HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wamatt

2,899 karma · joined February 21, 2012

username at Buchheit’s beta bunker
submissionscomments
wamatt··on The Secret Tesla Motors Master Plan (2006)
Musk's plan in a way serves as a reminder for those of us that tend to overestimate the role luck plays in the personal journey towards entrepreneurial success.

While generally HN users are open minded, no small number have derided the notion that others (perhaps far less capable than Musk), are capable of having a meaningful vision.

Of course having a justified belief and plan is a different approach to the lean startup philosophy. Lean effectively aligns more with the randomness worldview and iteration with an impartiality (or even celebration in some cases) of failure. Whereas OTOH, the visionary approach usually has more confidence in a self-directed path.

Those with this visionary quality (in varying levels of ability), can arrogantly dismiss others too, with behavior that is equally cringe worthy. Moreover, it would be hard to objectively and meaningfully argue either approach is universally "better".

However, perhaps the most significant indiscretion, is not in picking a side that works for you, but rather failing to see that two sides exist at all.

wamatt··on Evernote hacked
>"I have since seen an infuriating number of people point to it to claim that passphrases are more secure than random passwords. They are not."

It appears you have assumed all passphrases must take the same methodological route as outlined in the xkcd comic.

However, 'noozle stroodle' has an entropy of 69.303 [1]

The above quotation, is a passphrase, and it's more secure than any 7char printable ASCII password.

While I accept your argument that not all pass phrases are necessarily more secure than seven lettered passwords, one cannot rightly make the antithetical claim either.

The correct judgement is: It depends

[1] According to the JS tester, http://dl.dropbox.com/u/209/zxcvbn/test/index.html

wamatt··on How does the Internet work?
Indeed.

It's questionable how complete an explanation of the internet is, with little mention of peering agreements and transit relationships.

wamatt··on Google Chrome may soon get audio indicators to show you noisy tabs
On a somewhat related note, while an audio indicator is a nice addition, autoplay itself should really be a user controllable browser setting.
wamatt··on The Net Is a Waste of Time (1996)
That was a mostly prescient and enjoyable blast from the past. One thing though I was glad Gibson was wrong about:

>"It will probably evolve into something considerably less random, and less fun"

While his point was/is true of many systems and organizations, the internet is one example that has really outdone itself in terms of sustaining an unrelenting resistance towards a global monoculture.

Perhaps, like some older HN users here, when I go looking beyond the walled gardens of social networks, I feel just as fascinated by what I read today, as I did in the mid 90's.

wamatt··on Problems With Precision and Judgment, but Not Integrity, in Tesla Test
Kudos. It appears you've made a compelling case and I found those links to be interesting reading.

Of course we should still keep a close watch on the future to see how true it remains to the historical record and theory. But in the meantime, I'll be be updating my model, and nudging the needle, a little further toward the left. (if 'for the people' is left, and 'for the company' is to the right, on a 1 dimensional axis).

Thanks for taking the time to respond.

wamatt··on A Most Peculiar Test Drive – Follow Up
I've found Less Wrong to be somewhat useful and interesting community, and I've made some friends over the past year at a few of the meetups in the Bay Area.

That said, it's possibly slightly ironic that many (perhaps even the majority) of the LW members, (in my personal experience) seem to naturally posses low levels of instrumental rationality, and tend to be unusually self-unaware of their own feelings and unconscious motivations.

Another way to say this: "common sense" is not something (in my experience), that is respected, understood or utilized in spades within the community.

Furthermore, while there are criticisms of LW out there, I agree with Aaron Swartz's central claim[1] about a lack of skepticism. While I'm a huge advocate of Bayes theorem, I would be wary of calling myself a "Bayesian", or other self-reinforcing label. Although calibrated belief networks (eg BBN's)[2] are powerful, they can also fall prone to delusional outputs where there exists a lack of sufficient external feedback.

Much of the rhetoric focuses around the charismatic and arguably pompous (don't mean to sound harsh) character of Eliezer Yudkowsky. IMHO this is considerably more evident, than the level to which HN centers around PG, for example. As for LW, further comparison's have been made to a cult before. [3][4]

In addition, and this is more a personal quibble, there seems to be an inclination towards debate vs dialectic. But that's probably true of nearly any community out there. HTH.

[1] http://lesswrong.com/lw/atm/cult_impressions_of_less_wrongsi...

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayesian_network

[3] http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13018494520A...

[4] http://kruel.co/2012/07/29/possible-reasons-for-a-perception...

wamatt··on Things I found on GitHub: shell history
Interesting stats. I'd be wary however, of prematurely drawing any hard conclusions.

For example comparing vim to emacs, one should rather look at whether the bash history indicates a predominantly emacs or vim user, then isolate or compartmentalize that as a single vote.

Even then we can't be sure that it supports any grandiose claim, but it should in theory be a little more accurate.

wamatt··on Problems With Precision and Judgment, but Not Integrity, in Tesla Test
>"They may have some loyalty to the company they work for, but they work independently of the newsroom and in fact reporters tend to distrust them or consider them a nuisance."

Do you have anything evidence for that claim? Either first hand experience or perhaps a citation?

I will concede they are not directly PR people, but yet the role of "Public Editor" was created in the wake of an ethics scandal and PR tsunami[1] at the NYT. The position is also on the payroll of the NYT.

Occam's Razor would indicate we should follow the incentives.

Keeping an open mind as always, but I don't think there is good cause, a priori for the belief that the "Public Editor" is working tirelessly for the good of the people.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jayson_Blair#Plagiarism_and_fab...

wamatt··on Problems With Precision and Judgment, but Not Integrity, in Tesla Test
Strange reaction from Musk. He seemed awfully quick to jump fully onboard with a rather pallid response from the NYT's Public Editor[1] (a position somewhat analogous to the head of PR in a corporate).

While there could be many reasons, two more probable IMHO could be:

1) The "out" he was looking for: absolution for a somewhat strong initial overreaction.

2) He's simply being naive, and not reading between the lines.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_editor

wamatt··on A Most Peculiar Test Drive
That's a good point. Although, irrespective of how thoughtfully Tesla may have attempted to mitigate the fundamental problem through novel engineering, the reality seems to reflect something else. Having now entered the market in full swing, car owners are confirming this is a valid issue (especially in the very cold climate states).

To be fair though, sub-zero temperature battery issues generally affect EVs across the board.[1] However, Tesla is positioning itself as the first mainstream car manufacture to go all out on EV. Thus, surely the onus ought to fall with them, when it comes to educating the 'ICE(internal combustion engine)-driving' public as to the potential pitfalls and differences between ICEs and EVs? Instead the company seems to be ignoring the issue, hoping it will go away.

It's not within the public's experience, that if you leave your vehicle unplugged overnight, in extreme cold, the range can have reduced itself significantly by the next morning. Contrastingly, operating under normal conditions, the manual allegedly states (Page 25) about a 1% discharge rate per day. [2]

Now ordinarily I might say this is a once off. But it would appear, lack of adequate customer education is a recurring concern.

Consider the case of an early adopter (Max Drucker) that had his Tesla Roadster bricked [3][4]. He was told he needed to pay $40 000 for a new battery pack because he was 'negligent'. His transgression? Leaving it unplugged for 2 months in a temporary garage while renovating his home.

What could be negligent, is Tesla failing to highlight possible issues pertaining to their EV vehicles and how they differ from ICE expectations. Burying important or even critical details in the manual/warranty docket, seems questionable.

Still a huge supporter of what they are trying to achieve, but their refusal to admit any fault and tendency to blame the customer, is a tad off-putting.

[1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/01...

[2] http://www.teslamotorsclub.com/showthread.php/12188-Battery-...

[3] http://www.examiner.com/article/it-s-a-brick-tesla-s-batteri...

[4] http://www.wired.com/autopia/2012/02/bricked-tesla-roadsters...

wamatt··on A Most Peculiar Test Drive
Like the OP, I'm assuming many of us, have a great deal of respect for his intellect and integrity, but honestly, I can't help feeling a bit let down by the way Mr Musk has handled the situation.

Musk opens the rebuttal with: "We are upset by this article because it does not factually represent Tesla technology, which is designed and tested to operate well in both hot and cold climates."

It certainly feels somewhat disingenuous to mention nothing, of what arguably should be, the central discussion point: The Model S (more specifically the car's Li-Ion battery pack) performs unusually poorly in frigid conditions.

While as a nerdier group we tend to love data and generally have a higher faith in empirical methods, in this instance, it does appear more like a data deluge. As a result, this ends up detracting focus and deflecting any valid criticism of the car.

Although I've been following TM for years now, the battery pack temperature issue was still a surprise to me. More importantly, Tesla owners are finding this out the hard way too. [1][2]

Did the NYT reporter add a little journalistic embellish to the story? Probably. Is the review a complete work of fiction as Musk judged it? Unlikely, and what is more probable is that Musk has simply overreacted and has taken it personally. Indeed he is still human after all.

[1] http://www.teslamotorsclub.com/showthread.php/13633-NYT-arti...

[2] http://andwediditourway.blogspot.co.uk/2013/02/the-not-so-ev...

(attr. iyulaev)

wamatt··on Google Fails the Turing Test
"Or, say, personal information that can be used in targeting advertising."

This time, it's the word 'pay' that is being shoehorned.

Let's assume I run a survey company, and I invite a bunch of people over for a BBQ. During lunch I passively monitor their interactions and sell that data. Did the guests pay for the BBQ?

">I'd describe them a suppliers,"

That is a bit more specific and possibly more accurate, but at least 67% less sexy ;).

However it does not invalidate the original product claim. Often suppliers are part of that chain. They supply raw goods (personal data in this case) that gets packaged as part of a product offering (aka adwords) or service, and then sold to the customer.

wamatt··on Google Fails the Turing Test
"To say that someone is a product just because they don't want to pay money for something strikes me as borderline sociopathic."

Subjective feelings, while perfectly reasonable and acceptable in their own right, should maintain little bearing on the objective and consensually derived definitions of words, if one is being intellectually honest.

Simply put, it would be a stretch to convince us that your distaste for the concept (calling it 'borderline sociopathic') is not influencing your POV.

wamatt··on Google Fails the Turing Test
>"If you're not paying money, you're the product being sold" is one of those cached phrases that looks insightful on first glance, but contains no actual substance.

And that summary judgement follows a familiar pattern: 'This is meant to be insightful, but actually... let me show how the prevailing wisdom is wrong, with my new improved analysis'

The problem here, is that you're trying to be too clever in order to stretch words beyond their common usage.

Some personal perspective: Myself and the rest of the EA (Enterprise Architecture) team at my prior company spent almost a month painfully debating the meaning of word "Customer". Yes, I know, crazy and yet we had good reason for the corporate dictionary to be accurate. Financial control systems and exec reporting relied on it. But I digress, and while I can't remember the exact definition we used, the essential fact is:

A customer pays for goods or services.

It doesn't matter if they use dollars, bitcoins, or bushels of corn. Nearly all users of Google are NOT customers, and indeed do form part of the product offering, as the OP stated.

Additional references:

"A customer (also known as a client, buyer, or purchaser) is the recipient of a good, service, product, or idea, obtained from a seller, vendor, or supplier for a monetary or other valuable consideration. [1][2]

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Customer

[2] http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/customer

wamatt··on I’m Sick of Tiny, Tiny Type
While I too dislike small fonts, I'm particularly rageful of web designers that force this on the user using -webkit-text-size-adjust:none; [1]

That bit of CSS will prevent Chrome and Safari from allowing the text to be resized at all.

The Facebook Social Comments plugin is one such occurrence, but I see it all over the web.

[1] http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1831922/how-to-prevent-us...

wamatt··on Snapchat Lands $13.5 Million in Round Led By Benchmark
While I'm not privy to the specifics of this specific deal, I believe often the point of raising large amounts of capital, is to secure and ensure continued market dominance, in winner-takes-all stakes.

It's usually not the primary goal to innovate new features per se, although that is often what is stated publicly.

Furthermore, when it comes time to exit, a premium will likely be paid, for the competitor in pole position.

wamatt··on How to prevent a meritocracy entrenching itself
>Every elite in history has called itself a "meritocracy". Who defines "merit"?

I'd concede that the word itself may have been used questionably to capitalize on the associated ideological goodwill. However, simply stating it may have been abused, does not automatically preclude an actual meritocratic group from existing.

For example, while many generally dishonest individuals (eg sociopaths) may profess to being totally honest, it does not follow that a generally honest person, does not exist.

Similarly, it's quite possible to build something close to a true meritocracy. How do I know? Because this happened at my previous company. Merit, at it's core, was defined by outputs. Nothing more. Was it perfect? No, but we are dealing with messy humans, and subjectivity obviously occurs, but the point is to actively and continually encourage a culture of objectivity.

Over many years the track record bore this out.

There were those that started in 'serfdom' and yet over time, rose up. Actually, not always "up", as in traditional line management sense, but certainly in responsibilities assigned to them. Hence they received associated increases in compensation, benefits and peer respect.

Many know the theory, but how well it works in practice, depends on the ability of those leading, to truly believe and continually act in a way that promotes and entrenches the behavior, so that it becomes the culture.

An example, we had (and they still do), employees on the exec management team that started their professional journey's as junior call center agents. Conversely, those persons that partook in politicized self promotion, tended to enjoy a rather brief tenancy at the company. Either they were actively pushed out by peers and managers, or they passively drifted apart on their own accord, as their natural skills of manipulation and politicking, bore scarce fruits.

In summary, while perhaps uncommon, it is possible to for a meritocracy to flourish given excessive care and thoughtfulness is spent designing fair and useful incentives and metrics. Shallow or ill-conceived incentives and insincere leadership, could set the organization on a ruinous path over the longterm.

wamatt··on Eric Schmidt Plans To Sell 3.2M Google Shares
Interesting that you're appear so dismissive of Google's self driving cars.

I'm not claiming you're necessarily wrong, but I am intrigued about the other self driving options and how they surpass Google's solution?

It would appear to be a widely held belief, that Google is the pioneer and leader in the field, at least with respect to the software/AI.

wamatt··on Show HN: Chime - A Notification Center for the Web
Color me impressed gentlemen. A useful idea with great execution.

Now how about:

1) Ability to sleep/snooze on notifications. The use case would be when we are working in the browser and require focus. Some of us feel overly compelled to click little red notification badges, which can be distracting. Yes shame on us! :)

2) Make coffee and walk the dog

wamatt··on Tesla's ingenious strategy
Congrats on your purchase. By all accounts the Model S seems worthy of the accolades it's receiving.

What I do find interesting, is the apparent failure of the wisdom of crowds in this specific instance. While it has proven to be a useful construct in certain contexts, it's by no means a universal truism.

Searching for Tesla articles circa 2007/2008, one notices a stark contrast. The voice of the majority, as evidenced in the comments, echoes a pessimistic outlook with going so far as to strongly assert arrogance/foolishness on Musk's part.

It's almost too easy to praise a success, looking backwards through time.

wamatt··on Who Does Skype Let Spy?
FTA: "That's security in today's world. We have no choice but to trust Microsoft. Microsoft has reasons to be trustworthy, but they also have reasons to betray our trust in favor of other interests. And all we can do is ask them nicely to tell us first."

Schneier's opinion on security is generally held in high regard, however, in this instance, his fallacious reasoning is somewhat surprising.

IOW, it's highly unlikely that 'trusting Microsoft', is the only option we have.

wamatt··on Elon Musk: Boeing 787 battery fundamentally unsafe
The point you make about design of the 787 is fitting. Many of us can appreciate its awe inspiring technological splendor. However, one does have to wonder if it's possible, that this feeling could be overly motivating your defense of Boeing, and criticism of Mr Musk?

We can probably agree that no one (Musk included), is without reproach. However historically we see a person willing to go all in, literally putting all his liquidity toward his new ventures. It does seem somewhat implausible he simply keeps striking it lucky.

I haven't the foggiest clue if he's right or not, but it does appear he's taken a calculated risk. Accordingly, he will be punished or rewarded as the story unfolds.

His approach seems somewhat harsh/brazen, but is that what really matters here?

When your're the unlucky patient strapped to the operating table, in need of critical surgery (assuming only two doctors were available), would want the specialist with the highest level of competency, or the one with the nicest bedside manner?

wamatt··on Collaborative screen sharing (formerly PowWow)
Well crafted demo and UX. Nicely done folks.

On a side note: I found the submit to mailing list input to be non-functioning on mobile Safari (but possibly other browsers)

wamatt··on Why the Fuck?
>"The conceptual stream" is hard to follow. What conceptual stream? Do you mean you're having trouble articulating what you want to say? Then why not say that? "Conceptual stream" is not something usually said in conversational English

A fair point. While some statements could be a somewhat unfamiliar/unusual, it only take a little more effort to process, if one just thinks about it.

eg "conceptual stream"

Take the concept of a stream (aka a social network news feed, or a data stream). Take the concept of a concept. Then merge the two. Hence you should have an image of a stream of concepts, interconnected via a graph.

Another way to look at it could be to picture a sports commentator. We see him speedily narrating the action as he watches the game. Event's are often linked: "He hit the ball", "Now he's going for 3rd base", "Oh and it's a homerun", "the crowd is ecstatic"

Now what if we replaced the real word events, with concepts?

Sometimes events are completely unconnected too, concepts work in a similar way (at least for me).

Now in my head the nodes on the graph connect, although this may be non-obvious. Nodes could correlate with concepts and edges roughly with causality. How accurate that graph (map) to reality is, would always open to honest debate (if the goal is towards improving accuracy versus trying to score points).

It's difficult perhaps, because in some ways probably different to how you usually operate. There is also the very real possibility, that many simply find metacognition, largely uninteresting (which is fine too).

Continuing this theme, there are some are highly visual thinkers (such as Temple Grandin [1]), while for myself, for the most part am most comfortably naturally operating abstractly, conceptually, strategically and focusing on outcomes. In theory I tend towards impartiality, but in practice I'm biased towards a utilitarian framework.

Many highly intelligent people here operate highly tuned abstract pattern matching. I simply don't work like that, and yet I can appreciate its general effectiveness. I do feel genuinely happy, if on occasion, the courtesy is reciprocated. Ideally this would be irrespective of whether at that point in time, there happened to be agreement or not.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temple_Grandin

wamatt··on Why the Fuck?
Interesting that you should pick up on that. It usually depends on the audience.

In general if one has a slightly more divergent worldview than that of the company in which he/she finds themselves, it's historically been useful (albeit frustrating at times), to be more considered and precise.

Between my best friend, a fellow coder/entrepreneur of ten years, (who has a very different personality), we can communicate in shorthand as he understands what I mean, irrespective of the natural imprecision, that creeps in by wanting to be "good enough" to get the message across. Although the early days of our friendship was somewhat.. challenging.

Some of the usernames on HN that I've noticed that have insightful content, do not appear to reward sloppy rhetoric, and even, I suspect, use it as a filtering signal.

Hence, it would seem rational to at least demonstrate one is willing to embrace the norms of that group, but more importantly to avoid genuine misunderstanding, which has plagued me since childhood.

(I know what a cliche, what a special snowflake etc etc ;) Yes I dislike how it sounds too.

Lastly my own values dictate a personal preference for dialectic over sophistication. But perhaps that's a debate for another time.

wamatt··on Why the Fuck?
Thanks. In general I find articulating the conceptual stream to be a challenge, especially since it jumps around disjointedly.

Usually it takes a few iterations of a post, to improve the quality or tone, even though from my perspective, the core spirit of message remains unchanged between drafts.

The trick in communication is to be understood on multiple levels, not to simply output claims, irrespective of how accurate they are. Took me two decades to realize that, and still trying to improve. :)

Hence, the feedback is appreciated.

wamatt··on Why the Fuck?
Meta: OP is looking past the author's sentiment, generalizations and inaccuracies to respond thoughtfully to the central point of the message.

Someone is following their own advice:

http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html

So regarding hypocrisy, while it's true in certain contexts and under certain conditions, calling out hypocrisy, could constitute a logical fallacy, simply stating that possibility, says very little about how to value it.

Is hypocrisy good or bad? Perhaps the question is ill-framed. Avoiding hypocrisy, can create a powerful resonance between the speaker's aligned actions and words. It may be worth nothing this not a moral value judgement, but speaks to leadership. People on average, appear more willing to follow those with strong and bold congruency, and yet abandon them, when that illusion shatters (aka Lance Armstrong).

That said, my own view is that hypocrisy is generally inefficient, as it appears to increase the noise in the system.* As the proverb goes "talk is cheap" and hence it costs little to put an opinion out there, which is not bad in and of itself, merely that it requires little effort.

Thus with a sea of opinions floating out there, and limited time to process (if your cognition doesn't naturally operate in a frequentist manner), who can you trust?

There does not appear to be a definitive set of answers, however the heuristic of matching words to actions, while not perfect, combined with a test for integrity, has personally proven useful over the years.

*cf bounded rationality, opportunity cost, SnR etc.

wamatt··on O'Reilly donating ebook "Open Government" as a tribute to Aaron Swartz
Kudos for a thoughtful gesture from O'Reilly.

It does make one wonder, has openness in Government increased under the current administration or not?

While the reality might remain elusive, my sense is, at a minimum, the perception of openness, has strengthened with the public.

wamatt··on Website Sells Fake Facebook Girlfriends
>If people are so retarded to appreciate you more when they see you with a beautiful woman (instead of I don't know, judge you by your character perhaps?)

The irony of that statement just kills me.

As for CV's, happily I've never needed one, and am certainly not an HR manager, but I'd be most surprised to find "90% of people" merrily go around inventing full-on fictitious companies they've worked for.

For example:

While I accept your point that some may color their CV's... falling short, by embellishing one's previous role at a prior company, is simply not in the same ballpark as inventing a completely fake person that you're dating.

And for the record, the existence of gray in the world, does not give one a free pass, to simply proceed straight to black.

← PreviousPage 7 of 16Next →