1,511 karma · joined December 19, 2014
Youtube also increases ad load. More ads per video, combined with organic growth, higher engagement and wider distribution (smart TVs probably have insane metrics-- plus no real ad blockers there, either) mean they'll keep having display/video ads doing extremely well, too.
[1] https://www.techspot.com/news/102765-who-prabhakar-raghavan-... [2] https://methodshop.com/why-google-search-sucks/
They are growing and showing up everywhere, but you never hear about them in terms of real innovation, just helping build the surveillance state. Combine this with cloud based doorbell cameras and it seems like someone is always watching.
https://vgeek.net/gallery/index.php/category/103-green_bank_...
Look at defunct sites like Nextag that were moderately useful in the space-- they had free and paid placements. They were steadily growing search visibility until Google started pushing their own product (Froogle, free product listings in 2014ish) and Nextag suddenly "violated Google's policies" and lost 90%+ of their traffic rather quickly (probably 1MM daily visits to under 10k basically overnight). Google shopping technically offers "free product listing placement", hidden well below the ads-- likely as a defense to anti-trust on monopolization of that specific space.
Brickseek and CamelCamelCamel are the two most successful/long lived tools in the space-- and they grew their visibility from the now defunct but once huge deal site FatWallet and SlickDeals. Walled garden subreddits frequently disallow posting of specific tools, so it makes organic growth super challenging-- given that pretty much all commercial queries start with Google or Amazon.
Even recently, sites like CNN were using subdomains with affiliate offers managed by third parties(1). These sites weren't being de-ranked algorithmically-- someone at Google would have to apply a manual action to remove them from the SERPs. What incentive would there be to do so if a prior agreement was in place?
Google doesn't really care about discoverability for smaller domains that may have good content. They are either being risk averse (avoiding potential spammers, junk AI content) by favoring trusted domains, favoring brands who are likely to spend on display or search ads, or maybe a combination of these.
1) https://searchengineland.com/google-begins-enforcement-of-si...
The 3 components that make up quality score: ad relevance, landing page quality and clickthrough rate are a black box. You can have ads and landing pages that match specific keywords (such as in a single keyword ad group strategy) and still have 1/10 scores on ad relevance and landing page and an insane CTR (think 40%+). You can look at search competition reports, but in some niches with few participants (think very specialized manufacturing equipment) you end up with the same <5 participants for years, yet the effective ad costs increase every quarter/year. Google adjusts bid floors for auctions, even if there isn't really upward pressure resulting from an increase in number of advertisers or participant bids.
Related to this-- their goal is always to increase the number of participants in every auction. The ad fill rate is easily improved by loosening match types. It isn't just the SEO space that Google has been redefining words in-- they do the same with keywords and match types. For example, "cheap textbook", "cheap textbooks" and "cheapest textbooks" are 3 distinct queries with widely varying CTRs and conversion rates, and hence values to advertisers-- but even when using exact match, Google may give you any one of the examples when you specify which one you prefer as an exact match.
Most infuriatingly is how you don't 100% know what you are paying for-- even when you explicitly specify what you want. Anyone who has looked at the search queries report can attest that sometimes 50%+ (emphasis on the insanity! I have observed this on $x,xxx,xxx/yr spend accounts all the way to my own personal campaigns) of ad spend for search ads, where you are explicitly saying I want to show for these specific keywords, is bucketed in the "Total: Other search terms" row. *It did not used to behave this way.* Negative match keywords are less aggressive in what is excluded relative to their exact/(phrase)/broad modified equivalents. This entirely ignores concepts like Google Shopping Ads requiring constant negative matching of longtail keywords (including for terms that you can't even really discover) that are all super small amounts individually, but in aggregate can be ludicrous amounts of spend that is essentially impossible to block for less sophisticated advertisers.
Every incremental change by Google seems to be to make the quality worse for the end user-- whether they are the searcher getting worse results or* the advertiser being goaded into wasting money on things Google isn't accurately presenting.* Specialty publications like Search Engine Land covered large things like the changes in second price auctions, display going to first price and match types-- but they typically aren't super critical, because a handful of Google's organic search "liaisons" are hires from industry publications.
In ~2016 Google started shifting towards optimizing for financial objectives more aggressively than user experience. Timing updates to coincide with beginning/end of fiscal quarters, blending ads, features solely created to drive incremental searches (People Also Ask/Related Searches), various misaligned defaults within GAds interface, branded search extortion, stance against header bidding, etc.. Essentially when they stopped promoting the "Don't be evil." slogan, they had legitimate reason to do so.
If I could give anyone advice with regards to establishing a website that is reliant on Google for traffic-- it would be to be extremely careful. I have one site now that is super high utility for end users, great UX, super fast, high repeat user rate, no ads/tracking/popup spam, great feedback from users and it is -60% in Google traffic from the March 2024 core update. There is 0 support from anyone at Google to identify why a site suddenly loses traffic. There are search liaisons who give snarky replies, but good luck getting any constructive feedback.
Even relying on paid traffic is just as dangerous-- given the black box that is Quality Score (it ties mostly to Click Through Rate, but has adjustable floor to increase effective costs) and Google's consistent drive away from measurable performance that helped them destroy traditional marketing channels so successfully.
All that I can think is that there is absolute panic at Google right now. When >50% of product searches start directly on Amazon (https://searchengineland.com/50-of-product-searches-start-on...), Google can't siphon anything off. With Meta adding things like Llama 3 to FB Messenger, there is going to be another huge hit to Google query volume-- albeit most likely low commercial intent queries (see: not as monetizable by Google), at least initially, but it will help increase user familiarity with chatbots and observed data will probably help improve Meta ad targeting ability in ways that may rival search query intent.
High value categories like home services, banking and finance are among Google's last relatively safe bastions of profit-- but eventually advertisers in these spaces have to reach a level of sophistication to realize they're giving too much of their margin to Google, leading to push-back. Highly fragmented, lower margin spaces like restaurants (or other "near me" driven niches) that have success on GMaps seem relatively safe for Google at this point. If Meta handles the chatbot transition (if it actually happens) well, they stand to gain a lot of ground there, too, given that they do already have a decent amount of small businesses who use FB pages as their sole internet presence, along with associated meta-data like hours/location/menus/reviews.
From the employee side, they would get paid more, could pick up shifts at varying businesses based on their schedules. Then maybe at scale, such a platform would be incredibly useful for organizing labor. This obviously would terrify employers.
I'm not really debating, more of just sharing random ideas and complaining online, because this is basic game theory as to why employers wouldn't want such a tool (potentially higher labor costs short/long term, increased labor mobility, unionization risk, other issues like training/liability/insurance/taxes/etc.), but employees/labor could be greatly served by such a platform.
Given that labor is viewed as fungible by most employers, why not enable more promiscuity by employees to help with wages and/or security? Things like background checks seem fairly transitive. Maybe do some sort of skill set certifications like food handling, warehousing, basic labor, etc.?
PostHog is pretty popular for product companies now, but who knows how long they will continue with a free offering.
I had an interview at Kroger HQ out of college and it was probably the most depressing office building I had ever been in. That combined with the type of work encountered at legacy industry bigco and it has to be hard to recruit anyone decent. (This coming from someone who is wildly inept, too :D)
Their analytics company 84.51/dunnhumby was always the flashier option that could recruit at a national level.
The Corbin KFC/museum draws tons of tourists-- especially from China (I think they have more locations there than in the US.) If anyone happens to go there, Corbin also has a pretty good pinball arcade with ~60 tables and a redemption game section.
Marketers are going to be good self-promoters (it is their job, after all), and the good ones are worth a lot because they can save multiples of their comp in wasted spend, but most are unfortunately flunkies who parrot Google's talking points, always use automated bidding and constantly change KPIs.
Maybe Nixie tube clocks or e-ink displays?
It _is_ flexible for people wanting to be able to create types/taxonomies within the GUI, if you ignore the chaos behind the scenes. It also has good support for returning said content via JSON if you choose to do so, but if you're doing that, just define your own back-end and avoid the suffering.
As much as HN hates advertising, so many seem ignorant of how much of the ecosystem works. I guess lots of people simply work for companies involved in these schemes, so they simply turn a blind eye or feign ignorance.
Due to the availability of hydro generation in the early 20th century, Alcoa, TN (Aluminum Company of America) also established operations in the same area due to the energy required for smelting. Their other large operation hub? Niagara Falls.