[1] http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/p14.pdf, p. 14
16,839 karma · joined September 9, 2013
[1] http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/p14.pdf, p. 14
That said, I've probably played both over a dozen times each. It truly is a journey and one that seldom gets tedious for some reason.
There's no way I can encode a dynamic disequilibrating market process in this, and it'd be a fool's errand to treat models like this as having to say anything about real-world policy. Capital accumulation is far too dynamic a process to lead to rich-get-richer outcomes, anyway. See Capital and Its Structure (1956).
It's hypocritical too, because institutions like Bard and UMKC are home to a lot of heterodox economists who rant and rave against the neoclassical orthodoxy for making unrealistic assumptions, and then they pull off rigged pseudo-Paretian chicanery like this. An economy of zero transaction cost spot-exchanging automatons without so much as a capital stock.
This is nothing but a political provocation.
The MMT people have made their strides on the blogosphere, and did get Stephanie Kelton into the Senate Budget Committee. They loathe the UBI, however. They want to go straight for a job guarantee, as advocated in e.g. Hyman Minsky's writings. Assuming a Sanders presidency, their vulgar Keynesianism might pass.
These things tend to come and go, especially after crises. Sometimes they succeed. The Townsend Plan was a major impetus for Social Security. But I wonder if in some years we'll still be debating this.
If you don't know the answer to that question, then you are in no position to draw sweeping false dichotomies and grand proclamations as you did above. I have no interest in being your history teacher. I've posted plenty of papers on here, as has nickpsecurity here in the comments, and the link in my parent post provides a decent academic summary by one of the greats in the field.
(I'm not even sure if illumos can be described as "widespread" in any fair sense. In any event, being better than some relative competitors doesn't give one the carte blanche to be a pseudohistorian and denialist.)
He voiced all this here [1], and so I countered by listing stuck paradigms in traditional monolithic Unixes, as well as reopening my inquiry on Sun's Spring research system, which he seems to scoff at, but over which I am impressed by the academic research it yielded. He has yet to respond to my challenge.
The Chicago School has always been quite diverse, from its early days with Frank Knight, Jacob Viner and Henry Simons to later periods of law and economics, new institutionalism and other tendencies.
Saltwater/freshwater came about because of a dispute in the dominant neo-Keynesian macro at the time (which both sides subscribed to) regarding the IS-LM model and the Phillips curve unemployment-inflation trade-off. Naive expositions of IS-LM had ignored the money demand function, which Friedman pointed out and ended up kickstarting the monetarist controversy. Phelps and Friedman also discovered a flaw in the absolutist Phillips curve and augmented it for rational expectations in 1968, destroying its former validity and anticipating the ensuing stagflation. This influenced Barro and Lucas to start the rational expectations revolution in macroeconomics, but it ended up being taken overboard to model always-clearing markets and other perfections.
Make no mistake, though. Both sides were operating in the same general framework. Most Chicagoites absolutely did not deny that there could be aggregate demand shortfalls. They were mostly Keynesians like the rest.
Rob Landley sums it up well: http://landley.net/notes-2010.html#18-07-2010
The Kaldor-Kalecki nonlinear dynamic business cycle model, the Kaleckian profit equation and Robinson's growth model are probably the most interesting results out of that era that still retain an influence on heterodox thinkers.
That said, one should be very wary of all such simplifying models since they all carry contestable assumptions. Nonetheless, they do pose intellectual curiosities.
I don't know if Robert J. Gordon explores this. The Post's review mostly rehashes the more naive dystopian arguments, so I'll have to check.
Not using social media is considered a badge of honor by many. Not using the web (although that's not entirely true in RMS' case, he just heavily limits it [1]) should be considered a commendable feat, too. Since it's RMS, though, it's just another opportunity to disparage him.
He thinks that non-copyleft licensed projects can't work when there are tons of counterexamples.
Where has he said they "can't" work? The FSF lists scenarios where they endorse non-copyleft here: https://www.gnu.org/licenses/license-recommendations.html
RMS himself has encouraged use of non-copyleft in the cases of e.g. Qt and Ogg Vorbis, either as transitional licenses or as means to free up the software when the alternative would have been remaining proprietary. He says as much here: https://lwn.net/2001/0301/a/rms-ov-license.php3
I don't mean New Keynesian partisans like Paul Krugman. Actual Post-Keynesians (particularly Kaleckians and MMTers) and Marxians are rare, though perhaps growing as a result of the aftermath in 2008. Nevertheless, the Great Depression also had major economic cults emerge like the Townsend Plan and Social Credit which since receded.
trickles down
Trickle-down economics works for government spending, eh?
Starting from the contemporary Republican-Democratic dichotomy, you had Henry A. Wallace of the Progressive Party gaining 2.4% (1.1+ million) in 1948, George Wallace of the American Independent Party getting 13.5% in 1968, John B. Anderson as an ex-Republican independent with 6.6% in in 1980 and finally, of course, Ross Perot in 1992 and 1996.
(Eugene V. Debs was also an absolute sensation in the early 20th century. His imprisonment for sedition led to riots and he got 6% of the vote as a socialist in 1920 while in prison. Warren G. Harding commuted his sentence in 1921.)
Thus, Trump is in fact nothing new or all that interesting as far as U.S. politics goes. He's just in time. It had been 19 years since Ross Perot's last candidacy. I don't expect anything consequential to occur out of either Trump or Sanders.
Then amongst traditionalists and others, they can't agree on whether or not classical liberal principles are compatible with Catholic doctrine or not. Christopher Ferrara and others thinks that all of United States history was a giant mistake and that we should revert to pre-Enlightenment theocracy, Tom Woods and others argue that liberalism is what Catholicism logically leads to.
No, there isn't much certainty about overarching principles. That you can't conduct your own life based on secular morality is false. Most people don't conduct their lives on any explicit morality. The ones that have ever pondered these questions in depth have always been a minority. Everyone else has only trickled down breadcrumbs from some clergyman, or ignored it.
The idea that religion provides some sort of certainty is a complete falsehood trivially debunked by a cursory glance of theological discourse. It provides certainty only to those ignorant of it, just as those ignorant of secular philosophy who never deliberate any of these questions have quite likely settled on some ad-hoc worldview that works for them.
In practice, most of value theory is secular. The laws that underpin most contemporary states are secular. The meaning of life is an unanswered question, quite likely even an ironically meaningless question itself. The afterlife if any is also an unanswered question. Christians disagree between universalism, annihilationism, eternal torment and other dogmas on hell alone.
There are no out-of-the-box answers provided by anyone. Many religions actually conveniently avoid pondering them in any detail.
I'm not entirely certain of whether lethal dueling should be permissible, but complete prohibition might not be in order, either.
Not that it should necessarily be encouraged. But to prohibit it entirely seems counterproductive, like the hilariously unenforceable prohibitions against suicide (unless you survive, making you wish you had succeeded once facing the legal consequences).
Of course it's unfair. You have an artificially constrained supply.
I perceive it to be as a means for workers to make certain they have fair working conditions and fair pay for their work as a base.
In the same way, a business cartel is a means for firms to coordinate operations in a manner to mutually benefit in terms of profitability by vertically integrating stages of production or through more brute price gouging arrangements.
Of course, they have a high incentive to break down as a result of disobeying to exploit new opportunities from the leveling that has been done.
Unions serve the same function, but on the demand side (more specifically wage laborers). You can't support one without also allowing for the other.
Apparently we are at whim of a "single private company" controlling our transportation, but somehow being at the whim of state governments is not an issue at all.
Circumventing local regulations makes you a greedy monopolist, but instituting outrageous item and price controls doesn't.
And of course, the ultimate irony: complaining about monopolization and cartelization while praising unions. I'm not opposed to unions, but they are demand-side bargaining cartels and to be in denial over this makes you look disingenuous.
If this is "capitalism at its worst," I can only be horrified at imagining what the author thinks "capitalism at its best" will be. Food rationing, I presume.
Terrible article. Only gives more ammunition against left-leaning commentators and nothing else.
If that is implemented, coming generations would be well civilized and well behaved as it eliminates many societal problems.
Oh boy. Not even wrong.
See: Deschooling Society by Ivan Illich, Compulsory Miseducation by Paul Goodman, anything written by John Taylor Gatto, John Holt and A.S. Neill.
It's also trivially disprovable by mere observation.
No, it's a problem with the state. The state is not the society.
We are in the best time to implement true democracy.
No, we are not. No one knows what it even is.
Are the red and blue candidates your only choice?
That's a majoritarian consideration. Eliminating that for the U.S. is only one of many issues.
Is it so hard to implement a better way to field candidates based on merits/goods
Yes, it is extraordinarily hard. As a practical matter, any system based on electing representatives makes it impossible to ex ante anticipate the decision making that the representative will actually undertake in office. There is no guarantee that the elected agent will abide by the expectations that they have conveyed to the principal. Further, decision making in a system of collective action has profoundly different semantic considerations and rules from that of a contractual exchange.
(This topic has been well-studied under constitutional economics, voting theory, rational choice and political science. For starting points, see The Logic of Collective Action and The Calculus of Consent followed by Patterns of Democracy. For radical reappraisals, see Organization Theory (Kevin A. Carson) and Democracy: The God That Failed).
Even without that, systemd is still technically unsound in its design: http://blog.darknedgy.net/technology/2015/10/11/0/