HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vezzy-fnord

16,839 karma · joined September 9, 2013

submissionscomments
vezzy-fnord··on For the Wealthiest, a Private Tax System That Saves Them Billions
There's a difference between illustrating a qualitative economic phenomenon (which the Laffer curve does) and actually building policy proposals based on it.

It doesn't get more laissez-faire than Rothbard, and here's him ripping apart Reaganomics from 1987: https://mises.org/library/myths-reaganomics

That said, one should be careful on quantifying "incomes" since it's a multifaceted idea.

vezzy-fnord··on For the Wealthiest, a Private Tax System That Saves Them Billions
Might as well just scrap representative democracy as a whole rather than add band-aids like this.

Not that closing tax loopholes is even that huge of an issue. It's mostly a populist talking point. We're not pegged to gold anymore.

vezzy-fnord··on For the Wealthiest, a Private Tax System That Saves Them Billions
Scott Sumner (commenting on John Cochrane) hinted at something similar recently: http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2015/12/heres_john_coch....
vezzy-fnord··on Switzerland to vote on banning banks from creating money
Again, the problem is not the chartalism per se, it's that they read far too much from it for the policy aspects. They basically use the monetary theories as a front for the far more dubious Post-Keynesian policies, which have to be analyzed separately.

A good reading of the Public Choice journal and similar is a nice antidote to some of the zanier MMT and Post-Keynesian proposals.

vezzy-fnord··on Switzerland to vote on banning banks from creating money
The problem with MMT is that it extrapolates far too much from accounting identities and treats both the financial system and the state as a closed vacuum divorced from all issues of public choice and expectations. This is what leads to Mosler's "Seven Deadly Innocent Frauds" and his policy proposals. That they're frauds is technically correct from a national accounting POV, but taking them literally as the MMTers do can be disastrous. In fact, it's not taking them literally that separates MMTers and other people. It's not that mainstream economists aren't aware of the logical implications of ex nihilo fiat money creation.

Also, MMT is nothing new or groundbreaking, contrary to their claims. There have been chartalist and endogenous money creation theories for ages, and most mainstream economists are quite aware of them, contrary to the assertions of many MMTers. What separates MMT from the rest is its fusion with more dubious Post-Keynesian theories.

vezzy-fnord··on How bad are things?
Increased value of what? There's no such thing as this monolithic unit of value that is in conflict with the monolithic unit of profit. Values are not necessarily profits, but profits are values.
vezzy-fnord··on How bad are things?
I wasn't feigning anything. The GP was being unspecific.
vezzy-fnord··on How bad are things?
I had an earlier post listing various resources, originally from a drug-related debate: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10729233 (That you use straw men like opposition to all forms of social organization implies to me you don't have a background on these issues at all, though.)

A consistent pessimism for mankind should involve rejection of authority beyond corporate villains.

As for rejecting various parts of consumer culture, how would I participate in web 2.0 while rejecting walled gardens?

Web 2.0 is a useless term, but since we can assume it refers to social media that is intrinsically walled gardens, you simply do not participate in it. However, that you can't isn't strictly true. Metcalfe's law would make it harder since you'd need to restrict yourself to smaller social sites. Yet you're deriving utility from sites like HN, clearly, so this "Web 2.0" distinction strikes me as elusive. There's plenty of mitigations to lower your exposure to walled gardens while still nominally using them, it's not necessarily a binary proposition of accept/reject. Though, who ever said that rejecting consumer culture would be easy? Going outside any grain involves forgoing opportunities.

Your paragraph about profits is a tautology. Of course unquantifiable (psychic) profits are different and unrelated. Value and profits are not the same thing, and it's a red herring to bring up things like childrearing (which babysitters and nannies do for profit, nevertheless). How does this defy the intrinsic existence of profits and their neutrality? And, certainly, someone may indeed find value and derive profits (psychic or monetary) from conserving fish stocks or any other environment. Not only that, markets can be environmentalist. Check out these guys: http://www.perc.org/

Difficult as it is, the debate around the obesity epidemic is certainly heading in that direction.

No shit, people make decisions ex ante that prove ex post to have been incorrect (by whatever measure). I am unsure of what you intend by invoking the obesity epidemic (I''m presuming specifically for the USA?)

vezzy-fnord··on How bad are things?
Even if you believe "local government is an expression of communion," that would not invalidate the fact that there are important distinctions, as a many political scientist and public choice theorist have outlined. You may well believe it to be a purely benevolent arrangement by and for the people, but that is very weak and ignores problems highlighted by James M. Buchanan, Gordon Tullock and many others.

I don't understand the logic of "Direct family made this decision at some point, therefore you are obligated to perpetually obligate it." The "rightfulness" comes from the fact that the extended family may in fact be harmful and detrimental to one's well-being if it is highly dysfunctional. It can happen.

Our social self-image is dominated by only a few corporations, which have a lot to gain from controlling that image.

The implications of this statement, even if true, are quite unfortunate. It would imply the public is that naive and susceptible, but that moreover they have absolutely no recourse. This is a plain falsehood, they can each reject various parts of consumer culture if they wish, just as I (and presumably you) are doing by abstaining from lots of activities. You may also organize boycotts or engage in activism.

Obviously, without knowing who these corporations are and examining how they emerged, this statement you've given me alone is of little use to deliberate, and mostly makes the public look gullible.

Just as the military motive is intrinsic to a world of uncertainty, I guess. Is developing and deploying nuclear weapons wholly neutral too?

Well, you jumped the shark on this one. Whether you define profits as the speculation in opportunities concerning undervaluation or overvaluation of production factors, or profits as the surplus value extracted from variable capital, or surplus at all, I can't tell how it is anything but neutral. A particular profit-seeker may not be, but profit in general is. Production-for-use is a classic socialist anthem, but in practice it means always operating at subsistence and having distribution be inefficient because of cutting yourself off from a price system. Only in a hypothetical final state of rest/general equilibrium that cannot exist will profits disappear and only interest be obtained.

On the contrary, when the majority of consumers is led to the wrong choice (cue philosophical derailment about moral relativism), it becomes a systemic problem. Maybe it's time to stop relying on 400-year old dogma?

Not really moral relativism, but more that you cannot do interpersonal comparisons of utility. Even if you leave that aside, it is genuinely difficult to say that a majority of consumers are making a wrong choice, if it may be that is what they intended by their own volition. I'm sure going to strip clubs in general would count by a many definition, but, ultimately you have to convincingly prove there is both a massive and predictable irrationality going on. Even when you do, you have to weigh in the costs-benefits of intervention over individual bargaining and Coasian solutions of transaction costs and property rights.

If mine is 400-year old dogma, yours must be much older.

Your post also reads as the most cliched refrain of every economic anarchist. Can you even name one truly free market?

That's not the point, nor am I an economic anarchist. You can't just handwave useful economic research in a pithy one-liner about market irrationality without proposing a consistent model that doesn't lead to outright analytical nihilism, and you absolutely cannot refrain from extending irrationality to all other institutions and examine the effects, over merely assuming the perfection of some form of government.

vezzy-fnord··on How bad are things?
Parks, libraries and schools are largely not communally-owned spaces, but government-owned. Crucial distinction. In fact, some of the best alternatives to the traditional classroom model (i.e. Montessori, Sudbury, democratic, etc.) tend to be privately run schools. As such, private schools are on the positive side here.

Again, this mystical "community" is mostly an illusion. It's either private ownership or government ownership via eminent domain. Commons aren't applicable in most cases.

Bonds with extended family are to be settled on an individual case-by-case basis. Many people rightfully may consider their extended families to be not worth interacting with, and in any event this is all a flimsy normative sentiment.

Beauty standards are determined first societally, then by entrepreneurs. The profit motive is intrinsic to a world of uncertainty (see Frank H. Knight's Risk, Uncertainty and Profit). It is wholly neutral. There is nothing wrong with pursuing profits, even though a lot of people have an anti-capitalist bias and are convinced it's demonic.

I mostly agree, except in the sense that people are maybe being sold a bad cure for an ailment they might not have had, spending money they don't have, perpetuating the problems that caused them to want to escape in the first place.

Clearly these are unresolved issues on part of the consumer.

Markets are flawed because the actors in them are not rational or well-informed (which is often an axiom of whatever model one chooses to use), and because the actions available to them are dictated by those currently on top.

This is the almost cliched refrain of every moral reformer. Market participants are irrational, therefore $SOCIAL_ENGINEERING_POLICY_OF_CHOICE. Of course, there is information asymmetry in anything one does (market or no market), and the classic resolutions are through screening or signaling.

(Also, the definitions of "rational" and "informed" in economics are quite different from their colloquial counterparts. Moreover, assuming universal irrationality by default leads to nihilistic conclusions. At least it should anyway, most people use it as an excuse for their pet reforms by completely ignoring the irrationality in state institutions.)

For instance, violence or overt threats of violence in pursuit of gain is considered to be taboo in markets (that I know of), since those who have goods or the means to produce them generally want to keep that relative power over those who do not.

What the fuck? Violence is taboo in markets because the bourgeoisie capitalists want to exploit the underdogs? Could it possibly be because the initiation of force against voluntary actors is considered immoral by almost everyone? Hopefully you do, as well, but I can't deduce.

EDIT: The anti-capitalist and socialist crankery seems to be inherent from examining your post history.

vezzy-fnord··on ISIS Influence on Web Prompts Second Thoughts on First Amendment
Don't forget the whole eugenics movement. The likes of Lothrop Stoddard and Madison Grant were very popular in their day, but ultimately subsided and in retrospect are derided. The NSDAP did borrow a lot from them, though - Lindbergh was hardly the only one endorsing Hitler, he was an intellectual featherweight relative to many others.
vezzy-fnord··on How bad are things?
You're saying that a fundamental property of prosperity is a tendency for underconsumption? That capitalism therefore must mitigate it? So then, all your grievances are related to alleged cases of conspicuous consumption that are contrived by companies in response to a satiated, underconsuming populace.

I'm unsure of what "privatizing public spaces for socialization" is supposed to mean, or why it would be bad. After all, a private property owner may extend nonpossessory or usufructory rights to usage of their land, which would make it perfectly viable for social gatherings without being necessarily more exclusionary than a commons or public ownership. The promotion of the nuclear family model is an organic result of prosperity, which enables its existence to thrive. Thus, it's a social tendency first and then absorbed by industry. Same with beauty standards. I also fail to see how "promoting exotic vacations and recreational activities" is bad.

Your last sentence is confusing. Money is special because it is a good that, particularly fiat money, is almost entirely defined by exchange value over use value, and is the unit at which all other goods are priced relative to. Where are you drawing the association with "perfect markets," or whether markets would even need to be perfect?

vezzy-fnord··on DLL Hijacking Just Won’t Die
The classic way of mitigating the issue of intent, of course, is capability-based security. Standard ambient authority models basically leave the door wide open by decontextualizing all action, such that merely riding on someone's session from their end is sufficient.
vezzy-fnord··on State Considered Harmful – A Proposal for a Stateless Laptop
They're not really "states," but autonomous voluntary regions. After all, if everyone can opt out of the terms of a central monopolistic state, then they cease to be states in the normal sense of the term, since no monopoly on legitimate initiation of force is held and free travel between "borders" is permitted.

This is the so-called "panarchy" arrangement and emerges organically from most forms of anarchism.

Every community is responsible for its own defense, which it can hire out or assemble itself.

vezzy-fnord··on I thought all anti-vaxxers were idiots. Then I married one
I'm curious how far the label "anti-vaxxer" extends. Does it also include people who accept the science behind vaccination, but who as a political principle are opposed to it being made compulsory?
vezzy-fnord··on State Considered Harmful – A Proposal for a Stateless Laptop
A stateless society could still be democratic, but at a much more decentralized threshold. (per-neighborhood, per-cooperative, etc.)
vezzy-fnord··on Price discrimination tends to be worse for women
Assuming that, as implied, most of these goods are purely substitutable with no physical difference but in "gender-specific packaging," then one could actually interpret this as the capitalists (inadvertently or not) pushing consumers towards deconstructing traditional gender roles through their mark-up pricing. We can thus observe the profit motive serving a positive social function, though YMMV depending on ideological preconceptions.
vezzy-fnord··on Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation
Taxes only go so far. Higher wealth elasticities of demand among those of higher income means less sensitivity to it, and the greater purchasing power means a lower opportunity cost to avoiding those taxes. Then, once the taxed income is retrieved, you must rely that the state apparatus will properly allocate it without pork-barreling, corrupting or shoving some omnibus legislation on transit until it finally becomes executive procedure.

This means that, at some point, all forms of taxation eventually boomerang and become regressive. Even when you introduce tax credits for lower income citizens, the bureaucratic and personal costs to managing them also tend to become regressive since third-parties will usually be paid for consulting and navigating across the labyrinthian tax code. This creates a situation where you open up for rent-seeking players whose business models depend on the aforementioned labyrinth, and who as a result get to redistribute income via wasteful inefficiency, lobbying and then offset the gains from tax credits by the losses of navigating them.

"Big government" inevitably leads either to totalitarianism, or to "kludgeocracy" as in the United States [1].

[1] http://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/kludgeocr...

vezzy-fnord··on Super small Docker image based on Alpine Linux
Does upstream systemd build on musl now?
vezzy-fnord··on Bitcoin's mining difficulty has increased by 41.9% over the last 30 days
The problems faced by Greece are from a lack of monetary sovereignty, but to equate it as somehow being like a gold standard simply on locus of control alone sounds more like a political talking point than anything else.
vezzy-fnord··on Bitcoin's mining difficulty has increased by 41.9% over the last 30 days
Cutting rates would not necessarily stimulate investment: http://www.themoneyillusion.com/?p=31372
vezzy-fnord··on Bitcoin's mining difficulty has increased by 41.9% over the last 30 days
The problem sounds like the debts, not the gold. Since, if you accept the debt deflation hypothesis and the idea of debt overhangs, these obviously occur in fiat money systems as well. Gold makes it hard to inflate monetarily, but we observe that catastrophic debts still occur in its absence.
vezzy-fnord··on Bitcoin's mining difficulty has increased by 41.9% over the last 30 days
I am uncertain as to why you imply that a) I think a negative time preference is irrational or impossible apodictically, b) that the former is necessarily a neoclassical idea when the neoclassical synthesis in fact eschews it, c) that there is a natural rate of time preference, d) that time preferences do not differ per subjective valuations and units of goods on an individual scale, or that they are not dynamic, and e) that to respond to the assertion that deflationary spirals are unrealistic in presupposing a fixed natural rate of negative time preference with the opposite straw man idea of extremely high time preferences that favor immediate consumption is a convincing line of argument (indeed, the latter cannot be true for it would make capital investment an impossibility).

The three activities you list in parentheses apply only for those goods, and do not even imply a negative time preference. Saving doesn't have to be a result of negativity at all, per se.

vezzy-fnord··on Bitcoin's mining difficulty has increased by 41.9% over the last 30 days
Deflationary spirals are a hypothetical concern and mostly a fringe neo-Fisherian idea that has recently gained some mainstream nodding, but is otherwise difficult to verify in any way.

For one thing it assumes a massive collective irrationality where people's expectations are all rendered berserk and plunged into a negative time preference. It's a very tough gambit to make that people can withdraw their propensity to consume to such a high extent. It's tough to presume that the heterogeneous stock of capital and the time structure of production will just stand still to a deflationary pressure and not readjust to add more stages or adjust the price spreads in between. [1] Of course, BTC being a global currency means it exists in competition and per Gresham's law can always be driven out. Not a catastrophe.

[1] https://www.jstor.org/stable/2547921

vezzy-fnord··on What It's Like to Be Noam Chomsky's Assistant
Why would the libertarians need to be vigorously pruned?
vezzy-fnord··on Boringcc: Proposal for a C compiler for secure software
People trying to improve C are sad to watch.

Cyclone had a fighting chance once.

vezzy-fnord··on You are your phone
For me personally, I never even desired one to begin with for the purposes it's actually used in practice (social media and the miscellaneous service).

My line of reasoning went in that I'm buying a general-purpose computing device that has been deliberately constrained to make it as undesirable as possible to actually use like a general-purpose computing device. Why would I want it, when I have a perfectly good IBM PC-compatible/Wintel box at home? For telephony purposes, I've always used dumb cells running some Java ME bare-bones interface or similar. And so I continue to do. It's not like I get cravings to check my feeds if I'm away for a few hours.

On the other hand, the fact that I also feel no need to use any applications associated with the "sharing economy" probably helps, too.

Is it even possible to do so working in a tech field?

Absolutely.

vezzy-fnord··on You are your phone
I'm a rather unorthodox case in that I own several smartphones, but never use the telephony or even any social and entertainment applications. Instead, I treat them as testing grounds for various alternative platforms like KDE Plasma Mobile, Ubuntu Touch, Replicant, CyanogenMod and so forth.

My actual phone is a prepaid flip phone.

(At the risk of invoking "le wrong generation," I'm a Millennial. I find a certain humor in observing how older people are glued to their smartphones in spite of the frequent complaints that are implicitly assumed about me. I will grant that pathological smartphone obsession is a disgruntling phenomenon, but hardly contained to Millennials. I frequently find myself the odd one out not checking their smartphone in a waiting room.)

vezzy-fnord··on What It's Like to Be Noam Chomsky's Assistant
RMS isn't really an asshole, though he has some infamous quirks that some people tend to overemphasize because they find his otherwise straightforward ideas to be highly disagreeable to begin with.

Hitchens was inflammatory, but also flexible in his thinking.

Buckley was an interesting case. To some extent, he was more acerbic towards those he mostly agreed with than those who he had further ideological skirmishes with. For instance, he was friends and associates with Galbraith, but infamously brutal towards Rothbard over his non-interventionist views on foreign policy.

vezzy-fnord··on What It's Like to Be Noam Chomsky's Assistant
Chomsky has never been a part of the "tolerance brigade," his left-libertarian syndicalist views notwithstanding. In fact, he has always been brutally critical of postmodernism.
← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →