HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vlasev

597 karma · joined April 12, 2013

submissionscomments
vlasev··on Programming and Depression (2012)
The problem is that it's a lot easier for a musician to find an audience than a programmer to find an audience. Music is nearly universal but programming is quite obscure for people who don't know how. Everybody has seen a guitar or even plucked the string but not many people have seen a source code or written a few lines. Just because one can find an audience in theory doesn't mean it is easy. People are more likely to complain about his app's functionality than show appreciation. Now, if he really solves an annoying problem for the users, there will be genuine appreciation but those problem as rarer and harder.
vlasev··on The Decline of Wikipedia: As More People Rely on It, Fewer People Create It
A small but important victory
vlasev··on Xenopsychology
A bit of nitpick on point 3) - it's a logarithmic scale. The difference between +10 and +5 is 148 times and between +5 and +50 it's about 3.5e+19 which should be quite doable by something as large as a galaxy...
vlasev··on The Decline of Wikipedia: As More People Rely on It, Fewer People Create It
Look at the Wikipedia article on the Russian Armed Forces[1]. Look at the budget of 907 billion dollars (44% GDP) for 2013. That's ridiculous isn't it? I tried changing it to the proper 90.7 billion (4.4% of GDP) but it reverted back. I tried again and same thing happened. I rest my case.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Armed_Forces

vlasev··on Why being a thinker takes quiet time
These two things don't seem to be that contradictory. You need to have some kind of success and resources to help more people in a meaningful way. It's not impossible for example the likes of Bill Gates etc who give away massive wealth towards causes they deem good.
vlasev··on How Seinfeld's Productivity Secret Fixed My Procrastination Problem
The mistake you are making is that you think it'll take you 15 min/day to "restore state" every day. If you end up doing the same thing several times you'll get better at it. It's much harder if you skip days.

Another thing is that 15 min/day is pretty easy and it's main purpose is to lure you in. It's much harder to devote an hour or two or more. But 15 min is easy peesy. Once you are in, you tend to stay in for longer.

As for efficiency about cleaning the house, there is more to it than how much time it takes you. Having a clean home all the time is beneficial in ways that you miss when you only clean it once a week. You may not even be aware of the negative effects of the mess.

vlasev··on A Mathematician’s Lament (2002) [pdf]
The point he's making is against unnecessary rigorization of introductory calculus and I think you are getting a bit too hung up on the "function-based approach". I repeat - introductory calculus. There's lot of time and space to make things more rigorous in a class like Analysis.

When I help students with calculus most of them have no trouble with the ideas but the implementation that they are required to perform. I spend a lot of time getting them to understand the simple particulars. There are ways of teaching calculus that would dispense with some of the more rigorous aspects and make it a much more bearable experience for most.

vlasev··on Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups”
I agree that student evaluations are mostly garbage but they have saved me from bad professors at times. You just have to know what you are looking for. The reason evaluations are bad is that you can't just put a point scale on a professor and hope things will go alright. If you look at ratemyproffessor you'll see a lot of people giving bad rating because tests and homeworks were hard. This is BAD. You'll also see a lot of good ratings because the professor was easy. This is also bad.

You want to look at the ratings that talk about the teacher's engagement in the teaching process, not in how difficult their material is. Case in point - I had an amazing Group Theory teacher and the assignments and final were really difficult. You'd expect that some people will not distinguish the two aspects of teaching and slap on a bad rating because it's so difficult. Others will see the difference and give a good rating for teaching and describe the course as difficult.

vlasev··on Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups”
This is a very interesting study, thanks for sharing it. With risk to go against what I said earlier, I have to admit that I've seen the same thing in my own learning and that of some of my peers in my math program. The first two years of math courses were great and we did well and the more advanced ones were, of course, harder but we just couldn't do as well on them as we wanted. However, I'll argue strongly that it's not because our first few teachers were so good, from perspective of evaluation but because the later professors were not up to par.

You see, Calculus courses are taught so much that the material has been developed and optimized to an extent that when I took my Calculus courses, I fell in love with math. Even somewhat more advanced courses like Linear Algebra and Complex Analysis are quite optimized for learning. Go in a little deeper into things like Real Analysis, Group Theory, Abstract Algebra and Galois Theory, and all of a sudden, everybody teaches these courses differently. Of course, these courses are taught less and they are not as optimized. THIS, I will argue is the reason for the decreased performance in the "deeper subjects".

Let me use an analogy. Let's say your first big relationship is with a really easy-going happy person and you have great times but eventually you have to part ways for some arbitrary reasons. Some time later you get into a second big relationship and this time the other person is difficult. They are battling through a lot of childhood issues and have problems with self-esteem. All of a sudden, you find yourself unable to deal well with this person, eventually you break it off.

Now, was your lack of "performance" in the second relationship due to the first one being so good or due to the second one being so crap?

Now, from the paper's conclusion:

> A final, more cynical, explanation could also relate to student effort. Students of low-value-added professors in the introductory course may increase effort in follow-on courses to help “erase” their lower than expected grade in the introductory course.

I have seen and experienced this all too often. Case in point - one of my friends got a C in Calc 1 but went on to get A's in the next few Calc courses.

vlasev··on Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups”
Great person != great teacher. To be honest, if you watch [1] his lecture, he doesn't grab me as a good teacher. In fact I would probably fall asleep in his lectures. I've seen a lot of professors and how they teach during my undergrad and graduate mathematics education. It's not uncommon to witness a professor who has numerous awards for their research but who is awful as a teacher. It could be lack of motivation on their part for all I know. Dijkstra could be the very best out there in some matters but it doesn't mean we should take after his style of teaching.

To be more specific, Dijkstra's organizational matters make him seem to me as somewhat cold and detached. Watching his lectures on youtube confirms this feeling. He also TEACHES in that way and frankly this is not the best way to get knowledge into students' heads. Nor will students ever feel like he really cares.

Perhaps such a person will be more engaged if he teaches a graduate course with topics from his research but from what I've seen, this is not always the case. In fact, the worst course I ever had was by a professor with numerous awards, who's also great at giving presentations and talks, but who taught his research topics like absolute crap.

[1]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNCAFcAbSTg

vlasev··on 5D ‘Superman memory’ crystal could lead to unlimited lifetime data storage
Perhaps it is because this is a crystal and there is a relationship or redundancy between the different axes of orientation.

EDIT: Actually, this [1] paper says in the abstract that they use wavelength, polarization and the three spatial dimensions. So it is wavelength and not direction!

[1]http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v459/n7245/full/nature0...

vlasev··on How we perceive time: stop it slipping away by doing new things
Not quite. The amount of new experience in that trip is so much that if you perceived it at your normal rate in your daily life, it would seem like it took a lot longer. It's like filming something with a high-speed camera and then later playing it back on your TV at slower speed. Things didn't go slower during the actual filming but when the recording is played, you have more information.
vlasev··on Only clear skies on Google Maps and Earth
Oh my god! I didn't know that the the united states is literally crisscrossed by roads in a relatively square grid fashion, as in [1]. This kind of detail was invisible in the previous version. Here is a frightening image of China [2]. Each of these patches is a town!

This update of the maps is amazing!

[1]https://maps.google.com/?ll=47.115467,-97.306595&spn=0.29298... [2]https://maps.google.com/?ll=38.002656,115.434723&spn=0.67848...

vlasev··on Three Planets in Habitable Zone of Nearby Star
Actually, it's WORSE.

1 light year = 9.454 x 10^15 meters 22 light years = 2.080 x 10^17 meters SF to Paris, round trip = 1.877 x 10^7 meters Number of trips = 1.108 x 10^10

In layman's terms, it's about 11 billion trips!

Here's another way to get a sense of scale. The earth rotates the sun at an orbit with semi-major axis of about 150 million kilometers. Using some data you can determine that the orbit of Earth is about 9.398 x 10^11 meters in circumference. Divide the distance to the star by this number to get 2.213 x 10^5 years. That is, it takes the Earth about 220 thousand years to go this distance around the sun.

vlasev··on Obama does not feel Americans' privacy violated
Would you know WHICH 300 phones to check without the program?
vlasev··on Barns Are Painted Red Because of the Physics of Dying Stars
Here's another explanation, which I think is much better.

http://www.farmersalmanac.com/blog/2008/09/16/farmers-almana...

vlasev··on Barns Are Painted Red Because of the Physics of Dying Stars
Here's a cool picture showing the layers of a star before collapse http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/37/Evolved_s...
vlasev··on I Wasn’t Prepared to Work
The problem is more complex than that I believe. I can say that my experience with mathematics has been very similar up until a certain point during my undergraduate years when money became really tough for me. All the stress and uncertainty ate me up and I ended up feeling a lot like his later self much earlier than at a run-of-the-mill job. There simply aren't enough spots in academia and during graduate school a big portion of people like us don't get paid enough to get by. I'd say most of us burn up before they get to the end.
vlasev··on I Wasn’t Prepared to Work
I saw a statistic claiming there are about 5 graduate students for every professor in the American graduate schools. Unless you want to really pursue the academic path, maybe a phd is not worth it.
vlasev··on Global flight paths in pictures
We find places near water more desirable, especially coastlines. A lot of big cities are on coastlines
vlasev··on B go beyond – Quadcopter/RC car combo
Here are a couple of ideas to make the video better

1. Use a better microphone. The quality of your voice is not very good in the video.

2. Don't keep re-using the computer generated shots, it gets somewhat annoying.

Here are some ideas that could make for a better demo of B

- Test the flying mode somewhere more interesting like in the city where there are multiple levels to reach with flying.

- make it go from the first level of a house to the second level of a house by going outside of the window. It would be even more impressive on a higher building - go from the ground level to the roof level (and back).

vlasev··on Lyft Is Doing 30,000 Rides A Week, Raises $60 Million From Andreessen Horowitz
I'm from Vancouver and we have several car-sharing services here - Car2Go, ZipCar, Modo. There are not only dedicated spots all over the place, but recently a bylaw was passed to allow cars from car-shared services to park in all spots that say "permit required" [1]

[1] http://vancouver.ca/streets-transportation/residential-parki...

vlasev··on How to make wealth (2004)
Number 2 will not work without ample advertisement. And you also have to think which people do you want to want your product.
vlasev··on Doctoral degrees: The disposable academic (2010)
The right question to ask yourself is would have your experience been any different if you worked on a Master's in pure math instead?
vlasev··on Doctoral degrees: The disposable academic (2010)
It's often such a PITA to find free research papers if you don't have access to the paid journals. If it's just one paper, it's not such a big issue. The trouble is one of scale. A researcher usually puts a lot of time into looking for all the references and papers to read. If this researcher doesn't have direct free access to these papers and has to look them up on google every time, this increases the overhead significantly. We're talking about dozens of papers just to get started well on a topic.

Here's an example. When I did math research last summer at my university, I looked at 16 papers. It took a while to gather these even with my university account with which I obtained the articles for free. If I had to google every single article, it would have taken me much more time - at least double if not triple the time.

vlasev··on Doctoral degrees: The disposable academic (2010)
I have to disagree with you on points 1-3. They are the minor points. I think number 4 should be on top of your list. Number 4 and then number 3 together probably make up 90% of the real reason why people end up doing a phd.
vlasev··on Doctoral degrees: The disposable academic (2010)
What you are talking about when you talk about those large salaries is something of a pipe dream for most people pursuing degrees. I too was lured into more education with high prospects but the truth is that it's really difficult to get in on the awesomeness. If you want to make a statement about long-term benefits you better talk about the average situation. Some PhD's do provide quite a bit more money on average, but a lot of PhD's (math, for example) provide only a marginal benefit over a Master's degree. I don't have the data in front of me but when I checked the situation for math, the difference in the mean was about 2-3 thousand dollars per year. If you take into account the financial opportunity costs of doing a PhD (things like low wages, tuition, loans), it will take you about 40-50 years AFTER finishing your degree to be on par, on average.
vlasev··on An Unheralded Breakthrough: The Rosetta Stone of Mathematics
> The avatars of algebraic equations in complex numbers give us geometric shapes like the sphere or the surface of a donut; solutions in natural numbers modulo N give us other, more elusive, avatars.

If anyone is wondering what those "avatars" for solutions in natural numbers modulo N give, here is my plot for N from 2 to 22 that I made with Mathematica.

http://i.imgur.com/8JIocR6.png

vlasev··on An Unheralded Breakthrough: The Rosetta Stone of Mathematics
Here is an illustration I made with Mathematica just for you

http://i.imgur.com/8JIocR6.png

vlasev··on Student's self-driving car tech wins Intel science fair
What if one uses cameras set at different sensitivity, kind of like how one makes HDR photos?
← PreviousPage 11 of 12Next →