HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

whimsicalism

17,559 karma · joined October 2, 2020

i [care about improving people's lives | research inference on sequences for work] | opinions absolutely my own
submissionscomments
whimsicalism··on Anthropic apologizes for invisible Claude Fable guardrails
Maybe if you really squint. I'm asking them to reconsider their views because the cumulative result of many opinions is policy. And yes, I'm making moral claims. So perhaps that makes it religious? I don't really think so, but I recognize that comparing things to religion is an effective dismissal tactic on here.
whimsicalism··on Amazon Says Its Data Centers Use 2.5B Gallons of Water
My comment was in reply to the self-built renewable bit at the very end.

In terms of water, I also think that water is severely underpriced for a scarce resource.

whimsicalism··on Anthropic apologizes for invisible Claude Fable guardrails
EA essentially just is utilitarianism + a specific type of culture/community.
whimsicalism··on Anthropic apologizes for invisible Claude Fable guardrails
I think it is clear given the stakes why you would not want to make your guardrails probe-able/invertable.
whimsicalism··on Anthropic apologizes for invisible Claude Fable guardrails
I cannot overstate how much I think this take is wrong. Please please reconsider, look at the rate of progress being made, and consider that even if you only think ASI 'may' never happen in your lifetime it should still be one of your #1 concerns.

Honestly, that respect for 'copyright protections' has somehow become a leftist shibboleth is bizarre to me and indicative that something has become deeply warped in our discussions around this topic.

whimsicalism··on Anthropic apologizes for invisible Claude Fable guardrails
They are trying to guard against other people building ASI before they do because they think they are uniquely safety oriented relative to their competitors. Frankly, based on my knowledge of Anthropic and the people who work there, they are very possibly right. They care a ton about this in a way that is difficult for people outside this bubble to understand.
whimsicalism··on Anthropic apologizes for invisible Claude Fable guardrails
Excusing? Their comment is factually correct and the parent is factually wrong.
whimsicalism··on Anthropic apologizes for invisible Claude Fable guardrails
Guess FTX disproved the concept of giving to effective charities, time to start donating to my church again.
whimsicalism··on Amazon Says Its Data Centers Use 2.5B Gallons of Water
I hear that, but of course GPU compute is much more intensive than CPU & SSDs so they are touching on something real.
whimsicalism··on Amazon Says Its Data Centers Use 2.5B Gallons of Water
Just friggin tax carbon. The notion that we pick disfavored new industries and require them to bear the brunt of our renewable buildout is absurd and effectively a tax on the 'new'.

I see no reason we should grandfather in 'heritage carbon emitters' when we are emitting way more than we ought to.

whimsicalism··on Amazon Says Its Data Centers Use 2.5B Gallons of Water
I stand by it. If you only care about the climate for things that are socially rewarded (being anti-AI is, telling your friends to about the impact of eating beef or taking flights or other day to day activities is boooo you're being a buzzkill), you are being performative.

There's a reason certain types of misinformation become popular and others fizzle. The environmental concerns around AI are starting from the goal 'disliking AI' and going in search of a reason for many people. The environment is a convenient reason because it links to an existing left-wing cause & doesn't require conceding the frame of AI rapidly becoming extremely capable (scary! don't like to think about that!) so it's all comfort and outrage without stakes.

whimsicalism··on Amazon Says Its Data Centers Use 2.5B Gallons of Water
Yes, I'm extremely climate conscious and change my behavior around many things that I think have particularly high climate externalities. But ultimately, most of the people I know who are really concerned about this engage in extremely high externality behavior (flights, beef eating, etc.) regularly without even thinking about it. AI doesn't even come close and beyond that potentially enables a lot of solutions.
whimsicalism··on Amazon Says Its Data Centers Use 2.5B Gallons of Water
i find the climate/environment concern around AI so clearly performative and poorly calibrated that it actively angers me. moral panics are weird
whimsicalism··on Solar Energy Saves Europeans $135M a Day
interesting, so most power in Texas at night comes from batteries?
whimsicalism··on Solar Energy Saves Europeans $135M a Day
you can handle it with solar & gas alone
whimsicalism··on Solar Energy Saves Europeans $135M a Day
batteries are not yet competitive with fossil fuel
whimsicalism··on Leo's first encyclical attacks technological messianism
someone who knowingly/culpably rejects baptism is not going to purgatory. as a non-catholic, i think you are misinterpreting here.

this is verbatim from the Catechism,

> Baptism is necessary for salvation for those to whom the Gospel has been proclaimed and who have had the possibility of asking for this sacrament

Sure, there are other routes - but not for someone who has culpably rejected a water baptism. Again, from the Catechism,

> Purgatory is the state of those who die in God’s friendship, assured of their eternal salvation, but who still have need of purification to enter into the happiness of heaven.

> He himself explicitly asserted the necessity of faith and Baptism, and thereby affirmed at the same time the necessity of the Church which men enter through Baptism as through a door. Hence they could not be saved who, knowing that the Catholic Church was founded as necessary by God through Christ, would refuse either to enter it or to remain in it.336

Purgatory is not meant for those who culpably refused to enter, absolutely not.

whimsicalism··on Leo's first encyclical attacks technological messianism
What specifically is wrong?
whimsicalism··on Leo's first encyclical attacks technological messianism
I'm on your side, but I would argue many of the first computer discovered proofs might be called original proofs without intelligence, as they rely on massive programmatic case checking.
whimsicalism··on Leo's first encyclical attacks technological messianism
I would be far more interested in people making confident proclamations like this taking the notion of "what do we do if you are wrong" more seriously. I think you're wrong, I think it is fine to have the other belief, but you should at least start thinking about what is to be done if you are wrong.
whimsicalism··on Leo's first encyclical attacks technological messianism
It is interesting to see the progressive/left current in the US re-discover their close cousin in deontological christianity. It's obvious from an outside observer, as Nietzsche wrote on: these are both expressions of the slave revolt in morals.
whimsicalism··on Leo's first encyclical attacks technological messianism
> Techies have a weird way of thinking themselves world saviors and having poor binary decision making ability.

rich coming from a belief system that thinks everyone who had the opportunity to go through their water-dunking ritual and culpably didn't is automatically going to be tortured in the underworld for eternity.

whimsicalism··on Leo's first encyclical attacks technological messianism
the correct usage is dashes on both sides of the word, the usage above was extra confusing because it was incorrect
whimsicalism··on Leo's first encyclical attacks technological messianism
I use it, but you're supposed to hyphenate on both sides so this usage was incorrect.
whimsicalism··on Microsoft Office 2019 and 2021 for Mac view-only conversion
why do people build bots like ^ what is the motive?
whimsicalism··on EU fines Temu €200M for allowing sale of illegal products
yes, i'm very in favor of the shift towards direct-to-consumer among chinese retailers, but that might be because i'm not actually all that sympathetic to small business
whimsicalism··on Big tech's anti-labor playbook has come for Wikipedia
feeling better because your job fits better in your moral framework that you get from society is a status-mediated effect and i feel you can usually find social scaffolding under things that are articulated as purely intrinsic.
whimsicalism··on Big tech's anti-labor playbook has come for Wikipedia
both my parents worked for non-profits their entire lives
whimsicalism··on Big tech's anti-labor playbook has come for Wikipedia
absolutely and i'm surprised that you don't think so.

e: and to your edit, i'm talking about social/moral status

whimsicalism··on Big tech's anti-labor playbook has come for Wikipedia
people enjoy doing high-status things and will trade off pay for status. asking for equal pay as low-status work is essentially asking to have your cake and eat it too
← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →