HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

verylittlemeat

823 karma · joined January 5, 2017

submissionscomments
verylittlemeat··on The unnecessary demise of Barnes and Noble
I welcome the crumblings of the tech billionaires table. Let them think they're the masters of the universe while subsidizing my ability to spend my time the way I want.

Let the tech billionaires be saddled with the moralizing virtues of self-reliance and feelings of humiliation. Certain societies raise their youth to value work as a means of proving themselves. The truth is that perspective is completely subjective and in many ways a pathology more than a guiding principle.

Humans will work. That is what we do. If we're alive we will create reasons to do things. The problem is who is deciding the values we're supposed to work toward. Distributing work will fail because people don't agree on what is important and will even act against their own self interest. When that happens what do you do? Do you punish them? Do you leave them to die? Do you ostracize them from the community? That's why the system we have now in the industrialized west works at all, because it allows us the illusion of choice. Our shared language of moralizing and virtue signaling is how we cope with the fact that we actually don't have a choice, we're just pragmatically putting our heads down and picking our poison.

With UBI it's scary to think of millions of people unmoored from work because work is a form of social control. UBI will turn hundreds of years of social convention on its head. As much as we want to believe it there are no iron laws of culture. Some values will be destroyed and new values will be born. That's the nature of change.

Our descendants at some undefined point in the future will find our moralizing about work absolutely quaint.

verylittlemeat··on The FBI, CIA and NSA say American citizens shouldn't use Huawei phones
I actually have yearly reminders set in my calendar to make new usernames on sites I frequently comment on (with new registered emails, etc).

People with deviant opinions value anonymity. People who have to live and work in the US don't want to be associated with anti-US opinions for pragmatic reasons.

verylittlemeat··on The FBI, CIA and NSA say American citizens shouldn't use Huawei phones
>economic espionage is a scary threat model

RE: commercial information

Can you suggest any good books on what kind of information a "pragmatic" first world government might collect on citizens for blackmail?

I'm having a hard time thinking of examples aside from say sexual taboos or things that people find shameful for diverse personal social reasons (e.g. eating habits, media habits and so on).

When a citizen isn't engaged in explicitly illegal behavior is it really that easy to threaten someone's life/career in exchange for commercial/political information? The types of social/taboo espionage I mentioned above don't seem broadly applicable enough for a government to really bother with it as a generic model for blackmail.

verylittlemeat··on The FBI, CIA and NSA say American citizens shouldn't use Huawei phones
I really don't think it's bots. Being contrarian, anti-US government and skeptical bordering on conspiracy are all strong HN norms.

I'm not really saying that to be dismissive but it seems like a shared culture on this site since the fallout of Snowden (right or wrong, I'm just describing how I see things play out here).

HN seems to lean more towards the conception of reality where we're playing 9-Dimensional chess vs "attribute things to ignorance not malice."

verylittlemeat··on Fritz Haber: A Monster Who Fed the World
The United States doesn't conscript soldiers and yet can find hundreds of thousands of infantry soldiers to wage war.

I don't think it's controversial to say that there's way more going on behind the effort to staff an army than threat of punishment from the government. Historically there are many examples of citizens eager to line up and fight for their country (whether for pragmatic or idealistic reasons). This isn't just patriotic rhetoric, it's a very powerful social force once set in motion.

If our species has any enduring trait then violent conflict through war must be pretty close to the top of the list.

verylittlemeat··on Unilever threatens to pull its ads from Facebook and Google over 'toxic content'
It helps that cigarette smoking is physically addicting.
verylittlemeat··on Ancient kids’ toys have been hiding in the archaeological record
The same thing happened with the ancient Venus statues being considered fertility objects. The truth is your guess is as good as anyone's.
verylittlemeat··on How did Google Talk change from a dream to a nightmare?
Yes Discord is starting to really starting to dominate.

More and more often these days you'll find at the bottom of a community info page a discord rather than an IRC channel. Even big pirating communities are making the switch.

verylittlemeat··on A photographer capturing subcultures that refuse to die
To some extent though can you blame people for this form of cultural trolling? Some people will get violent with anger over what someone is wearing. Having the power to expose such a ridiculous reaction is probably very satisfying.
verylittlemeat··on A photographer capturing subcultures that refuse to die
To be honest though I think this is where a lot of the resentment of non-conformists comes from.

A conformist feels on a gut level that you're doing something "for attention" and resents you for that.

Of course even if that were true such resentment is ridiculous. But to me I think there is always an element of "cultural challenge" in non-conformity (even if say 99% of a man wearing a dress is deeply personal choice).

verylittlemeat··on A photographer capturing subcultures that refuse to die
In my experience some of the most toxic criticism short of physical violence comes from not acknowledging what someone believes are logical conclusions.

So wearing a dress is fine if the person wearing it is willing to concede at every moment that they're being socially deviant. The moment that you just wear a dress and make no attempt to justify yourself in terms of larger culture is when things get bad. Wearing a dress and acting like it's no big deal is an affront to the logic of someone who knows for a fact what you're doing is deviant..and they're convinced that you deep down know it too. You're more or less saying they think wrong in a very fundamental way. That gets people very upset.

verylittlemeat··on In a society obsessed with success, how do we come to terms with failure?
You're absolutely right. People should be free to choose to have kids if they want. On the other hand those same people should not project their expectations on others. We all come to our values through a complex combination of nature and nurture.

That is really the spirit of my comment.

verylittlemeat··on In a society obsessed with success, how do we come to terms with failure?
I mean the following without snark even though it can easily be read that way:

I contribute to society by making the choices I want and not imposing my expectations of contribution on to others.

The best thing you can do for society is take care of yourself first, because that's what you have the most control over. How justified is much of the debt, guilt and obligation that we feel? I guess most of us believe that if we shirked these things then babies would be abandoned in the streets and all sorts of lawlessness would occur.

Is my lifestyle naive and selfish? Maybe. But I know who I am and I don't have to justify my choices to anyone else. I am not going to make a list of my good deeds to make sure people respect me. What if instead of trying to save the world so you can be happy you chose to be happy and that led to you saving the world? Why do we assume the former is more true than the latter?

It's really hard to talk about these things without coming off as being "holier than thou" but I think they're questions worth asking. They're questions I still ask myself all the time, I don't believe that I've reached some higher plane of enlightenment with all the answers.

People should be allowed to suffer and sacrifice their happiness but they have to want to it can't be imposed on them (consciously or not).

verylittlemeat··on Why are successful professionals still working 70 hours a week?
So just because Jeff Bezos has worked tirelessly at Amazon for over two decades that means he's trying to show mommy and daddy he's a big boy? That seems like some next level armchair psychoanalyzing.

For some people "work" is the culmination and intersection of a number of hobbies they have thought about for decades. Some people are lucky enough to have the line between work and play to be so blurred that they get paid ridiculous money to have fun.

verylittlemeat··on In a society obsessed with success, how do we come to terms with failure?
Do you value you that? Then live your life in accordance with achieving that goal. There are lots of ways to see the world, from being a vagrant to a CEO who travels business class to the finest hotels.

I don't value travel enough to change my lifestyle so I wont work toward that end but if you do then you should. I say this with zero judgment or passive aggressive intention.

verylittlemeat··on In a society obsessed with success, how do we come to terms with failure?
It comes down to economic expectations.

I live below the poverty line in the United States and my life is great. My health insurance is 100% free and probably the best in the world. I get financial aid from different government sources that give me a comfortable simple life.

The people who feel they need to own cars or houses and have children struggle to meet their personal expectations. Their struggle and wealth subsidies my lifestyle.

I don't consider wealthy people my enemy or "rich fools." Instead I see them as people who psychologically for one reason or another have certain expectations about what life is supposed to be. They wouldn't want my life for free and I wouldn't want their life at a cost. Does my lifestyle carry a social stigma? Of course. But do I really care what someone else thinks when I'm basically allowed to live in a first world country for free? Not even a little bit.

To me this is as fair as you can probably get in an economic system.

verylittlemeat··on The Opium Wars Still Shape China’s View of the West
Sounds simliar to the US dustbowl where people were starving but entire crops were allowed to rot to protect commodity prices.
verylittlemeat··on Keeping the Art of Silent Film Music Alive
If we're sharing our favorites then I don't think you can go wrong with La Passion de Jeanne d'Arc (1928).

The criterion collection version is great and watch it with Richard Einhorn's Voices of Light, especially if it's your first time.

It's one of the more high profile silent films but with good reason. If you want to try something different with friends but don't want them to fall asleep I've had good success with this film.

verylittlemeat··on How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth
It's basically advocating a conspiracy theory.

"Well, we can't PROVE someone isn't exfiltrating chat logs, therefore slack can't really be secure"

What is the value of this statement? How is it an indictment of slack's security?

From the podcast :

"Geoff also concludes that companies should encourage basic security hygiene rather than seek a silver bullet that does not exist."

So despite good law enforcement people get away with crimes. What exactly is the insight there? What is the actionable information for both slack and law enforcement of these "unknown unknowns?"

verylittlemeat··on How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth
It is a poor comparison. If I'm being intentionally obtuse then the parent is being willfully disingenuous.

Lower detection of crime doesn't mean less crime and higher detection of crime doesn't mean more crime.

The point is the crime rate as a tool to understand the effectiveness of law enforcement is useless.

This is a common problem I see all the time in "fact based" circles. People care more about the fact that the needle is moving rather than questioning if they're even measuring what they think they're measuring.

verylittlemeat··on How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth
I really don't see this as anything other than a gotcha argument and I feel bad for anyone you tried to use it on who couldn't defend themselves in the heat of the moment.

The crime rate is a known political tool that is actively manipulated for political gain (stop and frisk anyone?). Everyone knows that being "tough on crime" is moral statement not a statement of fact. Outside of crime averages that operate on a continuum the crime rate is so subjective as to almost be useless.

I would say "the crime rate is down" as an argument is roughly equivalent to believing that any given president has an impact on the DJIA. Look at the cover of the NYPOST yesterday[0]. Attributing a president who has been in office for a year with anything having to do with the economy is almost always untrue [1]. In fact, if anything it's more likely that Trump is benefiting from the policies of his predecessor.

So in conclusion the "crime rate" is never up or down, it's just one tool in the political handbook to try and manipulate people with fear, uncertainty and doubt. As a basis of establishing policy it's almost always rhetoric. To further elaborate on your comment, it has less to do with when a crime is "detected" and more to do with what is a crime.

[0] https://i.imgur.com/uifDjWI.png

[1] https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/a-presidents-economic-d...

verylittlemeat··on Designing Social Systems Without Causing Depression and War
What is the value of a popular baseless comment on the internet?

In my opinion there is a system of homeostasis that exists in internet comments. When a popular wrong opinion gets large enough it is a huge low hanging fruit. There is a race to be the first one to debunk it and cash in all the delicious "well, actually" karma. Go look at the top comment on any given hacker news thread. I wouldn't be surprised to find an overwhelming number of "well, actually" child comments immediately below them.

Furthermore, popular anonymous comments are nice but the real world still operates on reputation based media. A popular comment might inspire a reporter at a media source of record to write an article about it but you can bet their first order of business is to cut out the rhetoric and make the opinion seem as objective as possible. In many cases once you cut out the rhetoric of a baseless popular opinion there is no article, so on a larger social scale the popular comment basically dead in the water. A firstname-lastname reporter is thinking in terms of a career, not upvotes. That's why when you read the sources of a non-fiction book you see The New York Times and not The Slashdot Comment Section.

* Also I just want to clarify that the "someone" in my original reply to your comment was not a veiled accusation, I literally meant someone (anyone). It was not a passive aggressive attempt suggest that you are getting too emotionally involved with your comments. I merely meant that a lot of people (myself included) get too caught up in thinking that 1. they are objectively right and 2. lack of recognition of this fact must mean that the system is broken.

verylittlemeat··on Designing Social Systems Without Causing Depression and War
I'm not so crazy about this criticism. Whenever I hear someone complain about echo chambers or contrary opinions being hidden it seems to me a case of "my personal opinion isn't being validated in this discussion." Does any forum on the internet ever claim that the most upvoted (or whatever metric) comments are the correct ones for all time?

A popular opinion doesn't make other opinions invalid and I think that's a mistake many people read into the situation because they're too emotionally invested. On top of that it completely ignores the countless variables that go into a top comment on a popular forum.

The best advice I can give is either 1. Don't take the unpopularity of your contributions so seriously or 2. take it so seriously that you're willing to understand how to game the system to MAKE your "objectively correct" opinion popular.

verylittlemeat··on Designing Social Systems Without Causing Depression and War
I'm not sure if "populist" is as pejorative as you think it is when describing HN.

Is it possible to have a forum on the internet with hundreds of active users that doesn't leverage a populist model (upvotes/favorites/likes)? Even places where the comments aren't ranked by the users they ARE ranked by activity (bumps/views) behind the scenes.

It seems like it would be very difficult to decouple "populism" from any large public forum worth reading so I'm skeptical of this criticism of HN. I would argue that it's disingenuous to accuse HN of mere populism without you defining your terms because even academics are skeptical of any one defintion. In many ways your use of "populist" is nothing more than a slur.

verylittlemeat··on Lyft says nearly 250K of its passengers ditched a personal car in 2017
- nyc has a huge park right in the middle of it and many large ones like prospect and forest park in brooklyn. Upstate new york has some of the greatest hiking in the country. Any number of stops 2 hours or less north of the city will take you to breathtaking natural sights

- I have been to nearly every state in the US. Amtrak and public transit.

- living in a major city means most of the events are here, not in surrounding isolated areas

>"You are a person who doesn't travel, and says they don't want to."

Like I said I've been all over the US and I definitely never said I don't want to travel. It takes a serious lack of imagination to believe you need a license to go places.

>"You are practically tied to your community."

Yup all 9 million of them in their diverse splendor.

BTW for the non driving curious it's very easy to do all of this touristy "I drive because I can go to national parks!!!!" stuff. While travelling around the US for 4 months (without a car) I found that almost every hostel I stayed at offered numerous daily vans for groups who wanted incursions to almost anywhere interesting in the area. Like I said many drivers don't even know these things exist because they're so tied to car culture.

In my experience with travel a car is for people with specific destinations. If you're more of a "the trip is the experience" type of person, you lose a lot of local color by just shutting yourself in your own world from point A to point B.

edit: in response to your edit, I think my original comment addressed your "on the road" suggestion well enough. Let me suggest one thing about your tone. If you find driving a car romantic in the vein of "On the Road" more power to you, I'm not gonna tell you what you know you understand and enjoy. But on the other hand I think you should step back for a minute and think about how much you REALLY know about public transit in the United States considering you willingly admit navigating public transit isn't really your cup of tea. Maybe rather than buying all of the "can you believe America doesn't have bullet trains!!!" hacker news echo chamber you should consider that living a perfectly fulfilling licenseless life is not just possible but actually preferable, yes, here in the "dire broken infrastructure" of the united states.

verylittlemeat··on How Automakers Invented the Crime of “Jaywalking”
So then who exactly is the OP arguing against? Who here is arguing people living in suburbs with no public transit should give up their cars?

The OP argues not owning a car is a "virtuous shtick" and then: "You have no social life with no car" and "People here [hacker news] don't get how limited your life is without a car."

Such ridiculous claims deserve to be challenged since the OP seems to be speaking about car ownership in general, not just people living in suburbs.

verylittlemeat··on Leap: An Online Community for Women
Careful, given the current atmosphere of sexual politics I'm not sure it's safe for even a woman to suggest women are more timid than men.

(in the past this would be sarcasm but these days who knows)

verylittlemeat··on Lyft says nearly 250K of its passengers ditched a personal car in 2017
It's just a hassle.

For you the cost in time and money is worth it. For other people like myself it's just not. I know "virtue signaling" is the hot new way to disagree with people on the internet but you should use it in a more discriminating manner.

Getting a permit is not free in terms of time or money. Getting a license takes even MORE time (pointless outdated mandatory education classes) and MORE money (lessons). That's not even considering taking the written and driving tests themselves. Or going to the DMV.

Yeah I know, all of this is super easy, look at the kind of people who drive, how hard could it be? But you know what I could be doing with my TIME and with my MONEY instead? All the things I want to do that I value more than driving.

Obviously this thinking is just amplified when you take into consideration gas/insurance/maintenance. And this doesn't even get into the psychological impact of driving a car. You know what one of my favorite things in the world is? Reading a book on my 2 hour commute home on the train. My sister just recently got her license and I can honestly say (no virtue signaling I promise) that it has taken a psychological toll on her. She would admit herself that being a driver has made her a more angry and on edge person than she was before.

Also it's pretty rosy speculation to suggest access to national parks has anything to do with motivation for car ownership. I think it's safe to say that can be covered almost entirely by "I need it for my job."

verylittlemeat··on How Automakers Invented the Crime of “Jaywalking”
I'm in my 30s / no license / live in nyc my whole life

I would be surprised to learn someone over the age of 16 doesn't have their license in a new england suburb. In my limited experience public transit is terrible in smaller US cities.

The truth is in NYC I don't even think about owning a car. In fact the opposite is true, sometimes I think to myself "wow, I'm so glad I can live my life and don't have to worry about all that car related stuff."

I'm not saying that's true anywhere else. I'm not telling you to feel guilty about owning a car. All I'm saying is that in NYC in 2018, no, life really isn't limited without a car. This isn't virtue signaling this is a calculated part of life for many people living in major cities. Public transit isn't perfect but the cost/benefit of car ownership overhead just isn't worth it in some places.

verylittlemeat··on Leap: An Online Community for Women
I'm not a woman so I'm not going to try and address what women do or don't feel about HN but I just want to say:

>“I’ve found that some conversations online escalate to shouting matches quickly”

How many people can find a group of people IN GENERAL (online/offline/anywhere) that doesn't rapidly devolve into power/politics/passive & active aggressive behavior? Go spend some time on a forum like metafilter where you have to pay $5 to comment and the moderators aggressively prune any opinion that doesn't tow a nominal progressive line. Even with all of that you end up with some of the most breathtakingly toxic behavior I've seen on any forum.

In my opinion Leap is a wonderful innovation. It will help lots of people realize being an asshole does not know gender.

← PreviousPage 10 of 12Next →