476 karma · joined February 14, 2013
That doesn't bode well for things working all that well. As someone who ran linux on chromebook for two years, then on a macbook for three, i'm a bit burnt out on this sort of thing.
You might be interested in checking out the rust implementation: https://github.com/rs-ipfs/rust-ipfs
Im not actually sure how well it would work for what youre after, but it is an option!
In the event that a censored party can create a heavier chain (has >50% of the mining power) then the argument that its more censorship resistant holds, but on the PoS side, you would be betting that not a single participant in the main chain included their new stake registration in their blocks. This is different than the PoW model as non-malicious nodes in PoW can still be part of the main chain. It's definitely not that cut and dry
(note: uber launched in 2009)
You can't say there's causation here necessarily, but the correlation is significant.
The initial release today focuses on Storage Mining, which requires the nodes storing the data to be online pretty much all the time to be able to submit proofs of that storage. This is because storage miners are the block producers, and we need to have high certainty that they actually have the amount of storage they claim. The requirements here will go down over time, we have a number of different proof constructions we are looking into that will improve things in nearly every dimension (zk-snark technology is still really young, and we're pushing its limits).
Filecoin (even today) has retrieval miners, that earn money for serving data as clients request it, but it needs a good deal of work still to form an efficient market. Its current state is more like Amazons 'Requester pays buckets' on s3, but is rapidly improving and many different groups are building out exciting things in this space. A retrieval miner doesnt really need to be online for any amount of time, only needs to respond to requests when it wants to get paid.
> a fairly large cloud storage provider, has a total network size of around 500 petabytes
Its worth noting that the current amount of 'committed power' (aka, proven storage) in Filecoin as of this moment is 572.8PiB, with significantly more than that waiting to get onto the chain. Most of this is just 'committed capacity', space that doesn't contain users data, but is proven to be there and ready to be filled with real data when it's demanded.
They can totally do this, but they are on the hook for that data. If the backing store for the data that the miner is trusting goes down, the miner loses a pretty significant amount of collateral (currently 0.2 FIL per 32GB sector).
In practice, we're seeing most miners set up their own storage clusters. Whether a bunch of small (100TB-1PB) nfs boxes, or much bigger single filesystem CEPH clusters.
Filecoin miners right now are making about 0.25FIL per day per TB they store. Thats just in block rewards (remember, Filecoin is a proof of SpaceTime network). Any amount the user is paying is on top of that price, so basically, if the user pays enough to cover the transaction fees and bandwidth costs (very small), it makes sense for the miner to accept the deal. This effectively means the block reward is subsidizing the price of storage.
Of course :)
> What are the latency expectations within the system when my node is asked for a Proof of SpaceTime?
We want them to be as low as possible, but the practicality of getting messages included into a blockchain, and the high cost of running snarks means its definitely on the order of minutes, realistically in the tens of minutes.
A few things to note, the Proof of SpaceTime happens over all of your sectors, not just one. So that ten minutes of GPU time per day is amortized across all of the data you are storing.
> Is it feasible to keep the sealing data, delete the file itself...
Yes, thats feasible if the file you are downloading is already sealed (note: sealing generates a piece of data unique to you, so wherever else that thing is stored is effectively your owned storage). This isnt really different than you having your data stored on a NAS box somewhere. What you cannot do is download the original unsealed data and hope to respond to the challenge in time, as that would require rerunning the expensive sealing process.
The ongoing compute cost for these PoSts are quite small, I think the current numbers (obviously subject to change) are that you have to do one PoSt per day, which is a single 100M constraint zkSNARK proof, which should take about 10 minutes of machine-with-decent-GPU time to compute.
The difference between sealing and an actual proof of work based network here is that once you've sealed a sector, you don't have to keep computing anything that expensive. If you seal 1TB and thats 1% of the network, you should win 1% of the blocks (ignoring network growth) without further sealing work required. I tend to think about it like a (calculus) derivative of PoW.
If you want an anonymous currency check out something like Zcash or monero. They use some fancier crypto to obscure transaction inputs and outputs, which gets you a bit farther towards being anonymous.
The alternative is Feross gets a job, and everyone invents their own stuff in-house, and we end up with 'open source' that is just what profitable companies want to have as open source. The set of things companies decide to open source is not a good overlap with the set of software that should exist.