Again, people don't just do things in isolation for enjoyment. What humans do is special, and the end result is not the only thing that matters. You don't understand that because you're an aberration.
True, what I'm saying is that if we can create jobs that also provide enjoyment, we shouldn't be so quick to destroy them for the sake of greater efficiency because that provides social benefits beyond immediate financial ones. Of course, from your previous responses, you probably have more than enough money not to care about that and that's a typical response from the better off in society: screw you, I got mine.
Yeah I think it's weird too. But tech really does amplify narcissism because it makes us very independent from people and community. So it's really not surprising that half the people in this thread are more concerned with manufacturing discovery than they are with having a cohesive society.
A large part of enjoyment is having a community who cares about what you're doing. So people will find it harder to enjoy it. Plus, some jobs actually are fun. Are you saying we should eradicate that fun because you hate your job? Some human being you are.
Now imagine a day where a new type of disease is discovered, but it needs some mechanical help from a surgeon because the AI just can't make the leap to do that. But there are no more surgeons because they didn't want to pursue a worthless career. What then?
The problem with your argument is that word "perfect". AI will never reach that stage and there will always be costs.
It differs because LLMs can and will eventually make inferences, even if they're not truly intelligent. They can do things that one can't predict ahead of time. In that regard, it's very different than asking a computer to multiply together two degree twenty polynomials. I could do it by hand theoretically in a completely mechanical fashion, but AI can do some basic inferences.
Almost all mathematicians I know admit to feeling spiritual about discovery in the mathematical world. Engineers are taught the rigorous thing but it goes way beyond that. In fact, I bet a lot of people find some satisfaction in their work that goes beyond the practical. Artists, etc. That's what AI threatens because it destroys strong communities of people who value such work.
Poeple once thought that it was ridiculous that a computer could beat a 1600 player in chess. Then they put it at master. Then international master. They still thought it was ludicrous that a computer would beat a grandmaster or the world champion.
Is it a leap for society? I'd argue that society is better off if it's mostly people doing things and feeling like they are valued. What is the end result? Endless surplus, where we have the cure for every disease, but are useless masses of flesh consuming endless entertainment? Sounds like a fucking zoo and not a life worth living.
Exactly. We should preserve a society where at least some people have a chance of doing what they love, especially if they have a talent for it. AI is eliminating that, whether or not people can find other jobs.
The whole point of math is to just have fun discovering things. You might be able to discover math with an LLM, but you'll never be a mathematician if you don't do it yourself. LLMs don't democratize anything. They just let you spew out results that aren't particularly impressive if you can't even understand what the hell you're creating.
Would it if it meant that the entire joy of creating art was mostly gone from the world because the social value of it was diminished? Not really. And all that technology is not free. It needs rare earth mining, land usage, and habitat destruction that will likely cause even more cancer, mental problems, health problems, etc.
Of course it does because the joy of math is discovering something yourself. At some point you just want to stare at a blank sheet of paper, start with a premise and go on a journey. Are you a mathematician or scientist? I am and just typing "tell me the proof of this result" sounds immensely boring to me.
Have you ever played a video game with an "invincibility cheat"? Boring. But you do get to the end and "solve the game".
No way. Science is not just about the desire to know. Almost all scientists I know (and I've met hundreds) care deeply about the joy of working out the problems themselves rather than just knowing the answers. The joy of finding that mental spark on your own to solve a problem - that's what makes it worthwhile. Just knowing everything right away is boring. If it were not, I'd just spend all the time in a library reading the work of others.
> I understand not everyone is like me but I really welcome the omniscient mathematician machine people are predicting. I can't wait to ask all the questions I care about.
To be honest, if a machine could prove the Riemann hypothesis and explain it to me, I wouldn't even care. I care about math because it's more of a way to express beauty and I find math interesting because it expresses the souls of those who create it. Just knowing the answer becomes boring after a while.
Most people are like that. Maybe 1% just care about pure answers.
> As for squeezing in the time to do mathematics if the paying jobs disappear, there is a good chance we will have a world of plenty very shortly.
That's laughable. We will NEVER have a world of plenty. If there is a lot more plenty, there will be a lot more people who will want a disproportionate share of it.
> Joy should not come from utility but its fundamentality of enjoyment. I still learn different programming languages because it's fun to do so, so sounds like it's a you problem.
I learn because it's fun but PART of that learning also comes from having an environment to show off my new skills. I think a lot of people downplay this but it's inevitable and AI is ruining that environment.
> I... disagree. The joy I get from learning a programming language does not come from knowing that it is useful. Rather, it comes from engaging with its abstractions and figuring out the associated mental puzzles.
Fact is though, a LOT of people derive joy from showing their creations to other people and others finding utility or awe in it because they created it with their hands. The fact that a few of us can sidestep that does not mean it's a general phenomenon.
> In the hands of great researchers, AI will accelerate and propel human knowledge far beyond what we could achieve with pencil and paper alone.
Did you ever think that the pursuit of knowledge might be not just producing it but discovering it as a collective human effort? Putting to much mechanization in it kills the joy of it.
Whether or not AI replaces work or not is an important question. It's already replaced some people's jobs. But regardless of the future of labor, one thing is clear: AI just makes everything less fun and places even more emphasis on efficiency over everything else. The world with AI is just not a fun place to be any more.
Does anyone get the feeling that this might be a bad idea? Even if LLMs are far away from real intelligence (which I think is probably true), increasing their power and letting them interact doesn't sound so great. What happens if their collaboration has new emergent phenomena that makes them want to do destructive things? What happens when someone, just for fun, puts one of them in a device that can physically manipulate the world, like maybe a drone or something.
Regardless of the hype, I think there could be quite a few unintended consequences from this sort of behaviour, which seems quite reckless to me. To me it seems that those who are pushing AI forward have completely lost their sanity.
Indeed - it helps people become much more efficient. When it comes to law, that includes criminals as well. Whatever gains in efficiency happen on one side, they happen on the other too. Yes, everyone loves to say how they coded a cool side project in a day instead of a week, but what of the situation where AI is placed in a situation with two sides going against each other. The same old fight, but with better weapons.
> And noone in their right mind would want to use the less secure one.
I mean, this is a perfect description of the prisoner's dilemma. Ins't it a shame that we keep playing that game? There's something seriously wrong if we just keep creating these new arms race scenarios. It's sickening.
Some of the reasons to ban LLMs are beyond what they do to code. I.e. environmental degradation, scraping without authorization, reduce human interaction etc. So I think banning them still makes sense.