HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vatueil

1,111 karma · joined October 20, 2017

submissionscomments
vatueil··on Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook
Yeah, I agree it makes sense that certain apps shouldn't be easy to get rid of, though in comparison Android does let users disable apps such as the default gallery, browser, and even app store. I think the stock dialer and SMS apps are the main exceptions.

If deleted built-in apps aren't restored even after resetting an iOS 12 device, it's a good thing some apps aren't removable. I wish I'd thought to check before trading in my old iPad.

vatueil··on Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook
What happens if you resell an iPhone from which you've "deleted" apps such as Contacts, Maps, and Music? Does wiping and resetting the device restore it to stock condition, including those default apps?

If not, that seems potentially confusing for secondhand users. Some apps such as Phone and Photos cannot be removed in any way, but users may still be confused if other default apps are missing.

vatueil··on Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook
You would probably want to download the latest update rather than using the old version from the system image, but that's correct. Though IIRC the Facebook "app" the article complains is just a minimal placeholder, with the real app downloaded from the Play Store.

There are some built-in iOS apps that can't be deleted at all, such as Photos. For those that can be "deleted" Apple says users can restore them by downloading the app from the App Store.

But if a user deletes all the built-in apps that can be deleted, are they restored if the iOS device is reset? I would assume so, since wiping a phone is recommended before reselling it and a new user may be confused if default apps are missing, though I don't want to wipe my device just to confirm.

vatueil··on AMD Radeon VII: High-End 7nm Vega Video Card
$699 matches the MSRP for the RTX 2080: https://pcpartpicker.com/products/video-card/#c=427&sort=pri...
vatueil··on Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook
Functionally, isn't that much the same as disabling an Android system app?

I wonder if these articles would cease if Android simply changed the label "disable" to "delete" and removed the ability to view and re-enable disabled apps.

vatueil··on Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook
If the default apps are restored after a factory reset then "deleting" a built-in app in iOS isn't really any different from disabling an Android system app.
vatueil··on Meat-free 'Impossible Burger 2.0' tastes even closer to the real deal
Eh. We exist in a society where people who perform abortions must live with people who believe a fetus is equivalent to a full human life. People who believe unbelievers go to hell must live with people who are atheists.

The tension between vegans and non-vegans is not unique or unprecedented. The only thing that's new is veganism's recent growth spurt, which has produced a lot of new converts that mainstream society is slowly learning to tolerate, and vice versa.

vatueil··on Otter Browser – Aims to recreate the best aspects of classic Opera UI using Qt5
According to this answer from Vivaldi it sounds like the public source is only partial (the Chromium source code and any direct changes Vivaldi made to it):

https://help.vivaldi.com/article/is-vivaldi-open-source/

> Is Vivaldi Open Source?

> Vivaldi is not made available under one unified open source license. It does contain the Chromium source code with changes made to allow the HTML/CSS/JS based UI to run. All changes to the Chromium source code are made available under a BSD license and can be read by anyone on vivaldi.com/source/. Details in this regard are explained in the the README and LICENSE files within the package.

> In addition, our UI code is written in plain, accessible code for those who read HTML, CSS and JS. This means that for all practical purposes the Vivaldi source code is available for audit.

> Vivaldi also contains third party code. Licenses for these parts can be found in the source package and in the installed browser by navigating to vivaldi://credits

This reddit comment explains in a bit more detail: https://www.reddit.com/r/vivaldibrowser/comments/5vwihr/is_v...

vatueil··on 4,400 year old Egyptian tomb discovered in the Saqqara pyramid complex
Is the Ancient Architects channel supposed to be a fictional work, as Star Wars is? As far as I can tell from your comments and the videos I've checked, the channel presents itself as a factual source. If I am wrong, that would be a relief.

The channel doesn't appear to be reporting fringe theories only for the sake of debunking them, à la Snopes. Rather, at least some of the videos seem to support the alternative hypotheses they present.

For example, this video was linked in your reply to another thread in this discussion:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BAqPZ3NqVFk

> Conspiracy: Silencing the Discovery of Egypt’s Lost Labyrinth | Ancient Architects

The most common theory among mainstream archaeologists is that the labyrinth at Hawara described in some ancient accounts refers to a mortuary temple that has since been largely dismantled, as evidenced by the remaining foundations. The video mentions the mainstream theory, but dismisses it in favor of the idea that evidence confirming the labyrinth still exists underground is being covered up.

Regarding Atlantis, I'm not sure how Ancient Architects's coverage of the topic supports the idea that it's a reliable source. The channel reports claims of Atlantis's existence very credulously, and even when it disagrees with certain specifics it instead presents its own theories regarding Atlantis or other lost ancient civilizations the YouTuber believes existed. These proposals tend to go against current scientific understanding, to say the least.

You could treat the channel as entertainment, I suppose, but I would not approve of it as an educational resource.

vatueil··on 4,400 year old Egyptian tomb discovered in the Saqqara pyramid complex
Thanks for the response. Would it be correct though to say the channel does not reflect mainstream academic views?

The creator of the YouTube channel describes himself on his Facebook profile as a geologist with an interest in Neolithic sites, but he does not appear to be an archaeologist, anthropologist, or any sort of professional historian:

https://www.facebook.com/pg/MattSibsonAuthor/about/

> Ancient history writer, geologist, currently re-writing the history of the Stonehenge landscape with new interpretations of Neolithic monuments.

While amateurs are capable of good work, and scientific consensus can change, eccentric ideas are more often wrong than right. Matt Sibson may mean well, but I would not consider his YouTube channel a reliable source given that the videos appear to diverge from the scientific establishment on a wide range of topics.

vatueil··on 4,400 year old Egyptian tomb discovered in the Saqqara pyramid complex
From a cursory glance at the channel's descriptions and video titles it looks sort of sketchy, to be honest. Is that impression wrong?

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCscI4NOggNSN-Si5QgErNCw/abo...

> Ancient history and civilisations channel brought to you by Matt Sibson, offering alternative interpretations on the most well-known ancient sites in the world. History isn't always as it seems.

https://www.patreon.com/ancientarchitects

> I find that most mainstream historical interpretations are full of holes, both historically and scientifically and I intend to look at all of the evidence and offer my own unique interpretation on ancient history and the countless ancient mysteries.

vatueil··on China harvested organs from political prisoners, says tribunal
The point is more that the parent comment raises a different issue that doesn't really address the topic at hand. Even if another search engine did appear, it wouldn't allow the authorities to target dissidents more effectively than existing services already do.

If we want to actually make a difference, we might consider calling for those existing services to change their ways. Harder to pressure the domestic Chinese companies, of course, but it's surprising how little attention is paid to Western companies who are actually in China and benefitting from it.

vatueil··on China harvested organs from political prisoners, says tribunal
I guess it wouldn't be HN if we didn't tie every story back to our own issues.

In this case, if Google ever does return to China I doubt the authorities would find it more useful for such purposes than existing sources such as iCloud, Bing, and Baidu already are.

vatueil··on Choose Firefox Now, or Later You Won't Get a Choice (2014)
It's not nothing, it just wasn't enough by itself to overcome the competition.

In the web's short history we've already seen several browsers rise and fall. It's possible Microsoft may in the future repeat what Google achieved with Chrome if it can find a new edge to compete, pun intended.

vatueil··on Microsoft Edge and open source collaboration
There's a new GitHub repository for Microsoft Edge:

https://github.com/MicrosoftEdge/MSEdge

The readme goes into more detail than the blog post announcement, including emphasis on Windows on ARM, information about WebRTC for UWP, and explicit confirmation that they plan to bring Edge to Windows 7 and 8 as well as macOS.

Also, looks like they're using the MIT license.

vatueil··on Microsoft Edge and open source collaboration
The GitHub readme is more explicit:

https://github.com/MicrosoftEdge/MSEdge

> We will evolve the Microsoft Edge app architecture, enabling distribution to all supported versions of Windows including Windows 7 and Windows 8, as well as Windows 10. We will also bring Microsoft Edge to other desktop platforms, such as macOS.

vatueil··on China backs bold plan to tear down journal paywalls
Agreed. Many countries already require publicly funded research be made available for open access. A list of US government agencies that require such access after an embargo period is presented here: https://scholcomm.columbia.edu/open-access/public-access-man...
vatueil··on The Creepy Line: a documentary about Google, Facebook and user manipulation
Listening to different political viewpoints can be good. I make sure to do so myself on many occasions.

However, the criticisms regarding this film raised in other comments and linked articles appear to be valid. It concerns me that you have repeatedly dismissed these objections as "slander", even before watching the film according to your own words.

You don't have to agree with someone's politics to work together on common ground, of course. And a film with a message may be worth watching even or especially if it challenges your views. But the film's agenda cannot be concealed.

The Verge article, for example, made no bones about its political views but also raised factual concerns about the film. It is also a fact, as others have pointed out, that the writer and director of this film, M.A. Taylor, also worked on political films such as Hype: The Obama Effect (which detailed "various questions about Barack Obama's past") and co-directed Clinton Cash along with former Brietbart chairman Steve Bannon: https://www.imdb.com/name/nm3379741/

vatueil··on The Creepy Line: a documentary about Google, Facebook and user manipulation
Sure, you could wish for that, but if we could have everything you wished for we probably wouldn't need DNT in the first place.

Since DNT was specifically raised, bringing up how Microsoft's hug of death killed it seemed pertinent.

vatueil··on The Creepy Line: a documentary about Google, Facebook and user manipulation
Microsoft turning DNT on for all Windows users automatically pretty much killed the movement's momentum. While privacy as the default has strong arguments going for it, as a practical matter since DNT was supposed to be an intentional signal Microsoft's mass-flagging effectively drowned the signal in noise. And those who didn't know better lauded them for it, too.
vatueil··on Second woman claims she was paid to pick up ballots in US House District 9 race
To be fair, this appears to be the work of a rogue candidate, Mark Harris, and his supporters, not the GOP establishment. The Republican incumbent, Rep. Pittenger, was also targeted, when Harris challenged and narrowly defeated Pittenger in the Republican primary earlier this year.

https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/what-the-heck-is-happen...

> It turns out that the data irregularities in Bladen County extend to past elections, too. The 9th District saw a contentious and razor-close Republican primary in May 2018, when Harris ousted incumbent Rep. Robert Pittenger by 828 votes. Bladen accounted for 56 percent of the absentee-by-mail ballots (456 of 811) cast in that primary despite being home to just 6 percent of those who voted — and Harris won 437 of those absentee-by-mail votes to Pittenger’s 17, a massive gap nowhere near either the absentee-by-mail results in other counties or the other results in Bladen. And in the 9th District’s 2016 Republican primary, 22 percent of the race’s absentee-by-mail ballots were cast in Bladen County. That time, they went disproportionately to Pittenger challenger Todd Johnson — he won a whopping 221 of Bladen’s 226 absentee-by-mail votes.

https://www.rollcall.com/news/politics/rep-pittenger-fully-a...

> “We were fully aware of it. There’s some pretty unsavory people out, particularly in Bladen County. And I didn’t have anything to do with them,” Pittenger said in an interview with Spectrum News in Raleigh.

> Pittenger, who lost his GOP primary to Baptist minister Mark Harris by 828 votes earlier this year, said he did not know what would happen to the general election results. Harris holds a 905-vote lead over Democrat Dan McCready in the election that has now been cast in doubt.

> “I don’t have a clue. I have my feelings about what’s right or wrong, but let’s leave that to those who’re [leading the investigation into the irregularities],” Pittenger said.

If the North Carolina Republican party were smart they'd support the bipartisan ethics panel and wash their hands of Harris.

vatueil··on Fortnite dev launches Epic Games Store that takes 12% of revenue
They've tried to prevent people from publishing shell games that no one actually buys to play, that exist only for the sake of generating keys that e.g. make the discounts on game bundles look more attractive, yes.

But in general what notafraudster said is true, and generating keys to sell is in fact explicitly condoned:

https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/features/keys

> Steam keys are meant to be a convenient tool for game developers to sell their game on other stores and at retail. Steam keys are free and can be activated by customers on Steam to grant a license to a product.

> Valve provides the same free bandwidth and services to customers activating a Steam key that it provides to customers buying a license on Steam. We ask you to treat Steam customers no worse than customers buying Steam keys outside of Steam. While there is no fee to generate keys on Steam, we ask that partners use the service judiciously.

In practice, as long as you're selling a real product and your keys are for legitimate sales then you'll face no restrictions. Pretty much common sense.

vatueil··on Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10
WebKit was forked from KHTML. Chromium used WebKit, until Blink was forked. All of that was only possible because the browser engines are open source.

As with anything, you always need somebody (or a group of somebodies) to help something new gain traction. There's no magic pixie dust that will let you develop a major new platform without commensurate resources. What open source does do is lower the cost of entry and make it easier to build up to a level where you can make an impact.

vatueil··on Fortnite dev launches Epic Games Store that takes 12% of revenue
Epic is in fact planning to buy third-party exclusives for their new store:

https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2018/12/epic-undercuts-steam-...

> Sweeney told Ars that the company plans to "start small" and will "sometimes fund developers to release games exclusively through the store," Sweeney told Ars.

vatueil··on Firefox desktop market share now below 9%
As others have mentioned and I believe you were referring to, Firefox does let you create bookmarks with keywords to accomplish the same thing.

Funnily enough, I've often seen Firefox users unaware that they can do the same with custom search keywords in Chrome, so the problem runs both ways.

As someone who uses these features in both Firefox and Chrome, I do think it would be nice if Firefox copied how Chrome automatically adds these search actions, and perhaps a bit of the UI polish too (like how Chrome's omnibox will recognize you're performing a keyword search and adapt accordingly). It doesn't make much of a difference for existing power users, but it could help new users discover and use the feature.

vatueil··on Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10
> If Google annoys enough people, people can take Webkit and do whatever they want.

Not sure if that should have been Blink, or if you're making a subtle point about how Blink was forked from WebKit (which was in turn forked from KHTML).

Personally, while I can see why some may react to this news with concern about a monoculture, I find it hard to feel sorry about the end of the last significant closed source browser engine.

If Microsoft gives up IE and Edge then all the major browsers will have an open source foundation. With Gecko, WebKit, and Blink there remains a healthy range of options, too.

And as the history of KHTML/WebKit/Blink demonstrates, derivatives will appear if there's enough interest. Perhaps someday Microsoft will follow the examples Apple and Google have set by creating their own fork, if the circumstances warrant it.

vatueil··on Valve creates new revenue sharing tiers to give big sellers a break
> you can generate steam keys and then sell those keys off platform (and take 100% of the revenue)

Which is significant, and missing from most of the discussions about Steam's revenue share. Game creators can generate as many keys to activate their game on Steam as they want at no cost, and sell them however they want. If you buy a game from Humble, Amazon, or any other website and receive a Steam game key, Valve doesn't receive any money from that purchase.

vatueil··on Scott Johnson: No Hangouts Shutdown Date; Transition to Hangouts Chat and Meet
Title shortened due to character limit. Original title from Android Police article:

> "Hangouts executive rebuts rumors of shut down, users will be transitioned to Hangouts Chat and Meet"

Scott Johnson is "director of product management and realtime comms product lead for G Suite (i.e., the guy who runs Hangouts at Google)". His tweet:

https://twitter.com/happyinwater/status/1068861340800958466

> https://9to5google.com/2018/12/01/google-hangouts-shutting-d...

> Hey @hallstephenj, I run Hangouts and this is pretty shoddy reporting. No decisions made about when Hangouts will be shut down. Hangouts users will be upgraded to Hangouts Chat and Hangouts Meet. Your source is severely misinformed. You can do better.

Previous frontpage discussion of the 9to5Google rumor: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18572510

vatueil··on U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute
Any outcome would be tainted by the nakedly partisan motives. It would send a clear message to companies that they must bend to the administration's ideology.

Anyone who opposes the administration would be short-sighted to allow themselves to be used as puppets in this manner.

Speaking selfishly from the outside the short-term effects might not seem so bad, but the I wouldn't relish the long-term consequences.

vatueil··on U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute
It's true that iOS has a smaller share of the market globally, including many parts of Europe, but this overshadows the fact that iOS is almost on par with Android in the United States (44.3% to Android's 54.5% as of May 2018), probably higher among affluent users, and the leading mobile operating system in other countries such as Britain: https://www.statista.com/statistics/266572/market-share-held...

I feel this is often overlooked in discussions where users from certain areas where iOS is less prevalent don't understand the perspective of users from other regions where iOS is more popular.

← PreviousPage 5 of 9Next →