HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vivekd

2,803 karma · joined June 30, 2016

submissionscomments
vivekd··on The Miracle of Photography
>hard transition from Platonism to empiricism during the Renaissance

I'm highly suspicious of the historical accuracy of this popular claim. I don't think any such transition occurred. In fact I think the idea of the Renaissance is more myth than reality.

See

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continuity_thesis

vivekd··on Maersk to cut 10k jobs as shipping demand drops
Ontario Canada's NDP gov't tried this approach in the 90s for the public service in response to a budget deficit. They called it Ray days. The approach was very unpopular with public servants and the public generally. It was one of the reasons for the party's loss of influence.
vivekd··on Large-scale violence in Late Neolithic Western Europe based on skeletal evidence
That's my interpretation as well. I was in a slum in Africa once and fell victim to that kind of random violence. I think it happens everywhere in the form of crime.

Obviously no one likes crime so societies try and clamp down in that

vivekd··on Is there anywhere in the world someone can just live for free?
That's possible, I'm not sure to be honest, I'd have to read more about rural life in turn of the century America to really form an opinion on this.
vivekd··on Is there anywhere in the world someone can just live for free?
This is an empirical question that I feel you are trying to twist into a political one.

The sole question is can you on 100 dollars a month today live in a manner similar to what the average person in the 20s did

The empirical questions are what does 100 a month buy you today and what was the average lifestyle of a person in the 20s in terms of how much would it cost to buy that lifestyle today

Questions of how we got feminnism and better medicine since then is irrelevant and trying to distort a simple empirical analysis into a political one

vivekd··on Portugal. The Man – Official Website Is a Google Sheets Document
Django provides an admin page that makes it easy for non programmers to update SQL tables so thats worth looking into as well
vivekd··on Is there anywhere in the world someone can just live for free?
Right, but staying on topic in terms of available material goods and income,

I don't think available goods and resources was as bad as this thread was making it out to be

vivekd··on Is there anywhere in the world someone can just live for free?
I think life in the 1920s, while having downsides, was a lot better than many people imagine.
vivekd··on Is there anywhere in the world someone can just live for free?
Cost of land fertilizer transportation animals etc have gone up to the point that I didn't think that life is possible for 100 a month

Consider that If this was possible I could work at McDonald's for two years and then retire to that kind of life. Obviously that's not realistic

vivekd··on The Anthropogenic Salt Cycle
There are cheap winter tires available for 90 bucks a tire in Canada, probably cheaper in the states. There are places that offer financing on tires.

We require insurance which is expensive. There's no excuse not to require winter tires, it's a basic safety requirement. Driving without winter tires is just dangerous.

It doesn't matter how much salt they put on the roads. The issue is that winter tires are made of a material that grips better in cold temperatures where ordinary tires don't grip as well when temperatures drop.

vivekd··on How Microsoft is making a mess of the news after replacing staff with AI
>poll next to murdered woman about why she died

>saying Democrats are causing covid

>saying dead basketball player is useless

I mean these seem like problems that could be easily solved by having a human intern read over the AI generated story before it's published.

I don't understand why Microsoft just let an experimental tech run a customer facing site without anyone to at least vet and read over the content

vivekd··on Amazon execs intentionally made site shittier to rake in more profit – Lawsuit
Exactly! I would go further it applies to almost 100% of all advertising from TV to radio to billboards, poster ads ...
vivekd··on Amazon execs intentionally made site shittier to rake in more profit – Lawsuit
Am I reading this right? Amazon accepted advertisers hawking junk ads which made ad prices more expensive and gave less relevant ads to their customers.

This can't be a violation of any law or ethical rules... Does anyone seriously think serving only good and relevant ads is an ethical obligation. Can't retailers accept ads from anyone without vetting for quality control.

The only thing I can think of here is FTC is trying to make a weak case that Amazon is a monopoly by claiming look they had the power to show crappy ads. Which is a weak argument.

Maybe Amazon is too big and too dominant in the market. I don't know. But this article and this aspect of the case looks weak.

vivekd··on Teen boys use AI to make fake nudes of classmates, sparking police probe
In Canada it is illegal to make naked pictures of kids even with ai. Not sure about US
vivekd··on Light can make water evaporate without heat
Isn't 'transfer momentum' just a round about way of saying "heat up."

I think the interesting aspect here is that the evaporation is greater than what can be explained by heat alone.

vivekd··on People go to Stack Overflow because the docs and error messages are garbage
> quick answer rather than understanding things beyond their current issue

Well yeah, what's wrong with that. Eg I work in construction I build concrete. I don't know about the various strengths and mixes of concrete. I just know my little field. Me trying to get the perfect concrete mix or designing the rebar would be bad because I don't understand engineering.

It's neither efficient nor productive for everyone to be an expert on every aspect of the tech they are using.

If I have a problem with one tiny aspect of a computer program I shouldn't have to gain an understanding of the underlying framework. I just need the specific task to solve my particular problem.

I want to use flutter to build an app not to understand the details of how these iOS and Android platforms and underlying tech work.

vivekd··on People go to Stack Overflow because the docs and error messages are garbage
You know when I get stuck I go to stack overflow and inevitably I see someone responding to a question with a link to the docs that is often unhelpful.

If you don't know an answer offhand and haven't worked with the specific part of the program the question is about then there might be an issue with implementing the docs you are unaware of.

Assuming the asker is lazy, didn't read the docs and just linking the docs isn't actually helpful behavior. Please do not do this.

vivekd··on People go to Stack Overflow because the docs and error messages are garbage
Mostly yes, there are exceptions. I thought Django and express.js were both well documented.

Baseline code also seems to be well documented as a rule. However modules in a lot of languages, even important widely used modules are too often very poorly documented.

vivekd··on See how AI image generators amplify American bias in gender, race and beyond
Well the article provides an example

>Stable Diffusion drew negative attention when requests for a “Latina” produced images of women in suggestive poses wearing little to no clothing. A more recent system (version 2.1) generated more innocuous images.

So at least in more obvious and extreme cases of bias something can be done to fix the training set.

vivekd··on How Bear does analytics with CSS
Google cloud and AWS VPS and many hosting services collect and provide this info by default. Chances are most websites do this including this one you are using now. HN does up bans meaning they must access visitor IP.

Why aren't people starting their protest against the website they're currently using instead of at OP.

vivekd··on How Bear does analytics with CSS
I'm a keyboard user when on my computer, qutebrowser but I think your sentiments are correct, the numbers of keyboard only users are probably much much smaller than the number of people using Adblock. So OPs method is likely to produce a more accurate analytics than a JavaScript only design.

OP just thought of a creative, effective and probably faster more code efficient way to do analytics. I love it, thanks OP for sharing it

vivekd··on Wikipedia Is Covering the War in Israel and Gaza Better Than X
Well I agree with you there, I don't think Israel's response is justified either.
vivekd··on Norwegian ban on Meta behavioral advertising extended to entire EU
Well first if tracking and selling data on non-registered users really is that trivial then the issue isn't Facebook it's every website that could be doing this.

Second more importantly privacy seems to be a watchword for tech people. Maybe people claim to care about the sort of privacy you are talking about when asked but their actions speak different. People use Facebook, google maps, leave location data on on their phones. Obviously people don't value privacy as much as they do having access to certain tech. Sad but that's the world, privacy seems to be a thing of the past.

We can all opt out by not using these services. To the extent that we don't there must be some extent to which we accept and consent to this tracking.

I care because I'm afraid of my government and want to keep myself secure from them. I also realize that's not the average person. My preference for privacy means not using Facebook it doesn't mean I get to control how Facebook does business or how people choose to use it.

My view is that ultimately people have to be responsible for the tech that they use and how they use it. We can't just pass along that responsibility to government or business.

vivekd··on Norwegian ban on Meta behavioral advertising extended to entire EU
>Have someone take a picture of you, even incidentally in the background in public, and post it to Facebook? They're tracking you

I would agree this is a big deal if it's true but I haven't seen evidence of it being true.

The rest of your arguments ignore the human choice aspect. Facebook didn't come pre-installed on my phone, I don't think it came pre-installed on anyone's.

At the end of the day using Facebook is a choice. Nobody has to have Facebook. I get by fine without it, without instagram, WhatsApp any of it. These are things people willigly choose to use and give their info to.

I think your arguments have weight only if their users are unaware of Facebook selling data to advertisers. You'd have to be living under a rock not to know that in 2023. I mean it's not just a choice it's an informed choice.

vivekd··on Norwegian ban on Meta behavioral advertising extended to entire EU
I have a hard time believing Facebook is tracking it's customers through CCTV.

In any case even if they are I still don't care because they're not tracking me. Know why - it's easy, I just don't use Facebook. People who complain about Facebook collecting their information all the while continuing to use Facebook are not victims - they're just complainers.

If stopping it is as simple as logging off forever and people can't even do that, I can only assume that they consent.

People who want the government to step in to prevent something they could prevent by hitting a log off button...I don't even know what to say about that.

Besides even the criticisms don't make sense - eg complaining that they won't say what info they have while at the same time complaining about video tracking. How do you know they have that if you don't know what they have?

vivekd··on Norwegian ban on Meta behavioral advertising extended to entire EU
I donno, I know I'm in the minority but I agree with the parent. Facebook isn't going to people's homes and rifling through drawers. They're using information people willigly share in their profiles.

They're not selling personally identifiable information. They're selling generalized group info on categories people fall into for targeted ads.

I don't understand how this is a privacy violation or unethical. Especially given Facebook isn't hiding what it's doing, they're open about what they're doing. I assume the customers are informed and are consenting to this in exchange for free use of Facebook's services.

I think it was wrong for Ubuntu to sell user data to Amazon because their users weren't informed. Some people choose Linux for privacy reasons and that trust was violated.

No one who values privacy would willingly use Facebook. Facebook doesn't hide what it does, it's a consensual sharing of information. They even have a big button on their site inviting their users to try targeted ads. Everything they do is in the open.

vivekd··on Home prices jump for seventh straight month in August
Strange, here in Canada home prices have started to fall amidst higher interest rates. I wonder why the same trend isn't playing out in America.
vivekd··on WeWork plans to file for bankruptcy as early as next week, source says
It's Chapter 11, not a good thing but hardly the end of the company. We work should survive this, this doesn't mean the business isn't viable
vivekd··on Wikipedia Is Covering the War in Israel and Gaza Better Than X
Maybe some of the people in mainstream militaries are psychopaths who try and kill innocent families to spread terror. And I think some cases like the firebombing of Japan and Germany do fall under that. But on the whole I think I'm mainstream militaries such actions are the exception and goals and targets are military.

In this case there was no parading over the body of an enemy. This wasn't an enemy this was a girl in her early 20s. How is she an enemy, she didn't do anything. We don't even know maybe she opposed Israel settlements and wanted a different approach to Gaza.

The difference with groups like Hamas is they don't care, everyone is an enemy deserving of rape and torture, even random girls in their 20s. It's not the same thing, comparing this intentional attack to unintentional breaks of discipline or accidents in military contexts seems insane in my mind. The difference is Hamas intentionally targets civilians as their official policy, that's their organizational approach.

vivekd··on Wikipedia Is Covering the War in Israel and Gaza Better Than X
We use the word war crimes for that. This isn't the same thing because there was no fighting at the time. It's not like there was an ongoing military engagement between Israel and Palestine on October 7.

In this case there is tension and bad things happening at the border with sporadic fighting.

Then on October 7 Hamas on its own volition crossed the border and did attacks on regular people.

Just imagine a different situation. Imagine Russian army started shooting Ukranian kids at a dance party, paraded the naked body of one of the kids in camera after they raped tortured and killed her

Would we still be having this intellectual debate about whether the word terrorism is overused and wether it can apply here.

You know what I think, I think this is the bigotry of low expectations. Some western intellectuals instinctively apply different and lower standards to people of other races.

← PreviousPage 6 of 26Next →