HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

whimsicalism

17,559 karma · joined October 2, 2020

i [care about improving people's lives | research inference on sequences for work] | opinions absolutely my own
submissionscomments
whimsicalism··on AI companies will fail. We can salvage something from the wreckage
i don’t find that at all a compelling argument, but maybe others will
whimsicalism··on AI companies will fail. We can salvage something from the wreckage
I am commenting on something in the background space of assumptions of the essay. Just because it is not the main thrust doesn’t mean I didnt read the article or used an LLM to summarize it for me. Take care
whimsicalism··on AI companies will fail. We can salvage something from the wreckage
You can read my reply to another comment making a similar point. In short, I think you are giving Doctorow far too much credit - the assumption that these tools are fundamentally incapable is woven throughout the essay, the risk always comes from the fact that managers might think these tools (which are obviously inferior) can do your job. The notion that they can actually do your job is treated as invariable absurd, pie-in-the-sky, bubble thinking, or unmentionable.

My point is I don’t think a technology that went from chatgpt (cool, useless) to opus-4.5+ in 3 years is obviously being oversold when it says that it can do your entire job beyond being just a useful tool.

whimsicalism··on AI companies will fail. We can salvage something from the wreckage
You’re arguing in a tautological fashion - anyone who suggests that AI can do a lot of their job must not have been doing important work in the first place. It’s a convenient psychological self defense mechanism that I see often here. Take care.
whimsicalism··on AI companies will fail. We can salvage something from the wreckage
My job is essentially delivering faster with no guard rails. I know it is a common HN sentiment that nobody can do my job better than me because I am the most thoughtful person to ever do it.

This is explicitly not what I am saying given that I am leading with AI getting close to being able to do much of what is currently my job. I find it hard to imagine a world where we stagnate right where we are and it takes a decade to do anything more aka I cannot imagine a world where a considerable portion of jobs are not automatable soon - and I do not even think it will be shittier.

whimsicalism··on AI companies will fail. We can salvage something from the wreckage
yeah it’s all branding. there is totally nothing different about this technology that might cause someone to say that…

e:tone

whimsicalism··on AI companies will fail. We can salvage something from the wreckage
My work involves reading papers, doing high level math, coding it, reasoning about the business environment, etc. etc. My work is important and I find the classic HN impulse to stigmatize people for saying this to be silly.

It is you who is the fool if you haven’t managed to use these things to massively accelerate what you can do and if you cannot see the clear trend. Again, it has been three years since chatgpt came out.

whimsicalism··on AI companies will fail. We can salvage something from the wreckage
I disagree. The article leads with the sentiment that I mention and has it woven throughout. The theme is AI is obviously not capable of doing your job, the problem is that the stupid managerial class will get convinced it is and make things shitty.

> This is another key to understanding – and thus deflating – the AI bubble. The AI can’t do your job, but an AI salesman can convince your boss to fire you and replace you with an AI that can’t do your job.

> Now, AI is a statistical inference engine. All it can do is predict what word will come next based on all the words that have been typed in the past. That means that it will “hallucinate” a library called lib.pdf.text.parsing,

I think it is a convenient, palatable, and obviously comforting lie that lots of people right now are telling themselves.

To me, all the ‘nuance’ in this article is just because the coyote in Doctorow has begun looking down but still cannot quite believe it. He is still leaning on the same tropes of statistical autocomplete that have been a mainstay of the fingers-in-ears gang for the last 3 years.

whimsicalism··on AI companies will fail. We can salvage something from the wreckage
It’s funny reading this parallel world that some portion of people have constructed for themselves.

It has been three years and these tools can do a considerable portion of my day to day work. Salvage the wreckage? Unfortunately I think that many people’s jobs are essentially in the “Coyote running off a cliff but not realizing it yet” phase or soon to be.

whimsicalism··on If you put Apple icons in reverse it looks like someone getting good at design
thank you for providing an exemplar
whimsicalism··on Earth is warming faster. Scientists are closing in on why (2024)
because technological progress means things that were costly and expensive are easier in the future. imagine telling people to stop using gas in 1950. it would have been fully impossible, now avenues are opening up.
whimsicalism··on Earth is warming faster. Scientists are closing in on why (2024)
i think we should be exploring all. carbon tax would be great, but currently seems politically impossible outside of Europe (and even challenging within)
whimsicalism··on Earth is warming faster. Scientists are closing in on why (2024)
I don't now who the BS in econ student you're referring to is, as it's not the context of the article. We have had massive SO2 emissions from past stratovolcano eruptions.

Sure - there is definitely some gap between these natural processes and the artificial processes being proposed, but it is a narrow enough gap that it does preclude a fair number of second-order effects, compared to almost all geoengineering ideas that do not have such natural experiment equivalents.

whimsicalism··on Earth is warming faster. Scientists are closing in on why (2024)
It gives us a bridge to figure out sequestration. Snapback is if we go from 100% to 0%, not just if we can't keep up with carbon emissions.
whimsicalism··on Earth is warming faster. Scientists are closing in on why (2024)
condensing the co2 to the necessary concentrations to drive these reactions is basically never economical - we will need widespread energy abundance before non-organic based removal becomes viable.
whimsicalism··on Earth is warming faster. Scientists are closing in on why (2024)
we already dump boatloads of 'chemicals' into the atmosphere, this is how we got into this whole mess.
whimsicalism··on Earth is warming faster. Scientists are closing in on why (2024)
Right, but the point is that we've already had the test with so2, so it's not really "before they happen".
whimsicalism··on Cloudflare acquires Astro
cloudflare wants to be vercel
whimsicalism··on Furiosa: 3.5x efficiency over H100s
Got excited, then I saw it was for inference. yawns

Seems like it would obviously be in TSMCs interest to give preferential taping to nvidia competitors, they benefit from having a less consolidated customer base bidding up their prices.

whimsicalism··on Roam 50GB is now Roam 100GB
i posted 4 times in this thread (once more than you), half of which were actually defending Elon Musk's contributions/companies. take care
whimsicalism··on Roam 50GB is now Roam 100GB
Does Jeff Bezos believe we need white solidarity to survive because non-white people are a threat to white men?
whimsicalism··on Roam 50GB is now Roam 100GB
https://x.com/elonmusk/status/2009171282030653877

I disagree that Bezos & Elon are comparably bad.

whimsicalism··on Roam 50GB is now Roam 100GB
Don't like what the guy says [0], but this is incredible technology and I'm impressed by how early we are getting it.

[0]: https://x.com/elonmusk/status/2009171282030653877

whimsicalism··on Roam 50GB is now Roam 100GB
thank you for not bidding up the price
whimsicalism··on Anthropic: Developing a Claude Code competitor using Claude Code is banned
they do have a moat. opus is currently much better than every other model except maybe gpt-5.2
whimsicalism··on A battle over Canada’s mystery brain disease
fair enough. i didn't really feel like getting in a back-and-forth about ME/CFS as i find they generally never end. CFS does not appear to impact energy to engage in online arguments.
whimsicalism··on Anthropic: Developing a Claude Code competitor using Claude Code is banned
disagree. it is much better for anthropic to bundle than to become 'just another model provider' to opencode/other routers.

as a consumer, i do absolutely prefer the latter model - but i don't think that is the position I would want to be in if I were anthropic.

whimsicalism··on Anthropic: Developing a Claude Code competitor using Claude Code is banned
i find cursor cli significantly better than opencode right now, unfortunately.

e: for those downvoting, i would earnestly like to hear your thoughts. i want opencode and similar solutions to win.

whimsicalism··on Anthropic: Developing a Claude Code competitor using Claude Code is banned
under the ToS, no - you cannot use claude code to make a competitor to claude code. but you’re right that that appears to mostly be unenforced.

that said, it is absolutely being enforced against other big model labs who are mostly banned from using claude.

whimsicalism··on Anthropic: Developing a Claude Code competitor using Claude Code is banned
For chats, unless you explicitly disable it they absolutely are.

Otherwise, these companies do have auditors.

← PreviousPage 15 of 34Next →