HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

whoisninja

218 karma · joined October 28, 2011

submissionscomments
whoisninja··on I've reproduced 130 research papers about “predicting the stock market”
the author is trying to sell crypto trading bot ! looks shady to me if anything guarantees you profit, run away from it as fast as you can : https://credium.io/

https://towardsdatascience.com/crypto-trading-bots-a-helpful...

whoisninja··on I've reproduced 130 research papers about “predicting the stock market”
i asked the author where did he source his data, his reply was "i scraped data"

how can you scrape pricing data? not every data in this is on public domain, otherwise there would be no Bloombergs, CapitalIQs selling data for millions(sure they're overrated and overpriced but still!). Or in other words, if he is right - he can sell data and make millions. no need of looking for an investment strategy. just my skeptical side saying :)

you need clean data to accurately test ideas. for instance getting tick data is quite expensive. most universities have free access to Bloomberg, CapitalIQ etc. datasets the reason professors can test and also the reason some smart guys in the industry work for university on the side

whoisninja··on I've reproduced 130 research papers about “predicting the stock market”
more important than this study if done correctly is the fact that he built a framework that can ingest all this data and that he had access to all these datasets

typical hedge fund spends millions of dollars in order to build such frameworks and buying datasets, sure most academic papers fail if you replicate but the framework and datasets are very valuable because you can eventually find something on your own or an improvement on existing ideas if you keep trying hard enough + there are other sources of ideas like quant research from brokers, ideas from platforms like quantopian etc. but yea in general if you have an outstanding idea that works - you would have very less or no incentive to publish it. why would jim simons have his researchers publish anything when they can make money for him all day long everyday ... just my 2 cents.

whoisninja··on Schneier on Blockchain, and Trust
and.... there's massive amt of electricity used in gold mining(and toxic for environment for how it's done) and so many banks employing millions of people and using so much computation to print money out of thin air (debt issuance, fractional reserve, derivatives, fiat-backed by just trust on your govt, artificially low interest rates, modern monetary theory - you name it) it is not sustainable dear sir.

Forget Bitcoin and crypto and tech, have you ever thought about that problem? It could very well be one of the biggest mess our society is in at a global scale.

whoisninja··on Schneier on Blockchain, and Trust
he's spot on about private blockchains

he's also spot on about Ethereum and other alts

he's not absolutely right about Bitcoin. If there's a hard money that is better than gold, and that's backed by electricity --- it solves lot of problems dear sir ! please try to understand that aspect. For the love of technology and logic.

Please read Bitcoin Standard once, of course it is massive experiment that can fail but saying that it is useless dis-credits the efforts of many bright computer scientists working in this field. Yes 95% is scam and most are conmans, but that is true with any greenfield area. AI must had, security must had scams.

whoisninja··on India reportedly wants to build its own WhatsApp for government communications
it will be hacked in a day
whoisninja··on New research on the cost of colonization to India
it is defrauding and if you consider the atrocities, shady unethical ways to enslave mass population, the Bengal famine of 1943 - you should be shocked

the so called "sir" winston churchill was after all a mass murderer in a sense. of course it is about power and exercising power, India should have fought back harder to protect itself

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bengal_famine_of_1943

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/world-history/winst...

whoisninja··on Coinbase is exploring the addition of new currencies
Finally, lightning network seems to be having a good growth at the moment, if it holds up for another year or two - i think Bitcoin will be in a very sound position for adoption in places where it is most needed. Financial markets will def react accordingly at that point. Until then I think it will cycles of busts/capitulation with speculators and wall-streeters.
whoisninja··on Coinbase is exploring the addition of new currencies
I should also mention that biggest technical debate to understand right now is scaling in this space for most part. Smart contracts is not that big of deal at the moment IMO. These are all open-source developments, adding proven features from one to other is always going to happen over time.

For scaling - you need to read understand a bit about pros and cons of on-chain scaling(ex. bigger block sizes,proof of stake, sharding etc.) and off-chain scaling (ex. layer2/lightning).

You might be surprised to learn that Bitcoin might be the only one or at least one of a couple that has/have the right fundamentals in terms of technology, which of course can still fail.

whoisninja··on Coinbase is exploring the addition of new currencies
this site only indicates how much it will cost per hour to sustain the attack. it is unknown how long it could really take for attack to be successful, also as others pointed out - there's no incentive But yes, most of these garbage tokens can be attacked. But it is quite evident to me that eventually people will understand that it is just Bitcoin that they need to follow to keep up to date with the field of cryptocurrencies. Others claim to bring cool concepts and technology but in actuality they don't work or are a messed up very large software project like Ethereum (and tons of projects don't are simply forks with no further development)
whoisninja··on Coinbase is exploring the addition of new currencies
they're doing so so that their same investors who have investments in these garbage tokens, can off load them - and leave retail people holding those bags full of non-sense.

Ethereum and 1000 other coins have simply created too much hype first and then bad reputation for the original cryptocurrency i.e. Bitcoin. There are people who think Ethereum is Bitcoin 2.0 but they don't understand that Bitcoin is built with the strongest fundamentals.

First of before making guesses, if you really want to know about this industry - try the applications, try to play with it (even if you put $10) - run full nodes, try wallets, try sending transactions. Trust me it is fun and you understand the basics then.

Secondly, separate out the financial markets side from the technology and it's potential itself. Even gold use-case initiated at some point in history. Not everyone started thinking of gold as store of value, so initially it price must have fluctuated quite a bit as well.

Third, try to understand how Bitcoin actually works - what is proof of work and why it is such an innovative idea to implement a decentralized network. I mean this is a very large network with almost 100% uptime, close to 10 years of history, storing Billions of dollars of worth of value and that people have moved 100s of millions of dollars worth Bitcoin with very little tx cost and time. I mean this alone requires a lot of credit as technology - no one needs an affirmation from someone like Jamie Dimon to know it is valuable or not - he doesn't know, no one does at this point. Statistically speaking, most experiments fail so it is a risk-averse position for someone in that position to say it will fail IMO. But opinions don't matter. Rome was not built in a day. Even the central banks and modern banks were not built in a day. Whatever these cryptocurrencies can replace or improve, let them take their due course or even if they fail. People are too much stuck on the financial market side of it, it is important to bootstrap it and take it mainstream but what happened in 2017 was a unsustainable and hack-ish way of bringing hype to this industry.

Please read if you're really interested : book:Bitcoin standard, please read works of Nick Szabo, read upon origins of digital money and cypherpunks behind Bitcoin

whoisninja··on Launch HN: The Buttermilk Company (YC S18) – Homemade Indian Food in 5 Minutes
Only suggestion in my opinion that matters : the food has to really taste great. Instant foods taste like hell generally. So this has to be significantly better.

Specially with Indian food, most Indians cook from scratch and the food only tastes good if cooked fresh with raw items/whole spices.

whoisninja··on Bitcoin’s Price Was Artificially Inflated Last Year, Researchers Say
wall streeters are liars, opinionated and biased bunch, if there was any manipulation in unregulated crypto markets because they were nascent shouldn't surprise you, why? ponder upon the following:

home prices were not artificially inflated during 2008 crisis

usd or other fiat currencies are not artificially inflated (hint: negative interest rates)

stock buybacks are not artificially inflating stock prices

negative interest rates and bond buyback programs are not inflating economies

hedge funds are not inflated, they just market themselves with buzz words like quant investing, alpha etc. yet most of them can't beat S&P and charge 2-20

business of banks are not inflated, they use 50 year old technology like mainframes and are overstaffed and charge $50 to wire $10 internationally

tech companies are not inflated, they sell your freaking data and sell you ads so that you can buy $hit you don't need

---- where there are humans involved, there will be greed

whoisninja··on Bitcoin is a Ponzi Scheme – Ajit Vadakayil
lame, pointless, ignorant

there's nothing more transparent that bitcoin. if you don't believe simply don't run a full node and enjoy your fiat money and the cycles of boom and busts(the real ponzi). The Keynesian economics is a money printing from thin air and never ending debt. good luck with hoarding fiat money.

the argument that gold is not volatile is childish, writer doesn't understand basic concepts (senseless copy pasting from wikipedia etc), when only a few hands were trading gold in its infancy, it must have be super volatile. simple math and economics that the writer can't comprehend

whoisninja··on A summary of what quantitative trading firms do
Because then one of the most successful quant funds like twosigma and rentec are not doing quant trading since hft is only small portion of their business. You cannot manage 50B in an hft strategy single handedly. The author lives in a different dimension, but my dimension could be wrong!
whoisninja··on A summary of what quantitative trading firms do
This alludes that all quantitative trading is high frequency trading. I would think all high frequency trading is quantitative trading but converse is not always true.
← PreviousPage 4 of 4