HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vouaobrasil

5,510 karma · joined August 26, 2022

submissionscomments
vouaobrasil··on To grieve, or not to grieve?
But AI can certainly aid in the ending of humanity with at least one living being with a will collaborating with it. So it's moot to ask whether AI can do that on its own.
vouaobrasil··on To grieve, or not to grieve?
Many people pursue knowledge precisely because it's still something new that no one else has done and because it is valued as a pursuit. When AI normalizes the discovery of knowledge as a mechanical process, the magic is lost to many. What matters is not what is discovered but the human process of doing that and participating in a culture amongst other living beings.
vouaobrasil··on Anatomy of a Lean proof for software engineers
The thing is, it's not about making anything easier to understand. It's about padding academic CVs with something new.
vouaobrasil··on Sites in ChatGPT
Because the goal isn't to make the future better for humanity. It's to make the future more addictive for humanity. Big difference. More clicks, more ad views, more engagement, not necessarily more pleasant. I mean, that's obvious.
vouaobrasil··on How do we prevent mathemathics from devolving into the Medieval Era of secrecy?
True, eradicated is a strong word and I do think it should be. And as horrible as a cataclysm is, I think it's still going to be less pain for humanity than going forward with this tech.
vouaobrasil··on Flet 1.0 – Build cross-platform apps in Python
What the heck? Python is a joy to program in and it's great for making small utilies, scripts, and even programs that don't require incredible performance. Perl is a pretty horrific-looking language.
vouaobrasil··on How do we prevent mathemathics from devolving into the Medieval Era of secrecy?
The problem here is that AI isn't just a problem, it also revealed a problem: too much emphasis on publishing papers and churning out new results. The name of the game right now is just that: make something new and significant. AI itelf is a problem around the world right now because we've set up some seriously bad incentives. Same with art - it devolved into content creation for money, so AI snaps that up.

What we need to do is make mathematics about understanding, rather than churning out results. People should be rewarded for reaching an ability to explain mathematics without the aid of computers, to teach people for the sake of their learning.

I do think AI also needs to be eradicated because of its destructive properties, but I think that at the same time it also is a manifestation of the sickness in our society to go after the wrong incentives that are detrimental in the long run.

vouaobrasil··on André Weil and the Hodge Conjecture
No way. Mathematicians don't assume things to be true even if there are no counterexamples.
vouaobrasil··on Don't be the out of touch Kung Fu master
I agree, if he were talking about programming a game. But he's not. He's talking about how to have fun from a priveleged position....

If Carmack said, "you're wrong in your game design, here's how to do it instead", yeah I'd listen. Same as if Kasparov gave me chess advice. But if Kasparov said, "AI won't take the fun away from chess" then how the hell does he have any expertise on that when he's spent the majority of his chess career without AI. Let's keep in mind that he made it to world champion before Deep Blue beat him.

vouaobrasil··on PS5 Linux lead quits: "a bunch of noobs using LLMs" that "they don't understand"
True. I agree. But I think it's also not very nice of AI programmers to actively work to take that fun away. And part of the skill of keeping a job fun is working against those who do attempt to take the fun away.
vouaobrasil··on A warning about 'model welfare'
We know animals have consciousness and many species have a rich life but we slaughter them and burn down their homes by the millions of hectares. Why not do it with a conscious AI?

(I don't think AI is conscious, just following the argument.)

vouaobrasil··on PS5 Linux lead quits: "a bunch of noobs using LLMs" that "they don't understand"
In general, society is experience a decoupling of fun from work. I can't say I enjoy every aspect of my job, but it's nice to enjoy some of it, and lots of people do find a lot of their job at least somewhat rewarding.

People who hate their job of course like to come out of the woodwork and say no one should enjoy it, but isn't it nice to have a society where at least some people can enjoy their work? I used to enjoy teaching but I'd never get a teaching job now because of how AI is being used in that sector.

Technophiles will say that we should embrace the future because its inevitable but how many good people quitting does it take before they realize that a vibe-coded future of fun isn't all there is to life?

vouaobrasil··on A beginning for mathematics
> Sure, but some proofs are so complex that even experts can't follow them.

If that's the case then I don't see much reason for them to exist in the first place except mental one-upmanship.

vouaobrasil··on AI research institute founded by Yoshua Bengio vandalized in Montreal
From their website:

"Mila is a community of more than 1,400 researchers specializing in machine learning and dedicated to scientific excellence and innovation."

They're also strong proponents of AI and integrating AI into society. They're just as bad as the AI companies themselves.

vouaobrasil··on Learning Programming in an Age of LLMs
The real problem is that the environment for healthy learning is gone. At least when I was a kid, there's something magical about having an environment where nobody knows what the hell is going on and the learning is, to use your words "painfully slow". I guess we've been trained to think that way with all this modern technology, but back in the day, it didn't matter whether the final result was accomplished or not. All that mattered was the fun of trying to get something to work.

Nowadays AI shifts the emphasis to the final product, and frankly that's boring. Kids will use it because it's there, because it gives that initial result really quickly and we're hardwired for that. But it removes that cool environment of having a blank slate and just seeing things happen all on your own accord.

Companies might like AI for the short-term gains but we're doing the entire planet a disservice by having even invented AI, in my opinion. We're all being trained to be producers.

Can a person like you create a little microcosm of learning that can work? Maybe, but I get the feeling that programmers these days are being blinded by the fun of AI and forgetting that there's actually more to life satisfaction than having fun.

vouaobrasil··on AI is breaking our proxies for expertise
Good for you. But some people need others to know that they are skilled to get a job or to be part of a community. You must be one of those priveleged ones moderately far along in your career that you don't need to worry about that.
vouaobrasil··on AI 'kill switch' may need to be mandatory, Anthropic co-founder tells BBC
LLMs don't need to hide anywhere to be dangerous, though. The danger can come purely from them reaching sufficient power together with some other idiot sufficiently crazy to use them to cause destruction.

I mean, in another thread somewhere around here, someone built an entire OS with an AI. What's to stop anyone with a sufficient taste for power to eventually use AI to cause havoc with it?

I think the underlying assumption in your post, which I believe is false, is that people are united somehow against catastrophe. They're not. There are plenty of people who participate in society currently but who would be more than happy to eradicate us normal people under different circumstances. Society often seems stable but it's far more fragile than we think.

vouaobrasil··on AI 'kill switch' may need to be mandatory, Anthropic co-founder tells BBC
Not if the extinction happens after they're dead. Then they wouldn't feel obligated to do so because it won't affect them. Instead, speaking hypothetically, if they truly believed that AI would cause extinction, then they would only implement the kill switch sufficiently many others believed it and they could claim plausible deniability for not truly understanding what AI would become.

** Note that I'm not claiming that AI will cause extinction, just continuing your hypothetical reasoning.

vouaobrasil··on A beginning for mathematics
AI will never be able to dumb down a proof to a level simple enough for someone to understand who has never studied math and put a lot of effort into it. Some concepts just need time and effort to absorb no matter how relatively simply they are phrased.
vouaobrasil··on A beginning for mathematics
Modern incentives, unfortunately, reward producing solutions rather than going after the joy of solving problems. And it's the latter that inspires others, not the former.
vouaobrasil··on Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High School Students
I know. I just thought it was kind of a sad state of affairs....
vouaobrasil··on The AI job market in 2026
Well for one, a lot of people now solo dev a project with AI and then often seem to abandon the project. There's not much sense of owndership in some of it. I try and use software that has as little AI influence as possible.
vouaobrasil··on Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High School Students
But isn't it a horrible thing that what you just described (being forced by the prisoner's dilemma), is what defines progress these days?
vouaobrasil··on The AI job market in 2026
> I feel both with new superpowers and dangerously threatened.

In some ways, having a superpower is not all that great because then you are forced by the prisoner's dilemma to use it. And if you think about it, it comes at a cost: a higher mental strain over a long period of time.

To use a physical analogy: a workout machine at the gym is very likely to assist you in targeting specific muscles compared to just lifting stuff you need to lift, but it also allows you to push that specific muscle group harder and thus increase the chances of injury to that muscle group precisely because it's so targeted. I think AI is like that with the brain.

(I'll add that it's perfectly possible to work out safely at the gym with lots of equipment. But I've spent years at the gym and I've seen a ton of injuries because the temptation to push a specific muscle group hard is there. And, AI is much worse because with AI, there is an economic incentive to push harder, whereas at the gym it's in your best interest to dial back...only sometimes people like to show off to their gym buddies.)

vouaobrasil··on The AI job market in 2026
I would like to have a resource, or maybe a coalition of companies that sign up and offer jobs that are guaranteed not to use AI. Although it might be true that there are some new jobs that didn't exist before, it would be great for people to band together to create a system that promotes the human element over using AI.
vouaobrasil··on Apple's Siri AI Can Be Swapped Out for Claude, ChatGPT, Code Shows
It would be great if AI could be completely removed from iOS altogether, including any underlying frameworks.
vouaobrasil··on Fable 5.1 Solves the Cyphral Distich, a 370-year-old cipher
If there is energy to be used, the system will use it because people always use power when it exists. AI can't do anything to stop it as it is both controlled by the powerful and has been trained on the tendencies of human beings to get ahead. If AI gives a person new capabilities, they'll use those capabilities selfishly, or even unselfishly but still causing harm because they're in an arms race.

We don't need a revolutionary technology. We need to experience immediate pain from reckless innovation so that we realize that innovation and tech is not the answer.

Technology only proceeds in one direction: unfettered growth, which necessitates unsustainable resource extraction. Your take is just your instinct for optimism, which in turn is just a trait that is only adaptive in primitive environments but is grossly misleading in a surplus-based society...

vouaobrasil··on Don't be the out of touch Kung Fu master
There will always be people who will like it because they are the ones getting ahead and get some reward. If a person is rewarded for something, it's unlikely that they'll care how the reward comes or be critical of the mechanism. It's just human nature; AI has incredible downsides but those who get ahead won't mind, as long as they get ahead.

I bet thieves feel a rush when they rob a store. Does that also make it right?

vouaobrasil··on Don't be the out of touch Kung Fu master
Not necessarily a bad thing. Just because Carmack has an optimistic view and has some catchet in the programming world doesn't mean he's any more correct than a raving lunatic. Frankly, he said relatively little of substance and it's only made more irrelevant because he's said it from a priveleged position.
vouaobrasil··on AI recursive self-improvement might not come so quickly after all
I don't think the end of the world would even be a bad thing; a lot of people assume that it would be disastrous but I think it's much more likely that it the "end" would just be a fragmentation that would be pretty uncomfortable, but not to the point of being horrific. I actually think that people are more resilient and creative than they think and if they were faced by a global economic collapse so strong that big tech would go bankrupt, they would bounce back pretty quickly. It's just that we've seen so many movies about the end and have been conditioned to believe that we're helpless that we think otherwise.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →