HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vezzy-fnord

16,839 karma · joined September 9, 2013

submissionscomments
vezzy-fnord··on Microkernels are slow and Elvis didn't do no drugs
Firstly, there is no "microkernel hatred" on my part, just hatred of pop-opinions of them being a 100% superior technology for all cases.

That's not a "pop-opinion". The popular opinion is exactly the opposite: microkernels are mostly a curiosity at best (if not a travesty) and monolithic kernels do 99.99% of what you want.

You're blinded by your microkernel hatred.

I fully understand the rationale behind running Linux in a microkernel, but it isn't something that reinforces the argument that monolithic kernels are "just inferior".

It isn't meant to reinforce such an argument.

In short, I'd be a lot more impressed if this dude spent the effort he used scouring the internet for quotes building something where he could just show us the code of a microkernel outperforming a monolithic kernel. Enough of the dogma.

Damage control. Those damned quotes from those damned academics, they don't mean a thing! All that matters is my stars on GitHub!

(Oh, and I don't call anyone "fags" either)

It should be obvious I was paraphrasing.

(Anyway, it's unsurprising to see you have no concrete rebuttal whatsoever and have to resort to deflecting.)

vezzy-fnord··on “Because I'm a bastard, and proud of it” (2000)
Actually, I agree with most of this. However, Linus letting in the cgroups branch instead of vetoing it proves the opposite, unless the presence of some kernel debugging (nothing close to kmdb, I'd think) depleted Linus' skills somehow.
vezzy-fnord··on “Because I'm a bastard, and proud of it” (2000)
We'd certainly have less. There would be no reason to presuppose that it would be better: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEFBR14

The key to better software is learning from the research literature, not thinking that you're improving because you write nothing but ASM macros in ed(1) in a TTY emulating a VT100 from the 70s.

vezzy-fnord··on Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2016 Edition
"Desktop system" is vague, but obviously u-kernels can serve as workstations, and hence desktops. CTOS was a major example of its day, if not the purest possible: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convergent_Technologies_Operat...
vezzy-fnord··on “Because I'm a bastard, and proud of it” (2000)
Again, this would require us to reject most advances in software after 1968 if we are to apply the logic consistently. Go back to single-tasking, cooperatively multithreaded systems with static file allocation tables and no access control. Actually even the Multics of 1968 was far more advanced than that.

Fact is, without debuggers, most highly subtle war story bugs would go unsolved. Logic analyzers, tracers and ICEs are debuggers, too. "Debugger" doesn't just mean gdb. Not that there's anything wrong with it.

vezzy-fnord··on Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2016 Edition
It's not bypassing the microkernel. It's using it either as a hypervisor or as a separation kernel [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separation_kernel

vezzy-fnord··on “Because I'm a bastard, and proud of it” (2000)
And yet, hardened Linux developers like Al Viro will rant all about the awful systems design inside and outside of the Linux kernel constantly (cgroups and udev are frequent targets of his). We can thus extrapolate that a lack of a kernel debugger has not reduced leaky abstractions in any measurable way. At best we can only speculate in counterfactuals.

Solaris has a kernel debugger and a more concise architecture.

vezzy-fnord··on “Because I'm a bastard, and proud of it” (2000)
That he has vetoed various frivolous proposals is undeniable. There's nothing "unfathomable" about it. I strongly approve of his visceral policy against people breaking userspace. His particular post linked here is nonsense, however.
vezzy-fnord··on Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2016 Edition
The point is his view about kernel debuggers is complete nonsense, and I'm baffled that you and so many others could ever take it seriously.

Yes, people would be more careful without debuggers, the same way they'd be more careful with cooperative multitasking hanging the system when they forget to yield. That doesn't make it good.

vezzy-fnord··on “Because I'm a bastard, and proud of it” (2000)
What can save your ass is automatic formal verification and static analysis.

That's hardly what I'd rate as "primitive".

That a lot of people carelessly throw together CRUD apps does not contradict what I'm saying. In fact, I'd say most CRUD app development is highly primitive, notwithstanding the complexity of the web platform itself.

Debuggers do tend to sometimes to mask heisenbugs, but this goes the same for just about any tool performing intricate binary analysis. And there's some subtle timing bugs where it's a fact of life that you'll get misleading readings.

vezzy-fnord··on Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2016 Edition
QNX4 is high throughput, mister.

Other contenders include eMCOS and FFMK, though those are obscure.

That said, I don't even understand the logic. HPC clusters where single-percentage overheads really matter are an extremely specialized use case, so of course COTS u-kernels might not cut it. Where's the shocker here?

Response to added: Not necessarily with message passing properly integrated with the CPU scheduler.

Response to added #2: Hosting a single-server is a valid microkernel use case. What's your problem? Isolation and separation kernels are a major research and usage interest.

vezzy-fnord··on “Because I'm a bastard, and proud of it” (2000)
I like how everyone here is discussing the rhetorical style and ignoring the fact that his rejection of kernel debuggers is batshit insane and idiotic, which is the main topic.
vezzy-fnord··on “Because I'm a bastard, and proud of it” (2000)
Absolutely not. Linus has been doing nothing but a managerial role for a long time. His initial cloning of Unix is something that university students across CS departments everywhere practically did as a rite of passage.

Theo de Raadt, on the other hand, has never stopped hacking since his days in NetBSD.

vezzy-fnord··on “Because I'm a bastard, and proud of it” (2000)
I didn't know the better the software, the more primitive the development tools.
vezzy-fnord··on “Because I'm a bastard, and proud of it” (2000)
What the fuck? Everybody here is praising Linus for some of the most perverse and regressive logic imaginable because they enjoy his supposed bravado.

What nonsense. You can apply his exact same logic about kernel debuggers to reject all advances in software made after 1968. If only all programmers used nothing but DOS and ASM on 4-bit CPUs, we would finally be liberated. Finally let "Darwinism in software development" take its course.

(Of course, I'm sure most people commenting here have never hacked on anything more sophisticated than a V7 Unix derivative.)

vezzy-fnord··on Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2016 Edition
"No" would be an understatement: https://lwn.net/2000/0914/a/lt-debugger.php3
vezzy-fnord··on Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2016 Edition
So now you're moving the goalposts with "design wins". Just what are the design wins of a SysV Unix clone like Linux, pray tell? It's hard not to be on the offensive when you seem to beg for it. Where did the Windows comparison come from?

The design wins, of course, should be obvious to anyone willing to do a modicum of research.

vezzy-fnord··on In Memoriam: Ian Murdock
kFreeBSD is still alive, though not a formal Debian port.
vezzy-fnord··on Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2016 Edition
BlackBerry doesn't seem to give out hard numbers for installations, but they have overviews of the market and lists of particular customers per category here: http://www.qnx.com/solutions/industries/automotive/index.htm...

It's not only worth looking how many, but what. They're in vehicles, medical devices, industrial automation, military and telecom. Those are all areas where blunders lead to loss of lives, not just annoying downtimes. Insofar as infotainment and telematics is concerned, they estimate at 60% of 2011, so it's likely your car runs QNX.

vezzy-fnord··on Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2016 Edition
"Widely adopted" is not a synonym for "known by the average consumer".
vezzy-fnord··on Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2016 Edition
I'm not sure what fantasy world you live in where the software industry is always adopting the most technologically superior solutions by default. No industry works like this.

YMMV on mainstream (they are widely adopted, though), but: OKL4, PikeOS, QNX...

It's quite obvious you have no background on the issues and are using this as an opportunity for provocation.

vezzy-fnord··on In Memoriam: Ian Murdock
It's probably the single most ported distribution, from a variety of remixes for desktop, netbook and recovery uses alike to usually being the first target for every microcontroller and single-board.
vezzy-fnord··on Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2016 Edition
Right, because most Linux proponents are kernel hackers. It's quite telling that you have no leg to stand on but to resort to hapless diversions. Or I suppose the flood of researchers who have built viable and innovative microkernel-based architectures throughout the decades are all a bunch of phonies?
vezzy-fnord··on Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2016 Edition
Kernel debuggers exist. Of course, we're all aware of Linus' opinion on the matter.
vezzy-fnord··on Migrating ifs to guards in Swift
Erlang has guard sequences, also a "when" clause: http://erlang.org/doc/reference_manual/expressions.html#id83...
vezzy-fnord··on Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2016 Edition
Tanenbaum was vindicated two decades ago, but most people have yet to get the memo. A lot are under the impression that basic software design principles apply to everything besides operating system kernels, for some reason. And the myth is highly persistent.
vezzy-fnord··on For the Wealthiest, a Private Tax System That Saves Them Billions
I'm not advocating anything personally, I'm saying the GP's proposal might as well go further into decentralized direct democracy, which is clearly the intention.
vezzy-fnord··on Switzerland to vote on banning banks from creating money
I keep trying to repeat that the monetary economics of MMT are not that objectionable, but that the MMT banner encompasses a host of other unrelated conclusions that must be examined separately, and moreover that MMTers do not take public choice seriously. This isn't some shit-flinging that you can address in a blog post. You seem to be completely unable to differentiate across several taxonomies.

(FWIW, I do intend on eventually writing a criticism of Post-Keynesianism in book form, but I'm still in earlier research phases.)

vezzy-fnord··on For the Wealthiest, a Private Tax System That Saves Them Billions
No, the land value tax is one of the most notoriously difficult taxes to properly implement, which is why it's so rare.

(Also, having it in addition to others, instead of making it the traditional Single Tax ruins the whole point.)

vezzy-fnord··on Switzerland to vote on banning banks from creating money
§5 speaks in broad hypotheticals and apologetics of efficiently administrated policy, and is unsurprisingly very weak relative to the accounting and qualitative statements in the previous four sections.

If anything, you've convinced me more that MMTers believe in a perfect State. Post-Keynesian ideas seem to emanate from it. Kalecki and Robinson were outright Marxists, the former basing their economics on class conflict and the latter praising North Korea and Maoist China. The entire Post-Keynesian literature is devoid of public choice considerations, sans one weak paper from ~2004.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →