Why not just say "Cyprus" rather than using the "Middle East" appellative?
1,111 karma · joined October 20, 2017
Why not just say "Cyprus" rather than using the "Middle East" appellative?
You're an AdGuard developer, I take it? Based on your Show HN post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18238503
Would you happen to know why AdGuard's IP addresses point to Russia, if you no longer have servers there?
The link I previously posted is simply a tool to look up AdGuard's DNS address: https://community.spiceworks.com/tools/ip-lookup/results?hos...
Any HN users can look up the same information themselves.
Similarly, Chrome's initial proposal suggested a limit of 30k, which has since been revised upwards to 90k to 120k based on feedback.
AdGuard and similar apps such as Blokada function as local VPNs, as mentioned, so most traffic does not pass through any particular external server.
The AdGuard app does use AdGuard's DNS servers, so DNS traffic passes through their servers in Russia: https://community.spiceworks.com/tools/ip-lookup/results?hos...
AdGuard says they do not log DNS queries.
The company was founded in Moscow in 2009. In 2017, they changed their official headquarters to Cyprus: https://adguard.com/en/blog/the-chronicle-of-adguard/amp.htm...
The concerns expressed by human rights groups such as Amnesty International are nothing so blatant as a direct backdoor, but the erosion of layers of protection that extend beyond technical measures. As the previously cited report notes:
https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2018/02/5-things-you-...
> Apple says it has control over encryption keys and that it won't allow backdoors. Won't that protect users in China?
> It all depends on the circumstances under which the company will allow GCBD – and the Chinese authorities – access to intelligible decrypted data on iCloud users. When users accept [the terms of service for iCloud in China](https://www.apple.com/legal/internet-services/icloud/en/gcbd...), they agree to allow their information and content to be turned over to law enforcement “if legally required to do so”. Significantly, from now on Apple will store the encryption keys for Chinese users in China, not in the US – making it all but inevitable that the company will be forced to hand over decrypted data so long as the request complies with Chinese law.
> Given that many provisions of Chinese law offer inadequate protection to privacy, freedom of expression and other rights, simply checking whether government information requests comply with Chinese law doesn’t address whether complying with the request might contribute to human rights violations. Apple hasn’t confirmed whether or how it will assess whether government information requests might violate users’ human rights. We won't really know how Apple will respond until it's put to the test, and unfortunately that’s probably just a matter of time.
> As for “backdoors”, or technical measures that would allow law enforcement or other government agencies to access unencrypted user data without having to ask for it, Apple’s commitment to prevent their use is admirable. But the commitment is meaningless if law enforcement can get the companies to decrypt user information simply by saying that it is for a criminal investigation.
https://youtu.be/VD1cP8SK3Q0?t=244
> VICE News: In terms of privacy as a human right, does that apply to how you do business in China?
> Apple CEO Tim Cook: It absolutely does. Encryption for us is the same in every country in the world. We don't design encryption for, you know, for the US and do it differently everywhere else. It's the same. And so to send a message in China, it's encrypted. I can't produce the content. I can't produce it in the United States either. If you lock your phone in China, I can't open it.
> The thing in China that some people have confused is certain countries, and China's one of them, has a requirement that data from local citizens has to be kept in China. We worked with a Chinese company to provide iCloud. But the keys, which are- which is the "key" so to speak, pardon the pun, are ours.
> VICE: But haven't they moved to China, meaning it's much easier for the Chinese government to get to them?
> Cook: No, I wouldn't- I wouldn't get caught up in the, uh, "where's the location" of it. I mean, we have servers located in many different countries in the world. It's- they're not easier to get data, uh, from being in one country versus the next. The key question is, how does the encryption process work, and who owns the keys if anyone. In most cases for us, you and the receiver own the keys.
VICE interviews are not held under penalty of perjury, of course, but we may give Apple's CEO the benefit of the doubt.
As Mr. Cook acknowledges, Apple did make significant changes to iCloud data storage for Chinese users, though he suggests in "most cases" users have control over encrypted data. The encryption angle was addressed in the article from Amnesty International as well.
Since the changes to iCloud for Chinese users in 2018 postdate the court filings in 2016, it does seem reasonable to feel less confidence in previous assurances with regards to China. They are not as ironclad as "threat of perjury" might suggest, at least.
Actually, according to Apple's statements Siri does not link recordings to your Apple ID.
That's a bit of a double-edged sword, though, since it means users cannot easily check what Apple has recorded either. Judging from public reactions, it seems many users think Apple doesn't keep Siri records at all simply because they can't access the audio history.
Reportedly, the only way to avoid letting Apple manually review audio was to not use Siri at all, unlike other voice assistants. If so, I wonder if that was also due to the lack of Apple ID, since if audio isn't linked to a user then it follows that it isn't linked to user preferences either.
I suppose you could still do something like send data from users that allow QA testing to one system and from those that opt-out to another, but apparently that wasn't done.
Feel free to criticize other matters, but don't lump in separate projects.
> [1] assuming orbits of 366 miles up, higher orbits would be even farther apart
If anything, such tangential criticisms are a distraction. Advocate for measures that would help, such as a carbon price and dividend, instead of attacking other causes and making unnecessary enemies.
I guess there's no reason not to include Widevine as well, but it's funny how this means the new Microsoft Edge supports features no other Chromium-based browser is allowed to use, including Google Chrome.
Getting rid of DRM in general is fine with me, but I don't understand why the focus on Widevine in particular given that its availability is relatively less restricted.
The original page is hosted on the original domain. What other hosts provide are AMP caches to display them faster. For example, Microsoft Bing:
- https://blogs.bing.com/search/September-2016/bing-app-joins-...
- https://blogs.bing.com/Webmaster-Blog/September-2018/Introdu...
- https://www.bing-amp.com/c/s/amp.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimf...
FOSS Patents is written by Florian Müller: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florian_Müller_(author)
As some may recall, Müller was frequently criticized back in the day for failing to disclose conflicts of interest in his reporting. Quote from HN user gpm:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18333187
> I wouldn't trust FOSS patents and the author Florian Mueller as far as I could throw him. He has a long history of being a paid shill, lying about it, and being flat out wrong.
> (Paid by oracle) http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20120419070127103
> (Paid by microsoft) http://techrights.org/2012/08/18/vile-lobbyist/
> (Paid by apple? I can't find other/primary sources to back up this claim though it does seem likely.) https://mrpogson.com/2012/08/21/apples-paid-shillconsultant-...
> (More examples of him being wrong) http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20120820111527257
> Refuting legal arguments takes time and expertise I don't have. He's good at his job, and I have no knowledge about this case. So while I put no faith whatsoever in his analysis I can't tell you how it is wrong, and yes this is an ad hominem.
https://www.xda-developers.com/huawei-android-alternative-fa...
> The Information‘s report differs greatly from what was reported earlier. Rather than being ready this Fall or early next year, they claim the OS is “far from ready.” It is reportedly being referred to as “Project Z” internally. The report also claims this OS would rely on 3rd-party developers to create apps for it, which may shoot down the idea of Android apps being able to run on the OS.
> According to the report, Huawei has been working on Project Z for several years, but its original intention was to be for their home Chinese market, and not a full Android replacement. If all of this is true, Huawei’s post-Android future may not be as positive as they’d like people to think.
(The Information: https://www.theinformation.com/articles/huawei-consumer-elec...)
Curiously, according to XDA's original Chinese source Huawei's CEO said the new operating system has a microkernel ("微内核") and that it's designed to support a wide range of devices using a single OS, including "mobile phones, computers, tablets, TVs, cars and smart wearable device": https://weibointl.api.weibo.cn/share/72019470.html?weibo_id=...
If that sounds familiar, you might recall Google Fuchsia with the Zircon microkernel:
https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2019/5/9/18563521/goog...
> Fuchsia is designed to run on smart home devices, wearables, or possibly even augmented or virtual reality devices.
Notably, Huawei has already tested Fuchsia on its devices before:
https://www.xda-developers.com/huawei-testing-fuchsia-os-kir...
> A new commit in the Fuchsia source code has revealed that Huawei has managed to boot the Zircon kernel on the Honor Play... You can check out the relevant commit here: https://fuchsia-review.googlesource.com/c/zircon/+/228577
Perhaps Huawei's "Project Z" is based on Fuchsia and Zircon?
To be fair, wouldn't that suggest strong oversight might work then? True, any test might differ from real-world conditions, but theories need to be tested one way or another and it would provide some evidence.
While caution during early testing might lead to less misuse, one could also imagine countervailing factors. For example, lack of familiarity with a new technology might lead to might lead to mistakes. Regulations are written in blood, as they say, and the development of new ethical guidelines may take time.
Which, as we've noted, could be a pragmatic reason to let others be the test subjects. I'm not eager to open the can of worms myself, though it might feel a bit selfish to put it that way.
> But again, once authorities have any of this data in their possession, abuse always happens. Literally always.
Well, before something can be abused it must first be available to use. Conversely, once a tool is available to use some may abuse it.
For example, if collecting fingerprints or DNA were completely forbidden then that might prevent abuse of such data (such as false matches). But it would also prevent any beneficial uses as well.
Banning facial recognition prevents not only abuse but also any potential good uses, such as locating victims of abduction or trafficking, and perhaps other uses we cannot foresee.
Killing it in its infancy may be easier than doing so after it takes root, but it also gives society less opportunity to learn what the consequences of the technology may be, intended and unintended, good or ill.
We know it can be abused, especially in the hands of an authoritarian government, but does that mean it cannot be used responsibly? Anything that gives the state power could be turned against the people, as libertarians might warn, but social progress also requires that we learn to work together rather than reject anything which might do us harm.
Perhaps a better argument for an early and complete local ban might be that it allows other regions to be the test subjects. Or that by taking a less compromising stance the anti-facial recognition side gains a stronger bargaining position at the table. But those arguments are not as attractive, maybe.
Smaller market of more demanding enthusiast users for internal drives. (Larger businesses aren't sourcing drives from Amazon or Newegg, unless the company is called Backblaze.)
Latter costs more to support and as niche users generally pay more. (The more price conscious resort to shucking external drives.)
At least, that's how it's been explained to me. I don't know if that's the entire story though it sounds reasonable enough.
- Blocked sources: https://news.google.com/settings/feedback
- Favorite sources: https://news.google.com/my/library
What I have noticed is that the filters don't seem to apply if you click on "Full Coverage" of a topic anymore (via the little icon with the colorful rectangles), perhaps in response to those echo chamber complaints.
- https://blogs.bing.com/search/September-2016/bing-app-joins-...
- https://blogs.bing.com/Webmaster-Blog/September-2018/Introdu...
- https://www.bing.com/amp/s/venturebeat.com/2019/05/09/google...
Microsoft is part of the AMP Project's governance as well, along with Cloudflare, Twitter, and other members: https://blog.amp.dev/2018/11/30/amp-projects-new-governance-...
I wouldn't be surprised if AMP starts appearing in other Bing search results, or if they start supporting links to AMP pages other than news articles in their carousels (which when you get down to it is basically all this announcement is about).
Is it, though? The top comments include ad hominem attacks on Google engineers, such as the replies to: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19886610
I appreciate how you responded to the worst attack, at least, but the general viciousness is still disappointing. I don't work for Google, but I'm sure not eager to present a contrary view if I'm just going to be mislabeled a shill. Doubly so for anyone who does work at Google, I imagine. Possibly developers from other members of the AMP Project's governing committees as well, including Cloudflare, Twitter, and Microsoft: https://blog.amp.dev/2018/11/30/amp-projects-new-governance-...
I don't want criticism of AMP censored, but I don't think AMP should be an exception to the rule against negativity either.
The flip-side of your experience is that it highlights the existence of a large number of Android devices based on AOSP that don't run Google apps, particularly in the PRC. Aside from the Chinese market, you have a major company like Amazon selling millions of devices with their own AOSP fork on them. On an individual level, I can install Lineage OS on my unlocked devices and use apps from F-Droid as well as many others.
Play Services does have a significant foothold in many users' experiences, which bears discussion, but it doesn't invalidate AOSP. It is Android's open source nature that allows for forks and for apps to be shared across the Android ecosystem much more readily than programs developed for an actual proprietary operating system such as Windows.
I see that there's a repo on GitHub: https://github.com/kiwibrowser/android
But the status of the code is unclear (the readme just says it's unsupported), and the last public commit was months ago while the app on the Play Store (having been restored) was updated much more recently.
At the same time, we're getting articles talking about how Microsoft is now an "open source company" because their proprietary operating system can run Linux and some open source apps: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/05/microsoft-the-open-s...