HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vbuterin

753 karma · joined December 31, 2012

submissionscomments
vbuterin··on Stellar
Ripple consensus.
vbuterin··on Why has Google cast me into oblivion?
There should be a name for deliberately making a big fuss of following every regulation as expansively as possible to prove a point; inverse civil disobedience, civil obedience maybe?
vbuterin··on For Sale: 29,656.51306529 Bitcoins
> An upward price trend (existing for whatever reason) encourages hoarding, which reduces liquidity. This creates a feedback loop, resulting in bubbles and crashes.

A downward price trend encourages splurging, which provides excessive liquidity. This creates a feedback loop, resulting in Zimbabwe. Bitcoin opponents have a vested interest; the desire to attack something you missed out on due to your own lack of foresight is a known psychological effect. I don't necessarily believe all of the above, but it's a pretty symmetric mirror image of the opposite argument. You could go up a notch and make the case that inflation is worse because at least an upward bubble has to end eventually whereas a downward crash can keep going down forever until the currency is replaced. I'm known for my stance that finite supply cryptocurrency is probably more deflationary than optimal (though my concerns are more about wealth concentration and the potential for use of seignorage revenue for secondary purposes rather than some idea that spending is good), but there are good reasons why one might think otherwise.

As for gold, an important point is that gold's volatility is quite recent. Before 1971, and especially before 1913, it was actually quite stable:

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/charting-price-gold-all-way-ba...

Yes, that's a 6x margin that maintained itself over six centuries. The 18th century fall and the 16th century fall can likely be attributed to the sudden introduction of new supply in North America; that's an uncertainty that cryptocurrencies do not have. I don't know why gold was stable before but is not now; perhaps it's the fact that a fixed-supply commodity is stable if used as a currency but not stable if used as a form of black-swan insurance. The former use case might have more constant demand, or price stickiness might play a role.

I'm honestly not sure what will happen. Maybe cryptocurrencies will die, maybe BTC will die but others succeed, maybe BTC will become gold 2.0 and other currencies will take on other roles (if this happens, environmentalists at least would be quite happy given gold miners' current track record), or maybe something else entirely. I do agree one-world-currency domination is exceedingly unlikely though.

vbuterin··on All Our Patent Are Belong To You
Sounds like "go ahead, but if you start trying to sue us then we'll sue you"
vbuterin··on Ask HN: Are we using the final numeral system?
Right, they also have:

十 = 10 白 = 10^2 千 = 10^3 万 = 10^4 亿 = 10^8

This leads to the non-Western-like feature that the word for a million is 一白万 (1 10^2 10^4) whereas ten million is 一千万 (1 10^3 10^4) instead of 十白万 (10 10^2 10^4) which you might expect if you think using Western number systems and just internalize the rule that "白万 = million".

vbuterin··on Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthiness of others
I'm not a steak-and-fries person at all (or even a sandwich-and-salad or rice-and-veggie person, which I've internalized as my own safe defaults); I go out and have unfamiliar dishes quite often. If I want to do something amazing and interesting I visit a new country or go on a 20km walk. And I've invented two programming languages as well :) However, I avoid alcohol specifically because it's just not something that I see myself needing in my life, and with the secondary goal of legitimizing nonconformism and pursuit of one's own values in general. I actually see drinking as a more "boring" choice than not drinking.
vbuterin··on Ask HN: Are we using the final numeral system?
Chinese:

零一二三四五六七八九

Africans are a diverse group so I expect that they have many different systems.

vbuterin··on Chain, the Blockchain API for developers
Works fine for me right now. When someone creates a competitor to BCI that provides SPV proofs in an API, I'll be the first to include fully validating support into pybitcointools. Until then, sorry, convenience and zero loading time (yes, even SPV clients are not instant) win out.
vbuterin··on Chain, the Blockchain API for developers
Because nobody wants to store and maintain a local copy of the blockchain. Simple as that. That's why I use blockchain.info for everything and not bitcoind.
vbuterin··on BADA55: safe curves for elliptic-curve cryptography
What these guys just did here is actually a very clever idea in another way. Suppose that there exists a weakness in 1 in 2^30 curves, and each curve takes 2^10 steps to generate. If they picked seeds NIST style (or even using cos(1), exp(cos(1)), sin(sha3(5)) or other permutations) then they would be able to find a weak curve in 2^40 steps. Here, however, they're adding another trivial property, namely presence of BADA55EC at the start of B, which only 1 in 2^32 curves have. Hence, this increases the difficulty of finding a malicious curve to 2^72, which is actually pretty close to what many people consider a secure cryptographic safety margin.

My preference would be to not bother with such tricks and adopt a standard for nothing-up-my-sleeve numbers (eg. find the lowest N such that sha(N) results in desirable properties) to avoid people from end-running around the whole concept with prime square roots, cosines, exp and log and the like, but this is still an interesting concept.

vbuterin··on Why is NaN not equal to NaN?
I think you just agreed with the comment you said "that's not true" to.
vbuterin··on You never did math in high school
It's useful in "shoot a ball out of a cannon at 50 m/s at a 27' angle, how far does it go?" problems.
vbuterin··on Advice for ambitious 19 year olds (2013)
> Everything we do, will ultimately be undone, if you extend the time horizon long enough.

Well, not necessarily. Economics quite clearly says that the total future benefit of any amount of nonzero-benefit present activity, at least if measured in currency units, tends toward infinity; that's why we have interest rates and the concept of rent. Of course, it's not the optimal strategy for securing personal happiness unless you already know you have a solid chance, especially if you're shooting for the "remembered by humanity for all time" mark and not something more modest, but living for progress is a perfectly reasonable thing to do.

vbuterin··on Truthcoin: Trustless, Decentralized Bitcoin Prediction Marketplace
Actually, you can even argue that the blockchain itself is a similar concept. It's a Schelling-point-based system for determining consensus, except its scope is limited to the simple question of which transactions came first.
vbuterin··on Truthcoin: Trustless, Decentralized Bitcoin Prediction Marketplace
Bitcoin does rely on an identity system; it's called proof-of-work. It counts hashing cycles rather than humans, but it's close enough since the final goal is decentralization and not perfect equality. Here proof-of-work or proof-of-stake are also equally necessary for bootstrap purposes; otherwise you can use whatever mechanism nodes use to get into the system in the first place ten thousand times instead of one time and thereby massively magnify your reward.

TLDR: proof of voting is a good consensus algorithm, it's not a good distribution model.

vbuterin··on Truthcoin: Trustless, Decentralized Bitcoin Prediction Marketplace
> What counts as a node? Can I spin up a million or a billion nodes on AWS and influence the vote that way?

Proof of work? Proof of stake? It's not exactly an unsolved problem.

vbuterin··on Bitcoin Price Pressure
The Bitcoin price is falling because the Google Trends search volume is going down. That's it. All of the technical analysis and China news is just a mirage that makes a few jolts in the short term.

http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=bitcoin&date=today%20...

And it will keep going down until the search volume stops going down, at which point it will stabilize, and then start to go up once again. Of course, this says nothing about whether the recovery will be $7 to $30 or $450 to $4000, but it's a pattern that has been quite consistently highly correlated with Bitcoin price movements in the past and I see no reason why it should not continue to be in the future.

Edit: the turnaround may be quite soon. We can already see that the price has actually moved by pretty much exactly 0% in total over the past 30 days: http://bitcoinity.org/markets/bitstamp/usd

vbuterin··on Announcing the MIT Bitcoin Project
Bitcoin users. Which is a larger population than that of many countries that have national currencies.
vbuterin··on Capital Man: Thomas Piketty is economics’ biggest sensation and fiercest critic
http://www.quora.com/Has-the-worldwide-GINI-coefficient-incr...

You're completely correct.

vbuterin··on When Diamonds Are Dirt Cheap, Will They Still Dazzle?
As an (armchair) economist, when looking at these cases of Veblen good consumption one of the things that always interests me is: is there some clever way to nudge our culture in such a way that the product of such consumption becomes socially useful? Diamonds have a negative external/internal benefit ratio, since child labor wars in africa etc, apartments on the edge of Central Park are neutral (the apartment in not helping or hurting anyone but yourself, and as per the Veblen good definition the people you're competing with). But what about Veblen goods with a positive external/internal benefit ratio? Charity auctions try to do that, and if the government were to monopolize access to one not-particularly-industrially-significant mineral and then sell it off at huge markups that would also work, at least among the subset of the population that believes government spending has >0 external benefit. I am also aware of the use of large public individual donations in traditional cultures. The cleanest solution seems to involve cryptocurrency, but that would only really start to work once everyone is wearing Google Glass and can, um, efficiently verify the results from a challenge-response protocol against a long-range RFID inside people's wedding rings.
vbuterin··on Greed and the Wright Brothers
I would say rename the whole thing to something like "intellectual use tax".
vbuterin··on Ask HN: What encryption algorithms should we take as compromised?
> SHA256 is an instance of SHA2. Presumably you didn't mean that SHA512 was bad, or, better, SHA512/256.

Right. But I don't see a reason why you would ever want either of those when SHA256 works just fine. Maybe because it's a bit more efficient per byte as a PRNG, but there are better specialized tools for that.

> ECDSA has another problem: it has a hard randomness requirement.

Not if you use RFC6979. In the Bitcoin space that's been standard since about three days after the Java.SecureRandom bug. As for curves, secp256k1 and curve25519 seem to be the most popular as far as I can tell.

> One-time pads are awful and should be avoided at all costs. Virtually every computer program developed by generalist programmers that claimed to be a "one-time pad" was instead a crappy stream cipher.

Well, yes, an OTP generated by a PRNG is a stream cipher by definition. You do need true randomness for them to work. I think they're very useful if (1) you're scared that NSA has a constructive proof of P=NP deep inside their lairs, or (2) you want ultimate deniable encryption.

vbuterin··on Greed and the Wright Brothers
The first step is to stop using the word "compulsory licensing". Compulsory licensing sounds like some kind of crazily authoritarian evil government regulation; if I didn't know what it actually is, and there were no triggers that convinced me the idea is worth taking an hour of my time to research, I would imagine I would instinctively oppose it. The language implicitly accepts that patents are a natural right, and that what it is proposing is an infringement on that right. In reality, of course, it's a limitation on a government-granted monopoly. Nobody is being "forced to give a license"; it's actually the derivative creator who is no longer forced to face unbounded cost when using something which was patented.
vbuterin··on Ask HN: What encryption algorithms should we take as compromised?
SHA256, SHA3, AES, ECDSA and ECDH/ECIES are all good, plus one-time pads and Shamir's secret sharing. There's no real need to use anything else.
vbuterin··on TurboTax Maker Intuit Funnels Millions to Lobby Against Easier Tax Returns
And out broken political process remains because of everyone in the government doing everything they can to sustain their own livelihood. Reality is a result of human action; to change reality you pretty much have to convince people to act differently in some fashion.
vbuterin··on TurboTax Maker Intuit Funnels Millions to Lobby Against Easier Tax Returns
Intuit's argument generally is that if the government was allowed to create their own online filing system then that would create an imbalance of incentives, since the incentive of the people setting up the tax form would be to try to screw people into paying more if possible. Keeping it to a pure private market of tax preparation companies ensures that companies compete to make their returns as favorable to you as possible, thereby counterbalancing the IRS.

I still think the lack of easy government-provided online tax systems is insane, but that's how the other side justifies itself.

vbuterin··on BitUndo – Double Spending as a service
They are useful in customer-merchant contexts because the merchant can cancel the order after anyway in case of a double spend, and in in-person contexts because you're in person so the risk of trying to cheat is too high. That's the main reason why zero-confs are fine; you only really need the preliminary notification to be instant, not total security.
vbuterin··on Ethereum White Paper
So the actual protocol change that needs to be made in order to make challenge-response protocols fully effective is basically the inclusion of merkle-sum-trees - make each node N = [ H, F ] where H = sha256(N.child0, N.child1) and F = N.child0.F + N.child1.F. Otherwise, there's no way to efficiently prove that a block does not have excessive fees. Unless you do some crazy ugly hack like creating a separate overlay merkle tree with its root being output 1 of the coinbase, that's a hard-forking protocol change.

As for changes actually being implemented, to be honest I haven't seen anything actually substantial since P2SH. The one big change that would benefit everyone now, increasing the block size limit, has been on the table for a year now with absolutely no progress toward pushing it through. If it does come close to happening, then I'll publish a bitcoinmagazine article cheering it on. For now though, it seems as far away as ever.

What I generally want to say when I make such statements in blog posts is "We _plan_ to do something that others have not yet _put into practice_"; of course, that just means we're equal and not better, but the point is to say that we're moving quickly and we'll get there soon. Bitcoin is currently a slow-moving target, and it given the $5 billion of existing capital stored inside of it it would be irresponsible to do things any other way; so I think it's unlikely that Bitcoin will develop second-layer scalability protocols first. If you wish to wait for actual results then that is a philosophy that I very much respect.

I have realized over time that pretty much nothing in Ethereum is new; Turing-complete contracts were in Ripple and Qixcoin (although I was not _thinking of_ either one of those two, and I did not even realize that Ripple contracts were Turing-complete, when I came up with the idea), Patricia tries I got from Alan Reiner back in 2012, all sorts of clever blockchain designs were mulled over on bitcointalk in 2009, and that doesn't even begin to describe the legions of forgotten hackers on cypherpunk mailing lists in the 1990s. A few weeks ago I learned about the concept of "rules engines". And then of course there's Yap stones. Meanwhile, Vertcoin is coming up with a memory hard proof of work that claims to be revolutionary and powerful but runs into a fundamental scalability issue that I solved months ago with Dagger. So perhaps I do need to tone down my "this is amazing and new" rhetoric; but at the same I've come to realize that since we are philosophically similar people attacking similar problems some degree of collision, whether of the "independent discovery" form or the "heard about it, forgot it, reinvented it without realizing" form is inevitable.

vbuterin··on Ethereum White Paper
> It's equally applicable to Bitcoin (though not implemented anywhere for any system yet).

I don't recall you describing it to me, but it's likely you did and I didn't realize it was important at the time. Also, I never claim that challenge-response protocols are not applicable to Bitcoin; theoretically, we know that any scalability improvement that is applicable to Ethereum would also applicable to Bitcoin simply because you can implement Bitcoin as an Ethereum contract. Rather, I made the claim that Bitcoin _does_ not have full support for such protocols. I count myself among those who are skeptical that substantial changes to the Bitcoin protocol will ever be made, primarily because of the "changing an engine on the run" problem and the nasty political issues involved (see: the recent Counterparty spat). Cryptocurrencies are not sets of abstract ideas, they are protocols that are implemented in code today and have to be judged on their merits as they actually are. And Bitcoin, as it actually is, is not fully secure with a light client.

vbuterin··on Ethereum White Paper
The information distribution should not be any more skewed than Bitcoin because every block can be validated by itself assuming only the validity of its parent as prior knowledge. This differs from the Israeli authors' GHOST, which assumes that nodes already have the uncles; in our system, uncles are included in the block. But we are definitely going to be doing various kinds of network simulations to make sure that every network protocol we push out is stable and convergent.
← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →