HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wbeaty

112 karma · joined May 14, 2010

I run SCIENCE HOBBYIST, http://amasci.com/ , also http://trafficwaves.org/
submissionscomments
wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
That's what I started out with! Fill the entire universe with solid rock (since air and vacuum are insulating.) Bore out a cylinder, fill it with water (electricity), and add a piston and spring. Wires are water-channels added to either end.

But note that, if we use a constant-force spring, then the voltage remains the same until just before the "capacitor" is totally discharged. So, it acts like a battery! To get a "capacitor," the spring must have an unchanging spring-constant, so that the potential-difference rises in proportion to how much water has been pumped from one terminal to the other.

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
Sure it does. You just have to look at the list of articles, not the giant pile of random notes.

BEN FRANKLIN SHOULD HAVE SAID ELECTRONS ARE POSITIVE? Wrong. http://amasci.com/miscon/eleca.html#frkel

EE would be much HARDER if Franklin had swapped positive and negative, since then our confusion wouldn't lead us to shatteing our own misconceptions. We'd never sit down and figure out what "conventional current" actually is. No, it's not backwards. And no, electricity is not made of electrons. In acids, the electric current is entirely a flow of protons. In dirt, oceans, and human bodies the current is at least two separate flows: clouds of positive ions passing forwards through clouds of negative ions travelling backwards. With two opposite charge carriers, what then is the "true" direction of electric current? What if there are five: +Na, +K, +H, -OH, -CL ?

Cute notion: Ben Franklin's kite string was an acidic conductor, a piece of twine which becomes insulating in dry conditions, so it's an electrolyte. And acid conductors have mobile +H ions to carry the current. (What's a hydrogen atom, with one missing electron?)

In other words, Ben Franklin's kite string is a Proton Conductor.

SO HE GOT THE DIRECTION RIGHT!!!!

:)

He only was wrong in the case of metal wires. In his day, a typical "conductor" was a small boy hired to hang from silk ropes, to connect the Leyden Jar to the "Electrical Machine." Or rather than commoners, sometimes they used chains of Elizabethan royalty, all standing upon insulating stools.

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
Hydrogen gas is insulating matter. Ionized hydrogen is conductive matter.

Too bad we don't have metallic hydrogen. It would be a solid conductor, just like any other metal.

"Conductor" actually means "contains mobile charges." Conductor doesn't mean "a hollow pipe which electricity flows through." Conductors are more like long, narrow ponds. They're made of 'electric fluid,' so if we have a ring-shaped pond, we can push the water along so it starts moving in a complete circuit, like a drive-belt.

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
When I step into the pond, the ENTIRE WATER LEVEL RISES AT THE SAME TIME! Water must travel instantly?

So, a hydro dam is actually a method for sucking the energy out of the entire surface of a lake, all at the same time! (Actually the pressure-waves travel at the speed of sound in water, a few thousand MPH.) It doesn't happen instantly, but damn close.

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
For those who don't like raw notes, why not read the finished articles instead?

The index to the large collection is here: http://amasci.com/ele-edu.html

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
So, you're saying that capacitors store electrons?!

Debunking this particular conception was the whole point of my capacitor article http://amasci.com/emotor/cap1.html

Capacitors "store" electrons, like springs "store" steel, or rubber bands "store" rubber. A charged capacitor has exactly the same number of electrons as an "uncharged" capacitor.

When "charging" a capacitor, charge is forced into one terminal, and exactly equal charge comes out of the other terminal. No electrons build up inside, nor are placed into it. They've just been moved around inside, same as the steel spring, or the spherical tank in the water analogy.

What then do capacitors store? EXACTLY! That's the questions that students should be asking. They won't think to ask it, if they've been taught that capacitors are like buckets full of electrons. Well, what does a steel spring store? Or a stretched rubber band? KG of steel or rubber? Nope. Capacitors store joules, not coulombs.

The above concepts open the way to unifying several ideas: capacitors store charge in the same way that inductors store charge! In both components, energy is stored, as e-fields in the case of capacitors, b-fields in the case of conductors.

wbeaty··on Drawing Holograms by Hand (2003)
Back in the old "Circuit Cellar" magazine era, they made a printer-hologram by photographing it onto film transparency.

I recall that it was a "binary hologram" 300dpi covering a full 11" page, then reduced to a few-mms-wide patch on monochrome slide film. Obviously the main challenge would be in getting the darned thing in focus, so the fine pattern doesn't blur out into gray.

Then, print out a feet-wide paper copy, so the pattern ends up as a few-cm hologram on your slide film.

wbeaty··on Drawing Holograms by Hand (2003)
> I never quite grokked rainbow holograms,

If you made a scratch hologram, but your compass-point had a small cluster of fifty tiny needles instead of a single big needle, that comes close to the fringe-structure of Benton white-light holograms.

:)

> But it's unfair to say all white-light holograms aren't holograms

True. By "white light" I was referring to Rainbow / credit-card / Benton holograms.

wbeaty··on Drawing Holograms by Hand (2003)
Key concept: what do the zoneplates of Benton holograms look like, as opposed to those conventional (off axis) holograms?

A Benton white light hologram is composed of narrow horizontal slices of zoneplates, one for each reconstructed point. Something like this:

http://amasci.com/graphics/swatch.gif

My insight was this: if the above zoneplate-slice is squared off and increased in spatial frequency, it still reconstructs the same 3D image point. If we drew the nested fringes of that above zoneplate by scratching with a needle, it still produces the same glowing pixel floating in space.

In other words, white-light holograms are frequency-independent, just as always claimed. Yes, if we change the frequency of the above zoneplate pattern, the rainbow coloration will shift, and may even appear white. Yet the reconstructed 3D image remains unaltered. The 3D image data is not contained in the spacing of the interference fringes. That's another way to say that the hologram still functions even if the spacing between fringes is randomized.

It even keeps working if all fringes but one are removed.

Here's the relationship between the zoneplates of Benton holograms, versus the 'zoneplates' of scratch holograms:

http://amasci.com/graphics/holo/onestp2.gif

Benton white-light holograms only use interference to record their zoneplates. They don't use interference to reconstruct the 3D image. (That's why they still function under white-light illumination.)

Or, here's another approach. Benton holograms and scratch holograms are based on Poisson's Spot. They don't act like a fresnel lens, instead they act like a conical lens, causing an incoming beam to both converge and scatter into a long locus with no focal point. The "facets" of Benton holograms and scratch holograms need no be diffraction patterns or prisms, they can be random striations, parallel fibers, narrow cylinder lenses, reflective wires, etc.

It's perfectly OK to insist that scratch holograms aren't genuine holograms. But to remain honest and consistent, we're also then forced to declare that Benton holograms aren't true holograms.

Or, as I said in the linked articles, the bench setup for making Benton white-light holograms is actually an optical device for producing entire scratch holograms all at once, with no individual scratching needed.

Heh, "metal rods are the interference fringes!" needs quotation marks, since I guess it wasn't obvious that I was being silly.

wbeaty··on Drawing Holograms by Hand (2003)
...and that's how we prove that white-light holograms aren't holograms. (Credit-card holograms function just like scratch-holograms, and their 3D image is not created via diffraction.)

[Are these REALLY holograms?](http://amasci.com/amateur/holo3.html)

wbeaty··on Drawing Holograms by Hand (2003)
Latest trick: LP albums, rotating scratch-hologram animations:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DLuvkcV2oi4&t=0m26s

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqNF9IWmFQE&list=PL60100E8F3...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H9gRPtkSOn0

Also gallery artists:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQ_sjQRYhX4

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G36kP8g6SrI

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=reM6XhbkQXM

wbeaty··on Drawing Holograms by Hand (2003)
Scratch holograms may have led to the invention of stereo photography.

Someone recently found that Charles Wheatstone wrote about this phenomenon first, after noticing it in lathe-turned flat surfaces. Wheatstone looked at it a bit, then taking inspiration from the obvious 3D images, went on to invent stereo drawings, photography, and the stereopticon.

But, Wheatstone never got it. He never realized that we can make our own scratches, and therefore draw any 3D object. "Steampunk holography" remained lost for about 150 years.

"It is curious, than an effect like this, which must have been seen thousands of times, should never have attracted sufficient attention to have been made the subject of [scientific] observation. It was one of the earliest facts which drew my attention to the subject I am now treating." From Wheatstone, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, 128, (June 1838) "On some remarkable, and hitherto unobserved, Phenomena of Binocular Vision" p371-

The same thing happened again in 1992. Two scientists at Polaroid corp. accidentally made some scratch-patterns producing flat images floating in 3D. They analyzed the scratch geometry. But they missed the secret trick, and never attempted drawing their "holograms" using individual scratches. doi: 10.1364/AO.31.006585

wbeaty··on The Daredevil Camera
Put one on ROV for a trip to Loch Ness! That, or scavanging old outboard motors in muddy lakes.

Don't miss multi-pages video gallery:

http://www.soundmetrics.com/Image-Gallery

wbeaty··on The Daredevil Camera
Nope, theirs is the sound-camera, detector array and sound-lens, but with an acoustic floodlight. I think they do use ranging though, so the 2D image is "sound camera" in one raster dimension, and "sonar range" in the other.
wbeaty··on The Daredevil Camera
Search: acoustic camera. They sell phase-array microphones for mapping noise sources. Rather than a plane array, theirs is a sphere.
wbeaty··on The Daredevil Camera
Very very cool!

And it's about time someone did it! Yours is the first hobbyist project I've encountered since my own extremely crude ten-dollar version in 1981. No square array or processing, mine was a mechanical scanner-disk: eight LEDs glued in a spiral to an old vinyl record album, each with an electret microphone and and op amp. Spin the disk with a motor at about 6Hz. Wind noise, so add foam to the mics. It worked. A mechanical acoustic-phosphor raster sensor and display screen, where sound patterns caused light patterns. The best part was to hold some headphones near it while playing 10KHz sine wave. This produced interference stripes on the scanning disk! I hoped to build a huge version someday, but somebody beat me to it: Tom Zimmerman, an MIT student who patented the dataglove, then used the money to work at Exploratorium Museum for a year (as Artist in Residence), building a scanning-microphone LED disk about 6ft wide.

Since then we have companies selling DIDSON full-blown video for underwater (with sonic illumination,) also a euro company with a 3D phase-array microphone imager positioned on a ring or a wire sphere. See:

http://www.soundmetrics.com/Image-Gallery/Fisheries/Habitat-...

Heh, the divers appear to be skeletons wearing scuba tanks.

http://www.acoustic-camera.com/en/products/microphone-arrays...

wbeaty··on Holography Without Lasers: Hand-Drawn Holograms (1995)
Too late! HP just announced a 3D semi-holographic display based on just this same optics. With theirs, each tiny reflective groove has several conventional LCD pixels in front, plus bright RGB edge-lighting. http://www.technologyreview.com/news/512716/new-3-d-display-...
wbeaty··on Holography Without Lasers: Hand-Drawn Holograms (1995)
See 3.4 in the paper, http://amasci.com/amateur/hand1.html#34 also figure 11b.

Yes, a proper "abrasion hologram" would have holo-pixels resembling little fresnel-lens cross-sections. The "hand drawn" version is simplified, and produces weird artifacts unless viewed perpendicular, and the reproduced image isn't too wide. Yet even so, we can create a 3D object in less than an hour via simple hand-scribed circles on soft plastic. Use an architect compass and an old CD case.

It's now appearing on vinyl, on Jack White Lazaretto album, also on recent re-release of classic 1976 "Rush 2112"...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H9gRPtkSOn0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqNF9IWmFQE

Find lots at https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL60100E8F3572CEB1

wbeaty··on How transistors really work (1995)
An electric circuit is a circular channel full of water, a loop-river.

An off-switch is a wall of dirt placed across the channel.

A battery is a dam with a pump, where the pump runs just enough to maintain a 1-ft level-difference across the dam. A resistor is a narrow section in the river, where the rushing water moves fast enough to heat up. (Or maybe a resistor is a swamp full of cattails and mangroves, causing the entire length of river-loop to move slow.) Amperes is gallons-per-second. Voltage is water surface altitude measured with respect to the center of the Earth, or WRT some average water level, or WRT any chosen reference-altitude.

wbeaty··on How transistors really work (1995)
Mcoils article was much longer, but I never made the GIF diagrams for the second half. Do this: make a small half-inch parallel-plate capacitor with a 10ft thick dielectric. Use the insulating dielectric as an "AC conductor." Break it in two to form an off-switch, and force the fractured ends back together to complete the circuit.

I do have a short piece of PZT piezo ceramic rod from eBay. But I still haven't tried using it to complete an AC circuit, or even stuck it on top of a Tesla coil. At high freqs, high-K piezo-ceramic insulators are a good conductor: a long, long filament of capacitor-dielectric which, in theory, can be wound into an AC electromagnet coil ...made of insulator. (Or, when put on top of a Tesla coil, I expect sparks to shoot out of the insulating ceramic tip!) But not nearly as fun concept as electro-electret solenoids that should attract rice crispies and small bits of paper.

I did build the chain-of-rings transformer, the waveguide for 60Hz. In a surplus shop I found a handful of big transformer cores; those tape-wound split-core type. I could pass copper rings through these (made some #10-gauge wire loops), using cable-ties to clamp the C-cores into closed rings. I drove one end of the chain with 1000 amps from a soldering gun tip. The other end was 30 turns of wire-wrap wire, and would light up a little 3v pilot light. I think there were six iron cores and five copper rings in the chain.

Of course if you want the ultimate chain, you'd need alternating rings of piezo ceramic and ferrite. Figure out how much horsepower could be sent along the floppy chain before it started heating up too much!

Handy note: if you need ~1000 amps AC for anything, just screw a short loop of #12-gauge solid wire into the end of your 300-watt soldering gun. Make a little loop coil, use it to demagnetize your screwdrivers. It's not 1000 turns of one ampere, it's one turn of 1000 amperes. Pass the conductor through a pair of tapewound C-cores and they slam together with 100s lbs force. (Measure it with a clamp-on ammeter, if your ammeter goes that high.)

For my next trick, I will shoot a smoke-ring made out of Luminiferous Aether across the room. But first I'll need a big deep hat, from which I'll have to pull two new Maxwell's equations! :)

wbeaty··on How transistors really work (1995)
As Win Hill says, his "transistor man" is later discarded, and replaced by voltage-based design which eliminates hfe, relying on Vbe and Ebers-Moll equation.

This makes his book even more excellent. And the lab book for AOA goes much farther, directly exposing the many mistakes caused by "current amplifier" design philosophy based on hfe.

Look inside a BJT op-amp, where diff-input is voltage-based. And the many Current-Source sections employ the transconductance model, Vbe-based explanations, not hfe.

Heh, the actual "transistor man" is made out of voltage; he's the base voltage Vbe, and he adjusts the thickness of the depletion layer inside the emitter junction. The depletion layer observes Ib, changes its thickness in response, and this thickness then determines the value of collector current Ic. Actually Ib cannot affect Ic or vice versa, otherwise we'd just have resistor action, not transistor action.

"As a young engineer struggling with my circuit designs in the mid 60's (remember the h parameters?), a wise experienced teacher sat me down with a single sheet of paper for 30 minutes and preached the value of Ebers-Moll and Re. What's the gain of a common-emitter amplifier stage? Easy, RL / Re. And Re is 25 ohms at 1mA.

"Oops, Re = VT/IC = 25mV/IC, and changes with current, causing distortion? OK add a degenerating resistance, RE - now the gain is RL / RE+Re, and I can quickly calculate my gain and predict the distortion level for my choices of RE. Try that kind of easy analysis with the βeta approach.

"So I changed my design approach and suddenly things start working as predicted. That is to say, I could reliably engineer instead of empirically-develop my designs. I could also safely do more complex designs." - 2011 Winfield Hill http://cr4.globalspec.com/comment/720374/Re-Voltage-vs-Curre...

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1995)
You're reading my raw notes from pre-internet days.

Please stop!

:)

Try my main article index, http://amasci.com/ele-edu.html

> Fair enough for him to make that choice

No, it's just that someone has found a deep link to my buried page of raw notes from 1989. I guess I should hide it better.

But from there the finished articles link is in the SEE ALSO, and also in the top edge nav bar.

MAIN INDEX: Articles Electricity http://amasci.com/ele-edu.html

Electricity FAQ: http://amasci.com/elect/elefaq.html

INDEX: Electricity Misconceptions http://amasci.com/miscon/elect.html

wbeaty··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1995)
Heh.

The very first line says that THIS IS 1989 RAW UNEDITED NOTES.

http://amasci.com/ele-edu.html is the large collection of finished articles.

wbeaty··on What if I were 1% charged? (2013)
Whoa, amasci.com traffic spike!

Heh, wasn't there a Larry Niven SF story where an alien weapon would zero out the charge of electrons, so the nuclei would fly apart? Our undergrad phys-101 had calculating the force between two (copper!) pennies 1M apart, with all electrons removed from one and deposited on the other.

Later I realized that it would have been even more impressive to estimate the energy-equiv of kilotons of TNT which would be released when the meter-long spark brought the two pennies back into equilibrium.

Another: calculate the width of one coulomb. It's about half a mm, like a grain of sand. That's assuming its the mobile electrons in copper wire (so, not Cu's electrons, but just one free electron per atom.)

wbeaty··on What Are Traffic Waves and Why Do They Happen So Much?
> How can you be sure the cars behind you aren't even more compressed

Because, uh, you don't drive slow.

You drive at the average speed of traffic. Not slow. To smooth out the traffic waves, you don't come to a halt, and neither do you rush forward. "Average speed:" that's when it's not fast, and also it's not slow.

---

Myth: if you have an empty gap, you must be a slow driver!!

Debunked: yes, genuinely slow drivers have big gaps ahead, but those gaps are continuously growing. If a clot of cars is going just 1/2MPH slower than average, then the gap increases rapidly: growing a half mile for each driving hour. If that clot of cars was 5MPH slow, then in just ten minutes the gap would increase by over four thousand ft.

But on the other hand, a constant-sized gap does not decrease your speed. Whether you're 6" from the car ahead, or 6ft, or 600ft, your gap has a constant size, and you're moving at the same speed as traffic ahead.

Slow drivers do make empty gaps, but empty gaps aren't any proof of slow driving.

Heh, so maniacal aggressive tailgating doesn't actually get you to your destination any faster? AMAZING! Who'd have thought!

wbeaty··on What Are Traffic Waves and Why Do They Happen So Much?
ACC just imposes safe driving behavior: proper spacing for the reaction time.

So if just 20% of humans were safe drivers (spaced out properly,) then everything smooths out.

That, or perhaps 0.5% of drivers could intentionally go at the average speed.

wbeaty··on What Are Traffic Waves and Why Do They Happen So Much?
The papers I've seen on this conclude that rear-end accidents are the major issue. Smoothing the waves can eliminate immense rush-hour delays, if this eliminates panic-braking that can cause minor daily accidents. Or as they say, "speed differentials are dangerous." In I-70 Colorado they claim that police pace-cars used to smooth out the fluctuations have cut the accident rate in half.

In theory the waves can represent a bottleneck, since the close-packed regions are low-flow, but the wide empty regions are also low-flow. If the smoothed wave results in traffic flowing at 35-40MPH, then smoothing will increase the flow, since the peak flow rate takes place at 35-40 MPH. But the increase isn't enormous. I think they said ~15%. That's nothing, when compared to the effects of removing an accident scene from a rush-hour commute.

You can play with those online JAVA simulators: set up unstable conditions on the ring-road, watch the initial flow, then after traffic-waves develop, watch the flow again. If enormous waves appear, the flow drops by ~25%, but if a string of small waves appear, the decrease is less than 10%.

wbeaty··on Holography without Lasers: Hand Drawn Holograms (1995)
Same principle as Benton white-light holograms, see 2003 SPIE paper linked on the site, also "Not true holograms?" The scratches are line-scatterers, not flat-bottomed as Fresnel, so no focal length.

Basically it's an enlarged Zoneplate rather than a fresnel lens. Arrays of curved line-scatterers can reconstruct single pixels with programmable depth. The fringes of Rainbow holograms do this, and their 3D image-reconstruction requires no interference nor monochromatic illuminators. Insight: change the spacing of the fringes of a rainbow hologram, or even randomize the spacing, and the 3D reconstruction still works fine. The 3D image doesn't depend on optical interference. A very weird effect! So, can we draw a Rainbow hologram by hand with a needle, by scratching the fringes with random spacing? Yep. We get 3D images, but they're white in color with no rainbow artifact.

wbeaty··on Holography without Lasers: Hand Drawn Holograms (1995)
Like mine here? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XUy8lELWhJg&t=50s

When people at work angrily insisted that these were not true holograms because you can't make opaque objects, I sat down and drew opaque objects. This was around ?1996? Instructions from published paper: sect. 3.3.1 http://amasci.com/amateur/hand1.html#331

wbeaty··on Holography without Lasers: Hand Drawn Holograms (1995)
That was my first thought ...while standing out there checking the video a few seconds after shooting. But it was confusing me, because there was no motorbike. I'd been trying to shoot without car noise, so I was facing the road, and (mostly) waiting for any vehicles to pass. When cars pass you can hear the loud wind/wheels hiss in this vid. I noticed that weird hum even in my tiny camera speaker. Later I checked for it indoors, and still there.

I suppose I should check the frequency. If not right at 60/120Hz, and has doppler of moving vehicle, then it's much more likely to be a bike(etc.) that I'd not noticed down the road, and then my brain had edited out while I was talking. Finally, there's a power line about 20ft up on the other side of the street. Huge current surge? The usual b-field from that thing is so strong that any small pickup coil in my house will detect it, and for sensitive work I have to go to the back of the kitchen, over 100ft distant.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →