HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vegardx

1,574 karma · joined June 27, 2011

submissionscomments
vegardx··on Rivian R1T is the first EV to win the longest off-road competition in the US
> I try! A few months before warranty runs out, it gets full inspection, and I claim every part that acts funky! It is a free money!

That's not what you claimed. This is clearly something that everyone that own a vehicle should do, and probably do. Obviously it makes a lot of more sense to do on a combustion engine that has literally thousands of moving parts that easily can ruin an engine. But any sensible person will service their car before warranty runs out.

> What exactly is the difference? If anything phone batteries are way more expensive and sophisticated!

I don't know where to even start. How does my example prove that they're more expensive and sophisticated? They fail to deliver enough power to the CPU so it crashes. So they have to clock the CPU down so the battery is able to deliver enough power.

> R1T can tow 100 miles on single charge. That is 1500 battery cycles within 150k miles warranty, or 3000 cycles if you do that daily for 8 years!

This argument makes no sense. You're constructing a edge case that doens't fit with reality. Show me a truck with a combustion engine that hauls max load all day, every day, for 150k miles without significant service requirement, to the tune that cost vastly more than a simple battery replacement.

> I actually want to use this as a truck. It should be soo much better, new revolutionary technology...

Then buy a truck that fits your needs. It's that simple.

> You claim that thing is useless "penxs extension", yet somehow manufacturer does not lie about its numbers!

I don't understand what or who is lying. Even most truckers will admit that most people that own a truck don't really use it as it was intended. The vast majority of trucks on the road has never had anything in their truck bed that couldn't fit in a Fiat Punto. I'm not going to stop you from getting a truck. Be that electric or combustion. I just want you to be consistent.

> OK, let's ban useless extensions. Why should people who actually need proper truck for work, pay fines and sponsor people, who buy useless EV penxs extensions?

Huh? I never made any argument like that. And it's okey, you're allowed to say penis[0].

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tona16xQCIg

vegardx··on Rivian R1T is the first EV to win the longest off-road competition in the US
> Wind is apparently a big factor in route planning so that also impacts the exterior design criteria as well.

Wind is a big factor for all vehicles. The big difference is that combustion engines need a lot of cooling, so there's not that much that can be done in regards to aerodynamics on that front. They still experience the same losses with headwind, arguably even more.

> For those who use their vehicles to do repair and other types of field or farm work the verdict is not at all clear.

Then don't get a battery-electric vehicle? There are plenty of completely reasonable cases where currently battery-electric vehicles isn't the solution. But the vast vast vast majority of trucks on the road has never had anything in their truck bed that wouldn't fit inside a Fiat Punto.

> I'd also prefer Fire, Ambulance and Police to stay on gasoline and diesel for probably the next 25 to 50 years, given the abysmal rate of infrastructure development that happens in this country.

I mean - sure? I imagine the people actually driving these vehicles are more than capable of choosing something that gets the job done. How you're able to look 25-50 years into the future is beyond me.

vegardx··on Rivian R1T is the first EV to win the longest off-road competition in the US
Do you really replace your car engine and transmission before the warranty runs out? You're constructing arguments that literally makes no sense. The battery in your phone isn't comparable to the one in an BEV. If that was true your phone would have a fully working battery ten years later, just with slightly lower capacity. Not one that dies because you open a webpage with a too many moving elements, so battery voltage drops and it turns off.

All that said - I don't think a truck like the Rivian R1T makes any sense. For the same reason that I don't think most trucks make any sense. They're just penis extensions that have little to no utility for a vast majority of people that buy them. But since we're OK with that for regular trucks, I think we should be OK with that for the battery electric version too. Lets at least be consistent.

vegardx··on Early Europeans ate seaweed for thousands of years
Seaweed has been quite extensively used as animal feed in at least Norway, to the point where some of the most known local species have names like kutare (cow kelp), sauetang (sheep seaweed) and grisetang (pigs seaweed), since that's what you used to feed your cows, sheeps and pigs.
vegardx··on In Defense of Electricity Markets
Latest data is from 2012[0], but to counter to my own argument, I have district heating in my apartment. Outside of Oslo or any of the other "larger" cities in Norway I think you're hard pressed at finding anything like that, the population density is so low that it economy of scale for systems like that doesn't work out.

I'm not going to pretend that these office buildings don't exist, but usually they're not really empty. I've yet to be in an office without obnoxious motion sensors that don't work properly so you end up sitting in the darkness when working either early in the morning or late in the evening.

All that said, light pollution is a huge problem here. When I'm out hiking I don't really need a compass or anything to know the direction of Oslo, I can just look at the sky. I think the point I was trying to make is that lighting is a very small percentage of electricity usage, especially now with LED-lighting. In the winter I use the equivalent of 2000kWh/month for heating and hot water. Lighting would be 75kWh if I left all light on, all day, all night.

[0] https://www.ssb.no/energi-og-industri/statistikker/husenergi....

vegardx··on In Defense of Electricity Markets
For most homes and offices the primary source of heating is electrical, so in the winter it doens't really make much difference whether you turn the lights off or not, heat is heat. In the summer there's no excuse though. Old habits die hard, or something like that.

That said, modern LED-lighting doesn't really use that much electricity, all lights in my apartment use a total of 100Wh, or 75kWh per month. I could turn off all lights in my apartment for a year and it still wouldn't be close to the energy needed for a single transaction on the bitcoin blockchain. But clearly some speculative investment has more utility than me not stumping my toe when going to the bathroom at night.

vegardx··on Workloads on Arm-based AWS instances
I don't think they document how how they're doing things in the background. Based on personal experience I've been notified that EBS-backed instances have been rebooted due to hardware failure. For instances with ephemeral storage you're given some time to migrate for scheduled maintenance, for hardware failures you're tough out of luck. I've never been notified about scheduled maintenance on an EBS-backed instance, which leads me to think that they just migrate it without telling you.

They're using KVM under the hood, which supports things like live migration, interrupts to facilitate memory transfer, and so on. At home I'm doing live migration with less than 300ms of interrupts with high memory pressure. It would make sense for them to move things around, just for things like maintenance and distributing load.

vegardx··on Workloads on Arm-based AWS instances
The T3 instances are all burstable, but they come with the "unlimited" feature toggled on by default. The T2 instances had this feature toggled off by default. So with this instance type you never really run out of credits, but you could quickly end up paying more than with other general purpose instance types, like M series, if you burn through a lot of credits.
vegardx··on GitHub Actions could be so much better
There's tools like Act[0] that tries to solve this, but this has been an issue with CI systems since they were invented.

[0] https://github.com/nektos/act

vegardx··on Mercedes-Benz picks Tesla's charging standard for North America EVs from 2025
Tesla Semi will use the MCS connector, an industry standard connector for anything in the MW-range. Luckily we've managed to choose a proper connector before things hit mass market.

In theory there's nothing that stops both CCS2 Type 2 and NACS to deliver up to 1MW, both have the required cable cross section and cooling to allow for it. Everyone that has used both NACS and CCS2 will admit that NACS is superior in handling, something that is important if you suffer from any kind of disability, and point I've also admittedly not fully acknowledged.

The NACS as it is today simply wouldn't be a good fit for Europe, it lacks a couple of leads, and CCS Type 2 doens't offer any significant advantage in the NA due to the lack of widespread residential 3-phase power in North America. In a dream scenario we'd have the NACS connector with the capabilities of the CCS Type 2.

vegardx··on Rivian embraces Tesla's charging standard for EVs
I don't think I've ever claimed that EVs are suitable for everyone right now or that the infrastructure is there to fully replace every single scenario. The point is still that most people can have most of their needs met by a simple wall plug for charging.

Chances are that you don't even need to charge on your 150 miles trip. Most modern BEVs will be able to take you anywhere from 300-350 miles on a single charge. In your scenario you could literally do a round trip and have a comfortable level of charge when you get home again.

vegardx··on Rivian embraces Tesla's charging standard for EVs
It's not being hand waved away. You're just constructing scenarios that most people owning an electric vehicle will agree is such a non-issue that it's not really worth debating. There are plenty of fast chargers to fill the gaps.

Many people travel regularly. Many people don't. That's how we ended up on the average being 50km.

vegardx··on Rivian embraces Tesla's charging standard for EVs
Most people don't drive 500km per day, the average is closer to 50 or so. So on average, you could easily top of your battery pack on 240V/10A circuit. That would be around 10kWh, which you'll do in 5 hours. Double the average and you'll still be topped up next morning.
vegardx··on Rivian embraces Tesla's charging standard for EVs
I don't know about the NA, but that is definitively not the case for most superchargers (or any other brand of fast chargers, for that matter) in Europe. Batteries are expensive so this is only done in very special cases. I know they've used battery banks at some of the electrical ferries in Norway, simply because the cost of running new high-voltage power lines was deemed more expensive and the schedule of the ferries makes it very easy to model.

Power grids are quite large, so any fluctuations across the grid is going to be minimal. They are quite good at modeling these things, otherwise we'd have rolling blackouts quite often. For homes it's the last mile that's usually the biggest limiting factor.

But I agree with what you said, for /most/ people anything more than 2kW (so 240V/10A) is more than enough to charge up overnight. A perk with CCS2 is the support for 3-phase power delivery. With very simple wiring and some smart(-ish) electronics you can opportunistically deliver around 11kW to a single car, or divide it with other house appliances or other cars. It's fairly common with 400V TN-system in some parts of Europe, which makes the support of 3-phase in CCS2 very handy.

vegardx··on Quick VPN Setup with AWS Lightsail and WireGuard
The stateless nature of Wireguard makes it kind of hard to implement. Having something DHCP-esque makes sense when you have an external mechanism for authentication, like most traditional VPN software does, but with Wireguard you have to exchange public keys with peers that communicate with each other, so you might as well just set up the IP at the same time.
vegardx··on Coinbase Sued by SEC for Breaking US Securities Rules
Or Coinbase hired the best legal team in the world to seed confusion because they never wanted or intended to register, but needed a hypothetical position to defend against journalists and skeptics.

Obviously a wild conspiracy claim. But then again we're talking about fintech.

vegardx··on Targeting Toyota for Its Electric-Vehicle Heresy
Who would have thought that a car manufacturer that still doesn't have a competitive option in the battery-electric market would constantly be making bogus claims with no sources to back it up. News at five!

This opinion piece is just a smoke screen. Toyota knows they've fumbled, and this is why shareholders are revolting. It's funny how this article tries to make it about politics, when it's literally about shareholders voicing their concerns about the future profitability of a company they're invested in.

It would take me literally hours to debunk all their claims, because it's actually a complicated topic with a lot of nuances and regional considerations to take.

vegardx··on EPYC 7002 CPUs may hang after 1042 days of uptime
I had a very similar issue with some AMD-based servers (bulldozer, I think) about ten years ago. There was a bug where Xen-based virtual machines could set a C-state on cores it was assigned, but for whatever reason it wasn't able to wake them up. It was fun trying to figure out what the heck was going on.
vegardx··on EU achieved independence from Russian fossil fuels
As of January the sanctions weren't in full effect. Like the article mentions the ban on refined oil products wasn't in full effect before 5th of February.

Russia has lost the single largest market they have for refined oil products, like diesel and gasoline. This is being replaced by increased production in European countries and emerging markets, like India. India is buying crude oil from Russia at a discounted price. Around a quarter of the cost of refined oil products is based on price of crude oil. Russia has more or less gutted it's entire refined oil industry. India, amongst others, are picking up the pieces.

So no, your assessment that Europe is pretending that they're not doing business with Russia is completely missing the mark.

vegardx··on Who owns this camera, Nikon? Me or you? [video]
This is just part of the story.

The other part of the issue has been importing refurbished items, like screens and other components. The parts are literally pulled out of Apple produced products, as is. But since Apple puts their logo everywhere on the parts, it's almost impossible to import them. They just claim they're counterfeit, without having to provide any evidence that they are. This went all the way to the supreme court in Norway, and the supreme court sided with Apple.

It's too expensive to remove the Apple branding on genuine and refurbished parts, so now we're stuck with actual counterfeits, often from the same factory as the originals, just without the logo. But we could have just used perfectly fine refurbished parts.

vegardx··on EU achieved independence from Russian fossil fuels
India sells refined goods to Europe. They buy crude oil from Russia because Russia has no market to sell it to, and have to sell it at a discounted price. If Russia puts any sanctions on where India can sell their refined goods they'll just buy crude oil elsewhere. Europe isn't the only market, and Russia isn't the only producer of crude oil. India is just making a premium buy using Russian crude oil.

The biggest loss for Russia isn't the loss of crude oil sales, it's the loss of sale on refined goods. They were a massive supplier of things like diesel to Europe.

vegardx··on EU achieved independence from Russian fossil fuels
India imports crude oil from Russia and refines it into products that Europe wants, like diesel as you mentioned.

You forgot to mention that Europe imported almost all diesel from Russia.

vegardx··on EU achieved independence from Russian fossil fuels
India wouldn't accept that. They don't have any leverage, they played their hand.
vegardx··on Ford EV Customers to Gain Access to 12,000 Tesla Superchargers
The benefit with 3-phase is that you now can use a single cable/charger to charge up to three separate cars, which greatly reduces the cost of setting up a lot of chargers in, say, a parking garage. And you can opportunistically deliver up to 11-22kW (240V/400V) to a single car. Greatly reduces the amount of hardware needed.
vegardx··on Ford EV Customers to Gain Access to 12,000 Tesla Superchargers
> Is that at all relevant for the North American market, where no one would be using three phase power to charge their car?

While 240V 3-phase isn't common in the US homes I'd imagine that it would be super handy for places like shopping malls or parking garages where you want to have lots of Level 2 chargers.

> Affordability is objective, NACS is simply cheaper to make. Less materials go into it, and that's a win.

I agree with you there, it looks much better and is slightly easier to handle. I doubt the material difference is much, it's just a little plastic. The amount of adapters likely makes up the difference.

> you don't have to remove a cover over the DC plugs

This isn't really a thing. These hard plastic covers is something people buy thinking it will protect them from being electrocuted. If they had known how the chargers work they'd likely be less worried. Except in France, where they've made CCS Type 3, which is about as French of an idea as you get.

> So what, then, is an objective argument FOR using CCS1 over NACS? I really don't see one.

The main issue here is that US decided to go with CCS Type 1, when it was clear back in 2014 that CCS Type 2 would be a much better and more future proof choice. It's something that should have been solved with regulation a long time ago. And now you're stuck with CCS Type 1 and NACS for the unforeseeable future. It's kinda funny, because in Europe Tesla went from only NACS (V1 superchargers) to NACS and CCS2 (V2 and V3 superchargers) to only CCS2 (V4 superchargers).

vegardx··on Ford EV Customers to Gain Access to 12,000 Tesla Superchargers
A Tesla Model 3 uses roughly 160Wh/km and has a 75-82kWh battery pack. You can easily do the math. I think you'll be surprised.
vegardx··on Ford EV Customers to Gain Access to 12,000 Tesla Superchargers
The MCS (Megawatt Charging System) is also designed by a committee and has been adopted by Tesla for the Tesla Semi, so I don't see how this is even a relevant argument. NACS does only support single phase charging, while CCS2 can do 3-phase charging.

The only truthful argument in this discussion is that Tesla already have a huge charging network using their (previously) proprietary connector and automotive makers want to have access to this. NACS use the same signaling protocol as CCS, which is also why you can get away with a pretty dumb adapter.

It has the same physical limitations as any other cable. If you want to deliver high power at low voltage you need thick cables, there's nothing you can do to get around that fact.

CCS Type 2 is rated at 1000V and 400A, or 400kW.

vegardx··on Expensive energy may have killed more Europeans than Covid-19 last winter
This is one of those hard things to understand if you don't understand the nordic mentality. Unlike a lot of places you rarely have to mandate something for people to adjust their behavior. So - no there weren't any lockdowns, but social gatherings was very limited, and people for the most part followed through with social distancing.
vegardx··on Tesla tries to get owners to give up ‘unlimited free Supercharging for life’
You're right. But they only recently started removing the rate-limiting when you got a new pack, which there was a lot of fuss about. I imagine there's quite an overlap of cars with unlimited supercharging and frequent supercharging.
vegardx··on Tesla tries to get owners to give up ‘unlimited free Supercharging for life’
I don't really see it.

They're competing with a ton of operators on cost, the margins are very small. When they start offering retail services on supercharger locations, then you know they're serious about making this a profit center.

But ... in Norway at least, Tesla was seemingly very keen on expanding their supercharger network fast, so they partnered up with everything from gas stations to fast food places.

← PreviousPage 3 of 22Next →