HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wamatt

2,899 karma · joined February 21, 2012

username at Buchheit’s beta bunker
submissionscomments
wamatt··on Website Sells Fake Facebook Girlfriends
>Besides, social interactions need some amount of deception; makeup is deception (and fake breasts, and hair dye, etc.)

Sure, I can empathize with that, no-one is perfect, not our heroes and certainly not myself.

Ashamedly at one point, I seriously contemplated buying Twitter followers, as a quick boost to perceived social status. I was already rationalizing 'Oh it's just marketing' before deciding against it.

It appears to be a slippery slope though, from which making up major parts of our life story, does seems rather far removed, from a flashy tie, or a dash of makeup.

Could we not turn our gaze from heroes, instead towards ideals, knowing full well that we will never fully be able live up to them, but with the daily challenge to see how far we get?

wamatt··on Website Sells Fake Facebook Girlfriends
It's kind of depressing, that promoting phoniness and deception, is elevated to the top of HN as a cool 'hack'.

Seriously? What ever happened to.. I don't know.. honor and integrity?

While not all are guilty, it does appear somewhat hypocritical that a presumably similar group, would grumble about the ills of Wall St. execs, and yet simultaneously employ analogous reasoning, just splashed with a little erudite cologne.

"Be creative, think outside the box", chanted COO Jeff Skilling whilst driving Enron to bold new heights. Results are all that matter right? 'Fuck the environment, or society or those pesky things of the past. What did you call them again? Morals? Oh how adorably cute and quaint.'

What's it called when the effects of your actions are not easily measurable and are lost in a web of causality? Who cares... it's not like we're hurting anyone elses feelings directly.

But I digress, and ranting somewhat, but please go ahead and rationalize it away (you'll feel better):

(a) 'What nonsense, you're just over-extrapolating, those things are in no way connected.'

(b) 'Ooh tell us how you really feel'

(c) 'meh'

(d) ...?

wamatt··on Calling bullshit on 'mobile strategy'
The OP has a point, however I'll add Supercell doesn't appear to be doing too terribly with their mobile only strategy.

http://pandodaily.com/2012/11/16/supercell-the-cash-rich-lit...

wamatt··on The Atlantic posts sponsored Scientology story, moderates comments
This does appear to be a disturbing trend.

I recall reading articles in the NYT derived from Quora answers.

While it may in the short-term produce increased traffic, it may become harder to maintain quality, as minimally vetted 3rd party contributions grow in number. It makes one wonder, what that effect that will have longterm?

It's also interesting that users on syndicated sites containing user generated content, will now be able to claim they have "written for the New York Times".

wamatt··on Results of Bruce Schneier's experiment in trust
You raise a really interesting point here, and it seems there may be an opportunism vs principles dynamic at play.

Without debating the orthogonality of that assumption, (because it really won't change the overall point), let me begin by saying, most if not all humans I've encountered, have varying levels of principles and opportunism, but we are not made equal (CF fallacy of gray).

>I won't answer yes or no to a commitment but instead say "I'll do my best."

I am one of those, that have traditionally found that statement slightly annoying, especially in a business context. It just seems slippery. What does "doing your 'best' mean? Are you truly going to do your very best and drop everything to fulfill the request? I think not. Hence the precision one is aiming for, does not seem like an improvement on the original brevity of the yes/no.

Furthermore it could give one an opportunity to flake and blame the environment, versus sticking to one's word.

wamatt··on VCs Think My Boobs Need An Algorithm
"Boobs" + "Algorithm" = HN frontpage. Savvy marketing there.
wamatt··on Ask HN: What are your big plans for 2013?
To think small
wamatt··on Making Facebook's native mobile app faster using HTML5
Many seem to be missing the point here. While native in the mobile context, has the potential to be faster, it's a necessary, but not sufficient condition for superior responsiveness and usability.

Even with the native app, the same poor design decisions are being repeated once again. For example, not caching data locally between screens - an especially egregious oversight in the context of mobile networking.

I think the broader issue however, is just how out of touch Mark Zuckerberg was with regards to mobile and perhaps even emerging web technology in general.

He eventually admitted to screwing up (great!), but then got it so wrong again, by declaring HTML5 as the culprit. The problem was almost certainly more attributable to people and management issues, rather than a technological misstep, irrespective of whether that resulted in a more palatable conclusion for Mr Zuckerberg's ego.

As for the Sencha demo, after installing it on my iPhone 4s it works really well, and installing it as app on the home screen makes it virtually indistinguishable from native. I think it's fair to say this is a rather significant achievement by Sencha, indeed considering it's a part time effort.

Which makes one wonder what a full time team, with the right leadership and resources, could have achieved at Facebook.

wamatt··on Myers-Briggs: Does it pay to know your type?
tl;dr - The issue of the MBTI and psychometrics in general is nuanced, and strongly held opinions of either pseudoscience, or devoted metaphysical truthiness, are equally problematic.

The MBTI test as it currently stands, deserves the reputation as flawed empirical instrument, yet at the same time it's utility is undeniable. Unlike horoscopes, individual descriptions do differ rather significantly. The biggest issue in my view is not a fundamental one, but rather a flawed set of assumptions. The principle being that the test taker, possesses intimate self knowledge and presents an accurate and unchanging self portrait. In addition to the wonderful qualities humans have, there remains a number possible impairments with regards to self assessment: bias, delusion, deceitfulness, fancifulness, ignorance or simply an innocent unrefined skill in introspective ability. Thus the issue appears to largely be with the test itself, and not so much any solid refutation of the Jungian theory on which it rests.

While Jung certainly had some strange and mystical ideas, which would be difficult to support in today's scientific environment, his theory of cognitive functions is uncannily prescient IMHO, and believe is most deserving of further scrutiny. He is also largely responsible for the introducing the concepts of extraversion/introversion in the early part of the last century which have remained a mainstay on both public and academic discourse. [5]

Thus upon reflection, the observation of Jung as a mystic, is not necessarily an indication of a weak mind. One should not overlook the fact Sir Isaac Newton, perhaps one of the greatest scientists of all time, had strong mystical[1] and occultist[2] leanings too.

One might argue "well, the 1600's are quite different to the 1900's and Jung ought to have known better". Yet if the whole idea of a personal God seems rather delusional in the 21st century, the fact that credible scientists continue to partake in it today, does not simply invalidate their scientific discoveries. For example, James Smalley's [3] won the Nobel prize for the discovery of Buckyballs while simultaneously being an ardent supporter of old earth Creationism. Another example would be notable Christian apologist and Human Genome Project pioneer, Francis Collins [4]).

Returning to the issue of the test itself, the primary concern is that it it relies on self-report and is not a direct measure of the physical cognitive diversity existing between brains.

On the topic of Jung and neuroscience there is some preliminary proto-research by done by UCLA researcher Dario Nardi investigating the possible evidence for Jung's cognitive functions within the brain. He gave a talk at Google in 2011 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MGfhQTbcqmA explaining his results.

Of course this is by no means an empirical vindication of Jung, but it does open up a potentially interesting line of exploration. As with any non-peer reviewed work, it should be treated with due skepticism.

Lastly, for those interested in further reading, I have digitized a copy of Jung's seminal work, 'Psychological Types (1921)' [5] am sharing it for anyone wishing to study the source material.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isaac_Newtons_religious_views

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isaac_Newtons_occult_studies

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Smalley

[4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Collins#Christianity

[5] http://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=extraversion%2C...

[6] https://www.dropbox.com/s/hrf6whb66fbmaux/Psychological%20Ty...

wamatt··on The Rise of the Secret Supper Club
FTA: “He is obsessed with obscurity, which is why I love him,” James Skotchdopole, one of Quentin Tarantino’s producers and a frequent guest,says.

Many of those that entertain being "cool", cultivate an 'underground exclusivity and avoiding the mainstream' image. Of course this helps to create the mystique. I would argue that a genuine desire to be obscure, is perhaps not the main emotional driver, but rather being seen as cool is.

If that were not the case, participating in a New Yorker feature would be an epic obscurity fail.

wamatt··on "Office Space" creator Mike Judge shooting new HBO parody of Silicon Valley
For sure, their Radimparency spoof is pure comedy gold, and rather scarily close to portraying a large portion of the startup scene here.

http://watch.vooza.com/post/27284828649/radimparency

wamatt··on The Case for Drinking as Much Coffee as You Like
>I still haven't identified how all this works, but it's an interesting anecdote

Coffee acts as a laxative. Interestingly, this effect is observed in decaf as well.

Source: Boekema PJ, Samsom M, et al. Coffee and gastrointestinal function: facts and fiction. A review. Scand J Gastroenterol Suppl. 1999;230:35-9. PMID 10499460

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10499460

wamatt··on 16 bits per second - the bandwidth of consciousness (2007)
The field may or may not have progressed dramatically. However, ironically your claim of a lack of evidence, is not evidential itself, and I suspect the dismissal is unwarranted. Tor Nørretranders[0] was expanding on the work of German engineer Karl Küpfmüller[1].

Furthermore Kupfmuller,Nørretranders are not alone in this regard:

"We can therefore conclude that the maximal information flow of the process of conscious sensory perception is about 40 bits/second -- many orders of magnitude below that taken in by receptors [nerve endings]."

-- Manfred Zimmermann. "Neurophysiology of Sensory Systems" in Robert F. Schmidt ed., Fundamentals of Sensory Physiology (1986) p.116

"... If we do not act in the way we think we do, the reason is partly to do with the bandwidth of consciousness - its ability to transmit information measured in terms of bits per second. [...] The bandwidth of consciousness is around eighteen bits."

--John N Gray (2002) [3][4]

First prize would be evidence for a refutation of the 'consciousness operates at a low information rate' hypothesis, as opposed to conjecture or speculation.

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tor_N%C3%B8rretranders

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_K%C3%BCpfm%C3%BCller

[2] http://www.amazon.com/Fundamentals-Sensory-Physiology-Spring...

[3] http://www.amazon.com/Straw-Dogs-Thoughts-Humans-Animals/dp/...

[4] http://books.google.com/books?id=k5PkZXJEQqoC&lpg=PA45&#...

wamatt··on 16 bits per second - the bandwidth of consciousness (2007)
>By that measure, a two-hour movie can be compressed down to 22.5 kilobytes... :-)

I can't speak for other's but for myself that sort of compression ratio seems at least possible.

Most of the conscious mind is dealing with a highly compressed stream of symbols (compressed abstracted versions of the actual audio-visual stream), and how they relate to one another in time and space.

More concretely, imagine yourself watching a movie in the theatre:

"That actor's accent is a bit off" "Why do her teeth look so bright?" "I forgot who directed this, hmm was it that Swedish guy.. the guy who directed 'Heaven', wait... was he Swedish? Aargh I wish I could go on IMDB now and check" ".. ugh that kid in the front row's phone is distracting" "The visual style reminds me of this other movie". "The music is getting ominous, something bad is about to happen." "Oh crap the main character is screwed, how he is going to escape this trap?" "I wonder if my gf is enjoying the movie?" etc

wamatt··on The last day
> it is the right perspective.

Interesting that you offer a subjective moral value judgement, in the language of a universal truth.

wamatt··on Warning Signs in Experimental Design and Interpretation
Yeah, can't remember but I might have browsed from one of your comments earlier. (lost in a sea of open browser tabs now) :)

Useful info (assuming one's utility function relates to acquiring more accurate beliefs), I had hoped other hackers might enjoy. Pity, as it seems to have missed the main page.

Many of us have probably made one or two similar arguments against "new paper proves xyz" overstated claims. But a large collection of these red flags, with historical examples to boot, in one document, is simply fantastic.

Thanks for sharing

wamatt··on Mark Cuban: Facebook Is Driving Away Brands - Starting With Mine
On the surface it may seem similar, but are actually quite different:

LinkedIn is mostly about connecting professionals to each other and companies

Facebook (in a business context), is mostly about connecting brands with consumers.

Consumers are not professionals, although the underlying people that participate in those roles may largely overlap (if you think about it as a Venn diagram)

wamatt··on Talk About Your Startup Idea with Paul Graham
While I cannot hazard a guess to intention, a lowish estimated price is beneficial in at least two ways:

1) Put's more heads through the auction house door. One group could be searching for a bargain while another group benefits from increased perceived affordability (even if it ultimately ends up being illusionary). More bidders on the floor drive competition and maximize the closing price.

2) Allows others to feel the item is undervalued, and hence provides an opportunity for positive comment. If most said it was overvalued, that would create negative commentary and hence an undesirable perception of the brand (PG is this instance). If priced according to what the market roughly perceives as accurate, it generates less discussion, or action.

wamatt··on The Best
The GP's post doesn't feel mean to me personally, it just seems overly subjective and I struggle to find any new conceptual information. However, what is interesting (not a value judgement), is that a visceral and emotional laden post, is voted to the top of HN. I think that says something about the collective emotional state of the current readership.

My interest however, is in concepts. One of the most fundamental ones, when providing social commentary, is that people are different, but usually not unique, along a preference axis. The data therefore is clumpy. People fall into clusters of preference, driven by genetic and environmental predispositions.

So what is the point of arguing about which clump is better than another? I will keep beating this drum until, people realize the significance, to the point at which it becomes standard in social science studies and general discourse about society.

To some, (eg the GP), Dustin's level of optimization meaningless. That's perfectly fine. Furthermore for the GP (and many others), their ultimate meaning is derived from their relationships with other people. That's also ok. Mine doesn't, and there are many others in my cluster too. (albeit smaller numbers). Neither is better.

I started a path of minimalist and aesthetic obsessiveness as Dustin describes, since my earliest childhood memories. I was way more extreme in this regard than anyone I knew. I was a very weird kid, and my friends ridiculed my need for the best and my ridiculous research binges (weeks or even months at a time), to satisfy these goals. Even so, I still believe it played a part in making me successful.

While those traits still lurk within, I've come to realize over the years through self analysis and introspection, that trying to maximize all things, (especially physical objects), at some point is irrational. Why? Because it becomes more about the pleasure of maximization, than about seeking a bigger goal, if one looks deeply and honestly within. Maximizing for the sake of maximizing. It's very easy to post-rationalize and fall into that trap, if you are type of person with a natural predisposition.

So it doesn't matter which way you are approaching the subjective truth about a cluster of preference that works for you. Dustin is growing to appreciate it more, I'm growing to appreciate it less. Others will never appreciate it at all, since they don't find it useful or it's not matched to the way they operate. Others might have different cognitive skills altogether. For example, my best friend can multitask and add large numbers, I can't do either but am good at reading body language and my own internal states. We are both of similar IQ, but have very different intelligences.

In case you suspect I'm advocating anyone position is more enlightened, I'm not. I think that's a magic word, and don't want any part of it.

For a being that is capable of decision making, there are strategies and outcomes.

The most rational goal of any sentience (biological or not), is maximizing the utility function defined by self preservation.

Fortunately, it gives me pleasure to think about existence in these terms, and to act in accordance to this self-derived framework for about most of my day (about 2/3's by estimation). I don't advocate it for anyone else, or actually believe I could possibly know what anyone else should do.

I suspect this will not resonate with many, simply because my own cluster of preferences, and the combination presented here, may not be representative. That's fine too, I'm like the GP, just being myself.

wamatt··on The Best
>I think that's the point, since he's the author

Well I could be wrong, but I assume he was trying to make a broader point than "Hey everybody, these Yanagi forks are best for me".

I'd also imagine discussing any individuals particular preference for some random product, is of little concern to HN.

Without getting into the materialism debate or Curtis's obvious aestheticism bias, I thought some might be interesting in a discussion about

"What does 'the best' actually mean?"

My bias, would that I'm thinking about the question mostly from the perspective of businesses wishing to supply products or services to consumers.

wamatt··on The Best
Haha now that you mention it, that does sound a bit odd! :)

While it was just an example.. perhaps though, it's possible for there to be morphological oral differences.

Similar to that which exists in other parts of the body, such as facial structure, eyes, noses etc

wamatt··on The Best
Mr Curtis could do worse than watching Gladwell's Ted Talk from a few years back:

http://www.ted.com/talks/malcolm_gladwell_on_spaghetti_sauce...

tl;dr when one asks a question involving people, and you want the most fitted data, then you need to consider grouping/segmentation of the population into clusters of preference.

What is the best spaghetti sauce?

It's a flawed question, as it contains an invalid assumption.

Thus what Curtis seems to be describing is a (great/awesome/very good) etc set of knives, but not 'the best'.

Very good = a maximization of universal requirements

Best = maximization of universal && local requirements (population segmentation preferences, spacial and temporal context etc)

Example: Those forks may be best for Curtis at his dinner. They are certainly not best for me, on my camping trip. Or best for a tribe in Africa with different shaped mouths and habits etc. Or best for someone eating Chinese takeout. etc

wamatt··on Zapier (YC S12) Raises $1.2M Seed Round
To be honest this comes across a little defensive and a bit elitist.

It is irrelevant if someone is paying customer or not, as you have no idea how much future business they will do with your company, or what blogger or friend of the press she or he talks to at social gathering etc etc.

A simple "Yup you're right privacy is important. Thanks for the headsup, we are gonna work on it!" would be a more effective response (assuming it's true).

Or if that's not true then:

"Well, we not sure if it's important but lets see if more users request it and if they pay us, then will probably look into it! :)"

wamatt··on Zapier (YC S12) Raises $1.2M Seed Round
Good stuff :)

Actually wasn't concerned with timelines, but rather a principle statement of agreement or disagreement. Of course there are pragmatic issues, but also its very easy for startups in public diplomatic relations to say "yup sure" and have little interest in following through. (not saying that is necessarily the case here of course)

Hence why I was raising the question at the principle level, rather than a specific feature level to be slotted in with all the other todo's.

Like I said before.. I have personally nothing to gain from this implementation. But if it takes more users to request it then so be it for you to notice then so be it. I will continue to raise awareness of the greater issue here. (Beyond Zapier as well)

wamatt··on Show HN: Circular, an open source clone of Buffer
Pure awesomesauce! :) Congrats on name pivot, Circular is a great choice.

With regards to Buffer, a potential friction point I pointed out to the team earlier this year, was the inability to select:

Who? (Friends, Public, <custom list>) and

Where? (private message, private group, wall post) a message should go to.

This is standard functionality in the Facebook sharer app, for example. (http://imgur.com/HPsXU)

Of course, Buffer and Circular adds When? (eg temporal dimension) to the mix, but no app I know of, has implemented all three, leaving you with a tradeoff, if all of those are important to your social workflow.

wamatt··on Scientists build the first all-carbon solar cell
It's significant from the perspective that it represents a new baseline.

This graph helps place, what you're talking about, in perspective.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:PVeff(rev110408U).jpg

wamatt··on Zapier (YC S12) Raises $1.2M Seed Round
Fantastic story, and I was initially excited for, and promoting Zapier. But then a simple request for single folder Dropbox access, seemed to fall on deaf ears.

I don't have a personal agenda other than good citizenship and concern for best practices that affect the community.

If you're dumping a file to my Dropbox, why do you need full read access to all folders?

If you adding a note to Evernote, why do you need full r/w access to my entire note store?

etc etc

The simple answer is often it's not needed. For example, Wappwolf gets it right in this case (http://i.imgur.com/Ug5Fi.png), by allowing the freedom to choose.

Sure it's simply easier and less hassle for a startup to deal with things like users privacy concerns.

However, if anything, it's an opportunity for you guys to be leading and setting the example in restricted, 'only what you require', SaaS security model.

This idea of giving exponentially more startups, complete access to your increasingly critical online services, does not seem wise at all.

Apologies for a bit of a rant, just rather passionate about this issue, and hope you guys will take it seriously :)

wamatt··on Google’s most advanced voice search has arrived on iOS
Woah.. this may be one of the few times so many hyperbolic adjectives in a HN post seemed justified ;)

Just fired it up now, and can attest it simply blows Siri's UX right out of the water.

Kudo's to the Google team!

wamatt··on Quantum entanglement shows that reality can't be local
Looks like you're a firm believer, so I ask, is MWI by your definition falsifiable?

Do any experiments past, current or future purport to test predictions made from MWI?

While MWI may make sense in a universal reading of QM, I'm not sure we can simply extrapolate this onto the macro level, despite it's pragmatic successes over the last century. IMHO QM itself, still feels like a temporary hack (shim), when compared alongside ER.

Until we have a TOE, it may be too presumptuous to be making positive assertive claims on the correlation between the MWI model and reality.

wamatt··on Markdown: The Spec - it's coming and it's full of personalities
An ideological debate between collaborative vs dictatorial approaches, misses the point entirely.

Markdown was a good effort, but I've been feeling for a while now can do better. It's rather encouraging, that there are others attempting to design a new standard. Ideally it would be one that's easier to work with, and less idiosyncratic. ('new' of course, does not automatically equate to 'better' in this instance).

Furthermore, developing this should not require anyone to 'be someone'. While it may help adoption, if it's great, then by it's own merits, it could have a decent chance of succeeding.

← PreviousPage 8 of 16Next →