initiating a new call, not for the current one, so it didn't work. The system timed out and she had to make a new call again. For reference, the way you're supposed to do it is to pull down the notification bar where to get back to the current call.

In contrast, on the iPhone when you hit the home button, there is a green strip across the top of the screen that says "Return to current call" so it is trivially easy, and if you go back to the phone app in the middle of the call, it takes you right back to the current call.

While on the phone app, when an incoming call comes in on it is difficult to figure out how to merge calls or hang one up and answer the other. To be honest, I still haven't figured it out yet. On the iPhone, the call comes and it has 3 big buttons: Hold current call and answer, Merge calls, End current call and answer. Trivially simple, good UI.

Other things, the Android virtual keyboard SUCKS compared to the iPhone. It's predictive text is just not as good and my typing speed has been cut in half with this device because it fails so often.

The gallery app, while flashy and 3D is slow and laggy, and I yearn for the simplicity of the iPhone gallery. I don't need my pictures flying around in 3D if it detracts from usability with performance issues.

Often on my Droid, I hit the home button and all I see is my background. I often have to wait a few seconds for my shortcut icons to load, then a few more for my widgets to load and refresh. It's terribly frustrating. And sometimes they don't all load, I just have to swipe on the screen to get it to work. I shouldn't have to wait for my home screen to load.

Mobile Safari is just a much nicer browsing experience than the Android browser. I've even tried Dolphin, but find it leaves a bit to be desired. It is just not as good at zooming, panning, etc. as Mobile Safari which is HUGE for a browser on a smartphone. With so little screen real estate, I don't want to spend my time frustrated with that aspect of the browser.

Overall, the OS just feels sluggish in nearly every way. I don't know how to quantify it, but everything is less smooth and responsive. It's sad that my 2 year old iPhone 3G feels faster and more responsive most of the time than my new Droid. I even tried overclocking the thing to 1GHz and it still felt like a dog compared to the iPhone. And it is almost certainly all software because the processor in the newer Droid is certainly faster than the iPhone 3G, especially when overclocked. But it still felt slower.

Overall, there are many more little UI problems all throughout Android which make it far more frustrating to use. I don't hate it entirely, I wouldn't have switched if I did, but it is annoying and I am willing to live with it because of a) Verizon and b) the Hackability. But I'm a big geek, I simply would not recommend an Android phone to most of my family/friends and that is a big problem.

vaporstun··on Bit.ly is Harmful to Your Reputation
http://goo.gl/

"Google URL Shortener is currently available for Google products and not for broader consumer use."

vaporstun··on Tell HN: Take My Idea - A Social Calendar
Going one step further, it would be very nice to be able to supply information to different users based on their group. This is another thing which is lacking in Facebook. In fact it is something which is currently lacking from every social network (that I'm aware of at least). Everyone scrambling to build the next Facebook in the wake of the recent debacle may want to take some of these ideas.

For example, in your "About Me" section, with your co-workers you may want to say that you enjoy programming and playing around with server configuration whereas with your old college pals, you may want to say that you miss the days of binge drinking and getting laid. You would not want either group to see the other explanation of who "you" are.

Specifically related to this idea, you may want to have enable your college pals to see that you are attending "Remembering the good ole days kegger reunion party" while you may want your co-workers to see that you are attending a conference on some technology. You probably do not want them both to see the events that the other sees.

On a basic level, I like how Google Voice handles this. You can specify a certain voicemail message to be heard by people who are not in your phone book, and different voicemail messages for any groups you have created. This allows me to have a silly message played only for my friends and not worry that an important call will come in from an unknown number and get my silly message. This concept expanded to any and all properties of a social network seems crucial as far as I am concerned.

vaporstun··on First, we kill all the patent lawyers
Good point.

One of the major issues with patent law is that it is stuck into the U.S. legal system and ultimately governed at the highest level by the Supreme Court who are technologically incapable. They do not have a scientific background, they are not even other patent attorneys, they are often people who have no idea what is going on and ruling on these issues.

It is the same with the legislature, where they are making laws related to technology without understanding the implications (e.g. net neutrality).

