HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wcarey

494 karma · joined August 26, 2010

submissionscomments
wcarey··on Bible API
I'm glad you found it thought provoking. The liturgical churches tend to follow a lectionary, which, as you say, excerpts from the scriptures. The RCL has some passages that I think are cut poorly, but generally keeps the unit of thought at the level of the particular story or argument.
wcarey··on Bible API
Perhaps! I've encountered lots of fellow Christians who construct arguments by taking individual verses from everywhere in the scriptures and arranging them into an argument assuming that all the terms are equivalent and that the context doesn't matter. It particularly perplexes me when someone will cite, say verse x and then immediately after it cite verse x-2, reordering them in a way that destroys the sense of the passage, but supports some argument.

Perhaps there's an uncanny valley between people who are familiar with the broad strokes and people who argue contextually.

wcarey··on Bible API
Sure - there are lots of folks aiming at a more authentic reading. In general, the older a church, the more it aims at a reading that avoids the modern atomizing impulse. The Catholic and Orthodox churches do some good work on that score, as do Anglican and Lutheran theologians.
wcarey··on Bible API
What are the upsides? What are the downsides? (And to whom?)

Note that I'm not saying the downside is "declining Biblical literacy" - by many metrics I'd imagine that's increasing? I wonder how you'd measure that? And I wonder whether whatever scheme you came up with wouldn't presume some hermeneutic and really just measure the extent to which people buy into that hermeneutic? For example, who is more Biblically literate? The person who can quote, verbatim, with correct citation 100 verses of scripture, or the person who can re-tell in paraphrase the story of Jesus forgiving Peter after the resurrection?

I'm saying the downside is a transformation in what it means to read the scriptures.

wcarey··on Bible API
So, it seems like you're claiming that some scammers believe that some religious people are gullible. That's certainly true, if not particularly interesting! Are you aiming at a broader argument or more expansive claim?
wcarey··on Bible API
Ah - apologies - I misread you. I'm not sure whether there are any mid-sentence verse breaks in the Old Testament. I'll look!
wcarey··on Bible API
It is, as you say, not particularly suited for something like an API for verses.
wcarey··on Bible API
Can you expand on the claim and warrant you're making there?
wcarey··on Bible API
Fascinating! Do you have a good book recommendation that introduces that? It's not something I know much about.
wcarey··on Bible API
I'm thinking, for example, of the RCL, which often breaks passages mid chapter and occasionally omits individual verses. What sort of Christian community do you mostly know?

If you said "The St. Crispin's day speech" I'd immediately know what you mean. I'm definitely a Shakespeare fan, but would have no idea which act, scene, &c. that speech occupies. I'd wager that's much less true of the scriptures in many circles.

wcarey··on Bible API
Indeed - and I'd say that the division of those sources has been broadly restricted to scholars, and that those scholars broadly also read those ancient texts in the enlightenmenty way that I'm suggesting does violence to them.
wcarey··on Bible API
Christians, in particular, would believe Christianity man made. After all, God became incarnate and fully human!
wcarey··on Bible API
So, having read the whole of what you wrote, the reason not to do both is that atomization promotes an epistemology that does grave violence to Christian belief. God's self revelation could have been a math textbook: a collection of independent propositions related by logical necessity. But it's not.

His self revelation is a person who has a story and who tells stories. When we atomize the scriptures, we're implicitly constructing an argument against the epistemology that God has revealed in the scriptures. That's the thing that Satan does in the wilderness when he puts Jesus to the test. We ought not lead others into that time of trial.

So the convenience of being able to cite a verse as quick shorthand comes at the price of a profound argument against the coherent truth of the scriptural witness.

wcarey··on Bible API
Sure - take a look at the first chapter of Paul's first letter to the Corinthians. The sentence:

Jews demand signs and Greeks search for wisdom, but we preach Christ crucified, a stumbling block to Jews and foolishness to Gentiles, but to those who are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God.

is divided into three (!) verses. That sort of thing is pretty common with the periodic structure of Paul's sentences. English readers, with our weak clause boundaries, struggle with those sorts of sentences anyway.

wcarey··on Bible API
Proverbs is certainly the book most amenable to division into verses.
wcarey··on Bible API
I chose "balkanization" to connote the things you reference; the atomic quoting of verses of scripture does violence to the text.

Verses are definitely not functionally paragraphs. Some aren't even complete sentences!

wcarey··on Bible API
I think my point, though, that the unit of thought in the scriptures is not the atomic verse, still stands. If you'd like to emend "collected works of Jane Austen" to "collected works of 19th century authors", feel free.
wcarey··on Bible API
Sure - by "Christian reading", I mean something like the practice of the ancient church that canonized the scriptures. That there should be normative Christian practice and reading is, perhaps, controversial, but a claim I'm happy to make. Modern American evangelicals who read the scriptures that way are doing it wrong and should knock it off.

The scriptures weren't atomized into verses until scholars of the 15th century wanted to work on them. The practice you see today is an outgrowth of that epistemology, and greatly to the detriment of Christian witness, theology, and practice.

wcarey··on Bible API
The gold standard for the Greek text of the New Testament is the critical edition (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novum_Testamentum_Graece) published by Nestle-Aland.
wcarey··on Bible API
Generally translations are subject to copyright and not considered inspired by Christians. There are a small minority of folks who consider the KJV an inspired translation, but that translation is too old for copyright law to speak to it.
wcarey··on Bible API
One of the most interesting things to happen to the scriptures is their balkanization into verses. We generally don't atomize other writings that way, and when folks read the scriptures as a series of disconnected logical propositions all sorts of wackiness ensues. What would it look like to have an API for the collected works of Jane Austen that returned snippets (some of which are not even complete sentences)? How would that shape the way we read, say, Persuasion?

That hermeneutic - texts are collections of independent logical propositions - was essentially unknown in the ancient world, and cedes immense epistemological ground to the project of the enlightenment that is diametrically opposed to a Christian reading of the Scriptures, which emphasizes their unity and their role in liturgical worship.

wcarey··on The largest city in each 10x10 degree latitude/longitude box
A fun thought experiment is to noodle through whether, given the method of choosing cities described, the choice of map projection would influence the resulting list of cities.
wcarey··on Show HN: My daughter and I made a site to explore the photos from the ISS
JPEG is good for display. If you want to do any sort of analysis on the image, you'll want a lossless format that can handle multiple channels and the georeferencing metadata. TIFF is pretty good for that. There are a bunch depending on what sensor you're getting them from and what you plan on doing with them. And how sensitive you are to having a pallet of hard drives fed-exed to your office.

GDAL (https://gdal.org) is a wonderful tool that can handle essentially any geographic raster image imaginable. Tools like ArcGis or Grass can also deal pretty well with hyperspectral images. Lots of GIS shops also roll very customized image pipelines if they have particular needs.

wcarey··on Problems with Remote Learning
As a teacher who uses versioned TeX for all of my artifacts, this isn’t the panacea you hope for. Many of my documents will only compile on my machine because I a have a bunch of dependencies scattered about. There are also many types of artifact that require an order of magnitude more work to produce in TeX compared to something like OmniGraffle or PowerPoint.

Even if you could somehow overcome the technical hurdles, you’d run into the problem of teaching materials not possessing even a partial order.

Even if you somehow get teachers to agree on a lattice or total order for teaching artifacts, you’d need to deal with the idea that producing teaching materials is a way for the teacher to synthesize the content they are about to teach. Often the artifact is something of a byproduct of the process of the teacher making sense of the rhetorical situation the are about to undertake. If you just snag the highest rated artifact, that process doesn’t happen.

wcarey··on How to Make this Moment the Turning Point for Real Change
Taboo is the exact right word for that.

In particular, the Gracchi violated an unspoken and unwritten compact that governed the behavior of the Roman aristocracy. In particular, they attempted to secure power for themselves using avenues not considered "in bounds". There was no institutional mechanism in place to process violations of that unwritten compact (social opprobrium had worked for hundreds of years), so the senators (Scipio Nasica in particular) immediately transitioned to personal violence.

Once the taboo against aristocrat-on-aristocrat violence vanished, Rome descended into waves of high aristocrats raising private armies to secure their personal power. It was, more or less, a game of last man standing that Augustus "won".

wcarey··on SpaceX successfully launches two humans into orbit
How much HTP would you need for the launch escape system?
wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
As someone who has pushed pretty hard towards precise definition and rigor as a teacher, you're in the (happy!) minority being able to approach mathematics that way. For lots of students, the process of moving from definitions and simple rules to other statements is extraordinarily difficult.

I teach the properties of exponents to 14 year olds as a unit on logical necessity - the properties all flow necessarily from the definition of the exponent. About a third of the students say, "cool" and never miss anything on any assessment again because the answers flow necessarily from the givens.

About a third work their way through it fine.

About a third continue to maintain that, say, a^2 + b^2 = (a+b)^2 despite working many particular examples where that is manifestly false.

wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
There are some gentle efforts in that direction (tau radians for example), but mathematical notation is old (except the parts that are new). And it's really hard to strike the right balance between concision and ambiguity.
wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
We explicitly encourage the "let's invent name for this similar but unnamed thing" with our students, and use whatever name they come up with for the thing for the rest of their time with us.

Sometimes those student created names become legendary. They really enjoy the idea that they can have "Jane's relation" be used by students after they graduate. (Of course, sometimes Jane's relation is really Euler's totient function, and we have to encourage them that even though they found something a very good mathematician also found, we're going to call it by the common name.)

wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
This is definitely a good explanatory strategy (and one that I'd use). I might label the units of the right side as well. Would you attempt to explain the abstract rules of fraction arithmetic as an system?
← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →