HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

whatyoucantsay

706 karma · joined November 11, 2015

HN went so far as to block this account from posting after I made the following comment:

It will be interesting to see how YC helps with this as their investment and relationship with China deepens.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16922566

submissionscomments
whatyoucantsay··on Quit Social Media, Your Career May Depend on It (2016)
You're shaming someone for having low stress, bland social media habits.
whatyoucantsay··on Thoughts on Embracing the Social Internet Over Social Media
This is a penetrating analysis and I completely agree with its values.

In practise, however, it is a very quixotic pursuit to try to pull the social world away from SV companies with network effect lock-in. The only way to succeed just may lie revolve in anti-social marketing behaviour.

whatyoucantsay··on Is Facebook Really Scarier Than Google?
Facebook is ethically bankrupt, but their power is much more limited. Google is nothing less than the greatest threat to humanity. Trump, North Korea, militant Islam and Putin all pale in comparison to what Google is capable of. Only Xi's increasingly nationalist and modernized China is capable of remotely the same kind of threat, but Google has a huge lead in military robotics and will probably reach the AI tipping point first.

They have been a beautifully gilded trojan horse, beloved in the beginning, but in the end most of humanity will likely regret having given away so much to Google.

whatyoucantsay··on For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Freezing Over
> what most people, including the Tawainese themselves, agree is a part of China.

I truly cannot distinguish if you're trolling or serious. You continue repeating the same points throughout this thread and they are not true. Taiwan has never been part of the PRC. Before the KMT invaded, Taiwan was part of the Japanese Empire. Claiming the PRC gets all territory once owned by the Qing Dynasty is roughly equivalent to Germany claiming all territory once owned by Prussia. It doesn't lead anywhere pleasant.

Your comments are reprehensible and I wish for you never have the experience of your home being under constant threat from an increasingly wealthy and aggressive neighbor.

whatyoucantsay··on Review of Steven Pinker’s Enlightenment Now
There is a difference between empiricism, as in testing ideas, and ideologically motivated behavior that involves only seeking only information that can buttress one's current beliefs.

> Only example I know, Giordano Bruno...

You know this example because I just pointed it out to you. There are many others, but I'm done doing your homework for you.

whatyoucantsay··on Why I didn’t fix your bug
I did read it. It fit the archetype.

A high agency individual looks for and finds solutions. Sidekiq is a great example. So is WordPress. Even Github was. Watch Tom Preston-Werner's Mixergy interview and you'll see that he specifically put thought into making sure it would generate revenue in a sustainable fashion if it were to become popular.

whatyoucantsay··on Review of Steven Pinker’s Enlightenment Now
> "while slightly missing the fact that society as a whole always has to be the enabler for what they do - even when it appears to be resisting them!"

Even when society was drowning and burning them to death for heresy? There are a multitude of examples of this, if you care to read histories of the Inquisition. I will give you a starting point—Google "Giordano Bruno"

> "They need to accept that maybe something in their (enlightenment) ideas and way of approaching things is part of the problem."

:/

> "but let's ask WHY intelligent people are doing that: because they believe that Pinker (et al) have a dangerous subtext, or that their ideas trend in a specific direction."

The reasonable answer is because they're highly ideologically motivated, not nearly as intelligent and certainly not as ethical as Pinker.

whatyoucantsay··on Review of Steven Pinker’s Enlightenment Now
> I’ve noticed that everything Pinker writes bears the scars of the hostile mistranslation tactic. Scarcely does he say anything before he turns around and says, “and here’s what I’m not saying”—and then proceeds to ward off five different misreadings so wild they wouldn’t have occurred to me, but then if you read Leon Wieseltier or John Gray or his other critics, there the misreadings are, trotted out triumphantly; it doesn’t even matter how much time Pinker spent trying to prevent them.

> I’m depressed, more generally, that for centuries, the Enlightenment has been met by its beneficiaries with such colossal incomprehension and ingratitude. Save 300 million people from smallpox, and you can expect a return a lecture about your naïve and arrogant scientistic reductionism.

whatyoucantsay··on Luck and startups: Our journey
It's very easy for a highly credentialed person who has lived in the first world of the first world for years before this startup.

These are becoming spammy.

whatyoucantsay··on Why I didn’t fix your bug
The tortured protagonist is a core online archetype.
whatyoucantsay··on Wyoming Passes Forward-Thinking Computer Science Education Bill
This appears backward thinking. A focus in CS would have paid off spectacularly over the past 25 years.

Forward looking might involve focussing rather more on the human capabilities hardest for machines to replicate—relationship building, comedy, sales, and one on one coaching or counseling.

whatyoucantsay··on Rising Anxiety Among American Whites
It's natural to think this way and it's a struggle to overcome it.

People are not only members of "groups" that you chose for them based on their race, sex, country, etc. Each person deserves dignity as a human. Even if their ancestors and yours were enemies, it's not right to use tribal affiliation to judge them. Doing this promotes conflict and eventually violence.

A group is made up of many people and deciding how much "privilege" a group has is like asking the temperature of Europe. You can use math to average, but that doesn't mean much to a person in Turkey or a person in Norway.

whatyoucantsay··on Rising Anxiety Among American Whites
From over here in Asia, your comments are both non-empathatic and dangerous.

Best of luck with your "non-empathy" approach, but I suspect it will make things worse for you.

whatyoucantsay··on Rising Anxiety Among American Whites
You're literally advocating non-empathy for a large group of people due to their heritage. You can't simply divide people into groups based on immutable characteristics and decide who does and does not deserve sympathy.

Punishing a person for perceived faults of their ancestors is a recipe for ethnic conflict and racism.

whatyoucantsay··on Rising Anxiety Among American Whites
Tribalism is a part of human nature and you engage in it, too.

It's not pretty in any circumstance.

whatyoucantsay··on China to bar people with bad 'social credit' from planes, trains
What you write is a reasonable precaution in 2018. Many, many HN posts and accounts were created before the Snowden revelations, before Xi came to power and before the Charlie Hebdo attack.

Many comments will be and have been mined years after their original posting. It's truly doubtful any country was logging every HN comment in the year you opened your account, for example.

whatyoucantsay··on China to bar people with bad 'social credit' from planes, trains
Have your extensive comments about the CCP on HN caused you any hassles?

The fact that comments cannot be deleted is increasingly unethical as ML makes privacy easier and easier to pierce. People who made rational decisions about the risks of sharing various opinions on a small site in 2010 are now locked into the consequences a decade later when both technology and political landscapes have changed.

It would be truly surprising if HN history doesn't eventually play a key role in someone being imprisoned or executed due to having expressed views that a country, religion or other organization finds objectionable.

whatyoucantsay··on Report Reveals Google’s Financial Support for European Academics and Think Tanks
This is about what a reasonable person would expect from Google.

Also concerning is that one of YouTube's primary stated goals this year is to tighten their content control. At first, it will likely be used for preventing content most objectionable to their advertisers and their leadership. Over time, it will almost inevitably morph into a system that distorts the worldwide flow of information to privilege Google's interests. It may not even be intentional, depending on how much ML is involved.

whatyoucantsay··on Ask HN: Is online self-education useful or just delusion?
Do you dispute that Carmack built rockets?

Have you read Masters of Doom or even Googled the question?

http://bfy.tw/H8Z5

whatyoucantsay··on Ask HN: Is online self-education useful or just delusion?
Yes. This is exactly why it's important to do a rigourous exam such as a GRE subject test or a CFA.
whatyoucantsay··on America’s technological hegemony is under threat from China
> On the other hand, you'd probably have a hard time telling the difference between a Korean and a Chinese northerner who lives near the Korean border, as well as the difference between a Vietnamese person, and a Chinese southerner who lives near that border."

Not once they start talking! I'd never mistake a Korean for a Dongbeiren!

whatyoucantsay··on America’s technological hegemony is under threat from China
> largely targeted at Chinese-speakers. These policies included major tax breaks for Chinese speakers with advanced degrees

It's not about being a Chinese speaker. It's about ethno-nationalism or racism, depending upon one's perspective. Merely speaking Chinese fluently isn't nearly enough for a racially European or African person to gain Chinese citizenship. The total number of those who have ever done so is less than the number of people the UK nationalises each week.

Even the green card is nearly unobtainable. Dashan could get one but the vast majority of expats who have spent a decade in China, marred a PRC national, and started a family cannot.

whatyoucantsay··on Stephen Hawking has died
> It is how they inspire an entire generation to seek out knowledge, understanding and fill us all with a sense of humility, awe and wonder.

It's one of the finest things one can do. In today's climate of dystopian science fiction, we could all use some awe and wonder.

whatyoucantsay··on Ask HN: Is online self-education useful or just delusion?
Doing certificates on edX and Coursera is the wrong path. Their certificates and "micro-masters" or "nano degrees" are worthless.

The way you do it is you go through a full 4-year program on MIT's OCW. You do the same assignments and write the same tests actual students did a decade ago. Then you take a GRE subjects test.

Whether or not you use the score to enter a graduate school, it carries weight. The same is true for those who self study through one or preferably two or three levels of the CFA examinations.

whatyoucantsay··on Ask HN: Is online self-education useful or just delusion?
Capitalizing entire words doesn't strengthen your case.

To answer your question, yes I would in cases where they are more educated than their schooled counterparts in the specific help I need. This is less common in medicine than in art, business or science, but it is not unheard of. In those cases, I would, and I have.

You should realize that with the exception of surgeons, most doctors lose skill throughout their careers. After medical school, doctors tend to slowly get worse in diagnostics and often ossify whatever was the best practice when they graduated. This is particularly clear in nutrition. Surgeons are an exception, due to the rapid feedback their work offers.

whatyoucantsay··on Ask HN: Is online self-education useful or just delusion?
Yes, but not in the way you think. They selected themselves.

Of course people know more of fantastic successes than those who end up in the middle or at the bottom of the heap. Many both with and without credentials fail. More of those with credentials succeed, but it is an extremely tenuous argument to claim that schooling caused its recipients to succeed rather than the more straightforward explanation that schools select those who would succeed even without them.

Selection bias is a factor (along multiple dimensions) and it isn't at all clear whether universities make a net positive or net negative contribution to their pupils. One thing is clear, however. It's better to force gatekeepers to filter you out rather than do the task for them.

whatyoucantsay··on Ask HN: Is online self-education useful or just delusion?
> But it really depends what you're learning. If you took a bunch of mechanical engineering self-taught courses, it is unlikely anyone is going to let you design a bridge.

And yet Elon Musk, who studied aerospace on his own, is building rockets. John Carmack, who holds no degree at all, has done the same on a smaller scale.

Who let them?

whatyoucantsay··on Ask HN: Is online self-education useful or just delusion?
From experience, most of them would have discarded their own founders' CVs.
whatyoucantsay··on When an AI finally kills someone, who will be responsible?
When homo-sapiens out-competed and slaughtered the Neanderthal, which Neanderthal was responsible?
whatyoucantsay··on Four Years After Declaring War on Pollution, China Is Winning
Cultural exports. Thanks to Hollywood, most the world confuses American for International.
← PreviousPage 4 of 11Next →