HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

victorf

192 karma · joined June 14, 2013

submissionscomments
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
That's not a crime, which is why I asked you to point out the appropriate legal code. You are now considered a troll. Have a nice day.
victorf··on Switch to HTTPS Now, For Free
I like the idea of a blockchain for it, the only downside would be using all that space.
victorf··on Switch to HTTPS Now, For Free
Do you not feel that, due to the security failure in 2011, they are one of the worst? I typically disable their certificate on my machines. The CA system is totally flawed anyway, I don't know why I bother.
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
The law requires intent and a crime. If you cannot tell me which specific crime, your argument is invalid.

Why you are having a hard time understanding that "we put him in jail because we don't like what he did" is wrong I have no idea. You must be a troll disagreeing on purpose.

victorf··on Create an algorithm to distinguish dogs from cats
If you can figure out the enemy dog is a fire type, you can switch your team up accordingly :)

Is state-of-the art for that kind of recognition deep learning?

victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
Please show me the section of US legal code regarding intentional access of data one knows one should not be accessing; without mentioning trespass, which he did not do, and without mentioning causing a computer to act in a manner the owner does not desire, which he also did not do.
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
He didn't exploit it or sell it and he's fucked. We're ignoring intent because a crime has yet to be committed. Intent doesn't matter without a crime. If intent is the only dividing line, you are in favor of thoughtcrime.
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
I know the US has decided to start prosecuting thoughtcrimes, such as jokes on FB, but that's actually unconstitutional. Accessing a server is not a crime, the user agent is not meant for authorization, and what he did was immoral, not illegal. The only difference between what weev and Aaron Swartz did is the type of content downloaded and the quality of the person downloading.

You're arguing to put this douchebag in prison, but not for an actual crime. Remember that the next time they use the CFAA to crucify someone who doesn't deserve it.

victorf··on Mac apps are harder than iOS apps
If you've used both you can tell that UIKit is the version 2 or 3 of AppKit, there are many things where UIKit is pleasant to use and AppKit is irritating for similar things.
victorf··on The $200K lesson I learned from getting shot
(The Voyager doctor was a pretty good character)

It is absurd. Everyone complaining about the wait is asserting implicitly that they need to be allowed to get their healthcare before anyone they are able to outbid.

Personally, yes, I want everyone poorer then myself to wait until my surgery is done. But that's because I'm not so far down. Is it what's best for society? Most likely not.

Probably ideally for healthcare you would live in Canada where it is not the worst cost to health ratio of all the western countries, but you're also able to nip down to the US and cut in line in a pinch.

victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
Why would we want an analogy that more accurately reflects the reality of the situation? We're trying to justify this, not let him out on appeal.
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
sneak you're one of the few "true Americans" (as in when people talk about upholding freedom above all else) and unless I remember your posts wrong, you've had to leave the country to feel free. It's truly a sad state of affairs.
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
If knowing that you are doing something immoral makes it a crime why isn't all of Wall Street in prison?
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
Both of your scenarios are inapplicable because physically entering a property is totally unlike communicating with a public machine in the way it was intended to be communicated with.
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
That's an actual CFAA crime because you have literal unauthorized access to the laptop. No further explanation necessary.
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
I like your analogy. Exactly what crime would you be charged with after calling with SSNs? He committed thoughtcrime, sure, but let's wait until he attempts to follow through with it before charging him.
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
Sounds like you were authorized; if that happened and you read the book what crime would you be charged with? Seriously. Taking advantage of a worker with intent to learn secrets? Totally immoral, not illegal.
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
How he did it absolutely does matter. He did not know what he was doing was illegal because that is the expected interaction with an HTTP server. He certainly knew it was immoral but we give Wall Street a pass on that.

Suppose I write a scraper with user agent "I am a teapot" and I discover AT&T emits personal data when I access with that user agent. What is the arbitrary cutoff for number of things downloaded before I am a criminal?

There are in fact actual criminal charges that can be brought for identity theft, we don't need the US courts to be more aggressive with the CFAA by considering thoughtcrime in their deliberations.

victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
Again completely wrong because trespassing on the staff lounge is nothing like receiving a response from an HTTP server. It is like asking for the Chinese menu and being given a list of customer records.

EDIT: and then noticing what happened you ask if they have a version in Korean.

victorf··on Fake Reviewers Snared in NY Attorney General Yogurt Sting
NYC actually has an epidemic of persons unlawfully looking through the pockets of black men and I think that should be attended to before restaurant reviews.
victorf··on The $200K lesson I learned from getting shot
Because your taxes are so high that people who might otherwise be able to afford a private jet now cannot? Not having a jet is quite embarrassing and really harms the jet-less that have to fly in merely first class.
victorf··on The $200K lesson I learned from getting shot
Of course the proper way to order surgeries is to give priority to the wealthy persons so they can quickly get on with creating jobs. Lazy poors aren't going to do anything significant anyway, so they can wait eight or nine months and it doesn't matter.

I cannot imagine raising taxes any further, if a wealthy child's parents couldn't afford to send him to a private school imagine what a terrible education he will have! He might even end up poor himself, which, I'm sure we can all agree, is a fate we should reserve for the already poor.

victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
So because there was some thoughtcrime regarding actual criminal activity we should accept the prosecution for scraping the website? No. Prosecute him for identity theft if and after he commits it.
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
No, it is because lying about your user-agent is not explicitly trying to make an HTTP server perform an action it is not supposed to perform and is therefore not in the same category as SQL injections. HTTP servers are not supposed to use user-agent as authentication.
victorf··on This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is bad for everyone
I upvoted immediately after your first two sentences, and wished I could do it again at the end of your post. Well done.

I've been trying to think of a proper analogy to changing your user agent. Wearing a fake mustache and requesting information from someone publicly giving information to only mustachioed persons?

    You: Can I borrow the book identified by ISBN 1234?
    Librarian: We restrict access to that book to only people who will read it with our page turning machine.
    You: Can I borrow the book identified by ISBN 1234? I am using your page turning machine now.
    Librarian: Sure, here you go.
victorf··on Ask HN: How much recurring income do you generate, and from what?
I've been curious because I was thinking of doing something that would host content; is it a legal nightmare if someone uploads illegal material? Is it common?
victorf··on The average faces of women in different countries
I prefer to have no input from that site whatsoever. Particularly after I read them and their commenters celebrating an actual assault on someone who made a tasteless comment. They only care about victim blaming in specific circumstances, it seems.

They are not for equality but are instead for gossip-mongering and creating false controversy; just like the entire rest of the Gawker network.

victorf··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
Citing the Google Chrome Security team regarding security is the exact opposite of the appeal to authority fallacy. It's an appropriate expert for the context.
victorf··on Why didn't we patent the spreadsheet? Were we stupid? (1999)
I disagree that "cowardly" is the appropriate adjective and suggest "pragmatic" instead.
victorf··on How To Validate Product Ideas Before (And After) Building Them
My opinion, and I think I got this from Patrick indirectly if not directly, is that you need to be selling something to people that will cause them to receive more money than your product costs. So you cannot target language learners (especially the relative immaturity of Reddit) because it's a hobby, but you can target businesses and professionals because they routinely spend money on tools and services. Sadly that's all I know about it, so I couldn't tell you who that guy should have targeted with the app. Doctors? Lawyers?
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →