HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vezzy-fnord

16,839 karma · joined September 9, 2013

submissionscomments
vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
The difference is actually subjective gauging of intent. Particularly your latter case of the "sleazy bastards" is often an intrinsic gray area and of course in the best case indistinguishable from a mere recommendation without special interests.
vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
Actually my opposition to regulation isn't an ideological default. It's borne out of my analysis weighing endogenous regulation (contracts signed by actors with judicial assistance to enforce them) against exogenous regulations, like that of a collective body of action, i.e. government. There's been a lot written on this subject.

(To answer your statement, if there is a stalemate such that both government failure and market failure are inevitable, I would prefer the latter, for the simple reason that it entails less layers of indirection and that it doesn't impose any upper bound on heterogeneous consumer preferences.)

That said, I do have some reading recommendations.

James M. Buchanan was an eminent economist and political theoretician. I'd recommend his classic The Calculus of Consent co-written with Gordon Tullock, supplemented with his own The Limits of Liberty and Costs and Choice.

William A. Niskanen wrote Bureaucracy and Representative Government presenting a budget-maximizing theory of government akin to a utility-maximizing theory of an economic actor. Both have limitations, but it's worth reading.

Don Lavoie wrote great primers such as Rivalry and Central Planning and National Economic Planning: What Is Left? which equally apply to a mixed economy.

R.H. Coase formulated the Coase theorem in his paper "The Problem of Social Cost," demonstrating how private property rights plus low transaction costs lead to endogenous self-regulatory actions.

Oliver E. Williamson wrote a technical work on transaction cost economics entitled The Mechanisms of Governance. Another technical writer was Lester G. Telser, particularly his work on the "core theory" related to cooperation, coordination and collusion.

Essays and papers by Armen A. Alchian, Harold Demsetz and Yale Brozen are also worth examining.

For a bare introduction, see Government Failure: A Primer in Public Choice, or a recent paper using behavioral theory to analyze public policy [1].

[1] http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2015/...

vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
I do not believe that the property owner may do whatever they wish within their property.

Then you don't really support property rights. I mean, certainly, property owners must be within the bounds of the common and civil law framework of their jurisdiction. Limiting how property is internally arranged is a wholly different matter, it's a direct veto on how someone schedules their production structure for no reason but the failings of people who they have no stake in. By protecting customers from "themselves" and thus also protecting owners from customers, you are curtailing rights of both to engage in voluntary contract.

It is a mere implementation detail, not an end in itself.

Not free market economy. Market economy in general. It's not at all an "implementation detail," it arises quite organically out of interpersonal exchange.

hence I propose regulation

You know what I loathe?

Let's take everything you've said at face value.

You provide a case for perceived suboptimal behavior of markets, but then by proposing regulation you completely ignore the prospect of suboptimal government action! That is absolutely disingenuous. Your proposal exists outside of reality and assumes a hypothetical benevolent exogenous regulator that doesn't actually exist (as opposed to real states which are complex institutions).

You'd do yourself good by reading up on some public choice theory.

vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
The purpose of a drug policy is (ostensibly) and has always been to reduce consumption rates

I should have said effective drug policy. Focusing on consumption rates is indeed what most people do, and it's completely wrong.

Are you saying there's no potential at which a drug should be illegal?

Hypothetically speaking, no. In practice, all attempts at providing classifications for which drugs to ban and which to keep legal are based on purely subjective and unscientific slippery slopes. With such a variety of narcotics, it's practically inevitable to see such regressions.

My example of theobromine in chocolate is a good one, I think. Nobody thinks anything of it even though strictly speaking it's quite toxic (though obviously negligible in the dosages it's consumed).

As such, if not legalize everything, legalize some of the higher profile psychoactives and stimulants and just decriminalize (levy a fine for) all the rest.

if addictive drugs were legal and fully unregulated, who do you think the majority of the profits would go to? Hint: Novartis, Pfizer, Roche, Sanofi, Merck...

Oh, so you'd rather they go to Los Zetas and Sinaloa Cartel?

Do you really trust them to freely market a compound that has 10%+ addiction capture rate?

We already do so for a variety of psychotropics, analgesics and so forth. The difference is we think of it as "medicine" rather than "drugs" and as such our perceptions are distorted. Yet the cost of vulnerable people getting high off over-the-counter drugs is pretty negligible. It takes no effort for a teen to dose themselves off DXM in cough syrup.

vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
Nothing like respecting individual rights by bringing the wrath of the criminal justice system on anyone who dares exercise their right to self-ownership by altering their state of consciousness.

The purpose of a drug policy is not to reduce consumption rates. Consumption is not intrinsically bad. My use of the dangerous and potent drug known as theobromine (translation: I eat chocolate) is not itself the problem. A higher rate of consumption of pure and unadulterated drugs with active health and rehabilitation initiatives is preferable to lower consumption but with autistically intervening in people's self-ownership through use of the police and penal apparatus, disincentivizing health treatment as a result, bringing about organized crime and making addiction more dangerous because of tainted drugs that are peddled by unreliable black marketeers.

Paternalistic and destructive nonsense through and through.

(You did say illegal, not criminalized. Latter would be more humane in being a fine, but still unacceptable.)

vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
I am not arguing for giving up the notion of personal responsibility, but

But you are.

When you get to micromanaging such trivialities, there's no limit what a planner's mentality will settle on next. A ban on restaurants that offer salty free lunches with every purchase of beer because they're relying on the customer to make up for it by ordering drinks.

It is absolutely not fraud. A happy hour was advertised, and the contract was heeded.

The property owner may deliberately arrange the environment so as to maximize an expected consumer end. There is absolutely nothing wrong with this. Supermarkets are architected to encourage higher shopping. Clothing retailers will arrange their luxurious brands to have a higher aesthetic appeal inside their stores.

Taking your logic of needing to regulate any "misleading action" to its conclusion will only entail the abolition of the market economy. There's no way around this. Anything and everything can be shoehorned under such flimsy logic.

(Moreover, expecting that consumers are morons who cannot regulate their own behavior will generally lead to policymakers drafting proposals that assume as such and end up fulfilling the prophecy on their own, since the resulting bureaucracy will be internalized by consumers in their expectations.)

vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
It certainly was a tumultuous period, but what reliable evidence is there of cocaine being a major causal factor? The USA was plagued by lots of labor-related violence, race rioting and organized crime (peaking during Prohibition, of course), but was cocaine ever anything more than a scapegoat?
vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
Is it OK for bars or clubs to offer a happy hour early in the evening to get patrons going, then turn up the heat and make it hard to find water so those patrons keep ordering more drinks and getting more and more drunk throughout the evening?

You honestly believe we need a law against this? God forbid a restaurant owner offer any promotion whatsoever.

vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
there's no doubt in my mind that fully legalizing drugs would lead to a more volatile society

Many hard drugs (including cocaine and heroin) were legal in the United States prior to the 1920s.

To the best of my knowledge, there was no massive social breakdown as a result.

The ultimate irony is that a major motivation for the criminalization of cocaine was, for poor rural whites, a fear that drugged up blacks would start raping white women. [1] Needless to say, this did not materialize and there is no reason it will if we lift the ban.

[1] http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2013/01/why-we-too...

vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
There's plenty of legal Ponzi and pyramid schemes out there right now. Amway and plenty of other multi-level marketing enterprises, for instance. As long as you're (sort of) honest about it, it isn't even fraudulent to run one.

"Magical remedies". I assume you mean alternative medicine. Does this mean you're going to ban various herbs, or what?

vezzy-fnord··on Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
Funny that this comes up. Donald J. Boudreaux wrote an entry just earlier on the same topic in response to Akerlof and Shiller's recent book: http://cafehayek.com/2015/12/the-role-of-market-forces-in-pr...

There's also a bit of a double standard about how advertising is perceived. Banner ads, editorials and similar are frowned upon. Yet it's quite likely you'll interpret someone promoting a work in the comments section of a site you frequent as a friendly recommendation, never mind it's still signaling availability of something in a manner identical to many less invasive ads.

vezzy-fnord··on Highly educated women no longer have fewer kids
I don't have children either, and I oppose any subsidy in general.

I interpreted you as arguing in favor of it.

vezzy-fnord··on Highly educated women no longer have fewer kids
That doesn't make the maneuver any less abhorrent or coercive, unless you regard attacking the development of your country's infants as a positive, of course.
vezzy-fnord··on Winston Churchill and Islam
The Armenian Genocide was carried out by the Young Turk movement towards the end of the empire. The YTs were distinguished by a stark materialism and secularism, and actually sought to revert the theocratic nature of the empire prior. So, not really Ottoman Islam, per se.
vezzy-fnord··on How Jefferson and other Founding Fathers defended Muslim rights
The real tragedy today is that there are many Americans who want a monopoly on American identity

American identity is much more heterogeneous today than ever before, in no small part thanks to ecumenism.

vezzy-fnord··on Highly educated women no longer have fewer kids
What subsidy? When you mentioned "society at large," I was assuming some hypothetical communal or kinship arrangements. You should be more clear.

The second idea is vile and destructive. Someone elects to have more than one child, and you come in storming to deduct from their payrolls and tax their income as if you deliberately want to wage a war of attrition against the parents' standard of living for raising a child.

vezzy-fnord··on Highly educated women no longer have fewer kids
I think the one child policy is a great idea.

How do you deal with those who defy it, deliberately or otherwise?

vezzy-fnord··on Highly educated women no longer have fewer kids
It is a great pity that it's so fucking difficult to do so in this day and age.

Elaborate.

vezzy-fnord··on The Saga of Craig Wright, the Latest “Inventor of Bitcoin”
I swear with all the rampant speculation and hunting for Satoshi's identity that have led deep to a multitude of rabbit holes, the only way for the real Satoshi's uncovering not to end up a disappointment, would be if he's also revealed to be simultaneously D.B. Cooper and Jimmy Hoffa (maybe even the Zodiac Killer while we're at it).
vezzy-fnord··on Real talk from real computer science teachers
Computer science is highly interdisciplinary and syncretic and as such cannot be neatly fit into a first-order subject without diluting it or investing in lots of prerequisite instruction, which for the purposes of a compulsory schooling system is next to intractable.

"Programming and scripting" classes are a different matter altogether with highly dubious benefits beyond far-fetched theorizing by its overly optimistic proponents.

Too much faith is put on compulsory schooling. Everything must be coordinated and planned. The very idea that one might acquire programming as a means to a pursued end later in life appears to be anathema to many people, who instead advocate that a ritualistic drilling of how to write lines of ALGOL will mystically make people "technically literate" and appreciative.

vezzy-fnord··on The political aftermath of financial crises: Going to extremes
more decentralized more democratic government

What decentralization are you talking about? None takes place. Party representation is increased in a central body. That's it.

vezzy-fnord··on Volkswagen and the Blame the Engineer Game
I presume the communist mode of production is one in a stateless, money-less society where factors of production are cooperatively owned by workers and where the production process is based on some definition of "use" rather than "profit". Profit would be the surplus employed by workers to create more use value. Goods would be traded "in kind" as is without a lubricant of exchange like money.

The canonical argument against this is "Economic Calculation in the Socialist Commonwealth". There's generally been two ways socialist thinkers have tried to get around this: a) calculation in kind, which essentially reverts us back to unscalable barter where there is no reliable unit of account, and b) the Lange model of a Central Planning Board, which immediately brings all the issues of public choice, bureaucracy and "state capitalism" as you derided it earlier.

vezzy-fnord··on Volkswagen and the Blame the Engineer Game
I don't deny the profit motive.

I deny a) the normative claim of there being some form of malevolence in it, b) the idea that it's the only thing firms maximize for when in fact we clearly observe that firms will sacrifice some profit for both internal equilibrium and sending out consistent signals to consumers and c) that a profit motive will not exist in a hypothetical socialist or communist society.

Whether it's the manorialist collecting rent on land or the bartering farmer balancing their supply of wheat traded to remain at a surplus while keeping a stock of other consumer goods they've bought, there's always a profit motive. The manorialist profits either from use of a land title or the use of land as a factor of production. The farmer profits by having their supply of goods be at a state where the marginal product of each good provides increasing returns for satisfying their ends. In other words, the farmer profits from having a heterogeneous stock over a homogeneous stock because they can use the former to obtain further goods to diversify their portfolio, or trade so as to improve the serviceableness and efficiency of their factors for growing wheat.

vezzy-fnord··on Volkswagen and the Blame the Engineer Game
Do you accept the labor theory of value and the tendency for the rate of profit to fall? If so, then any economic argument you make will be on false premises.

Firms and markup prices are not at all individual employer behaviors. They're industry-wide behaviors that practically define mixed economies and thus, by your own definition, capital (though I think yours is overly vague).

vezzy-fnord··on Volkswagen and the Blame the Engineer Game
AI is a factor of production, therefore it is a capital good.

The rest is delusional science fiction. "Ethereum contracts will magically grant every individual land, labor and capital goods for self-sufficient production." No.

vezzy-fnord··on Volkswagen and the Blame the Engineer Game
The enemy here, then, is capital, not these poor workers who fill necessary capitalist roles.

I'm not sure how factors of production (including durable capital goods) can possibly be an "enemy" of anything.

That said, your idea that capitalists act as crude profit maximizers is an oversimplification. In fact, most firms don't do any calculation of prices based on marginal revenues and marginal costs. Instead, they usually administer a markup price based more on internal accounting practices and then do not strongly deviate from the markup, choosing to downsize production when profits are low instead of upsetting the stable price signal they've chosen even if it would be more profitable to do otherwise.

vezzy-fnord··on Ubuntu 16.04 – Online searches in the dash to be off by default
They do if you export it through a synthetic file system interface.
vezzy-fnord··on BUS1: A new Linux kernel IPC bus being made by systemd developers
I can agree systemd situation is bad, but I don't think it's because of technical reasons

It is: http://blog.darknedgy.net/technology/2015/10/11/0/

The context of this comment section was about systemd in general, not the BUS1 concept specifically. It's too early to comment on the latter when it's still just a red-black tree with some stub functions.

vezzy-fnord··on BUS1: A new Linux kernel IPC bus being made by systemd developers
I wouldn't describe it as a technicality, but more of a carte blanche vacuity. What comprises "the system"? Just about everything. Hence "all system things" is really "all everything things". Such underspecified weasel wording is a chief reason for systemd's status at large.

Even your list involves diverse interfaces ranging from real-time kernel primitives to end-user archives (packages), so again, "system things" is more of a justification for perpetual consumption than anything resembling a mission statement or goal.

(Things that merely wrap syscalls would probably be part of a utilities package anyway, a la util-linux.)

vezzy-fnord··on BUS1: A new Linux kernel IPC bus being made by systemd developers
"All system things" is a meaningless statement. Syscalls can actually carry quite a lot of information (just look at signal semantics) and they're not "very low level".

The second paragraph is more wind.

I don't think it's a bad goal. You haven't even specified a goal.

← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →