HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

virtuous_signal

651 karma · joined July 2, 2019

submissionscomments
virtuous_signal··on Your New Medical Credit Score Could Deny You Care
>And given that it’s now a US requirement to have medical insurance

It became a "requirement" in 2014 with Obamacare, but since the repeal of the individual mandate in 2019, there is no financial punishment (except well, the increased possibility of medical bankruptcy) for not having insurance:

https://www.kff.org/health-costs/issue-brief/how-repeal-of-t...

virtuous_signal··on The secret of academic success, or fun filled failure if you prefer
I can see that perspective too. I had interpeted it as "don't make it seem that our research (via seminar talks) can be understood by undergrads!"
virtuous_signal··on The secret of academic success, or fun filled failure if you prefer
My takeaway/tldr: Act in a way that makes your colleagues (potentially future colleagues) feel smart.
virtuous_signal··on [dead]
A much more recent piece on the same subject came out yesterday: https://thehill.com/opinion/education/480603-what-is-uc-davi...

In the middle they link to Berkeley's report on one hiring cycle in the life sciences. In particular it turns out that the first cut, leaving only 24% of candidates, was done solely on the basis of diversity statements. You can see in the tables how some inversions in the demographics of the applicant pool occur from the initial to final rounds, e.g., white applicants made up 54% of a pool, then 48% of a longlist, then 13% of a shortlist.

I know affirmative action for university admissions and employment is illegal--is this a "technically" legal way to get around that?

virtuous_signal··on How knitters got knotted in a purity spiral
If you want to see the mentioned knitter's one-year-old blog post about her excitement at visiting India, including her apology, it is here: https://fringeassociation.com/2019/01/07/2019-my-year-of-col...

This will be fascinating for future internet archaeologists.

virtuous_signal··on How Firm Are the Foundations of Mind-Set Theory?
Full study from sci-hub: https://sci-hub.tw/https://doi.org/10.1177%2F095679761989758...
virtuous_signal··on The Internet of Beefs
This struck me as too tidy, so in the spirit of debate let me offer a little pushback:

>We are seeing such things dissolve because we have other options these days.

1) Do we have other options? I think we do, but I don't think the saturation is nearly as high as churchgoing or temple-attending was throughout history.

>In the past, people often grudgingly tolerated it because they had no place to go, not because being part of some larger community was some wonderfully fulfilling experience most of the time.

2) Religions grew and spread in every civilization for millenia. Ancestor worship in East Asia. Hinduism in South Asia. Animism among natives everywhere. Christianity in the West. What if religion and religious community grew and took the forms they did, because they met humanity's social and emotional needs?

So I would restate the original comment as asking (i) what problems arise when something everyone depended on so long disappears in a relatively short time, and (ii) how can we handle those problems. Importantly, stating these questions isn't suggesting that everyone needs to return to religion (which wouldn't even be possible without un-discovering science).

virtuous_signal··on The Internet of Beefs
I'm also LGBT and I have to guess that

>in many cities the queer people all know each other

is massively untrue based on my own anecdatum. Where I'm from, there is certainly a group who all know each other, who hang out at the gay bars, and who seem to have dated many others in the same group at some point. I have seen this by snooping on instagram or facebook - the same set of faces shows up at any gay event, and they do all seem to know each other.

I assume you're in that kind of community in your city. I'm glad for you. I'm certainly not within my city, although I've had "encounters" with people in that group. Given the significant percentage (3.5% according to google) of LGBT people in the population, I have to believe the vast majority of LGBT people are on the outside of any such group you're describing. Our social life is probably drawn from much more average sources (work, college friends, possibly church) than what you describe.

virtuous_signal··on The Internet of Beefs
Albeit I didn't know about those communes, but I think LGBT acceptance was extremely rapid. The only other change I'm ready to compare it to was slavery and black civil rights: consider that the first state to legalize same sex marriage was Massachusetts in 2004. Over the next 11 years, we reached 37/50 states total, and then in 2015 with the supreme court decision we reach all 50/50.

For civil rights: we had slavery since the arrival in 1619 (which is the date I hear); we get the emancipation proclamation in 1863 ending slavery; but there are still Jim Crow laws until the civil rights and voting rights acts in 1964 and 1965.

To me that makes the road to LGBT acceptance sound extremely rapid, but someone with more awareness of historical trends in the US should put these into context. In particular when might we say various struggles began seriously, or entered the public consciousness.

virtuous_signal··on The Internet of Beefs
This is spot on. I wonder if this exodus has resulted in people trying to make workplaces their "religious community"; but obviously people who happen to be at the same company don't have any reason to agree on important issues. So then the mission becomes trying to make everyone at work care about and agree on <chosen social issue>.
virtuous_signal··on Incarcerated and Facebook
A company can choose to ban you from their service for this. Uber eats, probably not an issue. But imagine the inconvenience of not having Uber for the rest of your life. Or worse, Airbnb which doesn’t even have a close competitor.

I would begrudgingly take the loss to continue having access to their marketplaces. These companies have notoriously terrible customer service and they don’t really have any reason to fix it.

virtuous_signal··on It costs $10k to ‘own’ a Chick-fil-A franchise
By casting the widest net I mean they are including everything possible in the denominator: perhaps everyone who does the first stage of the process. I know way too many people from my small social circle, who got jobs at Google, to believe that only 2 in 1000 serious applicants gets in.
virtuous_signal··on It costs $10k to ‘own’ a Chick-fil-A franchise
This website[1] says that $5mm net worth standard is for multiunit franchisees, whereas it's $1mm[2] for (presumably) a single store

[1]https://www.thebalancesmb.com/most-popular-food-franchises-a...

[2]https://www.thebalancesmb.com/wendy-s-franchise-review-13503...

virtuous_signal··on It costs $10k to ‘own’ a Chick-fil-A franchise
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/28/business/subway-franchise...

Apparently too many subways has caused bully by Subway the corporation of franchisees over good locations.

virtuous_signal··on It costs $10k to ‘own’ a Chick-fil-A franchise
I think either of these acceptance rates are computed by casting the widest net possible. Nevertheless I have to believe Chick-Fil-A has a very rigorous process for hiring managers, who in turn know how to hire good workers; I have never once encountered the typical surly fast food worker at any of their restaurants.
virtuous_signal··on A GRE-mathematics-inspired quiz used to test higher math problem solving skills
This has errors, including at least two problems with the wrong answer.
virtuous_signal··on Clifford torus
>Tori in 4 dimensions are just nicer in general.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clifford_torus#Still_more_gene...

Torus (as in 2-dimensional torus) is nice in R^4, and in general the n-dimensional torus is nice in R^{2n}

virtuous_signal··on Clifford torus
For anyone wondering about the significance of this, the following is my loose explanation: you probably know that a torus is the surface of a doughnut. Better yet, it can be thought of as a square with edges identified (like the videogame screen when you play asteroids: when you reach the top edge you come out the bottom edge at the corresponding place; same for left and right). The latter representation is "better" than the doughnut in the sense that it's symmetric: the horizontal and vertical directions are treated the same. But it has the downside that it requires "identifications"; corresponding points at the top and the bottom represent the "same" point while points in the middle of the screen are unique.

The doughnut representation satisfies uniqueness everywhere, but isn't symmetric: the circles in the vertical direction are all the same size; but if you consider circles in the other direction, they depend on the angle; for instance circles at the top of the doughnut are bigger than the circle encircling the doughnut hole, and smaller than the circle encircling the entire doughnut. You can visualize how this asymmetry happens by turning the square into a doughnut: start with the square above; make it into a roll so that the left and right sides are identified, and then now bend the roll to identify the top and bottom edges: if you bent towards you, then the backside gets stretched a lot more than the front side on the way to forming the full doughnut.

Clifford torus is a way to satisfy both properties (symmetry and uniqueness) at the same time and it's a theorem that one needs to be in 4 dimensions for this to happen.

virtuous_signal··on Algorithm for Drawing Trees
Fantastic. I would not have thought that binary-tree-drawing could be such a complicated problem.
virtuous_signal··on Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins
No -- I'm going off news that came out in light of the lawsuit against Harvard recently, but I have no reason to believe other elite universities handle it differently. These things are shrouded in secrecy for the precise reason that it is massively unpopular, but at least in this case we got an inside look because of discovery for the lawsuit.

Harvard creates a special "Dean's Interest List" (https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2018/10/18/day-three-harv...) which includes celebrities, "top donors", and certain athletes. The admissions rate restricted to this list was 42.2% in 6 recent years.

virtuous_signal··on Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins
This totally might be the case. However it's still a good change and might lead to other colleges following suit. I'm reminded of a recent trend among the Ivies where Princeton was the first to eliminate loans from its financial aid packages[1] and instead offer only grants. Of course they have the largest endowment per student in the country, so the amount they collected from low-income students via loans was probably trivial. However it did seem to kick off a trend to the extent that all of the ivies[2] (dartmouth and cornell being more stringent) have replaced loans with grants for low-income students.

[1] https://paw.princeton.edu/article/no-loan-pledge-decade-late... [2] https://blog.collegevine.com/does-the-ivy-league-offer-schol...

virtuous_signal··on Algorithm for Drawing Trees
So the author mentions hearing about the Reingold-Tilford Algorithm which wouldn't work for the example given since R-T is meant for binary trees and a family tree might have more than 2 nodes.

Which led me to wonder why is there even an "algorithm" per se for binary trees: wouldn't it be acceptable to just trace out a complete binary tree with spaces reserved for each potential node, and only fill in a space with a node if it is non-null? Or does this not meet some criterion of "niceness" for drawings?

virtuous_signal··on Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins
That's true, and in addition to the claim that legacy admits make the entire college experience more affordable for everyone else, is probably the strongest objection.

I would venture the following: if we agree on the norm that "power should stop being transferred dynastically or through nepotism in a modern civilized society", and abolishing legacy preferences bring us closer to this norm, then the negative effects will be transient, and worth it.

virtuous_signal··on Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins
I'm aware that it's typically an edge; what I mean by "mediocre" is not a personal description, but rather the state of being quantitatively less meritorious than those students who gained admission without the legacy edge.
virtuous_signal··on Online activity is now effectively a social ‘credit score’
This article feels like a big reach. Airbnb wants to keep its platform from being used for sex work (in my opinion this is understandable as once a platform begins allowing "sex stuff" it easily gets pigeonholed into being that platform - think Tumblr or Craiglist personals). So their algorithms to prevent advertisement for sex work caused at least one false positive. This, according to the author, means we now have social credit scores a la Black Mirror. (and was the vandalism at the end really necessary?)
virtuous_signal··on Show HN: Store your luggage in local shops
I think for a certain class of workers, their car is used exactly once to get to work and once to get back. If that were the case I could see Uber usefully taken control of the car in between.

A better example would have been Waze Carpool or even older the practice of "slugging" which finds riders needing to go a similar way and saves toll or gas.

virtuous_signal··on Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins
I haven't heard of studies on this but I would say the effect is potentially huge. For instance, just going by numbers of legacy admits at Harvard: www.cnbc.com/2019/04/07/harvards-freshman-class-is-more-than-one-third-legacy.html

And any natural experiment that could have been done due to JHU's change was probably messed up by the largest donation to a university, ever: www.nytimes.com/2018/11/18/us/michael-bloomberg-johns-hopkins-donation.html

virtuous_signal··on Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins
>The year I arrived, Hopkins had more legacy students in its freshman class (12.5 percent) than students who were eligible for Pell Grants (9 percent). Now those numbers are reversed—3.5 percent of students in this year’s freshman class have a legacy connection to the university, and 19.1 percent are Pell-eligible

This change happened in five years. Such a policy change would be extremely popular. For proponents of race-based affirmative action, this would serve as somewhat of a proxy due to the correlation between race and class. For opponents, removing legacy preferences makes admissions more meritocratic.

The only groups with something to lose are (i) mediocre children of alumni, and (ii) the university's endowments if alumni decrease their donations. I don't believe (i) is a strong factor in a university's calculations, which leaves (ii). I believe universities are happy to see the public fighting about race-based affirmative action: indeed, dividing and pitting the low- and middle-income groups against each other over their limited subset of the pie, means they will not be working together to increase their overall share of the pie.

(I think this issue could and should be considered orthogonal to race-based affirmative action. Race-based AA was never put on a stable enough legal footing and will continue to bounce back and forth in the courts until it's resolved, while this could be resolved quickly and uncontroversially.)

virtuous_signal··on Show HN: Store your luggage in local shops
This sounds great. I would compare it more to airbnb - using someone's stuff that would otherwise go unused. So actually extracting lost value. Uber might one day become that (I hear the typical personal car goes unused something like 90% of the day), but when everything is self-driving.
virtuous_signal··on An alternative argument for why women leave STEM
32 hour workweeks might work but there will always be the issue of defection.

If a company allows employees to take unlimited leave, then worker A who avails him/herself of it, will be at a disadvantage to worker B who keeps working like a dog, when it comes time for promotions.

If company A mandates 32 hour workweeks, then they will eventually lose out to their competitor company B who mandates 40 hours (or more informally).

If country A says ALL companies must have <=32 hour workweeks, then country B, with no such law, will become more productive. And on and on. There will always be some less enlightened competitor to take advantage -- and do we really think America is ready to stop being #1?

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →