HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

whaaswijk

81 karma · joined November 27, 2014

GitHub: https://github.com/whaaswijk Web page: https://whaaswijk.github.io
submissionscomments
whaaswijk··on Your doppelgänger is out there and you probably share DNA with them
That’s actually not clear to me. Anecdotally I have often experienced the saying “opposite attract” to be true. I have had discussions with friends who hold your point of view. Of course it could also depend on how we define similarity (e.g in terms of race, ethnicity, personality type, etc.). I wonder if there’s some percentage of the population that’s wired to look outside of itself.
whaaswijk··on Ethereum Goerli testnet merge goes live before move to proof-of-stake
Is there a mechanism in place to stop people from laundering money with ethereum? This is a serious question, I’m a total noob when it comes to crypto.
whaaswijk··on Consciousness is not computation
I’m not sure the analogy to gravity works. At least in the case of gravity we have a model which (largely) explains the planetary orbits. As far as I know, we are not even close to a model in the case of consciousness. And even if we had a model for the “easy problem” it’s possible that the “hard problem” would still remain.

Edit: to be clear, I’m agnostic on this problem. I just don’t really like the emergence “model”, where we have a bunch of supposedly non-conscious matter and if we put enough of it together in the right way consciousness just pops into existence.

whaaswijk··on Consciousness is not computation
What explanation are you referring to though? Just saying consciousness is an emergent property is not an explanation. Rather it is an assertion.
whaaswijk··on Nature has enormous emotional and cognitive benefits on people
Grass and trees and such. Perhaps bushes and animals too.
whaaswijk··on MSFT demonstrates formerly elusive physics needed to build scalable qubits
:-D
whaaswijk··on MSFT demonstrates formerly elusive physics needed to build scalable qubits
Are there any experts that can ELI5 this “breakthrough” for us? How much closer does this bring us to a useful number of logical qubits?
whaaswijk··on What’s so hard about understanding consciousness?
I guess this is where we differ. I don't see a sufficient reason to believe that increasing computational capacity/complexity alone gives rise to consciousness. Moreover, I think there are common sense reasons to believe that consciousness is not substrate independent. Therefore, I don't see it as obvious that Turing completeness is sufficient for consciousness. For example, as someone else on this post has pointed out, a sufficiently complex water pipeline can implement a Turing machine. However, I doubt it would ever be conscious, no matter how large we make it. I think representing and processing information is orthogonal to experiencing.
whaaswijk··on What’s so hard about understanding consciousness?
Well, as far as I'm aware notions of feeling or experiencing are not accounted for in our current physical models. Does an electron feel anything? On the one hand, if it does, it seems to me like physical models have to be extended to include some primitive form of consciousness. This would be something like panpsychism. On the other hand, if single electrons do not have consciousness, why do large collections of them in specific structures have it? Note that, to me, it seems insufficient to say that collections of electrons can be used to model or compute with. Namely because it raises the question of why this modeling has a feeling tone (qualia) to it.

Finally, I don't know if I can make a meaningful distinction between feeling and experiencing. I believe a feeling is an experience.

whaaswijk··on What’s so hard about understanding consciousness?
If I understand correctly, you're referring to the "easy" problem of consciousness, i.e. the "mechanistic" explanation of how a self could be constructed by the brain. That's an interesting question and I think your take is a coherent and plausible one (from a materialistic perspective). However, I still think this doesn't get around the hard problem of why these interactions actually feel like anything. I've never heard a satisfying materialistic explanation of that. Do you believe the interactions could in principle be implemented on any Turing machine? Or are they substrate dependent?
whaaswijk··on What’s so hard about understanding consciousness?
Serious question: how can consciousness be an illusion? I’m not even sure what that would mean. One could argue that many things are illusory (e.g. the external world). But it’s quite hard to dismiss the notion of actual experience occurring in the world. Our experiences could lead us to false conclusions, sure, but we cannot deny their existence.
whaaswijk··on Autistic people challenge preconceived ideas about rationality
I think many people are reluctant to use non-traditional pronouns. I’m not trying to condemn or condone that, just pointing out that to me this example seems unrelated to autism.
whaaswijk··on Scientists recreated classic origin-of-life experiment and made a new discovery
Would you like to say a bit more about why that's not a valid argument. To be clear, I'm not saying it is (I don't know enough about the subject to do so) but it doesn't seem that far-fetched to me. Isn't similar probabilistic reasoning used to explain why evolution by natural selection gives rise to various complex life forms? If so, do you also think that that reasoning is shoddy?
whaaswijk··on Transmission torrent client ported to C++
In theory there could be such a library but in practice I don’t think there is. Maybe because maintaining something like the STL is a non-trivial task.
whaaswijk··on A.I. can now write its own computer code – that’s good news for humans
Interesting. Could you provide such an argument?
whaaswijk··on Julia receives DARPA award to accelerate electronics simulation
With current EDA tools they already are :-)
whaaswijk··on Why are fewer young adults having casual sex?
I was pushing back to your assertion that viewing sex as entertainment is primarily a modern and western viewpoint. Certainly the west’s view of sex has changed in the past 100 years. However I would not be surprised if the current view is actually more in line with historical attitudes toward sex, not less.
whaaswijk··on Why are fewer young adults having casual sex?
I’m not a historian but aren’t those tightly controlled cultural practices a relatively modern invention? Certainly the ancients were known to have orgies (presumably for fun). People have observed how the 20th century was for many people a return to their “true” nature (eg free love, drugs, rave parties). Maybe it’s just always been true that, when their wealth/resources allow for it, people like to have sex for fun.
whaaswijk··on Dr. Leonid Rogozov operating himself to remove his appendix in Antarctica, 1961
For some of us the idea of cutting into ourselves is definitely not a no brained. I could easily see myself be paralyzed by fear in such a situation.
whaaswijk··on Finding new physics will require a new particle collider
How can you be sure that the new science won't have any practical applications?
whaaswijk··on Separating gifted children hasn't led to better achievement
Unfortunately I don't have enough karma to flag your comment. This kind of low-effort trolling adds absolutely nothing IMO.
whaaswijk··on Modern SAT solvers: fast, neat and underused
One industry where SAT solvers get used frequently is in Electronic Design Automation. One comment already mentions its use in hardware/software verification. It turns out we can also use them to find efficient representations of Boolean functions (and therefore electronic circuits). This also generalizes to the synthesis of quantum logic circuits. They truly are amazingly versatile tools.
whaaswijk··on Darpa Plans a Major Remake of U.S. Electronics
If you're interested in open source hardware, you might find the WOSET workshop interesting. It is a new workshop on open source EDA, related to this DARPA project. See http://scale.engin.brown.edu/woset/
whaaswijk··on Darpa invests $100M in a silicon compiler
The website isn’t up yet, but it’s organized by Prof. Sherief Reda at Brown University. You can contact him for inquiries.
whaaswijk··on Darpa invests $100M in a silicon compiler
I just got back from the Design Automation Conference in San Francisco. It is one of the major EDA conferences. Andreas Olofsson gave a talk about the silicon compiler. There was serious discussion about open source EDA. As far as I could tell it is still unclear what the role of academia will be. It seems tricky to align academic incentives with the implementation, and most importantly, maintenance of an open source EDA stack. However, there is quite some buzz and people are enthused. A first workshop, the "Workshop on Open-Source EDA Technology" (WOSET) has been organized.

I also thought I'd try to answer some questions that I've seen in the comments. Disclaimer: as a lowly PhD student I am only privy to some information. I'm answering to the best of my knowledge.

1) As mentioned by hardwarefriend, synthesis tools are standard in ASIC/FPGA design flows. However, chip design currently often still takes a lot of manual work and/or stitching together of tools. The main goal of the compiler is to create a push-button solution. Designing a new chip should be as simple as cloning a design from GitHub and calling "make" on the silicon compiler.

2) Related to (1). The focus is on automation rather than performance. We are okay with sacrificing performance as long as compiler users don't have to deal with individual build steps.

3) There should be support for both digital, analog, and mixed-signal designs.

4) Rest assured that people are aware of yosys and related tools. In fact, Clifford was present at the event :-) Other (academic) open source EDA tools include the ABC for logic synthesis & verification, the EPFL logic synthesis libraries (disclaimer: co-author), and Rsyn for physicial design. There are many others, I'm certainly not familiar with all of them. Compiling a library of available open source tools is part of the project.

Edit: to be clear, WOSET has been planned, but will be held in November. Submissions are open until August 15.

whaaswijk··on Is There a Smarter Path to Artificial Intelligence? Some Experts Hope So
Somehow the main article link is behind a paywall for me, but the mobile one is not: https://mobile.nytimes.com/2018/06/20/technology/deep-learni...

(YMMV)

whaaswijk··on Evidence of exponential speed-up in the solution of hard optimization problems?
It's worth noting that Scott Aaronson has commented on previous work by the same authors: https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=2212 . At the time, he was convinced that their approach wouldn't scale. I'm not sure about their current approach, but at a glance it seems similar to the previous one.

Previous work: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1411.4798.pdf

whaaswijk··on “Fiercely resist any further broadening of the scope of the C UB problem”
Typically in hardware design you'd use combinational equivalence checking (CEC) to formally prove that a synthesized design is correct. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formal_equivalence_checking. In CEC you use a SAT solver to prove that a new (synthesized and optimized) circuit is equivalent to some reference model (aka golden model) which you know is correct. So instead of relying on just testing (which is incomplete) you have a formal proof that your design is correct. Of course you still have to trust that the SAT solver works correctly... :-)
whaaswijk··on Ask HN: Which people and groups are researching new approaches to programming?
For more on program synthesis and verification see also the Leon system by Viktor Kuncak et al.[1]

[1] http://lara.epfl.ch/w/

← PreviousPage 2 of 2