HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vlasev

597 karma · joined April 12, 2013

submissionscomments
vlasev··on Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work
Yes, whenever I've done 48 hour fasts, I've had the same experience. This is due to the depletion of glycogen in your liver and muscles. At that point your body doesn't have the fat-burning machinery quite going yet, so you are in a temporary dip in energy. You'd have to do another 24 hours or so, I believe, to fully enter into that state. At that point it's business as usual except that you do zero digestion. It's where all the good feelings are. At this point your body balances itself for the time being and produces exactly what it needs to in order to function. You actually get a boost of hormones and metabolism.
vlasev··on Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work
It's very likely that it was most of it. It's just how fasting works. Your body enters ketosis in a day or two and uses fat for fuel. Your body would have to be rather dumb to burn muscle at that point.
vlasev··on Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work
It's not like your body is going to eat its own muscle! It's not that stupid. The muscle loss is due to the normal wear and tear of daily activities. If you train hard during a prolonged fast, it's likely going to lead to more muscle breakdown. And autophagy is not that either. Also, it kicks in much sooner than 5 days.

As for fat reserves, even fairly lean individuals can probably go a week or two without food without breaking down much muscle. 14 days at 2500 calories is merely 10 pounds of fat. Unless you are morbidly skinny, you should have 10-15 pounds of fat ready.

vlasev··on Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work
There is some good evidence (both studies and anecdotal) that there is some muscle memory in the sense that it's easier to regain muscle that was lost than to build it in the first place. So even if you lose some muscle during this whole thing, you should be fine. You want your body to be in as much in ketosis as possible; it has a huge reserve after all.

I'm sure you've seen or heard of this case study of the Scottish man who fasted 382 days [pdf]! Of course, he did it under medical supervision. But I think it's an important case of what CAN be accomplished.

[pdf]: https://pmj.bmj.com/content/postgradmedj/49/569/203.full.pdf

vlasev··on Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work
I'm not able to look for articles on this right now, but I believe that it was shown that your overall daily intake of protein is more important than the time of ingestion.
vlasev··on Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work
What about water fasting for longer periods? Have you gone 24/48/72 hours without any food? I find that longer fasts tend to work better for me, since I end up eating more calories in the 8 hours window in a 16/8 IF regime. But if don't eat for close to 36 hours, even with the increased food intake, I would still come out ahead.

If you fast long enough, say 48 hours I think, your body enters a mode of "autophagy", which is highly beneficial. So there's that.

vlasev··on Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work
Yes, you are right. And humans commonly engaged in a feasting/fasting cycle of having too much/too little food. But we've pretty much stopped doing the fasting stage. Look up "autophagy". It's a beneficial bodily process that only seems to happen within a long-enough fast.
vlasev··on Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work
Unfortunately the human body is quite a bit more complicated than that and a single article on examine.com is woefully inadequate at capturing the complexities. While people's metabolism doesn't seem to vary too much from person to person, it does tend to vary a lot within the same individual based on lifestyle choices. Whether I choose to eat or not, or choose how much to eat, my metabolism can vary.

When you consider your glycogen reserves, carb vs fat metabolism, insulin, ghrelin and other hormones, you get a rather complex machine. And what's really frustrating is that you are technically correct, in a sense. Eat fewer calories than you burn and you will lose weight. But that simplification borders on the dangerous. What's missing is that your body is not some passive observer, but an active participant, trying its best to help you survive.

Your body is amazingly good at adjusting how much you burn. When you cut calories, say 500 a day, your body will tend to compensate by burning a little less by reducing its temperature, by reducing fidgeting, by reducing your mood even! You'd need to cut 500 calories ABOVE that difference. So you end up having to cut closer to 750-1000 calories per day to get the same effect. Whereas when you fast, your metabolism rather obnoxiously tends to rise.

It ends up being healthier (and much easier) to eat 3500 calories less in one go, rather than splitting the difference across 7 days.

vlasev··on The Riemann Hypothesis, explained
It doesn't really have a proof of anything in there - just some empirical observations and heavy hand-waving.
vlasev··on “The Riemann Hypothesis” by Michael Atiyah – Preprint
You'll have to go to the previous paper[1], where this Todd function is supposedly defined and...it's not defined there either. I mean, the whole thing is really sad and not something that I feel like talking much. Just give things a read.

[1] https://drive.google.com/open?id=1WPsVhtBQmdgQl25_evlGQ1mmTQ...

vlasev··on People Like You More Than You Know
Now can you imagine...in someone's eyes, you are the person they are not even sure if he likes them or appreciates them or not!
vlasev··on Brain's Dumped DNA May Lead to Stress, Depression
I think you might be conflating ketosis with ketoacidosis. Very different things.
vlasev··on APL matrix product operator
Yes. It's quite easy to build up expressions one by one, whereas when you read those expressions, your eye and mind won't necessarily track through the same "derivation".
vlasev··on Don't Steal Money from Day Traders Before They Lose It
If you reduce the Formula 1 car's performance by as little as 25%, you would be able to get a much much higher mileage. Those things are so optimized that they break down much faster and easier.
vlasev··on Don't Steal Money from Day Traders Before They Lose It
If it's a temporarily biased coin, you can make some money off of it.
vlasev··on NYU Makes Tuition Free for All Medical Students
It's not so much about how much you can make but more about how much you need to make to stay afloat. It's a very different story depending on whether you have $0k in debt or $300k in debt.
vlasev··on Frink
I think you're wrong. Let's investigate the trigonometric functions from the point of view of differential operators. Those are essentially functions that take in functions and spit out functions. The operators we'll look at are made up of derivative operators like d/dx. Let's say we have a differential operator D. We might want to find properties about it. One good place to start is to find its kernel (all functions u such that Du = 0) and find it's eigenpairs (all pairs (k, u) such that Du = ku for k a constant. We'll focus on the latter problem

Let's look at the simplest D, that is D = d/dx. What function satisfies du/dx = ku? An exponential, of course, because functions of the type u = a^x have derivative u' = ka^x for some k. What'e the most fundamental such function? Well, it's the one where du/dx = u, i.e. k = 1. This is none other than the exponential function e^x with e as currently defined. Every other choice of a "fundamental" exponential function will run into a lot of inconveniences later on.

What about another example. Let's look at D = d^2/dx^2. It's simple enough. What functions satisfy d^2u/dx^2 = ku. It appears the solution depends on whether k > 0 or k < 0. If k > 0, we can show that the hyperbolic trigonometric functions do the trick, so we can rehash the discussion above. If k < 0, however, we get into the usual trigonometric functions, namely what we now know as sin(rx) and cos(rx) for some choice of r, since for both u'' = -r^2u and you can find r from there. Again which r is the most fundamental? r = 1 of course, and this leads to the usual trigonometric functions.

If you choose r to be something else, we'd have a problem as we'll no longer have the nice property that sin'(x) = cos'(x) and so on. Also, these two examples are really the same example since e^(ix) = cos(x) + i*sin(x).

As a side note that should really be the main note...aesthetic calls are very important in mathematics. No one likes scaling factors to their identities. We like using fewer symbols to talk about common concepts. If we could make e = 1 or pi = 1 without inserting the opposite problem of complicating almost every single identity in mathematics needlessly, we would have done it a long time ago.

I think the reason c = 1 works in physics is because you can change a few other constants around (usually to 1) and things works out well. I fail to see how we can do the same in mathematics where things need to work on many many different layers. Also, if you look at any "Natural units" systems, they all have pi in them. Why didn't they get rid of it? Because it's even more fundamental than c!

vlasev··on The Akrasia Effect: Why We Don’t Follow Through on What We Set Out to Do
This can be modeled fairly easy. Let's say we want to do X. In our estimation, it would take some amount of work E divided into effort P over time t (so E = Pt), to borrow language from physics. We estimate this quantity and set out to work on the task. We expect that we'll get there at a rate of dE/dt = P, but we don't. In reality, we most often tend to achieve less per unit of time. I'd say it's when the effort required is more than P that we are most vulnerable to quitting on a task.

But what if we've put no effort into the task yet? Well, I think procrastination of this sort is modeled well by our experience (Victor Hugo was an experienced author by that point). If in the past we've done some tasks and they've taken significantly longer time and energy than we initially thought, even if we don't consciously remember, our bodies will in some sense. I think what's happening is that there is a payoff based on the difference between effort P and required effort P' to finish in the same time. When P - P' > 0, we feel superb. When P - P' < 0, we feel like quitting.

You'd think one's perception would be improved after writing a dozen books, but maybe that's part of the reason a person starts writing another book after the first. A little bit of forgetfulness. But the brain doesn't forget. So, internally, it knows. So we have procrastination.

---

Example 1: Losing 20 lbs. How hard should it be?! A good goal to aim for if you do everything right and want to have a sustainable weight loss is 1 lb/wk. But realistically, it ends up being closer to 0.5 lb/wk for most. Would you spend something like 6 months to a year losing 20 lbs? What if there were more pounds to be lost? Now, if you go into this optimistically and not know this, you might lose a few pounds quickly and feel good, but then utterly quit when the real hard times come. (This mirrors any project that is easy to start but hard to complete, like html parsing)

---

Example 2: You intuitively know that a phone call to your phone company can help you save some money on your phone bill, but whether consciously or not, you somehow remember that it will take you 1-2 hours and a lot of emotional energy. You put this phone call off until it causes you enough emotional pain on the daily that putting it off by another day is as bad as the phone call itself. (This is an example of not even starting a project due to the perceived pain)

This highlights another thing. You can accumulate a lot of pain procrastinating on this call, but it's only the day to day pain that seems to matter in this strange internal calculation, because past pain is discounted a lot.

---

Example 3: (A bit tongue in cheek but...) Sleep. Let's say you've had some difficulty falling asleep over the last week. You perceive it as something that takes half an hour of "effort" to fall asleep. Naturally, you procrastinate until that effort is low enough, but this usually leads to too little sleep in the end.

---

Is there actionable advice from this? Yes. The more real-life knowledge you have of yourself, your projects (both successful and dropped), the more realistic your estimates can be. If you then bump up your estimates based on how off you were about them in the past, maybe then you'll get a glimpse on how much real work it'll take. Would you still start that project?

Maybe you'll end up starting fewer projects but dropping fewer before the finish line.

vlasev··on Katie's New Face
A good first step would be to create a good life for them that they could always go back to in the event if such a crisis. If you are happy or at least content being by yourself, even if you get cheated on, you can get back to normal. If you are empty without a partner and then get cheated on, you lose a lot more.
vlasev··on Frink
Yes. The radian is exactly what it HAS to be. Nothing more, nothing less. Just like the natural constant e.
vlasev··on Frink
I'm guessing they are from the US where carpenters work with feet and inches rather than with meters.
vlasev··on Melatonin: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
Have you got checked for sleep apnea?

Have you tried sleeping elsewhere? On a couch? What about sleeping in a semi-seated position? Would that work?

How's your weight? Does it go up or down?

Finally, if you are in bed for 30 minutes and you haven't fallen asleep, it's probably way better to either get up and do some stuff or to just accept that you won't be sleeping and just stay there and go through your imagination.

vlasev··on Dissolving the Fermi Paradox
No. This 1985 paper you reference talks about a logical argument for why there is no paradox, whereas the discussed paper is talking about how the uncertainty in the parameters is enough to yield something that is not a paradox.
vlasev··on For mathematicians, = does not mean equality
Sometimes we even leave it as "i" instead of "0 < i < n" or "i = 1 to n". Sometimes the range of the summation doesn't even need to be determined in intermediate steps.
vlasev··on Why Does “=” Mean Assignment?
You have something similar in mathematics. Recurrence relations. Since we are dealing with a sort of time difference inside a computer, something like "x = x + 1" can be interpreted as "the value of x at the next time unit is the value of x at the previous time unit plus one". That is "x[n+1] = x[n] + 1" and this is a recurrence relation. My guess is that early programmers were deeply aware of this time difference, so "x = x + 1" made perfect sense.
vlasev··on Probes Point to Northrop Grumman Errors in January SpaceX Spy-Satellite Failure
The angular diameter of stars that are light-years away are really really small. Yet they are visible to the naked eye and cameras all the time. So it's not just about the angular diameter.
vlasev··on The Rubik's Contraption
Yea, it's the maximum over the minimal solutions for each configuration.
vlasev··on China's Xinjiang surveillance is the dystopian future nobody wants
Xian's only the 15th largest city in China. No big deal.
vlasev··on There's a Persistent Hum in Windsor, Ontario, and No One Knows Why
Replace "comment out" by "turn off the electricity for" and maybe we can binary search it.
vlasev··on Eating Leafy Greens Each Day Tied to Sharper Memory, Slower Decline
Anecdotally, I've found that many people who are health-conscious come from a place in their lives where they were very unhealthy. So it became a thing for them to try out everything in order to get better. This should improve memory among other things. Still anecdotal though.
← PreviousPage 3 of 12Next →