HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vitaminj

548 karma · joined September 25, 2007

power systems engineer
submissionscomments
vitaminj··on How To Make The World's Easiest $1 Billion
Fractional reserve banking refers to banks holding only a fraction of their deposits in the form of liquid reserves, and lending out the rest.

The scheme in the article is about borrowing $9b from the Fed with $1b equity at a low rate, and then selling it to the government for a higher rate. So it's straight up interest-rate arbitrage.

In fact there's not even a claim in the article that the $1b in equity are deposits, so this bank is most likely not even a commercial bank. For all intents and purposes, this appears to be an investment bank, and it's very unlikely that it'd even have an account with the Fed to borrow that kind of money.

vitaminj··on What is math?
Also check out the reddit thread that inspired this post - http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/abiax/can_someone...

Some very eloquent responses in there. I was moved.

vitaminj··on How Wall Street is making its billions
Non-government deposit banks are legally allowed to create money (up to some reserve ratio).
vitaminj··on In which I stomp on some of our glorious “green shoots”
While I agree that most of the entrepreneurs don't have brilliant ideas, I thought there were two clear standouts:

1) The guy that developed carbon nanotube probes for microscopy applications (www.cnprobes.com)

2) The guy that hacked away in his basement and created new higher performance heavy duty machine lubricants (www.greasewarehouse.com)

vitaminj··on What happened to Argentina?
The idea that protectionism is bad needs to be qualified. Whilst the successful Asian countries that are cited here (eg. Japan, Korea, Taiwan, etc) are export-oriented and encouraged trade, they were all quite protectionist early on. Big companies like Toyota, LG, Hyundai, Samsung were all heavily subsidised by their governments in the early years, and were aided by other protectionist measures (such as local content requirements, import tariffs, etc). In these cases, protectionism served a purpose - which is to protect local industry until it is globally competitive (ie. infant industry protection).

Notwithstanding, these protectionist policies don't always work out (eg. see Indonesia's airplane industry). Furthermore, Korea and Japan have had (and still have) an extremely difficult time reversing protectionist policies due to the lobby groups that represent the vested interests of the now successful companies.

vitaminj··on Does ‘microlending’ actually fight poverty?
I can't say this is at all surprising. My experience in providing rural communities with electricity is somewhat analagous to what is being said about micro-credit.

I've been working on rural electrification in a small developing country for the last 7 months. Donors and NGOs are always banging on about how access to electricity will lead to income-generating and educational activities among the villagers, eg. they could buy a bamboo-cutting machine or study textbooks at night under fluorescent lamps.

But we invariably find that apart from lighting, the first thing most households do when they get electricity is buy a home stereo system or a tv and satellite dish. One of my colleagues scoured the countryside for evidence of income-generating activities and the best he could find was a bunch of villagers sorting farm produce under a lamp.

So like micro-credit, it seems that access to electricity is more about making life in rural communities more convenient than it is about climbing out of poverty.

vitaminj··on The Iraqi who saved Norway from oil
The risks associated with introducing new technology need to be taken into account. An oil company may not think it's worth the risk to try untested technology (or rather, try standard techniques on untested reservoir conditions). But the Iraqi engineer / regulator, who isn't bearing the costs of failed forays into new technology, may think its a good idea. So their incentives are different.
vitaminj··on The Iraqi who saved Norway from oil
The oil industry generally isn't very innovative, nor do they tend to test costly, untried technologies on their assets that already make billions of dollars.

Take water injection for instance, which is a standard method for maintaining reservoir pressure, ie. the pumping of water into the oil/gas reservoir to raise the pressure. In order to implement such a scheme, a well slot would be needed for the source water pump, and at least one other well slot for the injection well. Typically, these are done on separate water injection platforms. Add the cost of the workover drill rig to drill the wells and the increased cost of water/oil separation on the production platform, and it's a very expensive exercise... especially if it may not actually work (which is what is implied in the article with water injection in chalk reservoirs, which could potentially cause reservoir fracturing).

An oil company, especially a relatively new one like Statoil in the 70s/80s, would be justified to balk at costly experimentation with their fields, and would probably wait for others to prove the concept first. This is even more justifiable when the field is gigantic (like the Ekofisk field). Oftentimes, cutting edge technologies are used on smaller, marginal fields with relatively high lift prices, and where oil price volatility is the difference between profit and loss (I worked on a project in 2002/3 when oil was around $25 a barrel and this field was only profitable at a price of $30 per barrel... the field actually needed water injection right from first oil, which means that it was definitely marginal... so they were lucky when oil prices shot past $100). In any case, you don't see much innovation happening in the huge saudi fields that have very low lift prices.

vitaminj··on Study Says World's Stocks Controlled by Select Few
The results raise questions of where and when a company could choose to exert this influence, but Glattfelder and Battiston are reluctant to speculate.

"In this kind of science, complex systems, you're not aiming at making predictions [like] ... where the tennis ball will be at given place in given time," Battiston said.

It's nice to see that physicists are able to recognise the limits of knowledge when it comes to complex systems. You probably wouldn't hear a macroeconomist / econometrician say that, they would typically weigh in with some kind of prediction based on a dubious, self-referential model.

vitaminj··on Results of The Hacker Survey
Will you remove some of the obvious fake outliers from the data set? eg. Line 338 on the .csv file is a 99 year old female self-employed, pre-high schooler with 10+ kids working 140 hours per week and earning $1M per year. Sounds a little suspect to me...

Not to mention the 22 year old student who completed the questionaire 4 times and has 70 years of experience, works negative hours and earns $100M.

Or the divorced 407 year old female with 700 years of experience and 8 kids.

vitaminj··on On those "Entitled" Twenty-Somethings
If you go to the bank and deposit $20, you are entitled to get your $20 from the bank. If you fulfill your half of a contract, you are entitled to the other party’s performance.

Well, if you enter into a verbal agreement with someone, you're not necessarily entitled to anything. When your parents told you to work hard at school and college with the promise that the world will take care of you, you didn't enter into a legitimate contract. So despite your whining, the world doesn't owe you shit.

vitaminj··on [dead]
The government thinks they'll receive $990M at $50/oz in tax revenue. That means they've projected to sell 19.8 million ounces, which is equivalent to about 561 metric tonnes. That's a lot of weed...

EDIT: from http://www.canorml.org/background/CA_legalization.html:

"Over 1.6 million Californians have smoked marijuana within the past 30 days, according to the most recent National Household Survey on Drug Abuse, which found 5.6% of all Americans over age 12 are current marijuana users. Insofar as these figures are based on self-reporting of illicit activity, they are undoubtedly on the low side.

According to the survey, one-third of this population, or 530,000 Californians, are daily users.

The bulk of consumption is accounted for by "regular" users, who consume marijuana at least several times per week. Included is a small minority of very heavy smokers (10 or more joints per day), who push the average consumption figures upwards. According to a British survey by the Independent Drug Monitoring Unit [1], "regular" users average 2 oz of cannabis per month or about 2 grams per day (a gram yields one or two joints). The population of regular users is somewhat larger than that of daily users. Assuming 600,000 - 700,000 "regular users" in California averaging 2 grams per day, consumption by this group accounts for 1.2 to 1.4 million grams per day. Assuming the remaining 1 million monthly users average one joint every 10 days, this adds another 100,000 grams per day. Total marijuana consumption by Californians may therefore be reasonably estimated at 1.3 to 1.5 million grams per day, or about 1 to 1.2 million pounds per year."

vitaminj··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
Laos
vitaminj··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
Slightly off the beaten track - I'm currently in a small developing country in Southeast Asia working on renewable energy projects for rural villages. I've been here for 4 months and am absolutely loving it... it's actually a satisfying use of an electrical engineering degree!
vitaminj··on [dead]
For those that can't be bothered going through the photo slideshow, here they are:

Engineer

Nurse

Skilled Trades

Teacher

Sales Representative

Technician

Truck Driver

Information Technology Staff

Laborer

Machinist or Machine Operator

vitaminj··on The Capitalist Manifesto: Greed Is Good (To a point)
I'm not a Krugman apologist, and can't bear to read his NYT columns, but he does actually have academic credibility ( even though it is from work he did a fair while ago).

This is a good analysis of Krugman's contributions to international trade from when he won the John Bates Clark medal in 1991 - http://web.mit.edu/krugman/www/dixit.html. I'm not sure he's done anything too groundbreaking since then.

He's also co-written the textbook most undergraduate economists use (including me) for international trade - http://www.amazon.com/International-Economics-Theory-Policy-...

vitaminj··on Stop Aiding Africa - The Daily Beast
I was rather underwhelmed by this book, which has somewhat blunt policy prescriptions (eg. stop accepting foreign aid, take chinese money, issue bonds, etc) for what probably deserves a more nuanced and considered approach.

I think Shanta Devarajan's assessment of the book is spot on (this guy is the chief economist at the African world bank) - http://africacan.worldbank.org/a-partial-defense-of-dambisa-...

vitaminj··on Ask HN: How many of you play music?
I've got a maple custom absolute and I think it's pretty sweet, but that PHX looks sick... how new is that?
vitaminj··on If you accept evolution, you must oppose over-regulation of the economy
I don't think I've ever met anyone with a consistent perspective on everything (me included). People will accept contradictory premises, especially across different fields, all the time.
vitaminj··on A 'nerd' shoots for the stars, and NASA comes knocking
To be fair to the kid, he does state that the value is in 2008 dollars. But 27 years on the same real wage is still a stretch.
vitaminj··on With 'Atlas Shrugged,' Hollywood may have its first anti-bailout movie
I've got nothing against her philosophy in the abstract, it's how people interpret it that I have a problem with. The "selfishness" in living for yourself is supposed to be open ended, but often people interpret this as taking as much as they can for themselves, without thought of the consequences to others.

Rand positioned the major protaganists in Atlas Shrugged (eg. Dagny, Rearden, Galt, etc) as real producers, who through their selfishness, were actually acting in the public interest (railroads, steel, etc). The same can't be said for a selfish sub-prime mortgage lender. Rand's ideas are more or less amoral, and probably need to be coupled with some other moral framework for it to be described as "good".

vitaminj··on Why Marriages Fail
Economists (eg. Wolfers, Stevenson, Lundberg, Becker, etc) have been looking into the effects of no-fault divorce laws on the rate of divorces for quite a while now (refer to [1] for example).

Their general findings are that "the data broadly indicate that divorce law reform led to an immediate spike in the divorce rate that dissipates over time. After a decade, no effect can be discerned." [1]

They tend to attribute the steady rise in divorces to the changing nature of the family over the last century, things like increased participation of women in the labour force, advances in household technology, the contraceptive pill and the growing acceptance of non-standard family structures (eg. single mothers, defacto families).

[1] Wolfers, J. "Did unilateral divorce laws raise divorce rates? A new reconciliation and new results", http://ideas.repec.org/p/nbr/nberwo/10014.html

vitaminj··on The Paradox of Self-Education
There's only a paradox if you look at self-education from a vocational / market perspective. I'd imagine most auto-didacts learn purely for the sake of curiosity and the sheer joy of it (eg. it feels good to play music well, even if only to yourself).

I have no problem spending the time / money learning something with no prospect of monetary gain in the future. Learning is an end in itself.

vitaminj··on Basketball Stats: They all maximize what they think they’re being paid for
Also tangentially related, Rockets GM Daryl Morey is often referred to as "Moneyball Morey" by the basketball press.
vitaminj··on How Depressions Work
Some economists have proposed imposing a tax on cash holdings, which would theoretically push nominal interest rates negative... this would really give people an incentive to hold assets instead of cash.

http://blogs.ft.com/wolfforum/2008/11/the-case-for-negative-...

vitaminj··on How Depressions Work
Some economists have proposed imposing a tax on cash holdings, which would theoretically push nominal interest rates negative... this would really give people an incentive to hold assets instead of cash.
vitaminj··on Why Doing Things Half Right Gives You the Best Results
As far as HBS articles go, I thought this one was pretty good.

If you've ever tried to push a new idea onto a group of disinterested people, you'll know that you'll generally get apathy or pushback, no matter how much you extol the virtues of the idea. Giving people ownership of an idea actually works (at least in my experience) in engaging them and getting them thinking about the idea. Though the caveat is that the final result may not necessarily resemble your original idea.

vitaminj··on How Game Theory Solved a Religious Mystery
I'm not entirely sure why a god (or gods) would ever want the people to have a warship. Unless it's used to fight off other warships from competing gods. In which case warship possession is a plausible want for a god.
vitaminj··on Adult Fast-Food Diets Tied to Too Much TV as Teen
There seems to be a preponderance of these types of tenuous studies in social science. Somewhere, I'm certain there is a procedure for generic, shifty research that looks something like this:

1. Think up a hypothesis steeped in your own prejudices, eg. fat people watch too much tv as kids

2. Construct an experiment that doesn't control for any of the MILLIONS of other possible causes

3. Discover correlations in experimental results. Conclude that hypothesis is true based on correlations.

4. Issue a press release and make some tangential recommendations, eg. better parenting is needed

vitaminj··on Is College Working?
Woodrow Wilson was basically arguing the same point in 1909:

“We want one class of persons to have a liberal education. We want another class of persons, a very much larger class of necessity, to forego the privileges of a liberal education and fit themselves to perform specific difficult manual tasks.”

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →