HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vaporstun

778 karma · joined January 29, 2009

Victor Quinn

mail [at] victorquinn.com

http://victorquinn.com @victorquinn

submissionscomments
vaporstun··on If you aren’t embarrassed by v1.0 you didn’t release it early enough (2007)
Counterpoint: http://www.cuil.com/

Embarrassment ruined them and few will ever give Cuil an honest second look, regardless of their future additions/improvements.

vaporstun··on Ask HN: Rate my Startup www.birdpie.com (Updated)
I think this was an accident. The true homepage to this site is: http://www.birdpie.com/ and the submitted link is http://www.birdpie.com/railsbob which points to a user's page. The only way to truly fix this submission would be to edit the URL.
vaporstun··on OpenBTS: Cheap, open source cellular network
Looks very cool, excited about the possibilities, but my first thought was "FCC violation."

Did a quick Google search, looks like they did a test at Burning Man in 2008 and got local FCC approvals: http://lwn.net/Articles/297038/

vaporstun··on Productivity Hacks
This is a link to someone's take on someone else's blog post. The original post is here: http://www.bothsidesofthetable.com/2010/01/12/productivity-h...
vaporstun··on When Your Competition Gets Bought by Apple: The Melodeo Story
Single Page: http://www.xconomy.com/seattle/2010/01/12/melodeo-making-big...
vaporstun··on Ask PG: I'd like to delete my account.
use ack! - [http://betterthangrep.com/]
vaporstun··on Netflix Caves to Warner Brothers
I'd gladly trade 28-days on new releases for more streaming content.

With Watch Instantly on Netflix, I rarely bother with physical media anymore.

vaporstun··on A Mad Scheme To Kill A Scientist
I didn't say my system was without flaws, it's just my way of thinking.

And it is relatively rare that an innocent man is convicted and sentenced to death. We can have a system that forces all of us (as taxpayers) to pay a HUGE amount of money keeping all of the vile criminals alive for a chance that they're in the <1% innocent who were wrongly convicted. Does that make good financial sense though?

Also, I'm talking about the future, not the past. Sure there were many wrongful convictions in the past, but the same technology that is freeing those who were convicted wrongfully in the past is the same technology that will help prevent innocents from being put on death row in the future.

vaporstun··on A Mad Scheme To Kill A Scientist
I look at it from a financial standpoint.

When someone does something this vile, we (the people, by the courts) determine that they shall no longer have a right to their life. Whether that be by ending it via capital punishment or by keeping them incarcerated forever, they essentially no longer have a right to their life.

It costs ~$48,000 per year to keep someone incarcerated (at least in MA where I am: http://www.massbar.org/legislative-activities/mba-memo-on-se...)

If a court determines that someone will no longer have a right to their life and their remaining lifespan is, for example, 40 years, we will spend somewhere on the order of $2,000,000 to keep them incarcerated for their lifetime.

Of course, that assumes the value of the dollar is constant (it isn't) and that the price of keeping this murderer in a maximum security prison is the same as the average cost of keeping someone incarcerated. (it isn't)

When we are locking the door and throwing away the key, why not save the $2,000,000 keeping someone alive who we've deemed has no right to life anyway?

vaporstun··on Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... (2008)
Not when used correctly.

I thought this was on some sort of FAQ page or the guidelines but couldn't find it now.

Downvoting is not to be used to show disapproval/disagreement, but rather to filter out messages that add nothing to the conversation by being off-topic or just devoid of content.

If you use downvotes to show your disapproval and add nothing to the conversation, then I suppose you're right they are tantamount to DH0 comments, but when used correctly they can (in theory anyway!) help provide better, more intellectually stimulating conversations by burying useless banter.

vaporstun··on Court: Microsoft violated patent; can't sell Word
In this particular instance it was literal infringement meaning Microsoft literally copied i4i's patented technology.

First of all, i4i is not a patent troll, they are a document management company that actively deploys the technology on which they have a patent. One notable case of such is that they used it to overhaul the USPTO's own internal database.

Microsoft came to i4i and contracted them to help them move Word over to an XML format. They then tried to strong arm i4i into some licensing agreement which they did not accept so Microsoft just decided to willfully infringe. This means they decided they would just ignore the patent and use i4i's patented technology anyway without paying them. Essentially, they stole i4i's work when they refused to sell on Microsoft's terms.

More of the backstory in this article: http://arstechnica.com/microsoft/news/2009/09/i4i-says-micro...

vaporstun··on How Duke Nukem Forever Failed: Unlimited time, budget and ambition
Single Page: http://www.wired.com/magazine/2009/12/fail_duke_nukem/all/1
vaporstun··on Google Chrome more popular than Safari
I don't know why everyone is downvoting this, it's true as of 12/9/09. On SunSpider, Safari edges out Chrome by about 12%.

source: http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9142004/Safari_edges_...

Now of course on Windows there is no contest, Chrome is faster, but on Mac Safari is slightly faster.

vaporstun··on Google Chrome more popular than Safari
I've tried using Chrome as my default browser on Mac many times, but always end up going back to Safari. Chrome just isn't ready yet.

It has no bookmark manager, so when you have more bookmarks than space on the toolbar, there is literally no way to move them around short of deleting enough so that they all fit on the toolbar then moving them around. I ran into this when I wanted to add a new one to my toolbar and it was not possible. There is no way to rearrange them in the menu.

The scrolling in Chrome annoys me by being all herky jerky.

Lack of bookmark synching in Chrome is annoying. I have a desktop at work and a laptop for home use and it's so nice having my bookmarks sync up with Safari without any intervention.

Chrome on Mac is the first browser I've used where if I scroll down a page, go to a link on that page, then hit my back button it doesn't go back to where I was before. I have to scroll down the page again manually.

I'm a 1Password user and they do not have a version of their plugin that works for Chrome.

Chrome also does not make use of the standard OS X Keychain. So I have to put all of my passwords in again manually. Huge pain.

Some of these things can supposedly be remedied by using the latest version of Chromium which has extensions enabled and installing random extensions, but that is a workaround for a browser that's not ready yet.

Until it is possible to rearrange my bookmarks, sync them, use 1Password, scroll smoothly, and not have to scroll every time I hit the back button, I'll stick with Safari. Chrome has great potential, but is still not to the point where it can serve as a valid replacement for me. When I'm using Windows, it's my default for sure, but on Mac Chrome isn't ready yet.

vaporstun··on Reuters: Google phone with T-Mobile contract in Jan
Also worth noting, while Apple prices theirs higher because they make money on the actual handset, Google makes money on every smartphone that gets into the hands of a user from the ad revenue.

Get enough smartphones into the hands of users and Google will see their revenues increase from the increased viewing of ads. So they needn't sell the phone at such a high margin to make a profit.

vaporstun··on James Cameron’s New 3-D Epic Could Change Film Forever
Damn, nobody liked it when I submitted the exact same link with the exact same title 2 days ago. :(

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=991197

Oh well. Still glad to see that people get to read it. I was especially impressed by push in technology that Cameron has made. I had no idea he was behind a lot of the push to get 3D projectors installed in theaters and how much he did to influence the creation of the 3D cameras used in filming this and other movies. There are many technical accomplishments that have been made with this film that most people watching it will never know (or care) about.

vaporstun··on The patent system: End it, don't mend it
The author ignores the main reason patents exist by pulling in emotional things. Sure, in a magical happy world it would be great to offer children in Africa free AIDS medicine, but the fact of the matter is that millions of dollars go into getting a drug like that to market. It takes millions of dollars of research, millions of dollars to go through clinical trials, millions of dollars to go through FDA approvals, etc. And ultimately most drugs are very simple chemical compounds that could be easily synthesized in retrospect with the most basic of equipment.

While it's certainly bad for companies to exploit the patent system and try to extort profit out of sick and dying people, that does not justify throwing out the protection altogether.

If we threw out the patent system, none of the drug companies would spend the millions of dollars required to create things like a cure for AIDS as they would not make that money back because the next guy would just do some simple chromatography and have the same chemical compound synthesized for a fraction of the cost. What company is going to go tens of millions of dollars in debt with no hope of making that money back? When the incentive to do research is gone, we have no AIDS cure at all and in my opinion a world with no AIDS cure is worse than a world with an AIDS cure that's a bit expensive.

There are many things that are broken with the patent system for sure, but throwing it out completely would cause many things to fall apart and cause catastrophic damage.

vaporstun··on Crunchpad renamed "JooJoo" will cost $499 on sale Dec. 11
I am most intrigued at how Michael Arrington, a former attorney, [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Arrington] would have failed so miserably at doing anything to protect his interests. No contract? No formal IP? Nothing?

That's quite an indicator that he likely had little to do with this device as Fusion Garage claims. If he'd actually done more to bring it to fruition, he would probably have taken the appropriate steps to safeguard his investment. For anyone else I may attribute a lapse like this as simply a mistake, but for an attorney to drop the ball this badly sounds quite suspicious...

vaporstun··on WikiLeaks publishing over half a million intercepted pages from 9/11/2001
2001-09-11 08:47:46 Arch [0901509] B ALPHA Someone just told me there was an explosion at

2001-09-11 08:47:48 Arch [0901509] B ALPHA wtc....BR

This appears to be the first transmission about the actual attack.

(Edited to remove garbage in between from other pages)

vaporstun··on The Definition of Evil: Microsoft's Search Wars Hurt Us All
I agree this is fair if everyone has a fair chance to index that content for an equal price. If any search engine were allowed to index Fox's content (or any other site of course) for an equal fee then this is fair. It is fair and just for content creators to get paid. However if, as the article suggests, there is exclusivity and a case where Bing is allowed to index it and Google is not given a fair chance at such, this could run afoul of antitrust laws.

As I mentioned in a sub-comment below, exclusivity like this is inherently anti-competitive which has a high likelihood to be found in violation of antitrust. (Example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pict...)

vaporstun··on The Definition of Evil: Microsoft's Search Wars Hurt Us All
I agree that as a site owner you have the right to who has the ability to search your site, but when you start to have someone like Microsoft going around paying people to alter their robots.txt file to keep Google's crawlers out of it, I think you've stepped into distinctly different territory from a right of privacy.

Furthermore, I would make the argument that this is much different from signing a contract with a publisher. On the contrary, I would say this is akin to a movie theater paying a movie studio to keep a movie out of its competitor's theaters. This exact scenario was ruled to be a violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act: (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pict...)

This sounds to me as though it's the exact type of anticompetitive action things like the Sherman Antitrust Act were meant to prevent.

*Edit, added link to Paramount case

vaporstun··on The Definition of Evil: Microsoft's Search Wars Hurt Us All
While you're right that SAA cases are notoriously hard to prove, I simply don't think that Microsoft would even attempt something touching anything in that space given their history.

And the act was initially created in order to level the playing field to encourage fair competition. It does not seem farfetched for someone to argue that by using its immense resources to sweep Fox out of Google's index, Microsoft is engaging in unfair competition. This is the specific type of anticompetitive action the Sherman Act was enacted to prevent.

While it's true this probably wouldn't go anywhere without them getting to a point where they have a majority market share in search, this is a slippery slope and one I still think they won't go down, even if the viability of an antitrust case is low.

Can't argue that getting everything Fox off of Google would be fantastic, but the greater trend of fighting financially for search indexing would snowball into a huge mess. Imagine if you had to go to Bing to find stuff on Fox, Google for CNN, and Yahoo for BBC? The internet as we know it would start to fall apart.

vaporstun··on The Definition of Evil: Microsoft's Search Wars Hurt Us All
This sounds like a classic antitrust issue. Definition of antitrust from Section 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act:

A Section 1 violation has three elements:

1. An agreement

2. which unreasonably restrains competition

3. and which affects interstate commerce.

If Microsoft were to make such an agreement with Fox where they would pay them to be delisted from Google, it would be an agreement which unreasonably restrains competition and it affects interstate commerce. (As would anything online which is a revenue source)

I surely wouldn't put evil past Microsoft, but I doubt they would actually be so stupid, especially given their prior too-close-for-comfort experiences with federal antitrust law.

vaporstun··on Google Chrome OS Video
What I liked about this video is that it was so simple I feel like I could show my mother and she would mostly understand in a big picture way what they're trying to do with Chrome OS.
vaporstun··on Ask HN: Bank 2.0. How would you build a better bank?
There is a law going into effect July 2010 which requires banks to ask you whether you want to be in the overdraft program.

If you decide not to be in it, your debit card will simply be denied at the point of sale.

If you elect to be in it, you will be allowed to overdraft your account, but will be charged a fee like now.

http://money.cnn.com/2009/11/12/news/economy/overdraft_fees/...

vaporstun··on Ask HN: Bank 2.0. How would you build a better bank?
One thing that irks me about banks is that checks don't appear on your balance sheet until they are cashed.

More and more people these days aren't balancing their checkbooks and simply using the bank website's readout of available money to determine whether or not they have enough money in their account to pay for something. However, this is flawed for checks as they aren't logged until cashed. I've had more than one occasion where I got burned by this thinking I had more money in my account than I actually did because I had sent out a check that my landlord didn't get around to cashing for a few weeks.

This seems like the way the world is headed and it still kind of boggles my mind as to why we have both the account ledger at the bank's website and a separate piece of software to balance our books. (Mint.com, Quicken, etc.) The only reason this dichotomy exists as far as I can tell is for things like checks which are outstanding and not debited against your account when you cut them. (Ok, obviously there are other things they do like budgeting, etc. but why can't that all be done with my bank's website?)

My ideal Bank 2.0 would incorporate things so if I pay my rent with a check or send a check to someone through the web billpay, it is deducted from my account immediately so I cannot accidentally spend that money which is out there. Obviously it would take user interaction to log the check they wrote to someone in the case of a personal check, but with the web billpay it could be done automatically. By reducing the balance when that check is cut, it should do it throughout the system (aka not simply symbolically) so if I go to the store and make a purchase with my debit card, my balance with the check cut is taken into account and it doesn't allow me to spend the money for the check.

In the event of a stop payment on the check or a lapse of a certain period of time, the money would be returned to my account, so a lost check wouldn't screw me over. This would eliminate this huge problem along with the pain of having to maintain an additional piece of software to monitor my account.

vaporstun··on Google voice woes
There isn't any confusion.

They are discussing a distinctly different issue. It happens regularly to me and goes like this:

* My friend Scott has signed up for Google Voice.

* He regularly sends SMS messages to me with his cell phone. (Not his Google Voice number)

* I get a text message from his Google Voice number.

Google did some formulating in the middle and instead of giving me a random 406 number as you describe, it gives his Google Voice number which does multiple things:

* Potentially exposes to me a number Scott meant to keep as private

* Screws up the conversation because I cannot reply to the text message for he doesn't have forwarding on his Google Voice number (because he doesn't use it)

vaporstun··on Announcing Duck It, a new way to search
Or maybe add an option to your settings to allow users to pick their own.

This would satisfy everyone from the people that like your grey to the black and the #333 guy.

90% of your users probably won't touch it, but the ones who would may appreciate it.

vaporstun··on Apple plans to embed ads in operating system
I am not going to opine on the specific reasoning behind Apple's patenting this because only they truly know until a product is released, but if I were in the business of creating operating systems and I came up with a concept that could apply to an OS that was patentable, I'd surely do so, regardless of whether or not I planned on using it. It could be defensive, it could be an attempt to capitalize on a system by a competitor, or a pre-emptive move to stop competitors from doing this. They may use it in a specific niche product or they may end up using it, but there is rarely a direct correlation between a patent and a plan as the OP seems to claim with his title. The legal profession, especially relating to patents and the interrelation of companies is a huge chess game, one that I don't claim to be an expert on.

The title is misleading and makes it sound as though the next version of Mac OS X will be loaded with ads.

This simply is not the case.

vaporstun··on Apple plans to embed ads in operating system
Just because they patented something does not mean they plan to use it.

The title here is extremely biased.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →