I am now genuinely curious to know how this is to be achieved, and what safeguards/guarantees are to be encoded so the new org does not devolve into the existing police.
295 karma · joined December 26, 2018
I am now genuinely curious to know how this is to be achieved, and what safeguards/guarantees are to be encoded so the new org does not devolve into the existing police.
I am just curious at this choice of word that seems to be the clarion call, which means entirely different in the dictionary than what is being implied! :-/
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/nsa-i...
I can relate to this article -- my daughter went through programming courses in school (Bay Area public schools are full of these crazy STEM courses), but she did not understand a thing of constructing software. All they learnt was a bunch of syntax, and a bunch of solved problems. I think they will do much better if the STEM courses focus less on a "programming language" and more on "problem solving and thinking software" (I just made this up now). :-)
It may be worthwhile to spend time understanding this closed culture, the decision making, and its overall impact on the business. I recommend reading "The Culture Map" by Erin Meyer.
These tests are nothing but CISOs'(and Red Teams, and the whole industry around it) justifying their existence, and potentially doing a song-and-dance about it at the quarterly all-hands. Nothing more, nothing less. We can come back to this thread in another year/two years/five years/decade, and I can bet dollars-to-doughnuts, the industry will still be training humans, and claiming these pointless statistics about phishing. ;-)
On this note, see #6 "Educating Users", in Marcus Ranum's excellent article "The Six Dumbest Ideas in Computer Security": https://www.ranum.com/security/computer_security/editorials/...
Where are the problems to be fixed? I can see glossy bios' of mentors and their song-and-dance about how great this is, but it seems a PR gimmick from Mozilla.
Basically, don't try to solve a problem by humans when it can be solved more efficiently by technology!
Phishing exercises are absolutely pointless in my experience and contribute zero to increasing the awareness. Shaming does not address the underlying human weaknesses that make us fall for phishing, they simply make the IT Guys look cooler, and increase CISOs' and Red Team budget. :-(
Sadly, this also undermines trust in the overall state of "security research", which most of the time, borders on being silly. :-/
While I do understand your point, it still does not justify encouraging modern-day Robinhoods' and breaking the law.
[1] https://www.amazon.com/Programming-Language-2nd-Brian-Kernig... [2] https://www.amazon.in/Programming-Language-Kernighan-Dennis-...
And yes, as someone stated, privaty equity companies want to make money from their investments, believing anything else as their "goal" is utter foolish.
1984 it is indeed.
For e.g., even though TLS is end-to-end secure (and I don't doubt that), a website that uses CloudFlare front [1] is susecptible to its secure traffic being intercepted by CloudFlare, because by-design TLS would be terminated at CloudFlare servers'. However, note that the end-user does not notice that, rather he sees his traffic end-to-end encrypted.
[1] https://support.cloudflare.com/hc/en-us/articles/200170416-E...