What we really need is some system whereby those who are technically capable of making good legal decisions about the subject matter in question are the ones doing so instead of those who cannot (or choose not) to grasp it.

Until we reach some reasonable way of doing so, we are going to be stuck with things like patent law in its current incarnation which shouldn't really have any applicability in most cases when it comes to software.

vaporstun··on This year, Mac apps are no longer eligible for the Apple Design awards
I think this was very misinterpreted. The question was, "There's a rumor saying there will be a Mac App Store and no software without authorization from Apple will run on Mac OS X. Is that true?"

link - http://www.macstories.net/news/steve-jobs-no-mac-app-store/

His response was "Nope." And everyone appeared to be in a frenzy saying "No app store for OS X" when in reality that does not actually shoot down the possibility. Since the question takes the conjunctive form, his nope could be to either one of those statements. Everyone assumed it meant no app store for OS X, but it could just as well mean that there will not be a requirement of Apple authorization to run apps on OS X.

A minor technicality, I'm sure, but I would not be the least bit surprised to see an App store on OS X, just not the authoritarian, single point of app installing beast that is the iPhone/iPad app store.

vaporstun··on This year, Mac apps are no longer eligible for the Apple Design awards
While I certainly agree with you, I would also point out that OSX is also a very mature platform whereas iPhone OS is in its infancy.

So one could argue that OSX does not need as much hype to spur development, and since it has been around for so long, many of the critical gaps in the application space have been filled on OSX. Whereas there are still many opportunities for mobile device applications that solve problems that are not yet solved.

vaporstun··on Single menu bar for Ubuntu
It would be nice to at least have the option on the desktop, even if it is not the default.
vaporstun··on Dear John Letter to Coda
The one thing Coda or any other GUI based editor is really nice for is CSS. While it's rare at I have to delve into that stuff, it is really nice to have amenities like a color picker and a visual representation of the colors instead of just a hex code. So while I use emacs for my source as well, I jump into Coda for the rare cases where I am making style changes.

I'd love if there was some emacs-y way of doing this, but it's just not good at gui tasks.

vaporstun··on Apple: iPad will not be released internationally until the end of May
With all due respect, Apple is a US company, so giving preference to their homeland is hardly unconscionable.
vaporstun··on Google Developing Tablet to Take on iPad
cwilson said "touch enabled Tablet"

Touch enabled the TX1000 is not, it uses a stylus.

vaporstun··on The Opposite of Fitts' Law
This is true, but having to enable a GMail labs feature is a heck of a workaround for a simple UI issue.

That's a bit like saying let's put this vase right next to this punching bag and don't worry, if the vase breaks, we've got some glue over here. Obviously this is hyperbole, but I think it illustrates my point.

It would make much more sense to just separate the two very different elements. In fact, this is the point of this write-up and to offer a hackish workaround in lieu of a simple rearrangement is completely missing that point.

vaporstun··on Amazon shows off Kindle app for iPad
Also, use Readability: http://lab.arc90.com/experiments/readability/

to customize your viewing experience.

vaporstun··on Amazon shows off Kindle app for iPad
On a Mac you can hit CTRL-OPTION-CMD 8 to invert your screen. I do this often when I want to read with a darker background. It inverts everything so images look awful, but it is a really easy way to make some things easier to read.
vaporstun··on Please review my web-based Emacs color theme generator
Where were you when I was hand-coding my current Emacs theme??

Great work!

My only suggestion is that you could display the lisp code for the theme below the code window so I could both see it update in real time and be able to export it without clicking the button.

Surely you don't have to implement this because it was likely a free-time project and it is infinitely better than anything I've ever seen that tries to accomplish this, (because I haven't seen anything that tried to do this and when you divide by zero, well...) but you asked for reviews and that is my sole critique.

vaporstun··on Show HN: I finally released that sheet music app I keep yammering about
I'm really excited about the iPad app. Imagine sitting down at a piano, putting a iPad where you would normally put sheet music, and playing away with your app auto-scrolling so the musician never has to deal with a page turn. Anyone who has ever played piano knows how amazing it would be to have that eliminated. What a great learning device that would be!

Kudos and I eagerly await the iPad version!

vaporstun··on Anatomy of a Rumor: The Story Behind Chief Justice John Roberts's 'Retirement'
Indeed. I think this also goes to show the low standard of quality of many news sources. The fact that something so preposterous could spread at all without any verification is expected from the masses, but when news sources start mentioning them and fail to issue a formal retraction, instead sidestepping the issue, it should cause them to lose a lot of credibility. Unfortunately, in this day and age, many people would rather go to Twitter than to some reputable source for such news and that says a lot in itself.
vaporstun··on In Favor of Software Patents
One problem with having a software patent have a validity of seven years is that it often takes seven years or in some cases even more to get a patent through the USPTO.

If a patent's validity is up before it is issued, it is pointless.

vaporstun··on Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android
I wish more people would read the actual patent claims before coming to conclusions about them based solely on their titles. It seems that many news organizations have articles claiming this is a ridiculous lawsuit based on the titles which they claim are overly broad. If however they took the time to read the patent claims, they would see that they are relatively specific. For example: http://www.google.com/patents/about?id=L-IeAAAAEBAJ&dq=5...

Now I'm not saying that software patents are necessarily right, but I am growing weary of people making broad generalizations based on the titles of these patents and having them perpetuated. That is somewhat like a book review discussing the book's title and deciding whether or not it's a good book without having read the book or having any knowledge of its contents.

In other words, leave it to the lawyers. If you went to LN (Lawyer News - doesn't exist, but let's pretend for my analogy) and there was a lawyer claiming that Javascript is stupid because it has the word Java in it and therefore must have all the attributes of Java and he hates Java, we'd all cringe at his lack of knowledge of the subject and wish he'd leave it up to the Hackers who actually know what they're talking about to criticize.

vaporstun··on Apple Sues Nexus One Maker HTC
The date Apple received the patent is very different from when they filed the patent, or even when they first came up with the idea.

So in spite of the fact that it's a bit absurd, it is inaccurate to claim that anyone who had a lock screen more than a month old constitutes prior art.

vaporstun··on Tell HN: Credit Card type is very easy to ascertain from the number
I highly disagree with you. The less roadblocks you put in the way of a customer purchasing something, the more likely you are to get a conversion.

By this logic, Amazon's One-Click purchase would be a failure because people "expect" to have to enter their address and billing info every time. That's simply not the case.

Furthermore, some sites require this piece of data, some don't. I don't think this is like asking for the customer's email which they'd expect, selecting my card type is only present on ~50% of places I check out. (purely observational, no evidence to back that up) My point being that since entering your card type is not an expected piece of data every customer expects to put in for every transaction, they won't miss it to the point that they think your site is untrustworthy when it's not there. You have just made their life a little easier behind the scenes by not requiring them to supply it manually.

vaporstun··on JavaScript zip code to state conversion
That will be useful for narrowing down the states, but it doesn't actually convert zip code to state.

It just converts first digit of zip code to list of states to which it could apply.

vaporstun··on The 10 Most Addictive Sounds in the World
I'm a bit skeptical of the "science" they used to carry out this test.

For one thing, I can't believe the left off the NBC chime. This seems much more recognizable to the average joe than any other branded sounds they claim are the most addictive.

I am a bit annoyed at how many journalists use such ridiculous hyperbole in naming their articles.

"The 10 Most Addictive Sounds in the World"

Most of their top 10 belong to American brands, etc. I doubt this study truly applies to the entire WORLD. And I'd like to think that the company who did the study did not have such ridiculous claims. (though with names like Buyology Inc. and Elias Arts, I am a bit more skeptical about their ability to carry out an unbiased scientific experiment)

The problem is that journalists have no external check on them. They can give such ridiculous inflated claims with no repercussions. Almost every other field has some kind of consequence for making wildly ridiculous claims using absolutes and things that aren't true.

vaporstun··on Are special glasses needed for regular computer users?
I felt the same way.

Basically, first you'll notice the lenses are colored yellowish. They make everything feel a bit "warmer." I know that's extremely subjective, but I can't explain it any other way. I suppose one could argue the same thing could be accomplished by tweaking your graphics card settings or monitor, but this just automatically makes things feel nicer. Also, it's not so extreme that everything looks yellowy, it's very subtle.

But the main thing is that it has a different focal length. What I was able to gather is the following. Most reading glasses have a focal length that you'd have for reading. (~12-18 inches or so) These have a focal length which is 2-3 feet which is the viewing distance for staring at a computer screen. I'm pretty sure this is the main thing that helps eliminate the eye strain that I used to experience.

vaporstun··on Are special glasses needed for regular computer users?
I have a pair of Gunnar Optiks (http://www.gunnars.com/) that I LOVE.

I used to have ridiculous eye strain when staring at the computer screen for hours, but after getting a pair it's all but gone away. Like many here, I spend all day in front of a computer programming. Now I can't go anywhere I'll be using a computer for a prolonged period of time without them. When I bought them I thought they were a bit of a gimmick that worked mostly on the placebo effect, but after using them for close to a year, I can honestly say they have made a great impact on my ability to do work. I'd highly recommend that anyone who hasn't and has issues with eye strain give them a try.

Note, I do not work with Gunnar, nor am I associated with them in any way shape or form other than being a happy consumer.

vaporstun··on Ask HN: Gmail alternatives?
Yeah, I currently do that as well, but in the spirit of this thread, I'm looking for a non-Gmail way of doing this...
vaporstun··on Ask HN: Gmail alternatives?
Related question, does anyone know of a mail webapp that allows you to have a unified inbox with multiple IMAP accounts? In other words, something like Thunderbird or Outlook Express but web-ified.

I started doing a custom fork of RoundCube to do just this a few months back but never finished it...does anyone know of anything off-the-shelf that will do this?

vaporstun··on Ask HN: Please review our redesigned Web App, GradeMate
One thing I found a bit odd is when editing a course, the button at the bottom says, "Edit <course name>"

It seemed as though I had to click that button to edit the course when in fact I was already editing it.

Seems to me it would make much more sense to have that simply say "Save Changes" or something to that effect to be a bit more clear.

vaporstun··on JeffCroft.com: On Flash
Point taken, but that doesn't touch on the large majority of flash games and web applications that use the keyboard as the main source of input.

This helps for Flash on these devices IF the developers build in support for them, but that defeats the original purpose which is to give users the ability to interact with the current content on the web the way it currently exists.

Adding support for mulitouch in Flash does not solve the issue of keyboard input having prevalence in Flash-based games and web applications. Nor does it touch the issue of the many that currently track mouse movements. Sure, developers could all rewrite their games and applications to support this feature in the future, but that is hardly a solution to the present issue.

vaporstun··on JeffCroft.com: On Flash
One of the things I see almost no one addressing in all of these flash arguments is how there is an inherent problem with flash games on a device like the iPad, iPhone, or any other phone on the market with a virtual keyboard.

Most analysis when questioning games, this one included, point to the app store and claim it is due to the existence of the App Store and Apple's desire to control game content on their devices.

But they seem almost always to gloss over the fact that the controls would be a huge stumbling block. First, most Flash games use the keyboard for the user input. How would this work on something like a Nexus One? If the controls for the games use the arrow keys to navigate and the virtual keyboard has no arrow keys, how does the user control the game?

Likewise, many follow the mouse movement. However, on touch screen devices, there is no graceful way to track the mouse movement because there is no mouse. Swipes are generally used to indicate scrolling and touches selection. (like a mouse click)

So even if they allowed Flash on these devices, many users would be screaming about how Game X doesn't work and Game Y doesn't work only because the interface doesn't translate gracefully.

I am just constantly surprised that I haven't read any blog posts that address this (seemingly) obvious issue.

vaporstun··on Steve Jobs calls Google's "Don't be evil" mantra "Bullshit" and Adobe "Lazy"
I think many people are missing the fact that Apple saying Google's "Don't be evil" is bullshit does not imply that Apple claims they aren't being evil.

That is a fallacy.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →