HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wbeaty

112 karma · joined May 14, 2010

I run SCIENCE HOBBYIST, http://amasci.com/ , also http://trafficwaves.org/
submissionscomments
wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
Try the finished version! Those were just the unedited notes from 1988, and over later years I used them for a large number of articles and essays. http://amasci.com/miscon/elect.html is the big list of electricity misconceptions. The other articles are at http://amasci.com/ele-edu.html
wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
These aren't articles. READ THE FIRST LINE. They're random crude notes, scribbled down in 1988, and UNEDITED, so full of all sorts of horrible mistakes (that's what "unedited notes" means.)

The actual completed articles were written years later, many were even inspected/corrected by the phys-L group of college physics educators. http://amasci.com/ele-edu.html

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
Not articles, just crude notes FOR articles elsewhere on the site. I keep changing the name of this ancient 1980s txt file, but people keep re-posting it!

Try the finished versions instead:

List of electricity articles http://amasci.com/ele-edu.html

List of typical electricity misconceptions http://amasci.com/miscon/elect.html

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
THERE ARE NO ELECTRONS is incredibly excellent.

Another is Darren Ashby's "Electrical Engineering 101: Everything You Should Have Learned in School...but Probably Didn't"

ALSO SEE:

Are we teaching electricity the wrong way 'round? http://www.abc.net.au/science/articles/2014/02/05/3937083.ht...

Understanding electricity and circuits: what textbooks don't tell you http://web.archive.org/web/20080730063549/science.uniserve.e...

FIELDS OF ELECTRONICS: understanding circuits via physics https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/book/10.1002/0471433934

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
It's not an article. Read the first line.

The finished article(s) are listed at http://amasci.com/ele-edu.html

And heh, about maxwell, if someone claims to understand Maxwell's Equations, just sadly shake your head, then adopt an archly superior stance, and haughtily inform them that those four are HEAVISIDE'S equations, while Maxwell's were twenty equations based on the latest 1800s math-fad: Hamilton's "quaternions." If they don't understand THOSE, they don't understand Maxwell! (And now we've avoided having to admit we've never read any of them. Hee!)

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
It's not a collection of articles. Read the first line. It's raw notes, random musings, and uninspected WRONG CRAP scribbled out of order, on random bits of paper. In crayon.

> If you were not confused before reading any of it

If you watch discarded film-clips, all two seconds long and many of them backwards, expect to be confused.

The actual articles are at http://amasci.com/ele-edu.html

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
It's not an article. It's not supposed to explain anything. Read the first line. It's a wad of notes, a bunch of totally-unedited crap scribbled on napkins in 1988, while THINKING about writing a proper article.

For those who didn't read:

"BELOW are my original, very crude and totally unedited 1986-1989 notes and "raw data" for...

My actual completed Electricity articles are: http://amasci.com/ele-edu.html

wbeaty··on Richard Feynman’s Messenger Lecture Series on Video
The famous red books, paper copy Feynman Lectures, are free online: https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/

Also, there are LOTS more videos:

Robb Memorial Lectures http://www.vega.org.uk/video/subseries/8

Feynman full movie: 1996 "Infinity" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lcn4pfFslVE

The Pleasure of Finding Things Out https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLS8LbL7GIZiAHmR64oluO...

Take The World From Another Point of View https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL2DB73589969D47AB

---

And we can rent Feynman's beach house in Baja: http://casitabarranca.com/

Vid list: http://amasci.com/feynman.html

wbeaty··on What is Electricity? (1996)
Tesla is vindicated: it turns out that this whole article was debunked in 1936, but the debunking was based on an error. Single-wire transmissions are not against EM theory after all! Zenneck surface waves had long been disproved, but since 2005 the disproof is now debunked again. See:

http://web.archive.org/web/20161019214341/www.texzontechnolo...

As a result, Corum's company "Viziv Technologies" has built a thirty-story plastic Tesla-tower out in Texas wilderness, and is now performing Earth-resonance experiments down at 12KHz broadcast frequencies. See tower construction slideshow:

http://amasci.com/graphics/st/

wbeaty··on What is Electricity? (1996)
Also we don't really know what Optics is. Is it the lenses and prisms? Is it the light waves? Or is optics really the photons? Yet try as we might, we can only see the EFFECTS of optics, but we're not one step closer to understanding its true cause. If we just had a good enough microscope, we could examine those lenses and prisms and photons, and then truly discover the fundamental nature of Optics!!!!

Also, we don't really know what Biology is! We can only perceive the effects caused by Biology! But what is Biology, really?

Also, have you ever been zapped by electricity? That's nothing ...compared to getting ZAPPED BY BIOLOGY!!!!!

(Once I stepped in some biology, and then tracked it all over the rug. It still stinks a bit in there.)

wbeaty··on What is Electricity? (1996)
If "electricity" is really just a category ...then we've just added another definition to the list! That just makes things worse! (Well, unless you can somehow erase all the competing ones. Better choose one definition and then fight to the death with everyone who prefers another.)

So, which one is the One True Definition? Is Electricity the energy? Is it the charge-flow? Is it the electrons? Watts of electricity? Volts? Is Electricity really just a category (such as bioelectricity, piezoelectricity, etc.?)

Besides the strict narrow definition offered by Maxwell in his multi-volume EM treatise, I prefer the wise-ass definition crafted by Ambrose Bierce:

ELECTRICITY, n. The power that causes all natural phenomena not known to be caused by something else.

wbeaty··on What is Electricity? (1996)
Don't miss the YT videos: http://amasci.com/amateur/videos.html

Also on YT itself https://www.youtube.com/user/wbeaty/videos

wbeaty··on What is Electricity? (1996)
My parents were grade-school teachers, and my dad almost got fired for defending the idea that nickel metal is magnetic.

But it's right there in the grade school textbooks! The only magnetic materials are IRON AND STEEL! PERIOD! (Oh and also the blood in your veins is bright blue like paint. And gravity in space is zero.)

Back in the 1980s I decided to do something about this (via science museum exhibit designs.) Then I discovered the great power of "educational memes," like engineering your own Vaccina viruses which spread all through the textbooks, jumping from author to author and innoculating millions of little kids against the bad information.

But to do this successfully, I'd have to write website articles which 1) correct the misinformation in textbooks, 2) didn't draw attention from powerful critics who would put a stop to all that and, also 3) didn't create even worse mistakes!

My first one was this: http://amasci.com/wing/airfoil.html

This "lifting-force counter-meme" has now spread system-wide. Air doesn't split before the wing, then rejoins behind the wing. Instead the so-called"path-length" or "equal transit-time" explanation is wrong, and actually the air above the wing will greatly out-race the air traveling below. The parcels are split, but then they experience significant "phase shift," so they never re-join again (this as long as lift is being created.)

wbeaty··on What is Electricity? (1996)
> most people know they don't know transistors.

We don't know transistors because (guess!) WE WERE TAUGHT WRONG! http://amasci.com/amateur/transis.html

Latest news: apparently Shockley had to distort the explanation of the BJT transistor, saying that it was a "current amplifier," because the FET had been invented twenty years earlier, and FETs are obviously voltage-input devices. Since transistors already existed, the early Shockley transistor patents were being rejected by the patent office for "prior art." They thought the latest device was just another crystal triode invention like the FET invented by JE Lilienfeld around 1923.

wbeaty··on Teach Yourself to Echolocate: A beginner’s guide to navigating with sound
"the time for jacking around with Tesla coils and ball lightning in the garage is over." -Abe, PRIMER

Few additions http://amasci.com/news.html The Trafficwaves article made the WSJ, even with video. And Crown Flash (leaping sundogs) is now all over the place (see my upcoming bit on TV show Strange Evidence.) Magnetic analogy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tH-CAhtXBfQ

Fortunately (unfortunately?) I only posted examples of my somewhat-kid-friendly magic. Nobody died in microwave oven accidents. That plus a couple of minor inventions (made public as a test to see how fast the idea-thieves would pounce on them.) None of my frightening demos using vacuum pumps and Spellman supplies. Well, I guess I did write about our hypergun which fired a small plastic slug through a clay block twelve inches thick (a spinoff of the very first quarter-shrinker capacitor bank,) and no little kids yet tried building one: http://amasci.com/amateur/capexpt.html#shrink

An unexamined backwater is at http://amasci.com/weird/wtext.html

I still haven't tried out the giant version of Lord Armstrong's water-bridge, from an eyewitness report where a liquid "snake" several feet thick was extending itself thousands of feet across desert land during a thunderstorm. If such things are possible, then an HV supply of a few hundred watts and a couple hundred kilovolts should produce something similar (the recent water-bridge experiments use 10 to 20KV supplies at under ten watts, a 2cm bridge, a mm or two in diameter.) Rainwater or ddw on very clean sand? Needs a big Cockroft-Walton diode stack http://amasci.com/freenrg/wasser.html

And the infamous invisible wall at the 3M factory, recently someone claims to have seen an example caused by electrodes connected to a reversed pole-pig transformer, where coins would bounce off the empty space. This is silghtly conceivable: a corona in air may develop a stable annular double-layer with a significant space-charge and pressure-gradient of air. But would a metal object bounce off? Or just short it out? Plasmas do tend to avoid cold bulk metal surfaces (Tesla managed to make an opaque "neon sign" with a metal tube rather than glass, but skeptics refused to believe it was real. The plasma in near-vacuum can travel many inches through thin metal tubes without leaping to the metal! Try it, it's really weird: pipes full of glowing "electricity" rather than water.)

Speaking of PRIMER, did they actually base the plot on meissner maglev "null coils," placed in a circle rather than parallel rows? Then, put it all inside a "One Atmosphere Plasma Globe" full of argon? But then, where do platinum catalytic converters figure in that? Or maybe they were just huddling inside a styrofoam version of the USS Eldridge hull, covered with active magnetic shielding coils, but not turning invisible.

:)

wbeaty··on “Invisible Electrostatic Wall” at 3M adhesive tape plant (1996)
http://amasci.com/miscon/coherenc.html#pinhole
wbeaty··on “Invisible Electrostatic Wall” at 3M adhesive tape plant (1996)
It's still going! Latest:

- video of a tiny version https://youtu.be/vL3mnidBkeQ

- someone claims that objects do bounce off it https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/4jb24s/what_are_...

- someone claims that others made accidental forcefields https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/7kv54c/til_a...

After twenty years I finally tried a forcefield experiment: HVDC supply hooked to perfmetal electrodes as mentioned on Reddit. Nope, the high-field gap has no effect on intruding sticks, or even blocks nylon filaments. And reducing the gap just triggers big sparks. (But maybe it needs some 100Meg resistors, to stabilize it like an NE-2 neon bulb?)

wbeaty··on “Invisible Electrostatic Wall” at 3M adhesive tape plant (1996)
August 1980, they coulda used a Betamax camera! Of course megavolt-scale voltages would tend to fry any device not protected by a screen cage.

"Why didn't they take pictures" is a minor question, compared to "WHY DIDN'T THEY THROW STUFF AT IT?!!" Did the invisible wall block flying objects? Or was it really just caused by shocks, by tazed human muscles locking up?

wbeaty··on The rise of MEMS microphone arrays
Iwanna hacked version: phase-array real time acoustic camera, with audio Hz displayed as colors. Also perhaps tweet the azimuths of all distant gunshots.
wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
I suspect that it corresponds to Newtonian Statics, the study of mass and forces. It's a subject area; an ignoring of changes. Not a state of nonmoving. The Newtonian Statics viewpoint involves summation of forces. It may also involve taking a snapshot at one point in time.

E.g., when a mass above Earth is in free fall, it still obeys Newtonian Statics: the weight/attraction force, easily analyzed from moment to moment. The resulting acceleration and trajectory then falls under "Dynamics."

In other words, electrostatics applies to capacitors and to the mechanical forces produced by electric fields. Even if currents are also present, and even if the e-fields are changing with time, electroSTATICS still applies. (A high voltage, high-amperes power line is very "electrostatic," because of the significant e-fields and resulting phenomena.)

Static Electricity then is a chapter title, with no existence in the real world. Neither can we fill a box with Newtonian Statics. To be consistent, we wouldn't say "electrostatic motor," instead call it a capacitor-motor, or an e-field motor. (Heh, a stretched spring is statically charged! Full of Newtonian-static energy!)

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
Carver Mead! He's one of us, ONE OF US (physics crackpots, like JG Cramer here at UW.)
wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
Cool!

They can then check the possibility that, once formed, it remains stable at low pressure.

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
In 1975, our physics teacher said he'd been a consultant to the international group who was working on electric utilities and import/export of energy across the US/CA border. Trying to define what "electricity" actually was!

:)

Electric circuits are much like drive-belts, but using charged particles rather than rubber or leather. If a drive-belt extends across the border between two countries, what is being transported? It's not mass, since for every KG of rubber belt going out, an exactly equal amount is coming back. (Go further and use rotating shafts. Then the mass just spins in place, and doesn't actually cross the border at all.)

With circuits, with AC, the charges are just wiggling back and forth, and not proceeding forward. But with DC the charges are taking a closed circular path, so still are not proceeding forward. The thing which proceeds forward is radio waves. Sixty-cycle radio waves, forced to follow a waveguide composed of two or three conductors. EM waves are being sold to us by the utility companies. We live in a "radio-powered" civilization, but where the 60Hz EM waves are forced to follow waveguides, rather than leaping across empty gaps.

Humorous "legal" chapter in Feynman: IS ELECTRICITY FIRE?

https://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/ev3gy/excerpt_from...

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
DOH!

Fixed now.

I messed it up last time I was getting slashdotted by reddit and ycombinator, and everyone was complaining that the raw unedited notes were just a bunch of raw unedited notes.

Heh, it's still a 1995 gopher-era design, back when we put all our chapters on a single long page, to compensate for 300/2400b modem speeds. If it was broken up into many separate pages, you'd be waaaaaaiting for the text to finally appear.

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
Yep, a VDG machine is not a single-ended device. I tell people that there are always two spheres involved, although usually the second sphere is below our feet: planet Earth. Charge conservation says that, with a VDG, the e-field flux extends between the upper metal sphere and the ground below it. So, to concentrate attention on just the charged sphere, while ignoring the oppositely-charged ground surface, is much like concentrating on just one plate of any capacitor.

Better: hang many different metal spheres from insulating threads, then use a HV supply to deposit various charges upon them. "Capacitor" is always taken to mean a pair of opposite-charged objects. But miscellaneous "charged objects" aren't necessarily capacitors.

Also, this:

ENGINEER'S CAPACITOR, not physicists'

http://amasci.com/emotor/enCap.html

While employed at MOS in Boston I temporarily threw together a floating, double-ended VDG with a battery/motor inside one sphere. Like this: http://amasci.com/emotor/vdgdesc.html#diff

I thought it would much better communicate the true nature of electrostatic generators, but it never ended up in our exhibit. VDGs are just constant-current high-voltage power supplies. A long enough chain of 9V batteries would produce all the same phenomena ...aside from the 10amp short circuit current, and the megawatt arcing!

PS, weirdness

With VDGs I was triggering three separate kinds of spark. I've not seen this discussed anywhere. We have the usual kind, the thin straight "needle" that jumps between smooth spheres. Then we have the violet fractal tree. Attach a 1cm ball to a VDG sphere and watch in a darkened room. It periodically spits foot-wide lightning networks, just like the miles-wide kind. And third: occasionally I was getting "silent purple sausage" discharge about an inch thick and a couple feet long. In a lighted room they make a slight "thump" sound, so if you hear that noise from a VDG, try observing in total darkness. Sometimes the "sausage" would even produce branching (possibly nanosecond wave effects,) when it would leap out 1ft, then split into five branches from the tip, then proceed to the adjacent metal wall as five fuzzy pathways. Perhaps the particular "seed" at the micro-scale will determine the type of spark which propagates? Or maybe the "sausage" discharge was actually a relativistic effect seeded by MeV cosmic rays.

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
Note that photons only travel along FO cable because of the charge polarization of the silica. This is a direct analog to 60Hz "electric power" traveling along a column of mobile charges in a long conductor. In both cases, the electrons wiggle back and forth, while the photons couple to them, and are guided along. But charge is not energy, in exactly the same way that amperes are not watts, and current is not EM energy-flow. Coulombs wiggle within the waveguide, while the Joules proceed continuously forward as propagating waves.

The EM energy is in the form of propagating waves, while electric charge provides the medium: the waveguide.

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
The entire essay-collection is a critique of grade-school electricity textbook chapters, in the USA. (I don't know if the texts in other countries are promoting the same misconceptions.) To avoid reading critiques/corrections, go to any other site except mine. Also see:

Am I just a pedantic nitpicker?

http://amasci.com/miscon/nitpik.html

To deeply grasp physics, often one must UN-learn the common misconceptions which were acquired in our early school careers. The misconceptions in this list are the ones believed by educators, and taught to students.

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
Actually, it's electric wattage which is the moving photons, not electric current. Energy flow. Joules per second, same as with laser outputs.

So, the electric companies are selling us 60Hz photons.

But at the same time, the AC electricity just vibrates back and forth inside the wires, without any net forward motion.

About the only accurate diagram of EM spectrum I've ever encountered was the one made by R. Oppenheimer and sold as a classroom poster by The Exploratorium in SF. At the bottom, below VLF radio, we find audio-freq phone lines, and below that, 60Hz power lines. "Electric power" is on the EM spectrum, down below radio waves.

And yes, if we have a big enough antenna tower, then we can hook it up to a 60Hz dynamo, and spew 60Hz EM radiation out into space. Actually that concept was one of N. Tesla's great breakthroughs: hooking a steam-powered 50KHz alternator directly to an antenna, and broadcasting a silent carrier: CW. A couple years after his patents on this ran out, GE suddenly announced the "Alexanderson Alternator!" Finally making music/voice broadcasting possible! The public wondered how Alexanderson managed to come up with such an amazing idea. (If investors had bought Tesla stock, we'd have had AM radio ~20 years earlier. Tesla clearly grasped the concept that "radio" was the same thing as "electric power," just higher in frequency.)

https://www.datavisualization.ch/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/...

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
It actually is the electrons. But they never touch each other. Instead they push upon each other across empty space, by using e-fields and b-fields.

If there wasn't any chain of electrons inside the conductor, then the EM fields would just fly off into space, like with a transmitting antenna.

Wires can guide the EM energy because each electron can push the next one in sequence. But also, one electron doesn't just push on the next one. Instead, it pushes on a huge number of electrons far upstream and down the long chain of mobile charges going off into the distance. That's why the EM energy can "leapfrog" across the movable charges, at the speed of light. If each electron could only push upon its nearest neighbor, then electrical energy would travel at about the speed of sound.

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
But a water tower only has one terminal. A better "capacitor" would be a pair of water towers side by side.

To "charge" this double-water-tower capacitor, pump some water from one to the other. And, when the water-tower capacitor is entirely "discharged," the towers both have the same water level inside. (As with a real capacitor, the total amount of water never changes.)

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →