HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

whyenot

7,851 karma · joined November 29, 2009

submissionscomments
whyenot··on Meta launches Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp subscriptions
Maybe this was something country or region specific. I don’t remember ever seeing ads for TV, Red, or other products with my US premium subscription. Now, some channels will promote specific products in their videos (like the mini ads some do for square space, nordvpn, etc), but YouTube, now has a button you can click to jump over that garbage.
whyenot··on 'Backrooms' Stuns with $81M Debut
As someone already mentioned. Steam for movies already exists (iTunes, also Amazon’s offering). The problem seems to be that hardly anyone wants to actually own a movie anymore. There are places where the ownership model seems to still be thriving (books), but for video and audio, ownership (vs. streaming or renting) is largely dead.
whyenot··on YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
Hopefully it will allow you to filter out AI slop. TikTok currently does not do this, and it’s infuriating.
whyenot··on Tennessee man jailed 37 days for Trump meme wins settlement after lawsuit
I agree, and any time there is a security breach, bug or other employee-caused calamity at a tech company that results in a lawsuit or settlement, the money should come out of employee 401k accounts, stock options, etc. These people need to police themselves. By aligning incentives it will encourage the good developers and force out the bad ones.
whyenot··on Shutterstock to pay $35M over hard-to-cancel subscriptions
Because it is not obviously theft. If you are getting a discount for making a year-long commitment, and then cancel, breaking that commitment, isn't a cancelation fee appropriate?
whyenot··on Too dangerous or just too expensive? The real reason Anthropic is hiding Mythos
It's probably a little of both: dangerous and expensive. This article makes a good case that the cost is at least part of the reason.

I wish the article could have been a lot tighter and shorter. This is not earth shattering information that requires a New Yorker length piece of investigative journalism.

whyenot··on The AI zombification of universities
You give exams in person, in class, on blue books, no phones. This part isn't hard. Instructors have been doing it for generations. It's only in the post COVID era that some have moved to having exams take home and on Canvas or similar platforms. This is great for instructors -- less work! but I am not convinced it actually helps students.

The part that is more difficult is take-home work, and I think the solution is that instead of being something that you turn in for credit, it needs to move to being more of a chance to practice for in-person exams.

What about essays? I've taught classes where students had to write essays in class, in person. On paper, with a pen (this may no longer be allowed on many campuses because of access and perceived fairness reasons, which IMO is a shame, but it is what it is). I think the traditional assignment of "write a 15 page paper on XYZ" is probably done. Instead students will have to prepare to write an essay in class by reading the source material (books, papers, etc) and converse with AIs that are hopefully not hallucinating, to get an understanding of the material and then come to class and be prepared to write about it.

It's a new world, but one we can adapt to.

whyenot··on In-person examinations at Princeton will be proctored starting July 1
> Despite HN trendiness, SV and business world advocacy of 'animal instincts', and current cultural trends, humans are generally honest and honorable

I personally believe this (that people are generally honest and good). BUT, the numbers don't lie: 30% of Princeton students admit to having cheated on an exam. This is a "your house is on fire" moment. An honor code has has to be enforced, and that is apparently not happening at Princeton. Frankly, as someone working at a school that also has an honor code (most do, in my experience), that is where the problem lies: if you turn a blind eye to violators, it sends the message to everyone that the honor code is just words, it doesn't mean anything.

whyenot··on Princeton mandates proctoring for in-person exams, upending 133 year precedent
It's a nice saying, but the "head" changes every 4-8 years and this is a problem that has gotten worse over decades. Sometimes the rot doesn't start from the head.
whyenot··on Meta employees protest against mouse tracking tech at US offices
No it isn't. It's a collective negotiation between workers and their employer.
whyenot··on Meta employees protest against mouse tracking tech at US offices
No. I am not paying $1,000s in dues for them to spend it on a rally to "End Child Poverty" (to use an example currently in my inbox; and it's a good cause, just not a good use of my dues). My union exists to represent and protect me and my coworkers. Nothing more, nothing less. ...at least thats the way in should be, IMO.
whyenot··on Meta employees protest against mouse tracking tech at US offices
Like most state employees, I am in a union and while there are MANY things I do not like about my union, from its high dues, to its constant forays into politics, to the supine pose it takes to contract negotiations, there is one thing that it does very well, and that is stands up against BS like this in a very meaningful way. Tech workers need a union or some union-like organization that stands up for basic worker rights.
whyenot··on Meta's embrace of AI is making its employees miserable
> It's no surprise we're in a moment of extreme labor disdain.

So sad to think that a generation or two ago, everyone wanted to emulate the HP Way. Now all of that is gone and unless you are a superstar, you're just a commodity to be managed, and extinguished when the time comes.

whyenot··on David Attenborough's 100th Birthday
A lot, especially in organismal biology / field biology. We even name things after him, like carnivorous plants (Nepenthes attenboroughii), the whole genus Sirdavida, a hawkweed (Hieracium attenboroughianum), ... more than 50 taxa in all.

The unfortunate thing is that the area of biology he has drawn people to is difficult to make a living in. Jobs are few, there is intense compettion for them, they don't pay well, and there is often little job security. In some ways it is the Art History of a STEM discipline.

whyenot··on Canvas online again as ShinyHunters threatens to leak schools’ data
Isn't that due to FERPA related concerns?
whyenot··on I want to live like Costco people
Wouldn't you also need at least a little protein? and some lipids? For example, there is a lot more in Soylent than just rice flour. Oh, are we talking brown rice or white rice? That seems like it might make a huge difference, not only in nutrition, but also pooping.
whyenot··on RaTeX: KaTeX-compatible LaTeX rendering engine in pure Rust
I have been (and still am, I guess) a big LaTeX fan. I wrote a flora in LaTeX, with the idea that it would be a "living document" that I could update easily. That was a mistake. LaTeX really is very brittle. My flora no longer makes it through typesetting without erroring out, and trying to figure out what is going wrong takes so much time (not the first time I have had to deal with this). My idealism got ahead of practicality. Looking back, I should have used Word and InDesign; that combo would have prevented so many headaches and been more stable.
whyenot··on Farewell to a Giant of Botany
I met him about 10 years ago at a Southern California Botanists event. For someone held in very high esteem by most botanists (the organizers even printed t-shirts with his face on them), he was very humble and down to earth.

Among all of his accomplishments, one of the most important is the paper he co-authored with Paul Ehrlich on the coevolution of plants and the animals that eat them. It demonstrated the "arms race" where plants have evolved the ability to produce toxic chemicals to prevent herbivory while at the same time animals that feed on plants have evolved adaptations that allow them to detoxify these chemicals or otherwise not be affected by them. It is considered one of the foundational papers of modern ecology.

Ehrlich, Paul R. and Peter H. Raven. 1964. Butterflies and plants: a study in coevolution. Evolution 18: 586-608. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1558-5646.1964...

whyenot··on 'Point of no return': New Orleans relocation must start now due to sea level
I am increasingly pessimistic about the long term future of the US. What are the chances that we will still be one country in a generation or two? Trump might have poured gasoline on the fire, but the federal government has been in decline for years. Congress is completely dysfunctional. The filibuster prevents the senate from doing anything. The president is at war with the civil servants and more interested in grift, punishing percieved enemies and erecting monuments to himself instead actually leading.

Addressing climate change requires massive changes and a lot of political courage. There is none.

whyenot··on White House Considers Vetting A.I. Models Before They Are Released
Wishing a fond goodbye to the Gulf of Mexico.
whyenot··on Drone pilot makes US rescind no-fly zones around unmarked, moving ICE vehicles
> Do better or just don’t waste others’ time.

One of the nice things about HN is that we treat each other respectfully, even when someone posts a comment we may disagree with.

whyenot··on Supreme Court to hear arguments in landmark Roundup weedkiller case
From an environmental perspective you are probably right. One of the nice things is that glyphosate, unlike most herbicides, is broken down quickly by soil bacteria.

The longer term issue is evolved weed resistance due to its over use with "Roundup Ready" crops and for end of the season dry down.

whyenot··on Girl, 10, finds rare Mexican axolotl under Welsh bridge
What is scientific about this pronunciation? Axolotl is not the scientfic name (its Ambystoma mexicanum), and usually the goal with pronouncing scientific names is for the listener to be able to spell the name after hearing it (at least for botany, which is what I am familiar with).
whyenot··on US cities are axing Flock Safety surveillance technology
> People are not willing to sacrifice their freedom to save 40,990 people from cars, why should our constant locations be monitored?

We are all different, and I think where we each land on the security <--> privacy continuum will depend on who we are.

This is also true of constitutional rights. The US constitution was written by a small group of wealthy white men. At the time of its drafting, some people were considered property and had no freedom. Women didn't have the same rights as men and were not allowed to vote. Where the framers landed on the security <--> privacy continuum may have been a very different place than many US residents would land today. Rape, murder, property crimes, etc... even today some groups are much more often victims than others. Safety is a much larger concern for some groups than others.

I just feel like you are painting with a very broad brush when it comes to "people."

whyenot··on 81yo Dodgers fan can no longer get tickets because he doesn't have a smartphone
So what you are saying is, it's ok to exclude the Amish, and others who chose not to use a cell phone for religious (or other) reasons, from buying a season ticket. That sounds like discrimination on the basis of religion ;)
whyenot··on iNaturalist
I feel like this ship has already sailed. The home addresses of most people, especially if they have lived in the same place for awhile, is already online. In my case, even my salary info is online because I am a public employee.
whyenot··on Epoch confirms GPT5.4 Pro solved a frontier math open problem
Just an interesting thought experiment: if you took all the sensory information that a child experiences through their senses (sight, hearing, smell, touch, taste) between, say, birth and age five, how many books worth of data would that be? I asked Claude, and their estimate was about 200 million books. Maybe that number is off ± by an order of magnitude. ...but then again Claude is only three years old, not five.
whyenot··on Epic Games to cut more than 1k jobs as Fortnite usage falls
There are (were) ~5,000 employees at Epic. That seems like a huge number for company that has produced little more than various flavors of Fortnite and a failure of a store in the last 10 years.
whyenot··on iPhone 17 Pro Demonstrated Running a 400B LLM
Should have used a better platform. So long and thanks for all the fish.
whyenot··on Waymo Safety Impact
I realize it is hard to do this, but please understand that other people have different perspectives on personal safety. For example, try and image how things might be different if you were a woman alone in an Uber with a driver who starts saying weird things.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →