HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vy8vWJlco

1,236 karma · joined January 23, 2012

submissionscomments
vy8vWJlco··on Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website
The article touches on that angle:

Canipre quickly took on the role of “innocent” infringer and blamed their web design firm for obtaining the photos. The design firm allegedly took content from an image bank, but that would have to be a rogue outfit as Houk never sold away his rights.

In any case, Canipre is of course ultimately responsible for the content that appears on their company website, just like they hold an Internet subscriber responsible for the infringing behavior of their neighbors.

"At least" with direct commercial copyright infringement, there's something to sue over (the profit made from the sale), but when people go so far as to hold ISPs (including individuals running open hotspots, or routing gateways, or Tor exits - which few people can afford to accept liability for) and online services (like Megaupload and the Pirate Bay which, based on my current understanding, are not selling anything they aren't entitled to, even if one could show they made money off of aggregation; they aren't claiming to have made anything they aggregate), for example - when we are effectively holding intermediaries responsible for other people's behaviour I think something is wrong, and service neutrality is effectively on the block.

vy8vWJlco··on Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website
Fixed the caps for you, though perhaps the OP was referring to the absurdity of the scenario. :)
vy8vWJlco··on What is freedom?
Freedom: noun; 1. the state of having both the authority and ability to direct the course of one's own life, including to end it (IMHO).
vy8vWJlco··on A proposal for an always-releasable Debian
In short form: I think the turn around time is increasing because Debian has to wait for conflicting interests to settle. Solution: stop waiting for everything including the kitchen sink, and only worry about including the highest-yield and most necessary software in "stable". Let the newest desktops, for example, stay in unstable and layer them on stable (Ubuntu could be a themed faster-moving layer that could use as much of the stable core as possible). With the decreased turnaround time for stable iterations (the Debian ecosystem's "core" platform), less stable layers (derived distributions) would actually become less of a burden to develop since they would have a base they can depend on - one that isn't too far away from bleeding edge, but still solid as a rock.

In long form: I think Debian should focus on getting the slowest-moving targets and major package-management design and minimally necessary policies well before, and above, faster-moving targets like UI and experimental features, etc... This means rethinking repos with an eye towards community division of labour along lines like turnover time (some tools simply haven't changed much in 20 years), popularity/necessity (kernel support, bootloaders, libraries), and bleeding-edge version expectations (desktop). In practice, Debian is pretty monolithic. People mostly install what's in their primary repo (the walled garden problem).

In practice, IMHO, this would mostly boil down to making it easier to pull in separate repositories under one install, layering them on those provided by stable and it's official installer, and other special-purpose repositories (for example, with an distro-specific virtual package to articulate the dependencies and make upgrades/downgrades/sidegrades clear and easy). I recognize a lot of motion in related areas (blends, debian live, stuff outlined in the article, etc - and a technically savy user can modify their sources), but I think that there is more than necessary being attempted under the name "Debian Stable" and this has been distracting from "stability" (and costing effectiveness). Specifically, the fastest-moving targets should not be considered part of Debian at all, IMHO, but separate distributions along lines that maximize stakeholder ownership and improve turnover time. It then becomes necessary to allow seamless distribution (repository) layering and interdependence (something the package manager can already do, but is difficult in practice for more than a few sources, even to experienced users). In essence, the package+repo system does not currently help much with forks and merges at that level - even though it is one of the most common problems in open software development. (Git has spoiled me.)

Ideally, IMHO, all Debian-based distributions should be installable from the same installer, even if they may want to provide their own (like Ubuntu), something that would be made possible because the packaging standards would have solidified to the point that other distro-builders (repo, and special-purpose package maintainers) can rely on them (my hope for "stable").

That said, I am just another "user" who prefers things not break over them looking brand new.

vy8vWJlco··on Petition: Allow DEFCAD to resume distributing their files
Sure, the files are out - no going back there - but the defcad.org people are still subject to interference and possible legal issues, so they would probably still appreciate any support.
vy8vWJlco··on US Government Takes Down 3D Printed Gun Plans
"In Canada, it is legal to download the instructions, but there is a question of whether Canadians can legally print the components."

(from http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/story/2013/05/09/technolog... )

That's not especially significant in itself either, only somewhat reassuring for any Canuckois out there wishing to download the models.

vy8vWJlco··on Obama May Back FBI Plan to Expand Wiretap Laws
I do not consider pre-emptive interception capabilities to be a public or government responsibility.

Warranted interception can be helpful, but at this moment, I am concerned more by the cyber war/terrorism rhetoric and its effect on my democracy (Canada, in my case) than I am by any threat of violence (we just passed a bill called S-7 that allows for 3-day holding without charge, and 12 month conditional probation without charge, RE: "terrorism"). We usually follow the US example, so I watch these subjects with interest, and have been amazed at the choice to walk people out of their own homes in Boston, at gunpoint, "for their own protection." I'd rather take my chances and protect myself against terrorism. (A person's home used to be his "castle.")

Yes, privacy (and encryption, for example) empowers bad people - but it empowers the good ones too. Two wrongs don't make a right; I prefer to keep my freedom and strength than live in frightened "safety." So: encryption it is, even though it costs.

I wish governments and concerned citizens could see how they are creating the very walls that alienate and anger.

(FWIW, Canada had a bill called C-30 on the table last year with similar interception obligations and fines, and even though the government could have just passed it, because Canada is currently a political dictatorship, a huge number of Canadian's stood up and figuratively shouted in unison: NO. All it takes is saying I'm not afraid: I'm not afraid of terrorism, I'm not afraid of guns, I'm not afraid of other people's freedoms; no, I won't give away any more of my dignity. In fact, I want it back.)

vy8vWJlco··on Warren and Brandeis, "The Right to Privacy" (1890)
The fact that this was written over 120 years ago is a little depressing (in that we still confuse/have a hard time discerning privacy and property, at great public expense).

A couple quotes I find especially satisfying to read today:

"The possibility of future profits is not a right of property which the law ordinarily recognizes; it must, therefore, be an infraction of other rights which constitutes the wrongful act, and that infraction is equally wrongful"

"Thus, in Abernethy v. Hutchinson, 3 L. J. Ch. 209 (1825), where the plaintiff, a distinguished surgeon, sought to restrain the publication in the 'Lancet' of unpublished lectures which he had delivered as St. Bartholomew's Hospital in London, Lord Eldon doubted whether there could be property in lectures which had not been reduced to writing, but granted the injunction on the ground of breach of confidence, holding 'that when persons were admitted as pupils or otherwise, to hear these lectures, although they were orally delivered, and although the parties might go to the extent, if they were able to do so, of putting down the whole by means of short-hand, yet they could do that only for the purposes of their own information, and could not publish, for profit, that which they had not obtained the right of selling.'"

"The common law has always recognized a man's house as his castle, impregnable, often, even to his own officers engaged in the execution of its command."

My personal summary and interpretation: privacy is not the formative rational for copyright, patents, etc, and only for-profit imaginary property can be considered to be the subject of infringement since everything else is a mere statement of fact that has already been consensually published (and is therefor also not an invasion of privacy by those sharing and speaking of those facts, at their own expense).

The right to privacy has nothing to do with copyright, IMHO. In fact, if imaginary rights are taken to the extreme, my physical rights are obliterated by the desire to enforce imaginary rights (by spying and invading privacy - a physical right as considered by the article - and interference with my own computer usage and ownership) - IMHO - and I do not accept that.

vy8vWJlco··on Go ahead, pass the Internet tax. Your (foreign) competitors thank you.
My only real problem with a "race to the bottom" is when the competition is between countries with differences on subjects like human rights, since then it puts pressure on those involved to lower their own standards on those important issues as well, until they reach equilibrium. Otherwise I'd call it healthy competition, which I consider constructive in any democracy.
vy8vWJlco··on Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain?
The article mentions the TPP is on the horizon, which recently got a new trade representative/negotiator in the US.

Here is an email campaign to nag him towards good stewardship, for those interested: http://www.openmedia.org/froman?utm_campaign=Froman

The EFF also has a summary of the changeover: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5647596

vy8vWJlco··on Low-Lock Singletons In D
Thanks again. If I am right though, the memory barriers could also have been skipped without thread-local values since, due to the barriers on init, no thread's view would revert to it's pre-init state anyway. As rbehrends mentions, barriers are not the only factor... For example, global memory access may be slower on some systems due to decreased locality (a property provided by the TLS), but I don't know what if any value that would have in this benchmark. There is also a comment on that page that does the same thing as my TLS-free approach using a more reasonable static global initialization syntax in Java in response to a question of if D's initialization would be semantically equivalent too.

Edit: (Not waiting for reply link to appear...) When I say "the memory barriers could also be skipped" I am referring to any other memory barriers past those associated with initialization, not those associated with initialization. There would be memory barriers at initialization, but that is the only need for memory barriers and I believe that is provided here by the synchronized keyword. The object presented in the article then looks like a cache-friendlier version of a single global variable with the necessary barriers limited to the initialization of the global instance pointer (which might also be done as in the Java example given in the comments on the page). The TLS does not eliminate the need for any barriers, only helps eliminate non-local reads. That might allow a performance gain depending on the cache behavior (or, for example, in the presence of NUMA), but it hasn't reduced the need for locking IMHO.

vy8vWJlco··on U.S. Government Fears End of Megaupload Case
It would depend on how rayiner formed that opinion.
vy8vWJlco··on Low-Lock Singletons In D
Thanks for your comment. I do see that the TLS is used in a conditional to avoid the barriers in most cases (the already-initialized case), but the initialization still happens in a synchronized block. I may be wrong, but the docs for D say that effectively wraps the block in a critical section which seems likely to include rw barriers, meaning the code given has barriers at init and also uses TLS. If so, the TLS would be unnecessary, for my reasons above - causing me to suspect that the example has just hidden the barriers behind the synchronized keyword.
vy8vWJlco··on Low-Lock Singletons In D
Does D's synchronization not contain memory barriers (I don't know)?

(Edited)

vy8vWJlco··on Low-Lock Singletons In D
Right. I was still thinking in terms of my thread-local-less model posted before when I wrote the above, which took for granted those barriers once past init.
vy8vWJlco··on Low-Lock Singletons In D
Yep - it should be enough to force a coherent view for all as part of the initialization.
vy8vWJlco··on Low-Lock Singletons In D
If the pointer is 0 through a normal test, you would allocate the resource and do a compare-and-swap to record the allocation if the pointer is still 0. As noted beside this comment, you might wind up allocating several times in parallel (which may be undesirable too), but you would never clobber an existing allocation or change the instance that is dispensed.
vy8vWJlco··on Low-Lock Singletons In D
Yes, there would be an allocation race, so if you cannot accept allocating unnecessarily in a discardable/recoverable way (but also one that preserves the semantics of the singleton: one and only one instance returned over its life), you would still need a flag. Though you might instead use an "incomplete"/place-holder reference value to simulate the flag and prevent duplication of effort/wasting resources while the allocation happens - all in the space of the pointer.
vy8vWJlco··on Low-Lock Singletons In D
If you have atomic swaps (hardware "lock-free"), the global shared instance pointer should be enough - since it either holds a valid pointer or it doesn't.
vy8vWJlco··on Low-Lock Singletons In D
I don't think thread-local variables are necessary.

Consider a global flag that gets instantiated and synchronized across threads/cores to a state of 0 such that if it ever gets set to 1, it was after publishing and synchronizing the shared instance via a global pointer. This pointer, and the global flag, will not revert for the rest of the singleton's life (noted in the article) - so there is nothing to synchronize past that - and it is only for the guarding flag's 0 (unallocated) case that there is a question if things are synchronized. That check and potential allocation are what need a standard lock (provided by D's syncronized block), which the example already provides.

vy8vWJlco··on U.S. Government Fears End of Megaupload Case
> "A big part of megaupload's business was infringing property rights"

Objection. Hearsay, your Honor.

vy8vWJlco··on The world’s first entirely 3D-printed gun has been made
Sure - while it is an opinion about me (and others), it is also (simultaneously, though not exclusively) a recommendation (perhaps only an implied one) about what is in my best interests, when I alone can decide if I am safe, for example (it is not a lamp, or a number, it is my own feeling): therefore the commentor is speaking for me. Furthermore, since I define safety for myself, my assertion that the comment does not reflect my interests also makes it misrepresentation (in addition to speaking for me) in my case.
vy8vWJlco··on The world’s first entirely 3D-printed gun has been made
What characterization?

I am simply asking to not be spoken for, not saying the commentor isn't entitled to have an opinion. I say clearly above that I am OK with the comment as a mere opinion ("No, that part was OK" ...).

I'm curious if you read my reply closely before responding, or if you decided in advance what you wanted to say if I replied to you, because you seemed not to have received its intended meaning.

To repeat: I am not saying the commentor isn't entitled to an opinion, only saying that that opinion is wrong from my perspective and for my case since it is an opinion about me (and I was included by the word "we"). I am also entitled to my opinion.

On top of that, I also happen to think that my opinions about what is best for me should matter more in the public's view than what someone else thinks is best for me. I am not property to be managed, a sheep to be herded, or a child to be guarded. I am my own person - the horse's mouth, for my part - and I consider it offensive to be spoken for. Have you ever been told something is "for your own good"? If so, did you appreciate it?

vy8vWJlco··on The world’s first entirely 3D-printed gun has been made
No, that part was OK. I just don't want to be included, by assumption, in the set of people needing protection or those who should be afraid.

Even if the comment merely describes an opinion about me (and others) without directly putting words into my mouth, that opinion still seems to say that something is for my "own good." I disagree with the prescription and I would like to be excluded from the idea.

vy8vWJlco··on The world’s first entirely 3D-printed gun has been made
I think there were a number of factors also, including economic and others, but I don't know that hair and eyes were ultimately very big ones - since those didn't seem to help surrounding areas like Austria and the Netherlands. The map of the territories at the end of WWII just amazes me with Switzerland standing out almost like an island:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Second_world_war_europe_1...

There was also a report in the mid 80s penned by, among others, former General George S. Patton (who was active during WWII)... "In short, Switzerland is an armed bunker." (PDF page 8, https://docs.google.com/viewer?embedded=true&url=http://... )

vy8vWJlco··on The world’s first entirely 3D-printed gun has been made
Actually, I don't see that as a necessary goal either since what is considered reasonable or rational in a society/system boils down to numbers - including what I tend to call useful or objective truths (even science is iterative). Since I also think everyone deserves an equal opportunity ("has the right") to choose what makes sense for his or her self, I don't feel a need/want to control anyone but myself (to make sure he or she chooses according to my morality, or current scientific theory) unless I absolutely have to interact with him or her. I only want to also be treated equally in any and all social interactions (such as having the right to own anything anyone else, government or non-government, may), and to otherwise be left alone wherever possible, since I am only trying to speak for myself.
vy8vWJlco··on The world’s first entirely 3D-printed gun has been made
Are you saying Switzerland is not part of the "first world"?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_politics_in_Switzerland#Gu...

Germany invaded surrounding territories in WWII, but left Switzerland alone.

vy8vWJlco··on The world’s first entirely 3D-printed gun has been made
IMHO, disarmament creates that opportunity for abuse. I've never seen someone take advantage of the strong.
vy8vWJlco··on The world’s first entirely 3D-printed gun has been made
> "I don't like guns and I think the fewer people have them, the safer we are"

The best case scenario, IMHO, is that everyone has the means to defend themselves against abuse. I value equality.

The worst case scenario, IMHO, is a single person or group with a disproportionate ability to abuse those who are defenseless against them - and they know it (your fewer-the-better scenario). IMHO, crime happens because people think they can get away with it. Good fences make good neighbors, IMHO, so I feel safer when everyone has a gun, for example, since disarmament creates an opportunity that wasn't there before.

Long story short, please don't say "we," since your ideas are strictly your own.

vy8vWJlco··on Why I won’t buy another subsidized Android phone
Having spent money in the past, I have voted for Sony and regretted it. I am still washing the taste out of my mouth. Trust is earned, and we are not square. My threshold has not yet been reached (maybe others are more ready to forgive). If they interpret my distrust as you say, that would be unfortunate and inaccurate - but if I were to ignore the history of my encounters, I could make the corresponding argument: they might interpret it as acceptance of those behaviors. I can only guess about the future, but at least I can learn from the past.
← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →