HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vijayboyapati

748 karma · joined September 28, 2011

https://x.com/real_vijay
submissionscomments
vijayboyapati··on The Story Of Larry Page's Comeback
The one interaction I had with Larry that I remember was when we were moving from the old Google building (the "googleplex") to a much larger building in the old Silicon Graphics campus. I went there on a Sunday night to check out my desk and where I would be sitting and I ran into Larry (there was no one else around). He gave me a tour of the building and we walked up to a window where we could see the whole campus, with several other huge buildings. I asked him "how on earth are we going to fill this building?", which could have held several times the size of the company at the time, and he pointed at the other buildings and said we're going to fill all of them. Holy f*ck, I thought.
vijayboyapati··on H. G. Wells’ interview with Stalin (1934)
The interview is interesting from the perspective of economic history because it reveals the prevailing thinking of the era; namely that capitalism leads to "anarchy" in production. What Stalin and others did not appreciate is that the free market produces a "hidden order", which was understood by many 18th and 19th century economists. Another major error of the era was the belief that central planning of an economy - socialism - could replace capitalism. There was a major debate at the time, now known as the economic calculation debate[1], between socialist economists Harold Laski and Oscar Lange on the one hand and liberal economists Ludwig von Mises and Friedrich von Hayek on the other. In the 20's Mises had made the stunning argument that allocation of capital was impossible without the price function that is inherent to the capitalist system[2]. Laski and Lange obviously disagreed and provided the socialist counter argument. It was many years later, after the fall of the Soviet Union, that socialist philosopher and historian Robert Heilbroner admitted in the New Yorker "It turns out, of course, that Mises was right. The Soviet system has long been dogged by a method of pricing that produced grotesque misallocations of effort".[3] Still, many do not understand or appreciate the importance of economic calculation and the price function in the rational allocation of capital, which has implications not only for states, but for corporations[4].

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem

[2] https://mises.org/econcalc.asp

[3] Reflections after communism, Robert Heilbroner (apologies to those without a subscription) http://www.newyorker.com/archive/1990/09/10/1990_09_10_091_T...

[4] http://mises.org/journals/rae/pdf/rae9_2_1.pdf

vijayboyapati··on Krueger Statement on Use of Airbnb for Floating Brothels
It's always painful to watch luddite bureaucrats pontificate on technology and how it needs to be controlled to "protect" the population. I remember when I was at Google in 2003 there was a California politician who demanded that Google be regulated like a utility company because it was so important. That was when it was still a private company! Or when another California bureaucrat wanted to ban gmail because it violated people's privacy by showing targeted ads next to emails. Listening to people like this requires a perma-facepalm.
vijayboyapati··on Bitcoin Mining Boom Sputters as Prospectors Face Losses
Bitcoin is a bubble, but not in a bad way. All monetary goods display a "bubble" phenomenon. Their price cannot be explained by their use demand alone but by a monetary premium. This is true for gold and it's true for the dollar (which has no use value at all, unlike gold). This idea is explained best by MM in his bubble theory of money:

http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2013/04/bitcoin...

Also see: http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2011/04/on-mone...

vijayboyapati··on Bitcoin Falls Below $400
It's amazing to me how much price movements create news. Often people think the causality is the other way around; that there is some underlying news that must be responsible for price movements. Prognosticators in the stock market are forever looking for reasons for the price movements. Simply supply is greater than demand.

In the greater scheme of things this fall is no more significant than the last falls when bitcoin dropped from $30ish to $2, or when it dropped from $267 to $50ish. The question still remains: will bitcoin become a standard for online payments and a medium of savings? If it will, it will be a bargain whether it's $10, $100 or even $1000, and all these price movements, and the kerfuffle they cause will seem amazingly quaint to those looking back on the past (our present).

vijayboyapati··on Stripe: Bitcoin Sign-up
+1 to BIP70. Very exciting that a payment company as capable as Stripe is entering the bitcoin space. Much better for everyone if the Stripes of the world are at the center of the bitcoin ecosystem rather than the Gox's.
vijayboyapati··on IRS Rules Bitcoin Is Property, Not Currency
This strikes me as the most expected outcome. They are essentially treating Bitcoin as gold (actually slightly better, since gold has a collectible tax rate of 28% which doesn't qualify for the long term capital gains rate). The trickiest and scariest consequence will be for miners, who might need to report taxes at the time their bitcoins were mined and at the current market rate. This will mean a lot of people will need to retroactively declare gains, many of which may not have been realized. For small mining operations likely the miners will avoid reporting and just sell for cash. But for large miners who will need to use the exchanges, this becomes a real issue. Consult an accountant!
vijayboyapati··on Nouriel Roubini: Bitcoin Is a ‘Ponzi Game’
The fallacy here is that a monetary good requires some separate use. As a money per se, bitcoin is very useful. As I wrote in this thread, it allows the transfer of value to anyone, anywhere in the world without an intermediary. This has never been possible before, and it certainly impossible with the dollar. There are several markets for which this innovation has profound implications
vijayboyapati··on Nouriel Roubini: Bitcoin Is a ‘Ponzi Game’
- It's false that bitcoin isn't a means of payment. People DO use it as payment.

- It's false that it's not a medium of savings. It has reservation demand which is the only reason it has a price. It does not matter that it has "no assets in it", whatever that confused statement means. The dollar also no longer has any asset backing. The medium of savings role exists while people perceive there is value in holding a monetary good in the hope it will appreciate in the future. They perceive it will appreciate because it has comparative advantages to other goods which serve a similar purpose. Bitcoin has many comparative advantages to other monetary goods. In particular, it allows the transfer of value to anyone, anywhere in the world, near instantaneously, with low transaction fees, without the need for a trusted intermediary such as a bank. This has literally never been possible before in the entire history of civilization.

- It's true that bitcoin is not currently a unit of account. This mostly has to do with the fact that it's still nascent and needs to increase in liquidity. As it does more and more entrepreneurs who are primarily accepting bitcoin (it will start with the miners) will begin to calculate profit and loss in bitcoin terms

- It's true bitcoin is used for so-called criminal activities. But so too is the dollar. In fact, the dollar isn't just used for buying illegal drugs, the dollar is used to funnel gigantic sums of tax payer wealth to well connected bankers when their businesses fail. Which is the bigger crime, Nouriel?

- Bitcoin isn't susceptible to hacking - individual bitcoin businesses are susceptible to hacking such as the incredibly incompetent MtGox, which deserved to fail. Blaming Bitcoin for the incompetence of a particular business is like saying the dollar is a failure because Lehman Brothers collapsed. To me that is a much worse "hack" than anything that happened with Gox.

- And no, Bitcoin is NOT a ponzi scheme. Bitcoins are a monetary good whose price fluctuates with demand on the market just like any other monetary good, such as gold.

vijayboyapati··on Dogecoin market manipulation?
This illustrates a simple idea in economics: cartels are hard to maintain because participants will look out for their own self-interest.
vijayboyapati··on TigerDirect.com Now Accepts Bitcoin Payments
Merchants have the choice whether or not to hold bitcoin. It's probably fair to say many or most merchants will choose to receive dollars because their costs are in dollars, and the price of bitcoin is still volatile. But the price is volatile only because bitcoin is still nascent and not widely held. As it becomes more widely held and more liquid, the volatility will go down, and the willingness to accept and hold bitcoin will increase (i.e., there will be an increase in reservation demand). Merchants who are willing to accept and hold bitcoins will also benefit from lower transaction costs - those who have the conversion done for them are implicitly paying the transaction cost related to the volatility and bid/ask spread in the market (or perhaps more likely it is the consumer paying this implicit transaction fee).

It's also important to realize we're in the very very early days of bitcoin. This is really like 1994 for the Internet.

vijayboyapati··on Rapgenius Uniques Fall 90%
Not only is this bad for RapGenius, it's bad for Google, and most importantly bad for Google's users. Yes, RapGenius screwed up, and they've paid the price. But they've publicly recognized what they did and apologized. Google really should reinstate their ranking, because people searching for lyrics right now are being given the huge disservice of using the ultra-spammy lyrics sites from days of yore.
vijayboyapati··on Bitcoin and positive vs. normative economics
There is perhaps no compliment greater than a criticism from the econostrologist in chief, Paul Krugman.

He is right about one thing tho. Bitcoin IS a bubble. But that is not a pejorative. Any good that becomes money will have a price that is far higher than is warranted by its use demand. It doesn't matter whether the floor price is 10% of the monetary premium, 1% or 0%. The monetary premium is based not on the good's use value, but its serviceability as money. I.e., is it fungible, divisible, transportable, verifiable etc. And along all these attributes bitcoin shines - even more than gold.

The best explanation of this so-called "bubble theory of money" is proffered by Moldbug. To wit:

http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2011/04/on-mone...

and

http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2013/04/bitcoin...

vijayboyapati··on So, my Coinbase account was hacked, bitcoin stolen, now what?
I highly recommend the above advice. 2-factor auth is a simple step that hugely increases security. You must have it on your email at minimum - since having access to your email typically gives you access to many accounts connected to your email - and probably most of your financial accounts.

I might also encourage Coinbase to limit the maximum dollar value of transfer from an account to, say, $100 per day until someone enables two-factor auth. Typically people have very poor security habits, and strongly encouraging them to improve them will help both users and Coinbase's reputation.

vijayboyapati··on Thoughts on Bitcoin
Sam sees the flaw in his own argument - when he mentions gold and the possibility of its use a store of value. But he doesn't understand the full significance of his own comment. Moldbug has by far the most compelling (imo) theory on the origin of money and why bitcoin (and gold) float far above their use value. These two posts cover it very well:

http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2011/04/on-mone...

http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2013/04/bitcoin...

I highly recommend them to anyone trying to understand the economics of bitcoin

vijayboyapati··on I Am Not Satoshi
Because their theory inculpated a person (Satoshi) with criminal activity and they were wrong. That is why an apology was appropriate. This isn't just a matter of scientific incorrectness - someone's reputation was attacked.
vijayboyapati··on A Prediction: Bitcoin Is Doomed to Fail
He is essentially giving the chartalist theory of money. Money cannot arise except through the fiat of the state. Chartalists hate the Mengerian theory on the origin of money because it posits that money arises as a market phenomena. Eventually the state co-opted money, but that does not mean money arose because of the state. The emergence of bitcoin is a thorn in the side to chartalists. We can't really go back and figure out the exact history of how gold emerged as money, but bitcoin is being monetized right before our eyes. The angst felt by chartalists is also felt by inflationists. They hate the idea that you could have a successful currency that cannot be inflated beyond a fixed supply. So they are naturally defensive. Every success bitcoin has undermines their world view.
vijayboyapati··on I Am Not Satoshi
Looks like they posted a retraction: http://money.cnn.com/2013/11/27/technology/bitcoin-silk-road...

I hope they also apologized.

vijayboyapati··on Missing hard drive containing Bitcoins worth £4m in Newport landfill site
Ironically, some real mining might be needed to get those bitcoins back!
vijayboyapati··on I Am Not Satoshi
I wonder, is research like journalism where an academic is morally obliged to issue a retraction or correction for conclusions shown, conclusively, to be false?
vijayboyapati··on How Hacker News ranking really works: scoring, controversy, and penalties
What I find quite strange is that I have posted articles which show up in the new section, then later when they make the front page, it shows them posted as someone else. Either dupe detection isn't working (these are very simple URLs typically, like from the New York Times) or HN is rewarding the post to someone else after I've posted it. Weird.
vijayboyapati··on Senate hearing on Bitcoin [video]
This sounds very encouraging to me. A number of panelists have talked about how banks aren't allowing btc businesses to setup up basic checking accounts and how this needs to be fixed if the US isn't going to be left behind.
vijayboyapati··on What It's Like to Fail
This was a great read. Reminds me of a modern day version of George Orwell's classic, Down and Out in Paris and London
vijayboyapati··on Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable
He actually received a total of a little more than 19 bitcoins. He's a very popular and respected blogger among libertarian circles. One of the most well read (of history and economics) authors I've come across.
vijayboyapati··on Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable
This is what the real-time monetization of a good looks like. In the early stages you have massive price increases until there is enough liquidity and volatility declines. Bitcoin looks like a bubble, but money is inherently a bubble phenomena: http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2013/04/bitcoin...
vijayboyapati··on Why The Value of Bitcoin is Skyrocketing
My thinking is that if bitcoin becomes a monetary standard for online commerce it's orders of magnitude undervalued. If not, it's probably overvalued. So it's a perfect asymmetric bet. The most you can lose is the price of buying a few (or many) bitcoins. The most you could win is 100x or maybe even more. It's kind of like making an angel investment, except that instead of investing in a single company, you're investing in an entire economy. Imagine if instead of being able to buy shares in Pets.com or Altavista in 1995, you had a chance to buy a share in the Internet as a whole. That would have been an awesome asymmetric bet
vijayboyapati··on Why The Value of Bitcoin is Skyrocketing
I still think Moldbug has by far the explanation of the increasing moneyness and price of bitcoin: http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2013/04/bitcoin...

So when people say bitcoin is "bubble" they are essentially correct - although the condescension is usually misplaced. All money is a bubble in the sense that its reservation demand is far higher than its use value warrants. This is true for the dollar, and it's also true for gold, which also has a large element of "moneyness".

vijayboyapati··on Poll: What's your target price for 1 BTC?
I honestly don't know. The world is changing so fast now that it wouldn't surprise me if this happened in 10 years, or even 5 years. As context, just 6 years ago there was no iphone. 8 years ago there was no Youtube. 9 years ago there was no Google maps. 10 years ago there was no Facebook. I like to think how much these things have already changed the world, and my life, and how none of them were around just a decade ago. I'm very excited to see what the world will look like 10 years hence.

edit: a word

vijayboyapati··on Poll: What's your target price for 1 BTC?
The increasing price is a reflection of an increasing reservation demand for bitcoin - which is another way of saying bitcoin is increasing in "moneyness". Bitcoin's market capitalization is about 5B right now. Gold's is about 7trillion. On a technical level bitcoin is superior as a money to gold, so I wouldn't be surprised if bitcoin attained some large fraction of gold's market capitalization, eventually. E.g., it would not surprise me if bitcoin, or some other digital currency, increased in market cap to, say, 500B over the long term (i.e., less than 10% of gold's market cap, but 100x higher than it is today), giving it a price of approximately $50,000 per bitcoin.
vijayboyapati··on Czech bitcoin exchange Bitcash.cz hacked, up to 4,000 user wallets emptied
Using relatives is fine; my only point is that bitcoin is new and interesting and newsworthy and the negatives tend to get focused on. I honestly do not think that crime is more rampant in the bitcoin economy than the dollar economy. And this is just considering financial theft, and not institutionalized crime - e.g., innumerable instances of malfeasance committed by large banks or the wholesale robbery of the population through inflation of the dollar. Considered in total, I think bitcoin represents a far more honest and less crime-prone monetary system.
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →