HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vezzy-fnord

16,839 karma · joined September 9, 2013

submissionscomments
vezzy-fnord··on Why the Assholes Are Winning: Money Trumps All
The monetary theories come from E.C. Riegel and Thomas J. Greco.

Both models are fine. Private currencies have historically come from a variety of institutions. You could have a particular mutual credit bank issuing certificates convertible to a valued commodity as an incentive for locals to trade in and coordinate infrastructure renovation or other projects. You could have labor vouchers redeemable for some hourly or other unit of work, as Josiah Warren tried them.

Right now there are models like CES and time banking that are somewhat active but highly limited as a result of jurisdictional constraints.

There's no particular limit to level of subsidiarity or type of currency. Local currencies have a history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local_currency#Characteristics

vezzy-fnord··on Why the Assholes Are Winning: Money Trumps All
Subsidiarity is decentralization. You can't consistently abide by the principle of subsidiarity otherwise. The United States has tried, and the result is what is called "marble cake federalism". The demarcation between federal and state lines has become so ambiguous that virtually all programs are odd chimeras of both. State programs financed by federal funds with strings attached, or federal programs that are mandated on states without giving them any special funds for it, so on and so forth.
vezzy-fnord··on Why the Assholes Are Winning: Money Trumps All
Your definition is non-standard. You seem to be conflating public with common. They're two different things.
vezzy-fnord··on Why the Assholes Are Winning: Money Trumps All
It was the "profit seekers" who were some of the hardest advocates for mass public education. See, for instance, John D. Rockefeller's General Education Board.

The education system that we ultimately got was a far cry from John Dewey's philosophy, no matter how much lip service he receives.

vezzy-fnord··on Why the Assholes Are Winning: Money Trumps All
Distinction without a difference. Of course there will always be some unemployment for disability or other reasons.

As far as I can see, only industrialists who profit from lower wages and a more docile workforce would be against this.

Job guarantee proposals are minimum wage. Even if they were not, the idea that industrialists benefit from a "docile workforce" is couching things in a questionable Marxian reserve army of labor analysis. It's not as if state-administered job guarantees are going to be tools of empowering the working class. It's going to be administered as a neutral tool for economic efficiency. Even then, the industrialists absolutely benefit from easy access to a minimum wage workforce.

It was an attempt to marry it to Neoclassical economics, which was antithetical to Keynesianism in the first place.

Nonsense. Keynes came from the neoclassical Marshallian tradition.

No it wasn't. It was Hicks and Meade trying to apply some sort of equilibirium fetishism to the theory of interest, employment and money.

Yes, it was. Hicks and Meade only developed one particularly influential variant, and they were inspired by notes from Keynes' lecture attendees who were taught a four-equation model with almost no major difference other than having an exogenous variable for "state of the news" (expectations). Ultimately this was not a major difference, since neo-Keynesians like James Tobin did focus on such areas, and on financial instability as well.

Robert W. Dimand documents the origins of IS-LM and Keynes' Marshallian roots in a 2007 paper: http://www.unites.uqam.ca/philo/keynes/docs/dimand.pdf

vezzy-fnord··on Why the Assholes Are Winning: Money Trumps All
I presume Canada has legal tender laws, which effectively create a Gresham's law situation of bad money crowding out the good in the process. There are likely other confounding reasons, as well.

The private organizations are certainly large and centralized. They are this way largely because of legal climates that subsidize their inefficiencies and inhibit the onset of diseconomies of scale.

It's not a proper interpretation to think of the government and the private sector as being opposed. After all, governments do want economic growth and competitiveness in international trade. As such, their actions will often be to help private corporations get larger through protectionist measures that might have good short-term effects (higher employment and larger industry) at the expense of the long-term effects when the propped up large industry inevitably starts to trample on the citizens it was supposed to help. Again, the solution is not to keep engaging in the vicious circle of reform, but settle it grassroots at last.

Gabriel Kolko's The Triumph of Conservatism documents this process quite well during the U.S. Progressive era. Governments and corporations collude for shared ends more often than not. Corporations are creatures of the state, let's not forget.

vezzy-fnord··on Why the Assholes Are Winning: Money Trumps All
But the whole sentiment that looks down on poverty and exalts exorbitant wealth in of itself which the author underlines, emerges from the same train of thought that treats labor and full employment as the end of all ends. There's little functional difference between the conservative presenting a just world where hard work ensures success, from a social democrat who argues for large-scale centralization to shuffle people into the same capitalist institutions they allegedly look down on because "people want jobs". They're both far-reaching implicit assumptions of a labor theory of value in structuring a society.

Indeed, it was the neo-Keynesian focus on full employment that led to short-sighted reliance on economic models like expectations-agnostic Phillips curves and IS-LM models with interest-sensitive money demand to the exclusion of other macro considerations, that ultimately culminated in a stagflation bust in the 1970s. Nor was this even a perversion of Keynesianism. It was Keynes himself who formulated simultaneous-equations IS-LM in lectures from 1933-1934.

Employment as end in of itself also led to mercantilist-era injustices.

But again, this is tangential to the issue of money.

vezzy-fnord··on Why the Assholes Are Winning: Money Trumps All
One of the great ironies of contemporary left-leaning commentators is that despite their insistence on paying attention to institutional factors that others allegedly neglect (see how Pfeffer constructs the popular but false dichotomy of "self-interest and profit maximization" versus "human well-being, longevity and happiness"), they are largely stuck in thinking in terms of the very same institutions they abhor. Effectively, the current approach is mostly fine, it just needs a few tweaks and reforms to turn it into a "social democracy".

If money is the problem, then the solution is not to engage in petty social democratic welfare reforms, but to end the monopoly on currency and allow for communities and individuals to coordinate savings-investment decisions and account for their local capital using the denomination of currency that they have decided to create. This is the mutual credit solution as advocated by 19th century anarchists and a minority of monetary reformers since then.

Pfeffer quotes Article 23 on the "right to work," and indeed full employment has always been a bizarre fetish for Keynesians, social democrats, Marxists and conservatives. The Protestant work ethic is the right-wing version of the labor theory of value. It is a contradiction how so many bemoan the supposed rat race working conditions and then advocate the "solution" of having the state put everyone into the rat race through full employment policy. Nowhere have I seen any social democratic reformer argue for artisanal crafts and decentralized governance. It's always more and more massive centralization. I will note it was the mercantilists who first provided economic rationales for full employment. And they went to great lengths to achieve it: anti-vagrancy and poor laws to forcefully turn people into serfs. The current proposals are more humane, but borne of the same logic of "to live is to toil".

I will also note that a reason why formal models haven't focused that much on things like subjective utility and happiness is because those suffer from intractable aggregation problems. It's easy to speak of the "public interest" in colloquial language, it is brutally difficult to model and quantify it, actually drawing the line of how far it extends. Then, of course, interpersonal comparison of utility is fraught with issues because there is no measurement of utility as such. Robert Nozick's thought experiments have been good at illustrating this.

This trite paternalistic reformism leads nowhere except to further exacerbation of instability.

vezzy-fnord··on Goldman Sachs May Be Forced to Fundamentally Question How Capitalism Is Working
I never voiced a categorical opposition to all forms of regulation. I just have a general preference for endogenously emerging one over exogenous statute. Remember we are discussing theory, not the actually existing mixed economy. Of course a Microsoft can and has happened under the latter, though legal action also took place.

Nor was that a "No True Scotsman" reply. It's straightforward history. The Hamiltonian program prevailed over Jeffersonian democracy.

Granted, you're failing to draw a distinction between the state and government in the abstract sense of having governance. I would dispute alternate forms of governance being less transparent. If anything, the principle of subsidiarity by which issues of governance should be handled at the most localized and decentralized level would ensure greater transparency and a more effective participation.

"Consumer protection" has been handled by trade associations, private standards bodies and other institutions for centuries. Modern states have largely not devised any particularly new or innovative approaches, merely shifted the ownership thereof.

vezzy-fnord··on Goldman Sachs May Be Forced to Fundamentally Question How Capitalism Is Working
There is sometimes a need for strong regulation to prevent larger participants from using their size to gain an unfair advantage in the market.

The Coasian revolution and public choice schools have since challenged this narrative quite significantly, and have had an impact on economic discourse, though not on mainstream discussion.

The job of regulation is to ensure (as much as is reasonably possible) that no one gains an unfair advantage.

George Stigler devastated that interpretation, as well.

Nevertheless, I am talking about an ideal vision that we should strive toward.

Indeed, this is an ideal discussion. Hence I can't give you a straight example of a "non-governmental regulation that doesn't ultimately derive authority from government," though in fairness this is ambiguous. It happens that the judicial branch is governmental, but the very act of informal bargaining between property owners is endogenous, non-governmental regulation. You could also argue that private certification and standards agencies are endogenous regulators.

I am currently reading a book about the so-called "Robber Barons" of the later half of the 19th century. If you want to see what truly unconstrained capitalism looks like, I suggest you read up on this period: fraud, price-fixing, market manipulations, extortion, bribery

The so-called "robber baron" era was not one of truly unconstrained capitalism at all. The "robber baron" era had the strict mercantilist and interventionist policies of Alexander Hamilton, Friedrich List and the American School economists in full effect. Above all, it was driven by a complex interaction of tariffs (people keep forgetting how important tariffs were in United States history), land law acts and railroad subsidies, with heavy political collusion.

After you're done with that book, I suggest you read Gabriel Kolko's Railroads and Regulation, 1877-1916 to get a fuller picture. Ironically, the author was a member of the New Left.

vezzy-fnord··on Goldman Sachs May Be Forced to Fundamentally Question How Capitalism Is Working
The benefit that a free market is expected to give to society is, as far as I know, that it will cause a "survival of the fittest" scenario in which the best solutions for a problem gain widespread acceptance and bad solutions die out.

Not at all the case. You're injecting Social Darwinist assumptions. The benefit of a free market is in having individuals coordinate their plans most efficiently based on their subjective preferences and valuations, with prices as an epistemic vehicle for conveying notions of scarcity, opportunity for arbitrage or other criteria. It is thus a continuous and dynamic disequilibrium process that one cannot anticipate through outside observation, as optimal outcomes are by definition always being revised, renewed and discovered endogenously.

But that of course only works if there is actual competition - which in many fields isn't the case in our current situation.

Competitiveness is one aspect, but a much more important one is constestability. Free markets are by definition ones allowing for the greatest degree of it. And I absolutely agree that our current situation is far from optimal. We are not discussing our current situation, however. Monopolies are a multifaceted subject, many of them based on rents obtained from IP law and hardly "natural".

Similar thinks can happen with large-scale accumulation of property.

There are things called diseconomies of scale that put upper bounds on the profitability and viability of being too big. Economic calculation issues set in, principal-agent inefficiencies, coordination problems and so forth. It is only through the subsidy of an exogenous body such as government that one can hobble along in inefficacy for exorbitantly long times.

vezzy-fnord··on Goldman Sachs May Be Forced to Fundamentally Question How Capitalism Is Working
Firstly, most common standards for gauging market failure and inefficiency are based on static, institution-less Paretian general equilibrium and/or social choice models that require interpersonal utility comparisons, among other things. The public choice and Virginia school of political economy have critiqued those. More broadly, the subject of dynamic market process has been explored by Roy Cordato, Gerald P O'Driscoll and Mario Rizzo (The Economics of Time and Ignorance), Israel Kirzner and other later Austrian School authors.

I already listed you three authors about banking and finance. More broadly, we already live in the system that you advocate, and it does not work.

vezzy-fnord··on Goldman Sachs May Be Forced to Fundamentally Question How Capitalism Is Working
I'm advocating for actually getting acquainted with economic literature and not repeating moronic talking points about "redistributive and regulatory role of governments" that are filled with theoretical and empirical problems, and in any event are not a radical new idea but how it has always been to begin with. Whether it was anti-vagrancy and poor laws or the modern welfare state. Whether it was mercantilism or the state-guided capitalism of today.
vezzy-fnord··on Goldman Sachs May Be Forced to Fundamentally Question How Capitalism Is Working
"Perfect information" is an assumption used in static Paretian general equilibrium models, but it does not reflect any existing dynamic reality, and it is not at all a necessary prerequisite for free markets. Market power is vulnerable. "Interchangeable goods and services" - I honestly have no idea how you could come up with such a delusional prerequisite.

You seem to have confused neoclassical models for an attainable ideal compatible with empirical reality. But our world is one of disequilibrium, dispersed knowledge, plan coordination - ones most apt for a market and a free one at that. You are completely out of vogue.

vezzy-fnord··on Goldman Sachs May Be Forced to Fundamentally Question How Capitalism Is Working
A "free market" means lots of buyers and sellers participating on even playing field.

I've never seen this definition used before. Even playing field is a grossly inappropriate and unattainable normative ideal. Even playing field means homogenization, which is completely antithetical to a market as a vehicle for coordinating entrepreneurial plans, necessarily implying imperfections and heterogeneity.

Even Adam Smith acknowledged that government regulation is necessary in order to ensure that the market remains free.

Regulation is certainly necessary, at least in the sense of property rights enforcement and dispute adjudication. Government regulation it need not be, and it need not be anything more than a minimal legal institutional framework.

Left to their own devices, however, capitalists will naturally (and rationally) try to tilt the playing field in their favour.

How did you reach this conclusion? It makes no sense whatsoever. If anything, we would expect this behavior to occur only where there are large amounts of government regulation. That is to say, when there is more opportunity to exploit the political method over the economic method. Otherwise, how will they tilt the playing field? By forming cartels? Those are brittle. Any attempt at trying to use market power leaves you vulnerable to undercutting in some way in the absence of special privileges.

I am against capitalism, however, under a completely laissez faire economy.

Your taxonomy is worthless.

vezzy-fnord··on Goldman Sachs May Be Forced to Fundamentally Question How Capitalism Is Working
In case you haven't noticed, this has been how virtually all first-world states have operated for decades. This social democratic ideal has not worked out, but has led to a dysfunctional corporate statism where mere "deregulation" (which is a misnomer, as most cases of deregulation have really been regulatory adjustments in an overall baroque framework that unsurprisingly lead to new pathological regulatory states - just because you cut some edges off the graph doesn't mean the nodes are going to stand still) can lead to catastrophe. This is an example of the state being entrusted to ensure smooth regulation, and failing miserably at their task.

In fact, many banking panics and examples of financial fragility have originated from pathological financial regulations guided by desires of the state to subvert various public finance constraints. Authors like George Selgin, Kevin Dowd and Lawrence H. White have written on this subject.

vezzy-fnord··on Goldman Sachs May Be Forced to Fundamentally Question How Capitalism Is Working
Scarcity is not a property of physical abundance, but of use. To say that scarcity is over would effectively mean all wants have been satisfied and the economy has reached its final state of rest, and this is ludicrous. You can have a bundle of inert goods, but as soon as they are employed to fulfill plans, they become different goods where spatial, territorial and property constraints enter into motion.

Also people have been saying this for a long time and it has yet to bear out. Galbraith was railing on about the affluent society, how corporations are somehow artificially inventing wants through advertising and the necessity of an activist state. Developed countries have had their states get larger and more activist to no avail.

vezzy-fnord··on Tcl/tk vs. the web
The web's lack of "installation" is countervailed by its ad-hoc persistence methods like local storage, cookies, cache and sessions, as well as its forms of authentication in relation thereof. You can hang yourself on the web just as easily, perhaps even more so, and I have seen it happen many times. The web also has the intrinsic problem of unpredictability and unaccountability. Entire layouts can be replaced by developers instantaneously on unwitting users.

Most people would not download Office, of course, but use a friend or acquaintance's pre-recorded media. Actually even if it came to torrenting it, it wouldn't be significant of a load.

vezzy-fnord··on Tcl/tk vs. the web
Self-fulfilling prophecy: "Real people" are using web applications at higher rates because of programmers inevitably using the web as their main platform, creating a self-sustaining feedback loop. But, what the herd can adopt, it can also destroy.

FWIW I'm sure people who live in jurisdictions with subpar connectivity would appreciate a renaissance of desktop applications.

vezzy-fnord··on Tcl/tk vs. the web
Or, speaking of Sun, something akin to NeWS: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NeWS
vezzy-fnord··on The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness
The marginalist conception of value is indeed underwhelming, but it's also a compromise. Determining value through mathematical exercises using hypothetical n-commodity worlds with homogeneous factors and units is at best useful as an exposition for a theory of income distribution (as Sraffa tried to do) in that by assuming a labor or commodity theory of value you can attempt to argue for a rate of exploitation.

Marxian economics has a whole lot of categories that are awkward, like "constant capital" being homogeneous and "variable capital" referencing wages of labor in producing commodities. There's barely any room for disequilibrium effects, complementarity, reserves and so forth. In turn, the organic composition of capital is held to be c/s+v, but empirical evidence on relation between OCC and crisis is scant and the concept of OCC is again completely foreign to uncertainty, disequilibrium and capital structure. It's just a ratio between two questionable taxonomies. Marxian economics has many similar failings as neoclassical economics, but because of its origins as a heterodox critique of Smith, Ricardo and Mill from a particular period, its evolution has been even more confusing.

Marginalism is situated in a means-ends framework, which is the most one can really say about value without introspecting into personal intentions and valuations. It should be underlined that neoclassical production theory (MC=MR) is separate from the subjective theory of value proper, however. Menger, Jevons and Walras all had different takes on it.

It's also worth noting that Marxian conceptions of use and exchange value have little to say about contemporary monetary and financial economies. Marxians still focus too much on issues like falling rate of profit, accumulation and OCC and often miss elephants in the room like financial fragility, or downplay them. It strikes me as archaic.

Whether or not markets compute or define exchange value seems to me like a problem of overaggregation where the contemporary social institution of a "market economy" is conflated with a market in the abstract as a system of mutual exchange, as in Proudhon and others.

vezzy-fnord··on Privatization Means Rebuilds
Library mismatches, dependency conflicts and progressive destabilization/entropy (system package configurations approaching global failure conditions like boot stalling as time passes and upgrades are made) were all frequent experiences I had on dpkg-based systems with the APT frontend that ultimately made me return to Slackware and its spartan package management where I have since experienced nothing of the sort.

This is likely a YMMV issue.

vezzy-fnord··on The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness
But use value cannot be quantified, since utility is not a mathematical scale, but a subjective feeling that varies from person to person and with time as preferences shift or swing. I'm also unaware of how you can explain diverse business cycles throughout history as emanating from it.

Practically every economic theory that has tried to objectively quantify "value", i.e. those of Ricardo, Marx and Sraffa, relies on gigantic and complicated expositions involving leaps of abstraction and mathematical transformation problems that are completely detached from how real-world people actually think about or treat value.

(Indeed, such exercises in value theory aren't so much about determining value as much as trying to work out given theories of income distribution and perceived exploitation.)

vezzy-fnord··on The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness
In an interview, he clearly states that he favors maximization of state power in some narrowly defined "short term," and largely believes that the only alternative to a state is anarcho-syndicalism. He's relying on it withering away. [1]

I know full well he isn't a liberal and never implied that he's one (in the modern Galbraith sense). Nonetheless, most analyses by the revolutionary left are definitely slanted towards a picture of painting the issue as being primarily one of corporate hegemony.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PiqPCRtzOBw

vezzy-fnord··on The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness
What you're describing might explain fluctuations, but it's inadequate and incomplete for the business cycle.

Virtually no one, not even Keynesian or other left-economists support make-work. It's mostly an idea favorable to laymen, or often done for more nationalistic rather than economic reasons. FDR was inspired by William Trufant Foster's and Waddill Catchings' policy advice for instance, who had Keynesian-esque underconsumptionist views but did not derive these from any economic theory per se.

Even ardent Keynesians will advocate a more sophisticated proposal of what amounts to government-owned employment agencies that combine private contract procurement with state investment projects, with the intention of having the unemployed serve as buffer stocks of labor to meet some form of output target. But not quite brute make-work.

(Actually the "quantifying value" problem makes no sense. It's not as if there is some objective essence called "value" that people seek. Value is largely denominated in units of currency. I suppose what you're getting at is the importance of monetary policy?)

vezzy-fnord··on The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness
Funnily enough Chomsky is implicitly assuming that government spending has a crowding out effect, which is an idea popular with economists who are "hired to develop capitalist theology," as you label them.

But, probably not. Even "social spending" opens up lots of procurement opportunities for the corporate manager. There might be some crowding out in real terms (government having political authority to exclude activity it deems to be an interference), but it'll be offset by the likely benefits of ensuing expansion, corporate welfare grants and workforce mobilization.

The problem with Chomsky here and many others is that they have the causality backwards. They see corporations as evil entities that spontaneously emerged from the ground to usurp the state, when in fact they were explicitly cultivated by states looking for economic growth.

vezzy-fnord··on The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness
Monetarism is just a theory of the transmission mechanism going from money supply->price level->output, with some variations. Their policy proposals have been quite diverse.

Keynes himself had differing policy recommendations, as well, but ultimately settled on what he called "socialization of investment" where the state would fill in certain entrepreneurial activities that the private sector is deemed to be lacking, though the specifics were elusive. Contracyclical fiscal policy was actually popularized by Alvin Hansen IIRC, and the more extreme functional finance favored by Post-Keynesians was formulated by Abba P. Lerner.

vezzy-fnord··on Free Trade with China Wasn't Such a Great Idea for the U.S
Money is merely one slightly special and easy-to-measure token in an economy, but it isn't really what economics is about.

"It is self-contradictory to discuss a process which admittedly could not take place without money, and at the same time to assume that money is absent or has no effect." - F.A. Hayek, The Pure Theory of Capital, 1941: p. 31

Certainly, this is not to say economics is about money. However, to assume any form of monetary neutrality in the short or long run is a folly, for any economy governed by monetary exchange has a critical relationship with monetary and financial institutions. Monopolies on issuance of currency complicate recovery, as well.

If anything, many economists neglect money. Indeed, it was naive IS-LM models with interest-insensitive money demand functions was what ignited the so-called "monetarist counterrevolution".

vezzy-fnord··on Free Trade with China Wasn't Such a Great Idea for the U.S
Corporations exist only because of the legal fiat of "nations" (nation states, anyway).

But, certainly not. Mercantilism benefits corporations much more strongly. Diseconomies of scale can be mostly inhibited through a strategically designed trade and fiscal policy. Slower falling unit production costs and opportunities for price fixing abound, as the "nation" (well, non-aristocratic taxpayers, anyway) bears these costs. Nor do tariffs necessarily reduce unemployment. The mercantile firm may well decide to keep its selling prices stable at a markup (especially given its lower customer base) and just lay workers off in event of supply shocks or other.

Protection is a Faustian gambit for more rapid growth today at the expense of hulking inefficient corporations tomorrow. Corporations that would not exist without it.

vezzy-fnord··on The problem in American education isn't dumb teachers, but dumb teacher training
Indeed, the only complete solution to the schooling system's deficiencies will be its abolition. Education and the accumulation of knowledge should be understood as a subsidiary and decentralized activity, one heavily driven by autodidacticism. Autodidacticism is and always has been the primary force of education, not any formal regimented institution. One does not enter a school and come out "educated" by the receipt of a degree. In fact, the very idea that there can be such a thing as an "education system" is a complete perversity, a self-negating ideal of a social planner.

Schooling should be strongly differentiated from the formation of academic and learning communities. People can still partake in seminars, gather for lectures and conferences, form study groups and even build schools with regular curricula to voluntarily participate in, if such a structure is deemed useful. The accreditation process should be repealed, and a boom in alternative schools (free, democratic, Sudbury, etc.) would likely follow.

Research universities should remain as academic communities, rather than be bogged down by an auxiliary function of serving as ritual prerequisites for entering the labor market.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →