HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vouaobrasil

5,510 karma · joined August 26, 2022

submissionscomments
vouaobrasil··on There Is No AI (It's Just People) with Jaron Lanier
Not so sure about these analogies in this thread. Because autonomy is more like an emergent phenomenon that can't easily be defined, just like a few air molecules vs the eventual hurricane that can arise with trillions of them. Autonomy is more like an emergent phenomenon of a thing that's hard to pin down under the control of just a few individuals. AI is sort of like that even though a single line of output of one could eventually be traced.

Due to the complexity of AI and how it works, I think it's more autonomous than not; even if it's not truly intelligence, once it starts to display a sequence of behaviours that appear intelligent, we might have to deal with exactly the same problems as if it were intelligent...

vouaobrasil··on Void Linux Maintainer Orphans 100 Packages over AI Policy Dispute
No because some people are against AI for reasons other than just slop. Some people actually find it revolting that it uses so much energy and that it encourages deskilling in many. AI in my view is antithetical to human creativity and I try very hard to avoid software projects that use AI, whenever possible. And I try to only promote software that is AI-free.
vouaobrasil··on Void Linux Maintainer Orphans 100 Packages over AI Policy Dispute
> Banning the AI just means that everyone is using it, but nobody is saying it aloud. Since it saves so much time when used correctly.

Not exactly. It also attracts developers who are against AI philosophically. What I've actually seen is that there are a sizable number of people who are against AI and want a place for their code. You're also wrong that AI isn't the problem: it is. AI is the problem because it's too addictive and easy to use, and we're not rational creatures but instinctive.

Personally, I would only contribute to projects that have a complete AI-free policy. I hate AI and think it's a detriment to the human race.

vouaobrasil··on We must pace the frontier
Personally I find it more difficult now to execute my creative vision compared to years ago with a little less tech. I think there's an optimal point to automation that is easily reached and after that the benefit from automation actually goes away. People just don't like to acknowledge that because it goes against what they're doing and that creates unpleasant cognitive dissonance.
vouaobrasil··on We must pace the frontier
That's not really the point of technology at all. It was at one point perhaps with simple tools, but now it's more like "find a more efficient way to replace work in the short-term to get an advantage over others". The goal of our development has ceased to be improving life. Now it's just surviving in the market.

People don't use technology to free up their time any more. They use it because technology keeps making life more complicated and tiresome and new tech is a short-term amelioration to that until that too increases the complexity of life some more.

vouaobrasil··on We must pace the frontier
Well yes. Even though we can turn it off technically now, the prisoner's dilemma prevents it. It's not a technical limitations but for practical purposes, it's already virtually impossible to turn off.
vouaobrasil··on Navier-Stokes Announcement
I would burn it because it's too much power for any one person to handle. Or, I would take it for myself by force and use it to dominate everyone else.
vouaobrasil··on Navier-Stokes Announcement
if A then B

Can only be false if there is an instance where A is true, and B is false. In all other cases it's true, even when A is always false.

That's the key.

vouaobrasil··on Fuck it, make it anyway
I think it's more like the latter group likes the dopamine hit brought on my getting attention from release stuff.
vouaobrasil··on AI Is Breaking This Thing We Call Trust
I agree with that!
vouaobrasil··on A misalignment of AI in mathematics
People become interested in things when they become invested in it personally, because they've contributed to it. So I don't think it will stay relevant...
vouaobrasil··on AI Is Breaking This Thing We Call Trust
Actually, it seems that every time we do move forward, we do make things worse. So I think the tech doomers actually have a point.
vouaobrasil··on Show HN: Toast, a by default in-terminal IDE
Then maybe sometimes it's better to take a break and not bend the natural constraints of life for once. I mean, I'm all for easing some of life with automation but it seems that a general trend is emerging where people will just keep on going no matter what, when maybe we should just stop once in a while.
vouaobrasil··on I'm a Proud Luddite. That's Why I Use Linux
The problem with your argument is that there is a cost to using AI so it's not really free. There's an environmental and a social cost that restricts the freedom of others, which is technically still open source but not in the spirit of it.
vouaobrasil··on Txt: A fast, keyboard-driven terminal text editor for engineers
I miss the days when people would release software not touched by AI. And I wish at least there'd be a disclaimer saying that this was AI-assisted, so I could avoid it.
vouaobrasil··on I'm a Proud Luddite. That's Why I Use Linux
From the article:

> I am just trying to point out that the FOSS movement is not anything new, not really. It is just another manifestation of a drive that has been with us since time immemorial: the thirst for freedom.

I think that was true at one time, but I don't think it is true any more. With all due respect to FOSS, which is great, I think the movement has lost its ways. FOSS has become an industry to itself. If FOSS really still means freedom, why are so many people adopting closed technologies like AI to do open source? FOSS has become more about producing FOSS now, rather than creating software that actually means something. Even Linus Torvalds has used the rationale that his job is to make the kernel a great kernel and if AI can help him do that, all the better.

But I think the spirit of FOSS would be to make software that represents the human spirit, not simply produce it. Yes, there are a few developers who still feel that way, but by and large, technology has warped our way of thinking so that we care more about the final product than what we have to do to get there.

No doubt there's still some momentum of freedom in FOSS, but I think for the most part it's been thoroughly subsumed into the mainstream and it certainly no longer aligns with the Luddite tradition of restraint and keeping things small.

Personally, I've lost all faith in open source.

vouaobrasil··on The Four-Color Theorem Gets a Rare New Proof
I never accepted the proof of the original, because in my view a proof needs to be convincing as well as correct. Not every mathematician has this view, but language-wise I'd prefer to call the original proof a "verification of correctness" rather than a proof. The new proof is similar - more of a formal correctness verification.

What is the point of proof if not to actually convince the reader that the statement is correct? After all, most modern pure math is not terribly relevant to solve practical problems anyway, so if it's not convincing, then what?

vouaobrasil··on Stockfish 19
But as technology progresses and becomes more advanced, it does seem to set goals in all directions in that seems inevitable if we continue to 'collaborate' with modern technology. I mean, we no longer develop tools to help us out really, if you think about it. We develop tools to get ahead of other tools, to be faster than them, to protect ourselves from still other tools.

I'd argue that as we condition ourselves into a state of constant development, we shouldn't even call these things "tools" anymore, but pieces of an organism that spurn us to upgrade and complete it at every step.

Tools working for us only applies to local, simple tools that one person or a small communiity can basically understand and make, like a hammer. That's a tool. I wouldn't call a computer a tool any more just like I wouldn't say that our brain is merely a tool. It's more: it's an extension of us and even an integral part of us that modifies our very instincts and desires itself.

vouaobrasil··on How An AI math breakthrough ignited a controversy
I was talking about regular old keyboards. But you're just being pedantic.
vouaobrasil··on How An AI math breakthrough ignited a controversy
Keyboards don't suggest chains of reasoning or words to type. When I press the K key, I know exactly what will happen. It's just a translation layer that gives an output known ahead of time and thus does not impinge upon the creativity of putting words together.

A better example would be playing chess against a player slightly stronger than me and using a chess computer to suggest some good moves. I could win, but it certianly wouldn't be just my brain that wins. It would be an amalgamation of my brain with a machine that suggests good moves.

One cannot simply reason by analogy.

vouaobrasil··on How An AI math breakthrough ignited a controversy
The tools the researchers used though was much more than an spellchecker, because spellcheckers don't come up with chains of reasoning for the arguments in the book. The LLMs did in the case of the Navier-Stokes problem.
vouaobrasil··on What will our economic future look like?
I don't think they can make up for any mess. Because even if LLMs bring about a lack of scarcity across all domains, human beings will be alienated because indvidual differences and skills won't matter any more so we'll have to be genetically engineered to like that sort of future. I don't think a stable and healthy society can coexist with LLMs at all.
vouaobrasil··on Tao: Open math problems being non-renewably mined by AI
Yes, the glue is already breaking and AI is the next stage in the process.
vouaobrasil··on Ask HN: Is September 8th AGI Day?
Even horrible acts can originate from good intentions and places of beauty. The tool use does not blind me but reveals the stupidity of merely solving problems for the sake of solving them. Only your love and addiction to technology blinds you.
vouaobrasil··on Tao: Open math problems being non-renewably mined by AI
I agree that the low-hanging fruit has largely been picked. But then I think we should acknowledge that and stop innovating, or just work less on new solutions and more on clarifying old ones, and start to work on degrowth rather than useless problem solving. Because I really don't feel that any of this is really necessary or beneficial for the human race in the long-term.
vouaobrasil··on On the Navier–Stokes Millennium Prize Problem
Here's the point: when people solve problems, they come together and create a community to eventually use the new knowledge in positive ways, including inspiring younger mathematicians by sharing insights. The human element is key and it's not just about solving problems. People only think that because we've been conditioned by computers to value answers more than how we got to them.

But if AI can solve any problem and existing mathematicians just use AI to solve problems for the sake of solving them, the community itself with wither and so will the interest in mathematics and over a longer period of time, it will just become soul-less and uninteresting and the entire community powered by the fire of fascination will simply die.

vouaobrasil··on Ask HN: Is September 8th AGI Day?
As a former mathematician, I'm not impressed at all. I don't even care about the solution. I think an integral part of math is what the human mind can do, and if AI was required, then to me it's not impressive at all.

I never cared about merely solving problems. I care about the beauty that one can construct from the human mind, and that was the entire point, at least for me, to practise math. To me, what mathematicians have done with AI and Navier Stokes is worthless.

vouaobrasil··on Tao: Open math problems being non-renewably mined by AI
Actually there will because if you've actually ever spent time doing math, you only really get to that level of truly understanding and appreciating the stories if you've actually done the hard work yourself, which in turn will be economically infeasible due to AI. The analogy is interesting but incomplete and misleading.
vouaobrasil··on Tao: Open math problems being non-renewably mined by AI
The reason is because the entirety of society, historically, has been based upon humans using their differential skills to further it, which in turn promotes societal cohesion. If most human endeavours are solved, then we will enter a period of abundance that paradoxically will erode the glue holding society together. In short, endless abundance of solutions and ideas cannot coexist with a healthy society. Only those who are priveleged and have a naive belief in a Star Trek utopia think otherwise.
vouaobrasil··on How Golden Is Silence, Actually?
It's usually because they're not the ones living in the dense housing, or will ever.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →