HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wamatt

2,899 karma · joined February 21, 2012

username at Buchheit’s beta bunker
submissionscomments
wamatt··on Reconciling Mozilla’s Mission and the W3C EME
"No, DRM can't enforce it (since this stuff is pirated practically instantaneously). So why is it used?"

Strongly suspect this is due to contractual obligations with the studios.

The agreements will almost certainly stipulate that content must be sufficiently protected. Hence Netflix plays ball, if it wants access.

wamatt··on PG at Launch [video]
I find it interesting, in this case at least, PG appears to be talking against the wisdom of crowds.

Now I'm not sure if he is correct in this instance, but it's probably a good idea to keep mindful of both sides. Sometimes a small elite can be better positioned to make the call, and other times it's the crowd.

Regarding the WhatsApp deal, perhaps Mark knows better than the tech community, given the large information asymmetry at play. However the reverse could also be true too, especially in companies with visionary leaders. IOW, one could question how much 'towing the line' happens at FB, given a leader with a large ego footprint.

Looking back, Microsoft missed the internet boat in the beginning (allowing Netscape to dominate), and as a result needed to play catchup. But, I'd wager Bill Gates's own limitations of judgement and inward focus on Microsoft, was a large contributor to this blunder.

wamatt··on PG at Launch [video]
"we used to have more faith in brains". The context here was Jason Calacanis was asking PG what signals if any, had changed over the course of time, when selecting teams.

Perhaps this goes nicely with this New Yorker article[1] summarizing the gap between high-IQ and what I would call instrumental rationality (as opposed to epistemic rationality). Also, it's quite possibly old hat to those who've read 'Thinking Fast, Thinking Slow' and related literature.

Speaking personally, while I'm possibly different to many here on HN, I enjoyed a sort of ruthless pragmatism in my teens and 20's and almost dogmatic focus. These days, I'm falling more into the theory trap, and tend to enjoy the conceptual and theoretical, far more than accumulating operational domain expertise. I do wonder if that's a permanent inclination, or if it turns out to be more cyclic in nature.

[1] "Why smart people are stupid", http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/frontal-cortex/2012/06...

wamatt··on Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
> People are assuming a lot of things

> "Carlsen did what he wanted because the outcome didn't really matter to him."

Hmm.. didn't you just make an assumption too regarding Carlsen's state of mind and motives?

Honestly both you and the OP seem to be engaging in pure speculation.

wamatt··on I, Glasshole: My Year With Google Glass
Interesting that no one seems to be talking about the wisdom of placing an EMF field next to your brain, for hours at a time.
wamatt··on Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning clock back for mice
Since you asked so politely, I'll attempt, albeit somewhat hesitantly, to offer some feedback.

So looking back on my encounters with Aubrey, I can only say he seems perfectly content appearing old and wise. In fact he's well known to be anti-interventionist (for the meantime) and does not endorse supplementation or other strategies other than basic obvious health advice (eat well, exercise). This is in contrast to his friend Ray Kurzweil, who on the other end of the spectrum is ingesting 100+ pills daily.[1]

In terms of the HN reaction, I too admit at first, to an immediate emotional desire to downvote. On the one hand, I respect your breadth of knowledge and am grateful to your usually educational summations, but on this occasion, the dismissal seems shallow. The sense one gets, is that you're not really taking him seriously as a biomedical gerontologist, as a researcher studying senescence for the last 20 years. Instead it feels (at least to me) like a dismissal more slightly more appropriate, to a salesman peddling snakeoil.

So lastly, and perhaps most importantly, setting aside emotion, the dismissal was logically flawed. If a researcher produces findings and chooses not to follow them (by your implication the reason for his old and haggard appearance), it has little bearing on the validity of said findings. There may be many good (and not so good) reasons for not following the immediate implications of ones own research: Akrasia[2], lazyness, "wait and see". For example, theoretical research (eg murine models -- such as FTA) occurs long before a drug, has passed all the relevant safety tests in humans, and enters the market.

hth

[1] http://bigthink.com/videos/the-top-3-supplements-for-survivi...

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akrasia

wamatt··on Introducing Open Salaries at Buffer
>EDIT: As an interesting additional note, all salaries (beyond a token minimum) at Berkeley (and the whole UC system) are publicly available at http://ucpay.globl.org/.

Fascinating, I had no idea this was public. Looking briefly at the results, it reveals a curious data point:

UC's highest paid employee is not, as one might expect, the chancellor or dean, but in fact the sports coach ($2,884,880 gross)

wamatt··on Oculus VR raises $75M
Warren Buffett could be considered conservative, and having a generous aversion to all things tech. a16z, OTOH is almost on the opposite side of the spectrum when compared to Berkshire Hathaway. And yet, they both appear to following a similar fundamental principle:

Invest in truly exceptional companies and people, at a good price. Rather than a good company, at an exceptional price. [1]

[1] http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/1989.html

wamatt··on Chromium: I just wanted to quickly hack an iframe blocker for personal use
Neat. Analogous to using a personal firewall (eg Little Snitch), except for the browser.
wamatt··on Web GL Ocean Simulation
Might be system dependent, though couldn't help but notice a non-trivial difference in the OpenGL rendering quality, between Firefox and Chrome.

Chrome 32 beta on OS X, produced an anti-aliased canvas, whereas Firefox 25 had the dreaded jaggies @ 1680x1050

wamatt··on Angular Announces AngularDart
BrendenEich said this of Dart, 2 years ago on HN, and might help explain OP's sentiment:

For the record, I'm not worried about JS being replaced by a better language. I am working to do that within Ecma TC39, by evolving JS aggressively.

The leaked Google doc's assertion that this is impossible and that a "clean break" is required to make significant improvements is nonsense, a thin rationale for going it alone rather than cooperating fully.

The big issue I have with Dart, which you seem to consider inconsequential, is whether Google forks the web developer community, not just its own paid developers, with Dart, and thereby fragments web content.

A Dart to JS compiler will never be "decent" compared to having the Dart VM in the browser. Yet I guarantee you that Apple and Microsoft (and Opera and Mozilla, but the first two are enough) will never embed the Dart VM.

So "Works best in Chrome" and even "Works only in Chrome" are new norms promulgated intentionally by Google. We see more of this fragmentation every day. As a user of Chrome and Firefox (and Safari), I find it painful to experience, never mind the political bad taste.

Ok, counter-arguments. What's wrong with playing hardball to advance the web, you say? As my blog tries to explain, the standards process requires good social relations and philosophical balance among the participating competitors.

Google's approach with Dart is thus pretty much all wrong and doomed to leave Dart in excellent yet non-standardized and non-interoperable implementation status. Dart is GBScript to NaCl/Pepper's ActiveG.

Could Google, unlike Microsoft ten or so years ago, prevail? Only by becoming the new monopoly power on the web. We know how that story ends.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2982949

EDIT: updated to the long form quote, for additional context.

wamatt··on The Fireplace Delusion (2012)
See also previous HN discussion, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5355248
wamatt··on What happens when you're #1 on Hacker News for a day
I enjoyed reading the report back. The author laid it out clearly and informatively. However the dismissal of the top HN comment, appears unfounded. [1]

It reads like a case of minimizing dissonance. In other words, it seems the author is attempting to rationalize away another person's viewpoint, by simply characterizing it as snark.

Some more probable explanations why the comment made it to #1, could have been:

- It felt authentic. "I've lived and built two companies in Thailand over the last 14 years."

- The answer expressed a contrary viewpoint, giving HN readers a more balanced view of the topic.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6541441

wamatt··on The Man Who Invented Modern Probability
For anyone interested, the above appendix comes from ET Jaynes's[1] magnum opus, "Probability Theory: The Logic of Science" [2].

Which, IMHO is deserving of it's grand title and provides an excellent framework for using Bayes in the real world.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edwin_Thompson_Jaynes

[2] http://shawnslayton.com/open/Probability%20book/book.pdf

wamatt··on Humble Bundle releases EA/Origin bundle
Seems like a smart move. It could help to dampen the perception of evil attached to EA's reputation, whilst making a sizable ($1m+) difference to a number of charities.

That said, it would be nice to see a greater choice in the number of charities. My own preference would be to donate to smaller and more focused variety. Or, even combining it with charitable crowdfunded projects. eg[1][2]

Although, it may also be logistically harder to pull that off.

[1] http://www.indiegogo.com/projects/kite-patch

[2] http://www.indiegogo.com/projects/let-s-build-a-goddamn-tesl...

wamatt··on Your Thoughts Can Release Abilities Beyond Normal Limits
There is likely an element of truth to OP's general point.

For example, journalist and author, Joshua Foer[1], talks about the astonishing feats of memory by average people. It becomes more persuasive, when it turns personal. While he starts out by writing a story on memory championships, he decides to take it further and delves deep into learning the techniques himself. Some time later, he ends up becoming the USA Champion!

"In 2006, Foer won the U.S.A. Memory Championship, and set a new USA record in the "speed cards" event by memorizing a deck of 52 cards in 1 minute and 40 seconds"[1]

The Ted Talk provides more detail [2].

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joshua_Foer

[2] http://www.ted.com/talks/joshua_foer_feats_of_memory_anyone_...

wamatt··on Persona makes signing in easy for Gmail users
I believe Clickpass was YC '07. Falling short of a Series A raise, Yola/Synthasite acquired them in 2008 [1]

Then a few years later (2012), Yola sold the IP and users to Janrain [2]

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=402973

[2] http://janrain.com/clickpass-acquired-by-janrain/

EDIT: my pleasure callahad :)

wamatt··on Netflix ditches Silverlight with support for HTML5 video in IE11
The ideological debate is potentially interesting: Does DRM belong in HTML5?

(and yes, it's hard not to view the Netflix/MS situation cynically)

That said, ditching that godawful Silverlight plugin, is probably a welcome change from the customer experience perspective.

wamatt··on iOS 7
There has been much talk of Microsoft as the model of a floundering corporate, stagnant and lacking leadership.

So, and this is perhaps a small detail, it does seem somewhat interesting, that both Google and now Apple, appear to have adopted Microsoft's flat UI approach.

wamatt··on Logical Fallacies Are Usually Irrelevant or Cited Incorrectly
>And it's a lack of awareness of this point that often frustrates me about discussions here on HN.

Would possibly expand by saying, in my experience, self-awareness in society as a whole, appears to be a scarce and somewhat underrated quality.

Obviously not implying anyone is perfect in that regard (I for one, am not), but I feel it's something that could be useful to work at.

wamatt··on Logical Fallacies Are Usually Irrelevant or Cited Incorrectly
>If your "opinion" is stated in the form "x is y," then maybe you are the one who should be more conscious of the way people communicate.

Irony much? :)

>"It [x] is irritating and intellectually backwards [y].

wamatt··on Bitcoin sentiment analysis
> What a surprisingly naive post from Timothy! The reason these events did not affect Bitcoin's price is simply because they are all (except 1) affecting mostly the US market, wich is a tiny fraction of the worldwide Bitcoin market.

While there is a clear trend towards globalization of Bitcoin underway, the USA historically and currently, dominates the lion's share of the market. [1][2]

[1] http://bitcoinstatus.rowit.co.uk/countryHostsMonth.png

[2] http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-05-27/mapping-bitcoins-gl...

wamatt··on Yahoo submits bid for Hulu
>I've never understood why people dislike the commercials so much.

Speaking from a purely speculative and subjective opinion, it could be partially due to neurodiversity within the population. The root cause could be that differing clusters of people have differing cognitive processing abilities.

For example, personally I despise commercials, because they break the flow, and force a context switch. Similarly, movement on the computer screen, whilst trying to read text is highly stressful to me. For this reason, I choose to install extensions (adblockers etc) to make sure that the screen is static, and only moves when I want it to.

Some people try to control their environment, others tend to adapt. Case in point, my oldest friend, is the opposite to me, and he doesn't mind adverts, or distractions, and actually prefers to study with music playing. I'm constantly amazed how others like him, manage to blend so efficiently into the environment.

wamatt··on Tesla Repays Department of Energy Loan Nine Years Early
>Musk had very little to do with PayPal.

That's rather inaccurate. Musk's company was X.com and Thiel/Levchin/Noseks's was called Confinity. They had a 50/50 merger in early 2000, and at first the new company was called X.com.

Furthermore, Confinity[1] was doing Palm Pilot payments under the PayPal brand[2], while X.com was working on internet money transmission over email. Which idea was more useful in the long run? (hint: if you chose Palm Pilot's - you're wrong)

Much of the disinformation stems from a book called the "The Paypal Wars" written by a Thiel fanboy, that is embarrassingly biased. Musk writes:

"The only negativity in recent years was due to a book called The PayPal Wars, written by a sycophantic jackass called Eric Jackson. This guy was one notch above an intern at PayPal in the first few years of the company, but gives the impression he was a key player and privy to all the high level discussions. Eric couldn't find a real publisher, so Peter funded Eric to self-publish the book. Since Eric worships Peter, the outcome was obvious - Peter sounds like Mel Gibson in Braveheart and my role is somewhere between negligible and a bad seed. However, to his credit, Peter didn't realize the book would be as bad as it was and apologized to me personally at a Room 9 board meeting at David Sacks's home in LA."[3]

Post-merger it's hard to say who did what exactly, and Levchin for example was instrumental in Paypal's anti-fraud system, a key development that allowed the company to navigate around a potentially ruinous situation.

The bottom line is, 3 hyper-smart guys (Thiel, Levchin and Nosek), don't give away essentially 50% of their shares to some someone else (X.com) on a whim. This was a calculated and deliberate decision. Similarly, it's unlikely Musk would have succeeded alone either, and thus why they are all called co-founders of PayPal, Inc.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confinity

[2] http://www.halplotkin.com/cnbcs029.htm

[3] http://gawker.com/230076/an-alternate-history-according-to-e...

wamatt··on Apple's new Objective-C to Javascript Bridge
>And, if Apple were to switch, why would they pick a language as shitty as Javascript?

That seems to be a fairly popular dismissal for a language designed in 10 days, and perhaps rightly so. JavaScript probably classifies as mediocre language compared to the wealth of sanely designed choices we have available today.

That said, have you taken a recent look at the next generation of JavaScript aka ES6/Harmony?[1]

- Modules? Yup

- Maps and Sets? You bet.

- Tail call optimizations? Sure

- Classes? Finally!

etc

That's not to suggest that a single iteration will magically fix all of its quirks and shortcomings. However, one possibility could be that Apple picked JS, not on it's checkered history, or the fact that it is popular amongst web developers today, but where it is headed tomorrow and how it could be adopted and adapted.

[1] https://wiki.mozilla.org/ES6_plans*

wamatt··on Google to Microsoft: Remove your YouTube App from the Windows Phone Store
There used to be an understated, but strong implication, that Google is 'good', Microsoft is 'evil', and perhaps justifiably so: Microsoft didn't exactly make a good impression on geekdom during the 90's.

These days however, and speaking from a purely subjective perspective, Microsoft appears to be slightly softer and humbler, whilst Google under Page appears to be confident, maybe even aggressive and certainly increasingly ubiquitous. It's the last part that concerns me most.

Apple, Google and Microsoft however all pale by comparison when placed on the same scale as non-profit Mozilla Corp, in terms of openness and looking after our rights and freedoms.

Personally I'm somewhat of a bannerless citizen, but at least in theory, that's an organization that could receive my support.

wamatt··on PayPal exec aims to “obliterate passwords from the face of the planet”
> That's scary to me; one is proving beyond any shadow of a doubt that one was present at that place at that time.

To some, I imagine they feel could the opposite: Reassurance against wrongful accusations of crimes not committed.

wamatt··on Banyan, the "GitHub of Science", is now in public beta
While I can agree with the spirit of your message, OTOH...

> Not only do private corporations buy shiny buildings, but they also have a legal obligation to make as much money for their shareholders as they possibly can.

This seems to be a popular belief, but it's simply not true. Private companies have no legal requirement to make profits or pay dividends. Even public companies, do not have to by law, maximize profits ("make as much money").[1] Corporate officers do of course, have an obligation to act in the best interests of the company, and have maintain certain fiduciary duties.

[1] http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/8146/are-u-s-com...

wamatt··on Fix random few-second freezes in Mountain Lion
Same here. 2012 Macbook Pro, 16GB Ram, SSD etc. Pretty sure the issue relates to thermal throttling.

It's particularly bad when in clamshell mode, plugged into the Thunderbolt display.

kernel_task CPU usage shoots up when CPU throttling kicks in. I suspect however GPU throttling also is affecting performance.

At times the GUI just feels really slow and laggy. Seriously considering ditching OS X altogether.

wamatt··on Physicist proposes new way to think about intelligence
It's turtles all the way down, until you reach Philosophy
← PreviousPage 5 of 16Next →