HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

whitemale

13 karma · joined January 1, 2017

submissionscomments
whitemale··on How political data teams game Google to fool people
Maybe you didn't do it on purpose, but what you are doing is called nitpicking.

> nouninformal > fussy or pedantic fault-finding. > "nitpicking over tiny details"

> As far as I understand, it claims that it is the right-wing that has embraced it to a wider extent. And that is something that we have seen in late elections and referendums.

The original paragraph: "Is the solution - as the OP implies - for the left / center left to adopt the same dirty tactics as their counterparts? Is there any alternative?"

Clearly implies that according to the op, the left have yet to adopt the "dirty tactics".

whitemale··on Tesla fires female engineer who alleged sexual harassment
> In a statement to the Guardian, Tesla confirmed the company had fired Vandermeyden, saying it had thoroughly investigated the employee’s allegations with the help of a “a neutral, third-party expert” and concluded her complaints were unmerited.

> “Despite repeatedly receiving special treatment at the expense of others, Ms Vandermeyden nonetheless chose to pursue a miscarriage of justice by suing Tesla and falsely attacking our company in the press,” a Tesla spokesperson said. “After we carefully considered the facts on multiple occasions and were absolutely convinced that Ms Vandermeyden’s claims were illegitimate, we had no choice but to end her employment at Tesla.”

She tried to bully people utilising identity politics, the company got fed up and fired here. Too bad Tesla didn't also sue her back, it's a real shame that criminals like herself can get away with it, just because they are women. This encourages women to start weaponizing sexual harassment claims, they can gain a lot by bullying a company, yet they have nothing to lose.

whitemale··on Airbnb Employees Speak Out About Bullying and ‘Toxic’ Work Environment
> Logically speaking, it would also be a mistake to dismiss every report of poor employee treatment where those selection biases apply.

Remarkable claims require remarkable evidence, claims that are made without evidence, can be dismissed without evidence.

If a handful of people complain out of thousands and there is no hard evidence, then I see no reason not to just dismiss it.

whitemale··on At Google, an Employee-Run Email List Tracks Harassment and Bias Complaints
> the courtesy of possibly being mistaken and instead cast my position as a strawman prepared to burn for being wrong.

I thought you intentionally used 'systematic', the word 'systemic' actually makes your argument weaker.

> Though I am not surprised

Why are you not surprised, are all people just bad who don't blindly agree with you?

> For instance, your middle response (whether you are aware of it or not) excuses insults as exempt from being racist simply because the objective is to maximize harm, which is itself a pretty inflammatory proposition.

No, it does not excuse insults, insults of all form are bad. What I said is: when picking insults, you pick the one that hurts the most, because at that point, your objective is to do the most damage.

Just because someone utters the word 'nigger' does not make them racist. Otherwise Kanye and everyone who sings along would be racist, see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gG_dA32oH44 .

> Furthermore, you are keen on tearing my viewpoint apart without providing evidence of your own to show that yes, America is living in a post-race society.

The burden of proof is on the one making the positive claim.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_burden_of_proof

If I tell you the Earth is diamond shaped, I can't really expect you to believe it without some hard evidence.

If you say that society is still racist, you are the one who needs to point out why, I'm not the one who needs to point out why not.

> Notably, you actually did do this with the original anecdote about having a black president. Notably, you actually did do this with the original anecdote about having a black president. And, to disprove your point, the burden is on me to find a proof by contradiction, which I supplied also in the form of an anecdote.

The original claim: white men are privileged My reply to that: some of the most privileged people are black and/or women therefore that statement cannot be true

> Rather than acknowledge this, you instead replied that I was a hypocrite, a response I figured was not one worth responding to. If your defense is an ad homenim, I see no reason to engage further.

I used a few examples to disprove a generalised statement, you tried to use an example to reinforce a generalised statement. If you look at all my comments, I never imply that there is absolute 0 racism and sexism in the world, my issue is when people generalise and start pointing at mystical hidden 'systems'.

> (Rooted in strawman)

More like rooted in you choosing the wrong word.

> Who are you to dismiss their concerns when they give a clear signal this is a problem?

How does my character have anything to do with the ridiculousness of this claim? Who are they? Where is the study that proves out this is an actual issue?

I can find women who get offended if I complement them on their looks, does that make this sexist even if majority of the women would actually enjoy that?

> (A question that is a huge signal to your underlying intentions: to signal you disapprove of my viewpoint and never a chance to exchange ideas, and that you have won)

The intention was not to stop the conversation, I was pointing out that your arguments so far are incredibly weak, if you have better ones, I'm happy to debate them.

> Casting this as a me-versus-you is disengagement and disinterest on your part. I want to share, you want to win

It's not me-versus-you, it's me pointing out that people with similar opinions have trouble when they receive basic questions.

Examples: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCpfOW3vhZbPMsPHa8TGjL1Q/vid...

> Language matters.

It doesn't invalidate points though, just because I use harsh(for people worried about PC) constructs doesn't mean what I'm saying is wrong.

Trump won the election, despite his incredibly hostile and offensive style of discourse.

I worry more about the points I'm making than the style or tone.

whitemale··on At Google, an Employee-Run Email List Tracks Harassment and Bias Complaints
> Systemic doesn't imply directed, it can also be used to mean it is deeply embedded in the system.

The original comment used the wrong word. So what does this mean? are all white males part of this system that is designed to keep women down?

> It is one common example of a pervasive mindset that informs all kinds of actions

Can you name those all kinds of actions? If I go today and tell a female to smile more, can you tell me what dark path will that lead to? I would be also keen on seeing solid proof that connects telling women to smile more to the tragedies that women have to endure on a daily basis. Also, is telling women to smile less the way to fix all these problems?

> including seeing and treating women as decoration.

Treating them as decoration where and how? Also, are you familiar with this thing called biology and evolution? Members of species of the opposite sex judge potential mates based on a appearance (among other things).

Did you also stop to think that women might be equally or more judgemental about looks.

See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Ylmg9zrEDo

> Women can be sexist and perpetuate sexism too.

Or maybe it's just not really sexist.

> People do. This isn't zero sum though - people can protest that and other issues that are ongoing simultaneously.

What I meant is: protest against racism in areas where there is actual racism and don't just point the finger at anyone, you won't win people that way.

whitemale··on At Google, an Employee-Run Email List Tracks Harassment and Bias Complaints
> Systematic sexism

systematic

Done or acting according to a fixed plan or system; methodical.

Source: https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/systematic

If this is systematic, then I guess you can tell me who is in charge of this plan or system? What is the goal of this plan or system and who does it benefit and how?

> thousands of men telling women to "smile more" at work to look prettier

Is this the biggest issue in women's lives today? If these are the biggest problems we have, I would say we are in a really great place.

Also, what about women telling women the same thing?

> Is it acceptable to be openly racist? Yes, in certain parts of America. My grandparents' county courthouse had a KKK rally to celebrate census results showing no minorities lived there. This was early 2000s.

Do reports on it. Call them out and protest there instead of places where there is hardly any racism. Call out specific regions and people, don't just say that, well everybody's racist, because this will not get people on your side.

> Also, I'm not going to keep discussing this with you mich further

So these were your best arguments?

> as all your responses are not conveying a genuine desire to discuss and consider arguments you disagree with, which is frankly a waste of both our time.

I have no idea where you got that idea from, I was just raising genuine questions and counter points that most people with the same opinion as you are having trouble answering.

You can't expect me to accept the existence of things like "Systematic sexism" if you can't define what it is, and prove it.

If your views are on solid ground, you should have no trouble defending them.

whitemale··on At Google, an Employee-Run Email List Tracks Harassment and Bias Complaints
> most adults are able to be disagreeable without using a slur, such as us

The whole point of an insult is to get the other side angry, not necessarily for it to have roots in reality. I do agree that it's not a good way to have an argument. If I want to insult you I'll look at what hurts you the most.

Here is something that's not being called out as racist:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g5ulvcqaiM8

> I would say sexism wouldn't exist if people could disagree on merits of discussion instead of any insults (which, by nature of personal attack, immediately invokes all *isms of the victim).

Sexism exists because:

- there are a few actually sexist males and females out there see: https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=marissa+mayer+gender+bias&...

- biology is sexist and there is little we can do about that

- sexism can be used as a great excuse for failing and it can be weaponized, you can threaten your boss that you'll call him sexist if you, the female don't get the promotion instead of the more qualified male

What I don't believe exists is: systematic sexism, that I believe is made up to be the ultimate excuse for everything.

> there's a huge difference between insulting someone because of their perceived character ("asshole") with little cultural baggage, and insulting someone for being literally in their own skin with a word that has huge cultural baggage

There is no difference if your objective is to hurt the other person's feelings, you pick whichever is most effective.

> Finally, I do agree that the lashing out against Trump supporters is bad. Just as it was bad that Obama supporters also had to put up with burning crosses in their frontyards when he was elected. Both sides can't see this sucks for everyone at different times for some reason and it's a stupid cycle.

I mostly noticed this from Hilary supporters, it's not an eye for an eye thing: http://blog.samaltman.com/what-i-heard-from-trump-supporters

> continued ignorance of believing we are in some post-race society

Do we have slavery? No

Is it acceptable to be openly racist? No

What is your criteria for a 'post-race society'? What other checkboxes do we need to hit to get there?

whitemale··on At Google, an Employee-Run Email List Tracks Harassment and Bias Complaints
Is making fun of a group of people and having no hatred towards them the same thing as actually hating that group?

If I tell a joke about black/asian/latino/<insert your favourite race or ethnicity here> then I'm automatically racist, then I'm exactly the same thing as the KKK and the Westboro Baptist Church?

whitemale··on At Google, an Employee-Run Email List Tracks Harassment and Bias Complaints
What is your definition of racism?
whitemale··on At Google, an Employee-Run Email List Tracks Harassment and Bias Complaints
> Racism and systemic oppression didn't get solved just because you can cherrypick examples well.

And then you just cherry picked an example:

> ...and when he was reelected president, the Free Expression tunnel at NC State was spray painted with the confederate battle flag background, his "Hope" pose portrait, and in huge bold black letters the word "NIGGER".

Good job for being consistent!

> I don't see non-white people oppressing white people because Trump is in power, calling them/him a "cracker" or other slurs, on the same continuous intensity

Trump is being called names all the time, they even call Trump voters deplorable.

> Racism and systemic oppression

If this so called systematic oppression would exists, than how did Obama get elected? It seems to me that even if there is systemic racism, it's ineffective.

whitemale··on At Google, an Employee-Run Email List Tracks Harassment and Bias Complaints
How does society treat people as whole? can you explain what advantage do non-white-males have over everyone else?

> Citing individual examples doesn't discount macro trends

Sorry mate, if you look at statistics, Asians earn more in America than 'whites', so I guess we should start calling Asians privileged then, right?

whitemale··on At Google, an Employee-Run Email List Tracks Harassment and Bias Complaints
> privileged white men like myself

The former president of the US was a black man, he was arguably in one of the most privileged positions in the US / World.

The current Chancellor of Germany happens to be a women, which is the most privileged positions in Europe.

I'm also sure that you will find a lot of white men who lack anything that can be considered privilege.

> why people might submit anonymously to such a list > This trope of jumping immediately to the problem of false accusations is sadly common in discussions e.g. of rape reporting. Yes, some reports of rape (and harassment) are untrue. The vast majority aren't.

Even if a rape accusation turns out to be false, the damage is done, and nobody will care about your "privileged white men" because they don't have enough victim creds.

whitemale··on Patent Application: Full body teleportation system (2006)
Your stream of consciousness is interrupted when you sleep, so with that logic you technically die every night.

> But most people don't have that sort of objectivity.

Where did you get that idea from?

> If you're comfortable dying so that a copy of you can live the rest of your life, that's your business.

You will eventually die and (hopefully) a partial copy of you(children) will continue living on and you don't even have a choice about it.

whitemale··on Uber hit by legal setback in Europe
> As an European? Yes. > Things were evolving fine in Europe; from our POV, Uber isn't doing anything innovative - they're just a personal transportation company (we have those) with a cute app (we have those) that tries to outcompete everyone by unilaterally deciding that laws don't apply to them.

If you believe that taxis are getting better in Europe, see the following video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dl2QcEOIdHg

Sorry, I couldn't find proper English captions, however the numbers are still clear.

The person who made the video, made 4 trips from the same point A to point B and these are the prices he had to pay for the same exact journey:

- 1250 HUF - 2000 HUF - 2500 HUF - 5950 HUF

None of the drivers provided a receipt willingly. Meanwhile Uber cost 1105 HUF.

Note that: taxi tariffs are regulated in Budapest, yet it clearly doesn't stop drivers from overcharging unsuspecting foreigners.

whitemale··on The Boring Company [video]
> Why does everyone lack imagination on this topic?

You are right, I imagine that we should just have teleporting gates!

> if you drive to the subway

How about not driving to the subway? how about having local buses or that can take you there?

> where do you park your car

Car parks next to the station?

> how do you get to your destination once you get off the subway if it's not walking distance?

Buses or trams.

> Currently - people just drive.

Not everywhere, look at London for example.

> We could drill more regular roadways

No we can't, tunnels are expensive and bring a whole new set of problems like how do you handle an accident, how do you get to the surface etc.

> subway-like transport of passengers, or entire vehicles

That is horribly inefficient in terms of space and weight, average car weight is ~2 tons.

> powered electrically

Having it electrically powered does not mean that it's clean energy.

whitemale··on Reflecting on one very, very strange year at Uber
> I immediately took screenshots of these chat messages and reported him to HR.

Instead of just telling the guy never to make such a proposal again.

> this was clearly sexual harassment and he was propositioning me

You might as well call it gang rape. Sure it's one of the most idiotic ways to talk to women, however it's nowhere near a level that deserves to be called harassment, it also only happened once. I remember watching a video where a guy tapped a woman on the shoulder and people will calling it sexual assault.

It's a real shame that everything has to be about sex and race nowadays, I would rather talk about the rest of the article where she talks about corruption inside the company.

whitemale··on The Mark Zuckerberg Manifesto Is a Blueprint for Destroying Journalism
> In my opinion. If anything is destroying journalism, it's the fact that half this country does not care for fact vs fiction.

Too bad we don't know which half and which news is fiction.

> If some guy with a catchy domain name can produce content that goes viral, it doesn't matter how many Pulitzer the NYTimes has.

The NYTimes can have all the awards in the world if they publish articles that you can demonstrate beyond doubt to be bullshit or dishonesty.

> If anything, as someone who actually cares about facts, the latest changes in my Facebook newsfeed has gotten me to read a lot more publications because my friends are sharing stories from journals I don't normally read.

You should always look at what the other side has to offer, I talk to people who have polar opposite beliefs to mine on a regular basis, keeps me informed and makes me re-evaluate my own position.

whitemale··on How to Close a Gender Gap: Let Employees Control Their Schedules
http://www.chicksontheright.com/audi-accidentally-disproves-...

> @Audi You pay your female employees less than males? You know that's against the law, right?

> @TueborFrog When we account for all the various factors that go into pay, women at Audi are on par with their male counterparts.

I think that says it all.

Instead of worrying about wages, how about letting people do what they want and maybe fix the broken work culture that favours people who pretend to work hard?

whitemale··on Time to Take a Stand
Trump was bragging, it's something men do under circumstances.

If you would be a famous rockstar and women(or men) would be all over you, would taking advantage of it be a "nasty deed"?

whitemale··on Time to Take a Stand
> I think it's shameful to have an open Trump supporter as part of the upper echelons of YCombinator (Thiel).

I think it's shameful to bring politics into tech, it also goes against all that inclusivity talks that people give. Are we going to only allow people into tech if they subscribe to a particular political belief?

> Everyone is entitled to their opinions. But when you openly support a candidate who likes to "grab [women] by the pussy"

It's called bragging, it's what people do, and they make stuff up along the way, here is an example:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9oVoJMVsKtk

If you convict every single man in the US who has made such a statement, you would not have many left.

> how will female and muslim applicants feel if they know part of their process might be controlled by someone who finds this acceptable?

How do you think female rape victims who have been raped by muslims feel about this? I also find it funny that you played the muslim and the female card in one paragraph, go on the internet and look up how women are being treated by most muslim countries.

whitemale··on Time to Take a Stand
The word you are looking for is concerned not affected. As you yourself pointed out, so far he hasn't done anything that actually affects you. If you want people to take you seriously, you need to not play the victim card and instead make rational arguments.
whitemale··on Time to Take a Stand
> This false equivalence convinced people to vote for Trump.

"false equivalence" is a non-argument used by Hilary supporters to sidestep proving that she is objectively better than Trump, after it is correctly pointed out that she is not an angel from heaven either.

> No way Hillary would have implemented this ban.

This is a misleading statement that you can't even prove, because it requires you to either be a mind reader or being able to travel to an alternate reality. For the sake of argument though let's assume that she wouldn't have performed this action, can you prove that she wouldn't have done worst things? She gets money from Saudi Arabia, you would have a hard time proving that she can do no bad.

whitemale··on White House fails to make case that Russian hackers tampered with election
> I would believe the govt in this case, mostly because openly blaming another country for this is polically somewhat dangerous.

Not if the other country is being painted as the devil by the media.

> Blaming anyone and publicly admitting that your governments fundamental democracy was compromised is not to be taken lightly.

Democrats lost, instead of admitting defeat, instead of reflecting on what happened and realise where did they fail, they just blame it on the Russians. Was the fundamental democracy not compromised when the "grab em' by the pussy" audio leaked? I didn't see anyone going after that.

whitemale··on US Govt Data Shows Russia Used Outdated Ukrainian PHP Malware
> So claiming all of this was about propaganda really makes no sense given the facts on the ground.

Where are those facts? please show hard evidence. So far I haven't seen any hard evidence that proves it was the state of Russia who orchestrated the hacks.

> And please remember why Russia's relations with almost all of the world deteriorated in the first place. It's because they annexed Crimea (unprecedented for our generation) and allowed soldiers and weapons to flood into Ukraine which then resulted in Flight 117 being shot down.

If you believe that Russia is absolutely bad and the US and Ukraine are infinitely good and righteous, then you might want to look at what the other side says: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-KHCNk9BYy4

The fact that the majority of the Crimean population is Russian, should give you a hint that maybe there is more to this story than what the Western media says.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crimea#Demographics

I have yet to see Putin making an aggressive announcement, however US officials continuously keep making threats and sanctions.

> Nobody is looking for a fight with Russia but capitulating and doing nothing is not an answer either. Diplomatic sanctions have been the correct response and I don't see anyone asking for an escalation of that.

Destroying diplomatic relations and throwing sanctions sound like looking for a fight to me. I fail to see anything good coming out of this.

whitemale··on White House fails to make case that Russian hackers tampered with election
When the US does it to other countries it's good, when it happens to the US, it's tampering with democracy. Also, it's not like Russia created the corruption inside the democratic party. If the democrats would have been as innocent as they pretend, then maybe Russia's tampering attempt would have had no effect.

This whole narrative is a distraction from the real issue.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2