HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vezzy-fnord

16,839 karma · joined September 9, 2013

submissionscomments
vezzy-fnord··on Fed Ends Zero-Rate Era
What else is there to say about the GP's blanket assertions of opinion being bought out by corporate think tanks and a link to an article about labor-related strife? It's a predetermined conclusion.
vezzy-fnord··on Fed Ends Zero-Rate Era
All policy arguments are political, but not necessarily emanating from a moral philosophy. To the extent morality can be reduced to cause-effect propositions, it can also be subject to analysis.
vezzy-fnord··on Fed Ends Zero-Rate Era
Economists are agents of bourgeoisie capitalism, then. Alright, I'll end here.
vezzy-fnord··on Fed Ends Zero-Rate Era
The reason many economists are unsure or against the minimum wage is not because they're some agents of bourgeoisie capitalists, but because arguments in favor of it tend to be moral, not economic.

For instance, here's a case for the minimum wage presented by an (otherwise very knowledgeable, I'll grant) Post-Keynesian economist: http://socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/2013/02/the-e...

It's pretty weak. The first two are very flimsy normative/moral arguments that, even if true, do not at all imply minimum wage is the solution over say, basic income, unionization, community-based mutual credit or a variety of other initiatives.

The third one is a can opener assumption. "Oh, minimum wage might work, but only in the case of Post-Keynesian full employment with buffer stocks of labor." You might as well speak of spherical cows in a vacuum. Followed by an unsourced claim about post-WWII prosperity being strictly due to Keynesian policies, when there's no consensus what factors exactly caused it.

vezzy-fnord··on Fed Ends Zero-Rate Era
The competition in Google and Facebook's case isn't "programmers", but "exceptionally skilled programmers," which is a different good, a much scarcer one and with less diminishing returns than the former.

I'm not aware of the real estate situation in London to make a comment.

vezzy-fnord··on Fed Ends Zero-Rate Era
Competition drives prices down, but chances are people with limited options to shop around and who disproportionately head towards mass retailers already, by example, live in areas with imperfect competition and in the worst case, food deserts. As such, a minimum wage would seem to negate itself again.
vezzy-fnord··on I was denied admission to a PhD program because of my perceived political views
I don't know, I'm not a leftist. Though what you seem to be describing are postmodernism and moral relativism, and I know plenty of left-wing people who reject both.

Again, the term "left" is useless without defining it first. I have no idea what the hell you actually mean when you say "left".

vezzy-fnord··on Fed Ends Zero-Rate Era
How does a negative income tax subsidize any of that? If anything, it's much more neutral regarding wage labor (since it's based on the broader definition of income in tax codes) than, obviously, minimum wage mandates.
vezzy-fnord··on I was denied admission to a PhD program because of my perceived political views
This is clearly wrong unless you posthumously redefine all right-wing political violence as being leftist.

Though, really, "left" and "right" are useless terms without defining your usage of them beforehand. Rest assured, there are many right-wingers who are all too willing to make the personal political and to stifle dissent. In fact, that's more-or-less a signature distinction of the New Right that emerged around the era of Buckley and National Review.

vezzy-fnord··on Fed Ends Zero-Rate Era
Second is a real possibility during the next 20-30 years. First and third are significantly more doubtful.

Even assuming all three come in place soon, I don't understand how they'll fix public choice. If anything, at least autonomous electric vehicles will be a boon on private enterprise, which I don't think is what you had in mind.

vezzy-fnord··on Fed Ends Zero-Rate Era
Government spending on bureaus like the FDA, EPA, and BBB give consumers and citizens access to outlets for complaints against dirty businesses and give us a decent amount of protection against those who would harm us to gain more of those dollars you think they'd rather have in their own pocket.

Some evidence to the contrary: http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2015/...

There's always costs of utility forgone to putting upper bounds on heterogeneous consumer preferences, and as it turns out, they can be rather severe.

vezzy-fnord··on Fed Ends Zero-Rate Era
I made some perhaps overly hasty generalizations. HN is a community that is heavily skewed towards a belief in transhumanism (especially that AGI will be coming very soon) and moreover that high rates of technological unemployment are upon us, necessitating a UBI or stronger reforms to make sure the general-purpose labor saving of AGI doesn't cause social unrest from crowding humans out of the labor market.

I can't imagine what else could the GP have been referring to other than mass automatized labor for most sectors, hence either AGI or lots of narrow AI.

vezzy-fnord··on Fed Ends Zero-Rate Era
I argue my ideas only need to hold water for another 10-30 years, depending on if technology advancement keeps up.

Given that the AI community's prediction making skills have been just slightly better than those of Nostradamus, that's a very tough gambit to rely on.

Japan's been running structural deficits for decades, and still has a very high quality of life.

Except for the aftermath of the whole Lost Decade thing and aging population taking tolls on aggregate productivity. I'm not qualified enough to say whether causes were monetary, fiscal, sociological or some combination thereof, but listing Japan as a positive example here doesn't strike me as wise.

As basic minimum income solves this without the messy politics surrounding it.

UBI would theoretically handle a minimum transfer of purchasing power for every individual. We're talking about public programs and initiatives unrelated to that.

Though, if you're idealistic enough to think the UBI is a prospect soon realizable, I wonder why you're advocating minimum wage increases over say, stronger collective bargaining? Denmark for instance has never had a minimum wage law.

vezzy-fnord··on Fed Ends Zero-Rate Era
increasing the minimum wage

Be careful what you wish for: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2015/03/how...

legislation increasing entitlements such as social security

Expected to run structural deficits by a certain point. Theoretically speaking, an endogenously determined fiat money system doesn't really have "government debt" what with it being the sovereign issuer of debt to begin with, but in reality politics and the economy don't exist in frictionless vacuums and there are political costs to pork barreling, logrolling, unsound investments and so forth.

vezzy-fnord··on LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Docs, Office 365
You could just as easily use a lightweight native productivity suite. None of the arguments you're making imply web-based solutions in of themselves.
vezzy-fnord··on Government surveillance is as old as the telegraph
Like, duh. Telecom has always been entwined with state security - they're essentially two halves of the same informational entity.

It nominally should have been a "like, duh," but as it turns out, it was a great mystery to a many people, taking well until 2013 when Snowden finally made it stupidly obvious such that ignoring or denying it was simply rendered impossible.

I'm not sure how much of it was due to historical ignorance, faith in statism, or in the case of the United States - its history and culture generally being heavily enshrined in mythology.

vezzy-fnord··on Flint, MI: So much lead in children’s blood, state of emergency declared
Flint is often a forgot about place in the world.

Not since Michael Moore immortalized it. I wouldn't be surprised if many people upvoting this story were making an association with Roger & Me.

vezzy-fnord··on Developer claims 'PS4 officially jailbroken'
All goods that are non-excludable and non-rivalrous suffer from free rider problems. Blaming "self-entitled consumers" is an excuse, not a reason. Every time I take a whiff of my neighbor's cooking, I am freeloading off a positive (for me) externality. Any producer of such goods knows the risks.
vezzy-fnord··on Software Development Has Diseconomies of Scale
Diseconomies of scale certainly aren't unique to software, and the author sensibly notes "individual knowledge".

One of the main effects of protectionist and interventionist policies has been related to them. A domestic firm starts to rot, unemployment prospects are rising and a sense of national preservation starts to set in. Thus, in the short term, tariffs are levied, subsidies are made and some macro notion of "stability" or "optimality" is reached. The long term costs are the artificial delaying of the onsets of diseconomies of scale with state and business expansion leading to symbiotic interests. Then people complain about Big Business fucking them over.

(The fact that the author quote Keynes makes this all the more ironic. Keynes-the-man wasn't objectionable, but the neoclassical synthesis/"pop Keynesianism" of his disciples Paul Samuelson and John Hicks did influence government policy in a negative way, as noted in James M. Buchanan's Democracy in Deficit.)

vezzy-fnord··on Why Zuckerberg’s Critics Are Wrong
You have the causal chain backwards. It is the initiator of an action who must plan their decisions to reach an optimal end. It is not the fault of a consumer for refusing to engage in a given exchange with a producer. It is the producer who must make their offers palatable. In the same way, the government, being the one levying the tax, is the entity which ultimately bears the burden of structuring its tax policy to achieve the highest return.
vezzy-fnord··on Why Zuckerberg’s Critics Are Wrong
most important problems, like climate change, energy crisis, poverty or education, are of this type - for which both democratic governments and free markets fail spectacularly.

Countries with democratic governments generally do not have free markets. Don't butcher the term's meaning.

(In fact, there is evidence that markets, free or otherwise, do advance education. Alternative educational institutions like Montessori, Sudbury, Summerhill and democratic schools tend to be private.)

"Poverty" also isn't what it used to be for many in both First and Second World countries, unless you're extremely myopic.

vezzy-fnord··on Why Zuckerberg’s Critics Are Wrong
This is naive. Incentives matter. No matter how much you try to ethically spin it, actors generally perceive taxation as adversarial. Any country implementing a tax policy is fully aware of the risks they take from noncompliance and avoidance.

(Avoiding or resisting taxes is also not always a purely self-interested endeavor. It's a tried and true political protest technique.)

vezzy-fnord··on Why Zuckerberg’s Critics Are Wrong
I'd rather the public decides which propaganda our young generation's minds get poisoned with rather than a billionaire with uncertain motivations.

How are the public's motivations exempt from uncertainty?

(This is a false dilemma, anyway. The educational prospects of the poor in public schools are already bad, regardless of any action undertaken by Zuckerberg. I also find your implication that private school investment somehow "crowds out" public schools to be highly dubious. The real solution is abandoning the traditional schooling model entirely.)

vezzy-fnord··on UK citizens may soon need licenses to photograph some stuff they already own
I'm not advocating anarcho-communism or left-anarchism, necessarily. I'm more than aware of its bottlenecks regarding economic calculation and so forth.
vezzy-fnord··on UK citizens may soon need licenses to photograph some stuff they already own
The Whites were pretty clear in their goals, I'd thought: preservation of monarchy and status quo.

A more interesting counterfactual would have been Menshevik victory.

vezzy-fnord··on UK citizens may soon need licenses to photograph some stuff they already own
A lot of technologists here have certain dreams or aspirations they want to see materialized in their lifetimes. AGI, transhumanism, space colonization, etc.

My dream is that I hope to see the emergence of a viable minarchist or anarchist society (beyond Mennonite and kibbutzim arrangements). Thus far the closest was a brief period of Catalonian history amidst a civil war.

vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
My objections are a) there is so much more to a drug than how addictive it is, b) no one said anything about deregulation per se (you can have a regulated legal market), c) your analysis has an implicit anti-capitalistic and snobbish bias against the public to make its own decisions, d) it isn't even true that only huge corporate players will have a hand, especially in drugs that have a very low barrier to entry in cultivating such as cannabis, e) your argument from the ill-defined "medical utility" ignores that illegality hampers medical research to lesser or greater extent, f) you are ignoring regulatory capture is a significant issue in pharma company troubles and g) you clearly do not understand public choice theory.

Though I think it's clear you believe in copious use of intervention against individuals and have a hatred or fear of capitalism and free association in order to make such a batshit argument as arguing for cartel violence and regional destabilization because the prospect of corporate profits terrifies you so much.

EDIT: Scanning your post history, you make a reference to "the final solution to the capitalist bourgeoise swine". You might have been facetious at that time, but I believe it reflects a general attitude you hold that is spiteful. I hope you at least do not believe in discredited economic doctrines such as tendency for the rate of profit to fall, or labor theory of value.

EDIT #2: You also believe that free market players are purely profit-maximizing "with behavior only moderated by applicable government regulations". This is plain false, even by a left-leaning Post-Keynesian analysis. You also again do not understand public choice theory in the slightest and how endogenous regulations emerge by transaction costs and private property (e.g. Coase theorem).

You hold a lot of fallacies.

vezzy-fnord··on Show HN: FuckFuckAdblock
I wasn't opposing the joke. I was objecting on the basis of it being nonsensical, unless your goal was to just arbitrarily make a non sequitur.
vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
Unbelievable.

You have no problem with wide-scale organized crime networks who engage in brutal acts of terror controlling the drug enterprise, nope. It's the evil capitalist producers exploiting the stupid proles with their advertising. Horrifying. No, the cartels don't have options of using legal protections because the illegal ones are much more effective in terms of securing obedience, and destructive.

If your only criterion of a drug's adverse effects is addictive potency, then your criteria are critically flawed and next to worthless. Something not inducing a physical dependence doesn't mean psychological addiction does not exist, though of course I oppose bans on either grounds. Addictive potential is but one factor of many.

I'm becoming convinced your opposition to legalization is not at all based on a cost-benefit analysis of the public welfare, but rather on a kneejerk fear of capitalism and voluntary association. Your use of the word "deregulate" as somehow being a scary detriment seems to corroborate this.

It's quite disgusting that you denigrate and despise voluntary association between consenting individuals so much that you'd prefer cartels slaughtering and burning villages just so mean scary capitalists with their evil advertising rays of doom don't influence the opinions of the public, whom you clearly regard as morons incapable of critical thought. It is then unsurprising you advocate what you do if that's where you come from.

vezzy-fnord··on Show HN: FuckFuckAdblock
It also fails to disclaim liability, though the WTFPL does have an optional warranty disclaimer variant.

And no, I don't know what planet you live in, but it's not offensive to GPL evangelists (especially not more than proprietary licenses).

In fact, the big irony is that the FSF both approves the WTFPL and considers it GPL-compatible, [1] but the OSI rejects it entirely! [2]

The GPL evangelists have the upper hand here.

[1] https://www.gnu.org/licenses/license-list.en.html#WTFPL

[2] http://opensource.org/minutes20090304

← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →