HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

whimsicalism

17,553 karma · joined October 2, 2020

i [care about improving people's lives | research inference on sequences for work] | opinions absolutely my own
submissionscomments
whimsicalism··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
I do not believe for one instance that people are coming from a legitimate concern around planet-burning and reaching their conclusions about AI vs. reasoning backwards from wanting reasons to be anti-AI. Very few people I've met seems willing to make one iota of earnest personal sacrifice for avoiding actual in-real-life planet-burning industries.

Actively pisses me off hearing climate rationale for opposing something so relatively inconsequential while the house is on fire from pre-existing industry that is grandfathered in.

whimsicalism··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
I think people should be allowed to do things, generally. If it's not worth it, the people doing it will go out of business (and quickly, at these prices). I think it is likely more worth it than you realize.

We're not talking about criticizing, we're talking about bans.

whimsicalism··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
where there is a demand for results, academia will meet the supply
whimsicalism··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
This is technically explicitly a rule violation. Yes, yes we've been hearing it for years but it is much more true in the past 2-3 years than anytime in the past imo.

Frankly, it's a shame that the only high quality discussion I can find is on gross platforms like 'the everything app' or more obscure forums.

whimsicalism··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
i think this sentiment comes from a deep misunderstanding of how our modern society is the product of transitive satisfaction of wants. the developers churning out agent work on supergigaultramax effort are fulfilling the transitive preferences of people like supply chain managers, etc. who are in turn fulfilling the transitive preferences of a school teacher for cheap groceries, who are in turn....

This is how economies work and the alternative strategy of enumerating morally correct wants/needs and assigning the correct price from on-high has been a demonstrable failure. It is a cognitive failure of humanity that this strategy is so intuitively appealing to us.

whimsicalism··on Data centers raise nearby temperatures by up to 4 degrees in Phoenix
> The figures I've been seeing are something like half of all current private construction projects are data center related these days and it's the biggest single sector of construction in terms of money spent.

You view this as a measure of data center construction, I view this as a measure of how challenging we've made it to do absolutely anything in the US unless there are massive stacked financial incentives in favor of it.

whimsicalism··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
i don't think either of the first two things are generally true (usually tax positive, new usecases generally raise property value).

it sounds like you just want to ban American industry altogether, we've quietly let extreme conservatism sneak up on us in the US it seems.

whimsicalism··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
what if rather than enumerating the list of allowed/disallowed economic activities based on some moral criterion, we just tax the rich and redistribute it. i kinda thought this is what we spent the entirety of the 20th c. litigating but maybe i'm mistaken
whimsicalism··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
"i can't eat a cargo container so it's useless" -guy who can only see one level up the chain of abstractions that allow him to fill his belly.
whimsicalism··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
It's trumped up, pretty obviously. We basically low-growthed our way into a default sort of NIMBYism by the mid-90s and now there is pressure to build anything again and we are seeing the reaction.
whimsicalism··on Norway should buy OpenAI
I don't disagree with the sentiment but I think obviously negativity bias would be a significant cofounder.
whimsicalism··on Norway should buy OpenAI
There are definitely some weird mass psychological movements on the internet right now and I basically view this post as a wishcasting outcropping of this, stories the disempowered tell themselves.
whimsicalism··on Universal health coverage could save $1T and 114k lives a year: study
This study appears to just take observational mortality averages between insured and uninsured and then assume that UHC would close the gap. Patently absurd imo, but I guess I'm not a healthcare economist.
whimsicalism··on On AI regulation and messaging
Very much agreed - Dario is underestimating the current cultural zeitgeist and the power of scrollable video to make any narrative true. The amount of water, energy, copyrighted material, etc. that data centers actually consume is completely besides the point to be immaterial.
whimsicalism··on On AI regulation and messaging
Yes, you're running up against one of the pathologies of HN. I would recommend just disengaging, there's really no convincing..
whimsicalism··on Universal health coverage could save $1T and 114k lives a year: study
You would never see content like that on Reddit as it is far outside of the political valence there.
whimsicalism··on Universal health coverage could save $1T and 114k lives a year: study
You're actually talking about the same problem. Competition in healthcare is heavily restricted by stuff like certificates of need because there is little cost-sharing with utilizers so you get overutilization & induced demand. This is Roemer's law [0]. A large part of the reason for competition restrictions is because of a hacky attempt to control overutilization without direct cost-sharing.

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roemer%27s_law

whimsicalism··on Universal Health Coverage Could Save $1T and 114k Lives a Year, Yale Study
I'm earnestly curious what the alternatives to CU look like and what that would mean for for-profit companies like The New York Times?
whimsicalism··on Universal Health Coverage Could Save $1T and 114k Lives a Year, Yale Study
I'm honestly curious how we square this with the only experimental evidence we have on cost-sharing in the US, like the Oregon Medicaid Study and the RAND study which showed no impact on mortality or really any physical health outcomes at all.
whimsicalism··on Accelerating GPT-5.6 Sol Ultrafast
i assume they meant serially....
whimsicalism··on Grok Bot
I actually have set up something similar myself and it is much easier now that codex desktop for linux just came out (which has computer use/browser driving abilities). The issue is that on an rpi, I have to usually manually log into everything once.
whimsicalism··on Grok Bot
i just completely disagree. lots of people don't even have laptops and how will they keep my laptop alive and performing tasks while it's in my backpack on the subway not connected to internet?

i feel like there's an obvious advantage if your agent can work truly in the background

whimsicalism··on Grok Bot
This would imply you need to have your computer on in order for it to function, which seems like a deal breaker for many consumer usecases imo. I'd like to be able to say "order my groceries" and then I hop on the subway.
whimsicalism··on Grok Bot
How do they stop providers (like Amazon, etc.) from detecting and blocking these agents if they are running on cloud? I know that openai wasn't able to avoid this which is why they moved to 'computer use' on your local machine.

I almost wonder if this is a place where SpaceX, as an internet provider through starlink, has a unique advantage because websites are unable to block their networking as it could be residential starlink consumers.

whimsicalism··on Mojo 1.0
Sorry Chris, love you but will not use a closed language.
whimsicalism··on Compression is prediction
did the SSL cert expire? i'm getting a big scary warning about this blog
whimsicalism··on Nvidia Nemotron 3.5 Lightning and NeMo Switchyard
I think the path of least resistance will end up being the cheapest and that is scaling up the parameters a ridiculous amount until you get highly capable models that can develop/distill/design the RAM efficient models. Going straight for low param is foolish and just a cope by smaller labs because they don't have the compute/talent to train the large ones.

This is 100% true for pretrains, likely true for RL as well although maybe there is some benefit to smaller activated params there. There is of course 0 benefit to small dense models relative to large sparse ones that are equally as memory efficient if you have enough computers.

Many on HN are in deep denial about this imo.

whimsicalism··on Mistral Patent for “Code implemented tool calls”
i'm okay with participating in the software patent system for defensive purposes, but agreed that it is very stupid.
whimsicalism··on Smaller, faster, safer: running Kimi and GLM at scale
don't disagree, but there is a big difference between 'quantized model/weights' and quantized activations
whimsicalism··on Ten advances in mathematics and theoretical computer science
deflation will just be inflated away, always
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →