HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vlasev

597 karma · joined April 12, 2013

submissionscomments
vlasev··on Study finds connections between birth month and health
The conditions are correlated with the changing seasons so it's only logical to consider things on the other side of the equator. I suspect that all the effects will be gone around the equator where the differences between the months are quite small. I'm not sure about the city connections but I think there have been studies showing people in big cities suffer from more asthma and so on.
vlasev··on Study finds connections between birth month and health
Some of the correlations are based on environmental factors that change with the seasons, i.e. light, temperature, etc.
vlasev··on Study finds connections between birth month and health
From study[1]: "Our dataset includes 1 749 400 individuals with records at New York-Presbyterian/Columbia University Medical Center born between 1900 and 2000 inclusive."

They also compare some of their data to data from Denmark. So it's all Northern hemisphere, mid-latitudes.

[1] http://jamia.oxfordjournals.org/content/jaminfo/early/2015/0...

vlasev··on Study finds connections between birth month and health
While on the topic of astrology, people might find it interesting to read about IMO the definitive study that shows it's bunk [1]. In it you can see that they took a lot of "time twins" (people born within a small time window on the order of hours or minutes) and measure if astrology had any predictive power over their lives. Spoiler: no, not really. Just a couple of quotes:

"The spacing of human births in a large population is described by a Poisson distribution, which shows that every year in a city of one million people about 4,000 pairs of time twins are born 5 minutes apart or less."

"Unlike the Roberts and Greengrass approach (count each time twin against every other time twin within one day, which would have produced nearly 600,000 pairs), serial correlation counts each time twin once only, thus minimizing the risk of artifacts. So the test conditions could hardly have been more conducive to success. But the results are uniformly negative, see Table 2. The effect size due to astrology is 0.00 ± 0.03."

[1] http://www.imprint.co.uk/pdf/Dean.pdf

vlasev··on Study finds connections between birth month and health
It says 55 conditions are correlated with the month, out of 1688. That's a rather small effect. The skepticism is well-warranted IMO. Also 39 of them have been shown to exist before this study so this is not strictly new knowledge either.
vlasev··on “Thank You” in Hindi and English Mean Very Different Things
French had a large influence on Bulgarian. A lot of bulgarian words are borrowed from French.
vlasev··on “Thank You” in Hindi and English Mean Very Different Things
I think it's mostly because it's so long and somewhat convoluted. "Благодаря" has 4 syllables while "мерси" only has 2. It's similar to saying "thanks" instead of "thank you" but that comparison is lost because the two words in Bulgarian are so different.
vlasev··on Researchers Find Missing Link Between the Brain and Immune System
What boggled my mind is that in this day and age there could still be tubes within the human body that we don't know about! How is this possible?
vlasev··on How Much do you Need to Earn to Afford a Modest Apartment in Your State?
While I agree about the single-parent families, I disagree about students. No way a student needs a two bedroom accommodation.
vlasev··on MIT cheetah robot lands the running jump [video]
I also forgot to point out that their robot is capable of running in a staggered manner [1] and the results are much cleaner than non-staggered action [2]. You can practically feel the second robot nearly tear itself apart even at lower speeds.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1TXOHAVuS5Q&t=65

[2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=chPanW0QWhA

vlasev··on MIT cheetah robot lands the running jump [video]
We can't possibly know what the researchers have actually done in their study but I think it's safe to say that symmetrical action is a lot easier to wrap your head around (it essentially becomes a 2D problem). That's why a staggered action should be seen as an improvement to the already existing design.

When it comes to cheetahs, I bet a million bucks that it has everything to do with impact and smoothness rather than a compensation for changing direction and such. My confidence in this comes from my own experience imitating animal movement in parkour. For an example of one person running in a staggered way - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W8oh5Xuy7NA. Running like that is MUCH easier on the joints than running with a symmetrical action. If you make a human gallop in a symmetrical way they'd quickly give it up for staggered action, regardless of surface or directions.

vlasev··on MIT cheetah robot lands the running jump [video]
To your first point, wouldn't a robot like that benefit from staggering the action of the legs? Instead of X impact at one point in time, have X/2 impact at two points in time? Would that create too much strain?

For my conclusion in point two, my insight comes from experience of copying animal movement. When I trained parkour my friends and I would copy animal movement from across the whole animal kingdom[1]. Here's an example of quadrupedal movement[2]. A big problem for us bipeds in trying to run like quadrupeds is that our legs tend to be big, long and inflexible, while our arms tend to be much weaker than our legs. The effect of this combination is to make running properly like a an animal which evolved to run on all fours quite difficult. From my own experience, putting my legs more and more forward past my arms (i.e. copying the cheetah), made for a much easier time.

If you were to try to run like the robot, with symmetrical action, it would be extremely uncomfortable, because the impact is large at every step. Staggering the action allows for a much smoother run. Make any human run like that and they'll eventually automatically switch to the less impactful staggered run.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ymg1-Fhl69w

[2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W8oh5Xuy7NA

vlasev··on MIT cheetah robot lands the running jump [video]
I'm not talking about power here. I'm talking about flexibility though. I think it won't be a stretch to think the hind legs range of motion could be extended by 10-15 degrees so the hind legs could hit a point further along the way.
vlasev··on MIT cheetah robot lands the running jump [video]
Hahah, you are so clever! Do you have anything beyond sarcastic remarks though?
vlasev··on MIT cheetah robot lands the running jump [video]
No one seems to be discussing how this can be improved! Here are a few points:

1. Real cheetahs don't run like that. The action of both pairs of legs is staggered for smoother motion and control. Check this out - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=131wvVGjZUc

2. Looking at this jumping-over-obstacles video, it seems like the robot is lacking flexibility. The real life cheetah's hind legs go quite a bit underneath in preparation for push off. Contrast this with how the robot's hind legs are a little too behind and the robot stutters a bit after every jump. If the robot could put its hind legs further it would make for a smoother landing.

vlasev··on Why Should We Support the Idea of an Unconditional Basic Income?
The idea of Basic Income goes hand in hand with the process of automation. There are millions of jobs that will go away due to automation. The counter-argument to "will basic income lead more people to stop working" is not "people are working too hard anyway" but rather "most people won't have a job...coming soon". What are all those people going to do once this happens? Find another job? Yeah right. Here [1] is an article discussing this very problem.

Also, I don't think the second risk you mention is really applicable. What's to stop a nation implementing BI from capping the number of immigrants it admits? Or am I misunderstanding you.

[1]: https://medium.com/basic-income/should-we-be-afraid-very-afr...

vlasev··on Why Should We Support the Idea of an Unconditional Basic Income?
Please take a look at the FAQ[1] on reddit and perhaps at this article[2] about calculating whether USA can afford BI.

[1]: http://en.reddit.com/r/basicincome/wiki/index

[2]: http://www.economonitor.com/dolanecon/2014/01/13/could-we-af...

vlasev··on Computer-Generated Image Captions
This one http://www.cs.toronto.edu/~nitish/nips2014demo/results/82676... has a tag "fingering"
vlasev··on Losing it All
OP had a house and an expensive car to pay off. That's got to be a lot of money right there. Also, OP probably ate more expensive food and probably ate out a lot more. It's not difficult to imagine how a lot of the money can be spent on these things. Let's not forget that taxes will eat a lot of the gross income too.
vlasev··on What Are Traffic Waves and Why Do They Happen So Much?
One problem of the "car idle" in terms of humans is that it takes almost constant attention to make sure you don't bump into the cars in front. Compare that to the speed-up/break/slow-down which allows time to relax. In my own driving I tend to have a more relaxed speed-up/slow-down cycle which is somewhere in-between the two modes you describe.
vlasev··on A Curious Property of 82000
Here [1] is a page with lots of neat proofs of the solution of the Basel problem.

[1]: http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/8337/different-metho...

vlasev··on Teen invents a system to keep germs from spreading on airplanes
Well, why don't you do it then? Make it happen. Submit an article, etc. If you CAN do it better you SHOULD!
vlasev··on Apple's Collatz Hash Patent Application (2013)
Imagine patenting fractals, as in functions f(z) that can be iterated to make fractals!
vlasev··on The Failure of Agile
It takes two people. I guess I'm implicitly assuming that the student will be relatively bright and wiling to learn but will be lacking some of those soft skills at first.
vlasev··on The Wolfram Language Image Identification Project
Interesting. Did you use the original high-res image?
vlasev··on The Wolfram Language Image Identification Project
Well, it's not ENTIRELY wrong https://www.imageidentify.com/result/0j627xm37r6yl
vlasev··on The Failure of Agile
You can teach them. I personally had a lot less attention to detail before studying math. Good work ethic and perseverance can be taught as part of reaching a bigger goal, for example in sports.
vlasev··on Famous Unsolved Math Problems as Homework
Confidence is quite important in mathematics. You would usually go further if you are confident than if you are not. That said, most unsolved problems in mathematics require more knowledge to state than these simple problems.

I think for most people, not knowing a problem is unsolved will lead them to try out many more approaches than if they knew. The problem is that most of the approaches will be approaches that have already been tried before and the rest will be useless. This does nothing for the solving of the problem but greatly aids your own understanding.

vlasev··on Famous Unsolved Math Problems as Homework
A good down to earth mathematician will always look ahead and try to solve more problems, do more math, etc. It's not surprising that he wanted to create new math despite already doing so.
vlasev··on Famous Unsolved Math Problems as Homework
As some of the people have already said, this is the Collatz conjecture aka 3n+1 problem aka half-or-triple-plus-one (HOTPO)problem. The fact that we don't know if the algorithm will certainly land on a power of two shows that it's quite a difficult problem. The famous mathematician Erdos said that math is not yet ready for such problems.

There are heuristic to show that the algorithm should terminate but there are numbers for which it takes an arbitrarily long time for convergence. Furthermore, there are similar problems that have divergence or loops. What makes matters worse is that it's been proven that such problems are undecidable in general.

← PreviousPage 8 of 12Next →