HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vishnumohandas

2,085 karma · joined November 23, 2016

v [at] vishnu.tech
submissionscomments
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Ente is available on the App Store: https://apps.apple.com/app/id1542026904

Looks like we've quite a bit of "ASO" work todo. Thanks for the heads up!

Regarding encryption, the link you shared points to Immich. Ente uses client side encryption, so your data is encrypted before it leaves your device, and only you have the keys to decrypt it.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
This[1] seems like a well maintained repo.

And thank you for the pointers, we'll try to get ourselves added here :)

[1]: https://github.com/awesome-selfhosted/awesome-selfhosted

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Yes, it means on device.
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
From what I remember, 2FAS does not offer e2ee backups. I'm not sure if that has changed.

There's a discussion here on PrivacyGuides, that might offer more details: https://discuss.privacyguides.net/t/add-2fas-authenticator-a...

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
This was the intent.

But like OP pointed out, "reputed" could also mean

> generally believed to exist or be something specified, but not definitely the case. "a reputed budget of $165 million"

For now I've replaced it with the less ambiguous word ("reputable") to remove any confusion and will pick a better way to phrase this the next time we iterate on the landing page.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Did not expect to see this! This was recording during Ente's early days, and that was a very special time. Thank you for jogging my memories, and thank you for the wishes. You're very kind :)
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Account creation is optional, and unlike Aegis, Ente is cross platform. The latter might not be relevant if you aren't opting into e2ee backups.
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Thank you, you're very kind! :)
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Hey!

> data out

You can use our Desktop app[1] or CLI[2] to export your data, incrementally. There's a toggle within our Desktop app that will perform this operation continuously into a directory of your choosing. You can of course script the CLI however you'd like.

There is no data-loss, you export what you import.

> clients are not open source

Our clients have always been open source. You can find them within our monorepo here[3].

Currently you have to pass a flag at build time to configure the endpoint, but there's a discussion[4] to add an option in-app instead.

> Immich and Photoprism

Ente comes with e2ee[5] and replication strategies[6]. The former means that we've to run ML on the Edge, while Immich and Photoprism can run ML on their servers. If your primary use case is self-hosting, Immich is the more "intelligent" option. If you value convenience, Ente is the one.

[1]: https://ente.io/downloads/desktop

[2]: https://github.com/ente-io/cli

[3]: https://github.com/ente-io/ente

[4]: https://github.com/ente-io/ente/discussions/504

[5]: https://ente.io/architecture

[6]: https://ente.io/reliability

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
This is on the cards. Thanks for reinforcing the importance :)
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
TIL about progressive JPEGs, will check it out, thanks!

We currently render the thumbnail first (in most cases it's available locally) and then replace it with the original image once fetched from remote, while replicating the zoom and pan operations (if any) performed by the user. So it is "progressive" in some sense, but goes from something like 20% to 100% in one shot.

("20%" is a simplification, the actual value will depend on the resolution of the original image and that of the generated thumbnail, the latter is fixed)

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Update: This comment[1] made me realize that you could run Ente locally, use our desktop app to backup your data, and then export it back out to get a clean copy.

Not very straight forward, but it should work :)

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39576825

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Hey, the server was open sourced just yesterday. We are yet to update our landing page copies, and we definitely weren't ready to be in HN today (but are glad to be here!) :)

So there is no black-box magic that the subscription enables. Our live, breathing production setup is available in a monorepo here[1].

> is this not even possible

This is very much possible.

I've added an updated comment here[2], thanks!

[1]: https://github.com/ente-io/ente

[2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39576920

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Yes, there is https://tmsearch.uspto.gov/search/search-information
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Thank you Frank! We really wouldn't be here without you!
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Semantic search is ready. Face recognition should be ready by Q3 2024.
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
The server was open sourced just yesterday, wasn't planning to show HN this soon, but here we are :)

We've a discussion to add an option in-app to configure the endpoint @ https://github.com/ente-io/ente/discussions/504

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
This is currently only supported via build flags.

Addition of an option in-app is being discussed @ https://github.com/ente-io/ente/discussions/504

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
That's odd, thanks for the report, will look into this!
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
The primary issue with Bitwarden is that your passwords and 2FA tokens are stored at the same place, essentially nullifying the second factor.

Also, the feature to store 2FA tokens is only available on Bitwarden's paid plan, while with Ente it's free.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Sorry, we don't support use cases above 6TB right now. This is an arbitrary limitation, it is just that we haven't figured out a sensible price point for larger tiers.
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
To double check, I just recorded a slow-motion video, downloaded it from Ente to my desktop, ran `ffmpeg -i FILE.MOV`, and the stream info says:

```

Stream #0:0[0x1](und): Video: hevc (Main) (hvc1 / 0x31637668), yuv420p(tv, bt709), 1920x1080, 78644 kb/s, 239.70 fps, 240 tbr, 2400 tbn (default)

```

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
I believe that we can build an incredibly profitable business by serving photos well. SmugMug has proven this. But their audience is Pro while ours is consumers. ARPU and TAM are different for both, but I think the product will favor us (once we are about more than just e2ee).

That said, I understand your concern.

Open-sourcing the server was a step towards ensuring posterity. Pricing ourself sustainably from day #1 was another. We'll have to do a lot more work on this front over the next few decades and eventually find someone aligned with our ethos to pass the baton to.

I find this to be a very interesting problem to work on :)

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Not yet, but you should be able to drag-and-drop the data on your disk into Ente's desktop app[1].

Please note that if you're primarily using SmugMug to store RAW files, their support (in terms of previewing capabilities) is limited right now. It's on our roadmap, and we will prioritize it, but just wanted to give you a heads up.

[1]: https://ente.io/download/desktop

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Not right now, sorry!

There's this tool that can fix capture times: https://github.com/mattwilson1024/google-photos-exif

There are perhaps more that I'm unaware of.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Yes, we do backup updated photos.

Just tested out a slow-motion video on iOS, we unfortunately don't retain the transformation.

On the brighter side of things, it's just a transformation. We are retaining the original file as is. So will look into how Immich is handling this format. Thanks for bringing this up!

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Hey, not yet.

Currently you've to pass build time flags[1] to modify the endpoint.

Providing an option in-app to change the endpoint is under discussion[2].

[1]: https://github.com/ente-io/ente/blob/main/server/RUNNING.md#...

[2]: https://github.com/ente-io/ente/discussions/504

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Thanks for the information. This is sad if true. In my limited experience Zoho been an honest business to deal with.
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
We don't support nested albums, yet.

Thanks for sharing your use case, will figure out how to best solve for it.

(Right now a "stream" of photos within a feed sounds like simpler UX than nested-albums, but will think more)

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Thank you for your kind words, will forward them :)
← PreviousPage 3 of 12Next →