HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

waterhouse

4,371 karma · joined October 7, 2009

submissionscomments
waterhouse··on Researchers find Alzheimer's-like brain changes in long Covid patients
Correct. The study in question: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10246135/
waterhouse··on A road safety plan that will lead to cars communicating with each other
Some googling yielded: https://www.bikeattorney.com/bike-accident-common-causes.htm...

  18 percent – driver failed to see cyclist
  24 percent – cyclist ran a red light or failed to stop for a stop sign
  22 percent – driver or passenger opened a car door into an oncoming cyclist
waterhouse··on Ask HN: Determine sound quality of a file, objectively?
If you check the usernames, the one who suggested and the one who followed up are the same person. :-)
waterhouse··on In ‘The Book Against Death,’ Elias Canetti rants against mortality
If you're going to retire in N years, then that gives you an upper limit to how much you can benefit from learning (or even experimenting with) a new and potentially better approach, versus sticking with what currently works for you. As N gets smaller, the cost-benefit analysis increasingly favors the latter.
waterhouse··on X redesigns water pistol emoji back to a firearm
Sure, glad to help. I can give more detail including etymology.

"Woke" originally meant that a person has "awoken" to the true nature of society. They see the thing that others do not see! Unfortunately, it seems that that's also the only thing they see, or the only thing they care about. And that thing is racial / identity-group conflict. As I say, they cheerfully sacrifice principles like freedom of speech, meritocracy, proportionality, hard-fought civil rights ideals, etc., when it's inconvenient for the fight they want to pick in the moment. I think that, to a first approximation, when anyone says "Is this going too far?", they get accused of sympathizing with the oppressors and shamed or cast out, so the group goes farther, and we are seeing the results of iterating this process for decades. A peak moment was tearing down a statue of Abraham Lincoln, apparently in the name of anticolonialism.

That's the woke people themselves, a small, aggressive, highly vocal group with outsized influence. (There's also a larger group of relatively normal people with a surface-level understanding of it who go along with most of it; I think if they understood and believed all the details, most of them would recoil.) (Incidentally, most people instinctively understand that aggressively attacking others is bad, but via concepts like "microaggressions" and "privilege", the woke frequently find reasons to think that someone else attacked first.)

Then there's the legal and corporate environment. Civil rights legislation brought laws against discrimination and creating a hostile environment for identity groups in companies. In the absence of mind-reading, a claim of discrimination is difficult to prove or disprove, and a "hostile environment" could be interpreted in many ways. I think that the "game of telephone" chain from the text of the law, to the interpretation of the law (and evidentiary standards) in courts, to lawyers' understanding, to what company lawyers tell management, to what sticks in management's brain and gets implemented, has yielded essentially "If you offend the woke identity groups, then that puts you at significant legal risk, so best appease them. Also it's good to pay them lip service, host Pride events, etc., because that reduces legal risk." Additionally, some portion of management themselves are woke, and some additional portion earnestly believe in civil rights as a cause and tend to take the woke at their word when they claim their policies are the right and proper next steps. And finally, on a personal level, expressing dissent against a woke-aligned policy is, in many cases, perceived to put one's own career at risk (in some cases the lawyers may say it's a liability to keep a person like that; and, having seen cases of this, many people err on the side of caution, creating a "chilling effect").

So you get a lot of corporate policies meant to appease the woke. Some may be the exact policies the woke asked for. Others may be cynical appeasement, and by design they will be difficult to distinguish from the first type. Some policies are invented by well-intentioned people believing in civil rights principles. Some are the outcome of some kind of compromise.

It's not necessarily clear which of these should be called "woke policies", both in theory and in practice. It doesn't help that, whereas you could identify Democrat or Republican policies by looking at official websites, and probably get reasonable consensus on what are "conservative policies" or "progressive policies" based on prominent self-identified conservative figures and institutions, the woke do not call themselves "woke" (with occasional exceptions like "Woke Kindergarten") and object to anyone else calling them that; it's understood to be a pejorative. The woke will tend to call themselves advocates of civil rights or of specific groups' rights, and try to blur any distinctions between the classic civil rights movement which enjoys majority support (things like non-discrimination and gay marriage) and what they're trying to do (things like discriminating in favor of their identity groups and policing pronouns). This serves to make the case that anyone who disagrees with them is a 1950s Jim Crow racist, and anyone who isn't a 1950s Jim Crow racist must agree with them, which is useful for coercing acquiescence and support. It also makes it harder for the rest of us to notice the patterns and call out the damage that the woke have done and are likely to do. But I think we're getting there.

waterhouse··on X redesigns water pistol emoji back to a firearm
(Not the person you were asking, either)

In one sentence, wokeness is aggressively pursuing racial (and other identity-based) conflict above everything else, not caring what else you trample on (including even classic civil rights principles). "Microaggressions" is probably the most distinctively woke concept.

Censoring gun emojis is not woke in that respect, since it doesn't pursue any particular identity conflict (except, maybe, crusading on behalf of anyone with gun-related PTSD?). But the method (forcing people to sanitize their communication) and some aspects of the motivation (hand-wringing about some bits of language, acting like some people have extremely delicate sensibilities, using that to justify censorship) are similar to some prominent manifestations of wokeness and the corporate policies they push. So I can understand why the connection was drawn, though the term isn't quite appropriate.

waterhouse··on Jiff: Datetime library for Rust
Or 0.days(5).hours(8).minutes(1)?
waterhouse··on CrowdStrike Update: Windows Bluescreen and Boot Loops
Staggering is necessary in some cases. I've heard of scenarios where a company has lots of devices in the field which all simultaneously try to download a big update, and DDOS the servers hosting that update.
waterhouse··on The Delusion of the Polygraph
Scene from The Wire doing roughly this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bg13hyfm2Ik
waterhouse··on AT&T says criminals stole phone records of 'nearly all' customers in data breach
From a justice perspective, it should be scaled according to the number of customers impacted (and how bad the impact was). Which is likely to be about the same as scaling with revenue.
waterhouse··on Round Rects Are Everywhere
Related, fun post: https://ridiculousfish.com/blog/posts/roundy.html
waterhouse··on Microsoft Chose Profit over Security, Whistleblower Says
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lavabit famously shut down rather than compromise its security.
waterhouse··on Lynn Conway has died
If you were looking at the same revision I saw, the "citation needed" was on the word "was", and on mouseover said "Please add credible news of death".
waterhouse··on Hacking millions of modems and investigating who hacked my modem
I take the "professional value" to mean essentially putting it on your resume, gaining publicity by blogging about it, getting conference organizers to let you give a talk about it, etc., all of which may ultimately increase the money you can earn doing computer security.
waterhouse··on OpenAI partners with Vox Media, Anthropic brings ex-OpenAI safety lead
> OpenAI partners with Vox Media

This strikes me as very weird, coming after some highly critical reporting by Vox about OpenAI: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40447431

waterhouse··on Ask HN: Why don't VCs just "suck it up" and pay founders a competitive salary?
In theory, you could pay yourself 2x for 6 months, then 0x for 6 months if the startup lacks money but seems worth persisting at. I think it's not especially rare for founders to work for temporarily zero pay early on. Seems like the main difference between that and "1x for 12 months" is providing an incentive to yourself for the last 6 months, and signaling that to others.
waterhouse··on Autism makes travel a challenge. Here’s how I learned to cope
The best, most plausible-seeming description I've encountered is that autism is a collection of imperfectly correlated traits. One may be able to make "often" and "usually" and "sometimes" statements, but probably not "always"/"never" statements.

Is there a better description out there that manages to be true to reality?

waterhouse··on Harvard will require test scores for admission again
> pick the people that were going to succeed no matter what, and claim credit for preparing them.

I do think this is what lots of schools do. I mean, "the best people available" will be roughly identical with "the pool of people that contains the highest fraction of those who would succeed no matter what". And if your alumni are successful, then you claim credit. Why not? (I've occasionally seen people attempt to calculate "value added", but completely accounting for selection effects is difficult.)

And, by the way, just because someone would have succeeded no matter what doesn't mean you can't increase their success. It's plausible that some highly-driven highly-competent genius would have ended up becoming a top engineer going to school X, but would have co-founded a billion-dollar company going to school Y, due to some combination of getting a somewhat better education and meeting the right people. So the value proposition may be real.

waterhouse··on Cow Magnets
An implication is that, of the metallic debris a cow might ingest, a large fraction of it is magnetizable—otherwise there'd be little point. I wonder, does this feed back into the decisions that are made? Do people deliberately choose magnetizable metals for things that might get broken up in a cow's environment?
waterhouse··on Anger is eliminated with the disposal of a paper written because of provocation
The evolutionary use of anger is to disincentivize others from mistreating you.
waterhouse··on Google's Chrome antitrust paradox
> when competitors point out the superiority of their own product, are they also often correct?

I would say they are in fact usually correct about the specific point they're making. However, it's also common for them to be drawing attention to the dimensions on which their product is better, which may not be the same as the dimensions that matter most to customers. They may be reporting selective truths and making correct-but-mostly-irrelevant points. This also goes for criticizing competitors, of course.

waterhouse··on Randomization in such studies is arguably a negative in practice
I'll note that one could say the same about any specific feature that improves a study. There's a list of ways that a study could go wrong, and if nine aspects are good, that doesn't rule out the tenth being awful enough to torpedo the conclusion.
waterhouse··on Some colleges will soon charge $100k a year – how did this happen?
Presumably a reference to this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bretton_Woods_system

> On 15 August 1971, the United States "temporarily" suspended the convertibility of the US dollar to gold, effectively bringing the Bretton Woods system to an end and rendering the dollar a fiat currency.

waterhouse··on Discord to Start Showing Ads for Gamers to Boost Revenue
If you do, then that marks you as having cash to throw around, making you a more valuable ad target. So the advertisers raise their bid. It's part of the great cycle of digital content channels.
waterhouse··on OpenVoice: Versatile instant voice cloning
Suppose all existing voice actors, and, to be maximally generous, everyone who had spent >1 year training to be a voice actor, was given a pension for some years, paying them the greater of their current income or some average voice actor income. And then there would be no limits on using AI voices to substitute for voice actors.

Would you be happy with that outcome, or do you have another objection?

waterhouse··on Handwriting but not typewriting leads to widespread brain connectivity
Probably https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peripatetic_school is the one, certainly based on the name.
waterhouse··on The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be considered hazardous substances
How does that work? If it were simply "oil can be turned into fuel or turned into plastic", then lowered demand should lower the price. Is it that turning oil into fuel produces plastic (or plastic precursors) as a byproduct?
waterhouse··on Hearing aids slow cognitive decline in people at high risk
> RCTs are also observational

The key phrase is "purely observational". Now, occasionally you end up with a "natural experiment" in which some accident has effectively done the randomization for you—specifically, where the mechanism that puts people in the treatment group vs the control group is something you can be very confident has no other causal interactions. This was a good example: https://twitter.com/PGeldsetzer1/status/1661776663074738176

"Causal evidence that herpes zoster vaccination prevents a proportion of dementia cases [...] To provide causal as opposed to merely correlational evidence on this question, we take advantage of the fact that in Wales eligibility for the herpes zoster vaccine (Zostavax) for shingles prevention was determined based on an individual's exact date of birth. Those born before September 2 1933 were ineligible and remained ineligible for life, while those born on or after September 2 1933 were eligible to receive the vaccine."

But any time you're looking at a scenario where treatment vs non-treatment was the result of individual human choices, that opens up a potentially very wide range of ways for something you didn't know about (and potentially something difficult to accurately control for even if you do know about it) to cause treatment and cause the outcome, instead of the treatment causing the outcome.

> it suggests that we can't build confident causal inferences without a certain study

I do think there's an upper limit to the confidence you can justifiably hold, and that it's often not very high. Consider the studies that observe "A bit of alcohol correlates with better health than zero alcohol". You control for wealth, education, and maybe other things, and the apparent effect remains. How high confidence should you have in the result? Then someone realizes: Some fraction of people who consume zero alcohol do so under doctor's orders because they have health problems, and if you exclude those people then the effect disappears.

No matter how many causal pathways you think you've controlled for, how confident can you really be that there isn't a new one you haven't thought of? (And controlling has its own perils: if your measurements are noisy, or if you end up controlling for the outcome.)

> it's incorrect to say they can uniquely detect causation

Oh, correlational studies can "detect" causation, but the hard part is being certain that the thing detected isn't a false positive.

waterhouse··on Hearing aids slow cognitive decline in people at high risk
I'm advocating that people do studies with randomized interventions—an approach that is capable of proving causation—and not being satisfied with purely observational studies that look at correlations, which are often hopelessly confounded and can't distinguish between "X causes Y" and "Z causes both X and Y". I was pleasantly surprised to find that this study was of the first type rather than the second.
waterhouse··on Hearing aids slow cognitive decline in people at high risk
A randomized intervention! Huzzah!

> The researchers randomly assigned participants to one of two interventions. About half received hearing aids and instruction in how to use them. The other half were assigned to a health education program focused on promoting healthy aging.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →