HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vouaobrasil

5,510 karma · joined August 26, 2022

submissionscomments
vouaobrasil··on TheoremDB – A public workspace for machine mathematics
No there were a few people that could. And in principle, if Andrew Wiles did it, others could too and were motivated to do it. What I'm saying is that people will be conditioned to explore less on their own with tools like this and thus fewer and fewer will bother understanding the proofs.

Math is getting very specialized it's true, and I think that's part of the motivation to use AI. The specialization is itself a bit of a problem, so AI is simultaneously exposing that and hiding it under another layer of abstraction.

vouaobrasil··on Illinois just told every operating system to start reporting your kid's age
I think it depends on whether the app will make the developer significant extra money. And if so, then the money wins.
vouaobrasil··on TheoremDB – A public workspace for machine mathematics
I suspect tools like this will change human behaviour in the future so that no one really understands the math any more. If a solution to the Riemann hypothesis is found with it, I wouldn't be surprised if the person finding it didn't even understand analytic continuation. And that those that do just click like and scroll to the next problem.
vouaobrasil··on São Paulo resident transforms degraded area into urban forest
Hence the desire to tear it down.
vouaobrasil··on I have never seen a game fail because the artists were too slow
But then again, knowing what is fun does not automatically imply that one can build what is fun. Rapid prototyping at the expense of slow development often leads to superficiality in a direction of interesting which is never actually reached...
vouaobrasil··on São Paulo resident transforms degraded area into urban forest
The general direction of society is still immense destruction of the biosphere. That doesn't change because you can make conditions better locally and in the short term, especially when such actions don't go against the general momentum of society. The fact is, there's often conflation with improving individual lives and conditions (the warm fuzzy feeling) with actually doing real good when it comes to our impact on this planet. The former is not necessarily related to the latter, especially since the system has just the right amount of leeway to allow people to feel better and let off steam without really changing the ultimate long-term direction.

Even if there are many opportunities as you say, if the general momentum of society has three destructive acts for every one good one and that doesn't change, then society is still as destructive as ever.

For instance, for people who care deeply about nature and the non-human aspects of the planet, human society is incredibly destructive and hasn't done much to change that direction, regardless of how many feel-good projects have occurred.

vouaobrasil··on When online commenters detect my art as AI
But that's the entire purpose of AI: bring the value of the work of others down so that those at the top lessen the dependence of the economy on the masses. Of course, this will in turn eventually slow down the economy but if AI can take care of the majority of the needs of the rich, why do they need us?
vouaobrasil··on How can a junior dev get better when they have to use AI in their job?
Quit? There's no joy in working with AI. Find something else to do in life that doesn't require AI.
vouaobrasil··on Why Erdős Problems Are Falling to AI
Yes, that's correct. I've done research in pure math, but left after the postdoc level. I enjoyed it for its artistic sake but it's not something that gives anything practical. Most pure mathematicians don't ever work on practical problems either. They just teach and in return get to do their hyperspecialized research. It's done for its own sake. (Some pure math eventually ends up having applications but it's rarer and rarer and it wasn't very common to begin with. Like applications to crypto or whatever, but that was always a tiny slice to begin with.)
vouaobrasil··on Why Erdős Problems Are Falling to AI
Most modern pure math has no practical use whatsoever. It's amazing how few people understand this. Mathematics is a service department and maybe one in a hundred thousand results have any practical use. (Speaking as someone with a PhD and over a decade in pure math with several published papers...)
vouaobrasil··on Pangram – AI Detector
I don't want better search. I'd rather have less commercialization of the internet. And as for SPAM, it's good to have spam filters but even better to have less incentive to send spam in the first place....
vouaobrasil··on LLMs reward expertise
But maybe there's a limit to the usefulness of this abstraction. Perhaps forgetting too many basic skills lower down isn't always as useful as going from Assembly to C. I'd argue that there's a law of diminishing returns there, and it's not an endless series of benefits.
vouaobrasil··on Pangram – AI Detector
I just feel the whole process of emerging AI and then AI detectors is dehumanizing. If someone were to use it on my work, I would feel another layer of the machine between me and that person, another layer of distrust. I think it's sickening that we've come to this stage in the world where people try and cheat (on university essays and projects and job applications) by wasting energy and then people have to use more energy to detect it. It feels futile.
vouaobrasil··on Mathematicians Need to Act
Exactly. Luddites are not necessarily completely anti-tool. They were against large scale applications of complex technology to replace human beings en-masse. Personally I'd consider myself a Luddite but I'm not against a hammer or even a calculator but I am against AI completely, and I think more and more people should be Luddites...
vouaobrasil··on Mathematicians Need to Act
The goal of math is perhaps the answer but also the understanding. One can't use the answers without understanding them, which is a fundamental difference between math and a program. Most modern math isn't applicable in the sense that you just take some result and it gives something practical. The value of math is in understanding it so that it can be properly applied which requires a deep knowledge of why it is so in the first place.

> If they had no useful purpose, why did we think about them for years?

A lot of mathematics is mostly useless, and probably will be for hundreds of years. Some of it ends up being useful, but it's unlikely that much of math like work on geometric langlands will have any applications whatsoever. Math is a service department and the way people teach math best is to be experts in it. In turn, the best way to do that is to develop new math, at least within the context of academia.

Yes, there is some pure math that is used eventually, but I'd say (as someone who worked in pure math for over a decade) that as the results become more specialized and abstract over time, fewer and fewer of them will ever be used.

Every once in a while you see a news article about some math related to physics or something but that's 1/1000 results, if that. The fact is, most modern math research is likely never to be "used".

That doesn't make it useless because maybe we just want to know, but we have to be realistic here...

vouaobrasil··on AI's debt binge can't last, hidden borrowing reaches $1.65T
I guess if you're older, retired, sufficiently wealthy and have few needs (house paid off, lots of savings, don't care too much about acquiring new tech) then you can easily not be affected.
vouaobrasil··on Wind and solar overtake fossil fuels in Germany for the first time
I switched to fortified soy milk and haven't looked back. Milk is tasty but soy has less sugar as well and now I prefer it. Cheese is harder to make a substitute but eating it 1-2 per year satisfies my craving.
vouaobrasil··on Don't be a meat proxy
Not exactly. A drawing program could just create a new "blank slate" that substitutes some old skill requirements for new skills. The key point is that SOME machines create a sufficient mass of "blank slate"-like environments for active creativity and others (like AI) only diminish that room for creatvity to flourish. The danger is creating and using machines of the latter type.
vouaobrasil··on Don't be a meat proxy
> Do you guys think we're going to see a de-evolution of human beings due to technology?

A de-evolution of culture for the sake of efficiency, sure. The entire culture will shift to a greater degree of superficiality, not just because of the lack of deep understanding of what they're doing, but because AI will condition (and is conditioning) people to want the more superficial stuff.

This isn't a phenomenon exclusive to AI - but AI is at the apex of it and is the worst we've seen so far because it, much more than anything else, targets the mental domain whereas most previous automations have targeted the physical but the mental as well to a lesser extent.

The end result is a huge amount of technical debt that simply can't be recovered and a huge increase in myopia that will prevent us from truly understanding and solving serious problems that will undoubtedly occur.

Most people can't see this because they're already addicted to the dopamine hit of the tech, but it's one reason I'm 100% anti-AI and I hate it with an immense passion.

vouaobrasil··on Don't be a meat proxy
I wonder if in the long run it's really learning in the traditional sense, or just a shallow version of it along the lines of absorbing a bit of knowledge along the lines of reading a pop science book? Nothing wrong with that but I'd argue a lot of people who think they're learning are just "recreational learning" in the sense of hobbyist fun rather than deep study. And in the long run I think there is not much value in AI beyond turning our society into a bunch of apes who know a bit of sign language.
vouaobrasil··on The AI Productivity Gap
The scary thing is that the system moves in a direction such that it seems that it doesn't really matter. People on an individual level care but due to the strange economic conditions, LLM use is still rampant because experienced people can get some benefit from it in the short-term even if that means the long-term degradation of our collective expertise and thus a net negative. It's blindingly obvious but just like climate change, people can't help on an individual level to take the immediate reward.
vouaobrasil··on Prevent cognitive debt by manually retyping LLM-generated code
There's always some component of a skill that is not merely knowing something but practising something seemingly procedurally. Even if I understand integration well and have done it thousands of times, if I don't continually practise it from scratch, I begin to forget tiny bits and pieces and that accumulates to an eventually lack of understanding. So it is true for all mental tasks. There really isn't such a thing as understanding something completely without working it out by hand, from scratch. AI exacerbates a lack of understanding in this regard, although admittedly layers of abstraction in the coding realm already do that to some extent...
vouaobrasil··on Physicists Solve a Muon Mystery. Now, Old Results Don't Add Up
I think it depends on who has the hot paper and who has the outdated results. I was in academia for quite some time and when sometime cool comes out that renders other results less important, there are always winners and losers beccause the only thing that matters in academia is impact and the latest and greatest - not the blind alleys along the way.

There isn't really an "us" in academia like there is in a private company, who all have a common goal: in academia the goal is to get there before another does and be on top.

vouaobrasil··on US gov and OpenAI mislabel map of Africa at global conference
You actually can blame OpenAI for it. Because if a tool exists and people use it, that tool is an effective means of normalizing behaviour. We change our perception and behaviour through the use of tools, at least partially. So if someone invents a tool to do something poorly, and it becomes popular, then doing things poorly becomes more normalized.

It can work in a positive direction, too. Have you ever used Vim or Emacs? Haven't you noticed how dedicating some time to learning a complex system like this also makes you proud of mastering a precise set of tasks? It almost becomes religious. The tool promotes care.

We all have a societal responsibility to consider our inventions and what behaviour they'll encourage when people use them. OpenAI should also be held responsible, like all AI companies. The lack of care they encourage is enough for me to think that they should be all taken off-line and rendered bankrupt.

vouaobrasil··on US gov and OpenAI mislabel map of Africa at global conference
But one can say that previous technologies only magnify and exacerbate this lack of caring. The internet for example, makes most of our interactions casual and sometimes anonymous, and we get trained and even grow up on that model. And on the internet, what gets attention is what matters, not the consequences after because things move so fast.

AI is just the latest step in that. It is the apex of a phenomenon that dehumanizes people. Yes, there were people who just cared about appearances before the internet too, but there were greater consequences of that. Now the consequences have been reduced and it causes this behaviour to spread.

vouaobrasil··on RFC 8890 – The Internet is for End Users (2020)
I think fighting for a purpose-based ideology of the internet is actually doomed to fail because the form of the technology will dictate how its used and regulation and efforts will only slightly affect that.

E.g. If the internet is super-fast and has the capability to deliver video ads, it will be used for that. If everyone just had a connection with the speed of a 56K modem, that video-based ad model wouldn't work.

If we really want the internet to be a certain way, we have to change the underlying technology used, not the ideology behind it. Because if an technology has a capability, it will be used to do whatever is most successful in the capitalistic system, not what's best for 'end users'.

Regulation sometimes be effective, but...the model of regulation in a world of freely-evolving technology is a broken system most of the time.

vouaobrasil··on Alan Turing's biggest AI assumption may have been wrong – ScienceDaily
I mean this stuff is obvious. I think those that put "human-level intelligence" as a goal for AI are doing so mainly for two reasons: either they like the goal, or they want to be deceptive because they know it can't happen but it provides a great distraction into what they're really trying to do. The fact that someone has to take time to write so much about it shows how much we've been brainwashed by the modern culture of innovation-at-all-costs.
vouaobrasil··on The Cold Email
The most important thing is that you are really, truly engaged in trying to connect with the person. I've had great success with cold emails, but only because I write to people that I seriously want to get to know, even beyond just quick networking.
vouaobrasil··on Why too much time online makes us unhappy
Every week I take one "internet-free" day and it's become my favourite day of the week. Once I settle down a little more I'm going to increase it to 2 or even 3. (Can't do too much more as I work remotely.)
vouaobrasil··on A.I. companies are recruiting electricians and carpenters by the thousands
That's correct! AI is a negative for society no matter how you look at it. That's the entire idea!
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →