748 karma · joined September 28, 2011
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem
[2] https://mises.org/econcalc.asp
[3] Reflections after communism, Robert Heilbroner (apologies to those without a subscription) http://www.newyorker.com/archive/1990/09/10/1990_09_10_091_T...
http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2013/04/bitcoin...
Also see: http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2011/04/on-mone...
In the greater scheme of things this fall is no more significant than the last falls when bitcoin dropped from $30ish to $2, or when it dropped from $267 to $50ish. The question still remains: will bitcoin become a standard for online payments and a medium of savings? If it will, it will be a bargain whether it's $10, $100 or even $1000, and all these price movements, and the kerfuffle they cause will seem amazingly quaint to those looking back on the past (our present).
- It's false that it's not a medium of savings. It has reservation demand which is the only reason it has a price. It does not matter that it has "no assets in it", whatever that confused statement means. The dollar also no longer has any asset backing. The medium of savings role exists while people perceive there is value in holding a monetary good in the hope it will appreciate in the future. They perceive it will appreciate because it has comparative advantages to other goods which serve a similar purpose. Bitcoin has many comparative advantages to other monetary goods. In particular, it allows the transfer of value to anyone, anywhere in the world, near instantaneously, with low transaction fees, without the need for a trusted intermediary such as a bank. This has literally never been possible before in the entire history of civilization.
- It's true that bitcoin is not currently a unit of account. This mostly has to do with the fact that it's still nascent and needs to increase in liquidity. As it does more and more entrepreneurs who are primarily accepting bitcoin (it will start with the miners) will begin to calculate profit and loss in bitcoin terms
- It's true bitcoin is used for so-called criminal activities. But so too is the dollar. In fact, the dollar isn't just used for buying illegal drugs, the dollar is used to funnel gigantic sums of tax payer wealth to well connected bankers when their businesses fail. Which is the bigger crime, Nouriel?
- Bitcoin isn't susceptible to hacking - individual bitcoin businesses are susceptible to hacking such as the incredibly incompetent MtGox, which deserved to fail. Blaming Bitcoin for the incompetence of a particular business is like saying the dollar is a failure because Lehman Brothers collapsed. To me that is a much worse "hack" than anything that happened with Gox.
- And no, Bitcoin is NOT a ponzi scheme. Bitcoins are a monetary good whose price fluctuates with demand on the market just like any other monetary good, such as gold.
It's also important to realize we're in the very very early days of bitcoin. This is really like 1994 for the Internet.
He is right about one thing tho. Bitcoin IS a bubble. But that is not a pejorative. Any good that becomes money will have a price that is far higher than is warranted by its use demand. It doesn't matter whether the floor price is 10% of the monetary premium, 1% or 0%. The monetary premium is based not on the good's use value, but its serviceability as money. I.e., is it fungible, divisible, transportable, verifiable etc. And along all these attributes bitcoin shines - even more than gold.
The best explanation of this so-called "bubble theory of money" is proffered by Moldbug. To wit:
http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2011/04/on-mone...
and
http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2013/04/bitcoin...
I might also encourage Coinbase to limit the maximum dollar value of transfer from an account to, say, $100 per day until someone enables two-factor auth. Typically people have very poor security habits, and strongly encouraging them to improve them will help both users and Coinbase's reputation.
http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2011/04/on-mone...
http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2013/04/bitcoin...
I highly recommend them to anyone trying to understand the economics of bitcoin
I hope they also apologized.
So when people say bitcoin is "bubble" they are essentially correct - although the condescension is usually misplaced. All money is a bubble in the sense that its reservation demand is far higher than its use value warrants. This is true for the dollar, and it's also true for gold, which also has a large element of "moneyness".
edit: a word