HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wildmanx

1,370 karma · joined February 25, 2019

submissionscomments
wildmanx··on MIT invents $4 solar desalination device
And how sustainable is that solution?
wildmanx··on How I regained concentration and focus
What's the tangible benefit of reading a history book? What's the tangible benefit of learning about quantum physics, evolution theory or the history of the French Revolution?

My iPhone works anyway, the grocery store sells chicken anyway, and the latte at Starbucks won't taste any different.

None of that directly changes by you learning more things. But it makes you a more well-rounded educated person, equipped to make better decisions impacting your own life and possibly society as a whole. And, frankly, to make sth out of you that's more than a monkey living merely to survive and procreate.

wildmanx··on How I regained concentration and focus
Let's assume that's the case. Then without having witnessed the propaganda, I'd not have proper context to what you just told me. I'd have to go with somebody (you) claiming what had been the propaganda back in the day. And that sounds pretty unbelievable, so it's good that I witnessed it, then I can appreciate the point that you are making.

Either way, better to have had open eyes and ears than not.

wildmanx··on How I regained concentration and focus
You'll have witnessed history unfold in front of your very own eyes.

You'll know the difference between what the history books will claim 20 years from now and the public debate shift based on that, and what you've actually witnessed.

Granted, you are (likely) not actually on the ground where the tanks and rockets and soldiers meet, but you are another layer or two closer to being a witness of history. Which you are not if you ignore it.

wildmanx··on How I regained concentration and focus
> There are much, much better ways than reading CNN/NYTimes every day.

Reading those once a day is actually pretty good, let's say at a dedicated time. In contrast to many-times-a-day-let-me-just-check-the-app. The latter is just causing dopamine rushes. The former keeps you informed.

What did you have in mind?

wildmanx··on Show HN: Emery – Personal productivity workspace
Sure, but this here is "Hacker News". We are the 1% that you are talking about.

Export functions wouldn't convince me though. Those can disappear och be broken or miss things, which I wouldn't only notice when it's too late.

wildmanx··on Show HN: Emery – Personal productivity workspace
This. 100%.

Because of this, I've come to distrust any offering that's not self-hosted on my homeserver. Sounds drastic, but I've been burned too often. The quality I get from this is significantly lower, the amount of work I need to put in is much more, and though often fun it's not always at convenient times and sometimes I hate it. But I'm fairly confident that all my data, be it email, cal, notes, pictures, whatnot, will still be accessible 3 years or 10 years from now. Some things from 10 years ago I dearly miss, and I don't want that to happen again.

wildmanx··on Asus Zenfone 9
Yeah, this is ridiculous. Notice how all the models on the page have big to giant hands?

One of my earliest smartphones was 4.2". That was already problematic for my hand. 5" is too large, 5.9" is out of question. I don't want a tablet for a phone. I want a phone that I can use with just one hand and still reach all corners of the screen comfortably with my thumb from a firm grip (i.e. not from the side, but with the bottom right corner firmly tucked in the palm of my hand, if that makes sense). And my hands are not even small.

wildmanx··on Asus Zenfone 9
> If it isn't buggy

That's not how software works. Software is always buggy. Question is only how severely functionality is impacted and when those bugs will be found. Most bugs are never noticed since they only concern corner cases that you normally won't hit in the field or would even have a hard time driving the system into even if you tried on purpose.

The main issue is with security-related bugs. Especially with mobile phone software, which has an enormous attack surface and has really wide distribution, this is a constant issue. No mobile phone OS ever will be bug free and will always contain security flaws. Over time, more and more of them are discovered, and it's a race between the vendor fixing them and malicious actors exploiting them. That's why the OS (and all the apps) need to be constantly updated. The longer you skip updates, the more you fall behind and the more doors are open that better be closed once they are known.

> needs to be paired with an argument that they ship buggy or incomplete software.

That argument is an easy one to make and everybody familiar with software engineering should be intimately familiar with it. This is not about some button not working, it's about somebody pwning your phone.

wildmanx··on Five Laws of Human Stupidity (1976)
Not sure which part. You quoted an implication. Do you find my description in the antecedent arrogant (i.e. my characterization of the beginning of the article), or the implication itself?

If the former, I spent quite some time to argue in favor of my opinion in my original comment. You are welcome to argue the opposite. Just calling it "irony" is not much of an argument though.

If the latter, then I'd like to understand why. Do you argue that no matter how nonsensical some text, you need to read it fully before expressing any thought about it? Or do you mean something else?

wildmanx··on Five Laws of Human Stupidity (1976)
Well said, thank you.
wildmanx··on Five Laws of Human Stupidity (1976)
I disagree. When reading material that's so utterly flawed, full with oversimplifying stereotypes and arrogance, then it's entirely possible to have formed an opinion before finishing the piece. Nothing could have come after the first "law" that would have made the part up to that point better or more defensible.
wildmanx··on Five Laws of Human Stupidity (1976)
> The article defines stupidity in a very precise way

No, it doesn't. The part that you mention is "law" 3 of 5. I stopped reading mid-way into the first "law" up to which the article already used the term "stupidity" multiple times as if it's obvious what that is and was so unbelievably presumptuous regarding people that are somehow less worth than the author that it became unbearable.

wildmanx··on Five Laws of Human Stupidity (1976)
This is a terrible view of humankind, society and the people around you.

What is "stupidity" other than a concept vague enough that you can just throw it at anybody to, in part, immediately raise yourself to some level of superiority, and essentially defame without actually having to argue anything? Obviously they are stupid, and since you realize that, you are obviously not, so what's there to argue, right?

Human intelligence, if that's what "stupidity" is supposed to be about, is many-dimensional. Even within a single dimension, most actions, opinions or expressions of such are not clear-cut more or less intelligent. Often you just happen to agree with one or see problems with another one. But it doesn't immediately mean somebody is "stupid". And it also ignores the "why". Maybe somebody is lacking education in a certain field, perhaps because of a lack of funds or opportunity because they grew up in a disadvantaged neighborhood. Or because of a medical condition. Or maybe they are just tired. Who knows. Oh right, they are "stupid", that's what they are.

And finally, even if somebody does something "stupid" .. don't put yourself on such a high horse. You likely also do "stupid" things. All the time. You don't realize it though, you'd otherwise stop doing that thing. So, if the conclusion is that we are all "stupid" in some way, they yeah, we can claim that there are "stupid" people all around us, but that's not a particularly meaningful statement.

Honestly, this was a very sad read.

wildmanx··on Ten Percent of the Brain Myth
Check out https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LrQnnhAXLt0 around 3:16. It's not just a percussive stab. It is actually a valid chord (all black keys) in that key.
wildmanx··on Ten Percent of the Brain Myth
Also feels like they are more common on mainstream-ish TV.
wildmanx··on Sound of Colleagues
I work in Europe at a nice company with nice offices. It's beautiful.

Most of the time we all have our doors wide open, it's glass doors, mostly glass walls, very bright, very modern. Everybody is welcome to stop by at any time when the door is open. Door closed means "please don't disturb unless it's an emergency". People close doors to have longer discussions, to have confidential discussions, or to have peace and quiet.

The doors basically serve the same purpose as headsets. They just make more sense and are more ... human.

Yes, some offices house more than one person. Typically 2, some have 3. But the employees in this situation are quite content with this and could request single offices at any time.

wildmanx··on The Uber leak exposes the global war on workers
> How do you compete with that? Taxi business need to reflect.

Did you read the article? The reason this worked for you is that you benefited from exploiting some underpaid soul that was up at 5 in the morning to barely scrape by.

wildmanx··on Blackmail attempt left a Houston restaurant bombarded with 1-star reviews
The purpose of shadow banning is to make it hard for violators to work around the restrictions. If the feedback loop is in the order of seconds, then the bad actor can quickly find a way to just pass the filter while still dumping the crap they want. The more cost each iteration incurs, the more the bad actor is deterred from doing that.

Of course, delaying the complaint and doing full shadow banning are still different things, and the former would suffice, but they chose the easy way out I guess, because their main objective is to keep the bad guys out.

wildmanx··on Sound of Colleagues
Office designers on the European continent have come up with an ingenious invention for this: Individual offices!

Site managers in North America rarely want to hear this, since it's more expensive and supposedly prevents close collaboration and encourages slackers, but that's just a bunch of BS. It's absolutely fantastic to just be able to close your door and have peace and quiet if you need to get into flow. Much better than being forced to wear headphones all day, for noise-cancellation or forced-music-listening instead.

wildmanx··on State lotteries transfer wealth out of needy communities, investigation finds
> Is it really a tax if it's voluntary? That seems like a contradiction of terms.

Um, it's not voluntary. Buying the product is voluntary. But the state taking a cut once you do buy the product is not voluntary. Don't mix those two aspects.

It's voluntary to buy a pound of chicken feet. It's not voluntary to pay VAT on that purchase.

It's voluntary to go to work and earn a salary. It's not voluntary to pay income tax on that salary once you earn it.

> And why not ban the lottery entirely if you're not going to use it as a revenue source? Keep it around just to entertain poor people?

One reason is to keep a legal way to do this, since otherwise illegal ones have higher demand and pop up. It's more expensive (and arguably worse for society) if you make gambling entirely illegal and instead need to go hunt down illegal lotteries with more police resources.

> 99.999% of them will still lose money anyway if it's morality you're worried about. Does it really matter to the winners whether they take home $100mm or $70mm (and the gov the remaining $30mm)?

You clearly don't play the lottery (and I don't mean that negatively). Most wins are small. $400 here, $2000 there. That's how you keep people hooked. And in those orders of magnitude, it makes quite a difference in practice.

wildmanx··on State lotteries transfer wealth out of needy communities, investigation finds
> For some people winning the lottery (even smaller prices) is literally the only "realistic" way of getting a moderate amount of "wealth"

That itself is questionable. Let's say somebody of poor socioeconomic background wins $100,000 in the lottery. Would they suddenly make reasonable financial choices with that money and "make it"? It's possible. But it would require completely changing the mindset that made them play the lottery in the first place. You know, the "It's a gamble and it's risky, but I feel like it's all about God." mindset. Possible. But unlikely, if you ask me.

This is a poor argument in favor of lotteries. It would be more beneficial for people in those areas to have less incentive to burn their money on lottery tickets, and the money that does get burned go to better education and improving conditions for them to climb the social latter and provide more realistic ways for building wealth. Instead of hoping for God's intervention through lottery wins.

wildmanx··on Meta managers are urged to identify, push out low performers
That's the kind of short-sighted thinking that makes the difference between high performers actually wanting or not wanting to work for you.

(In more detail, the two reasons my sibling comment gave.)

wildmanx··on Open source is not about you (2018)
> If instead a project is described as “I built this thing for me. Here’s the source. Please don't trust me, or my code, with anything valuable” expectations can be better aligned perhaps.

Every open source project states this explicitly. In the license. Usually in all caps. Wanna see?

MIT license has:

--- THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE. ---

See? "No warranty of any kind." I.e. "don't trust this with anything valuable". How can this be more explicit?

GPL:

--- 11. BECAUSE THE PROGRAM IS LICENSED FREE OF CHARGE, THERE IS NO WARRANTY FOR THE PROGRAM, TO THE EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE LAW. EXCEPT WHEN OTHERWISE STATED IN WRITING THE COPYRIGHT HOLDERS AND/OR OTHER PARTIES PROVIDE THE PROGRAM "AS IS" WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EITHER EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. THE ENTIRE RISK AS TO THE QUALITY AND PERFORMANCE OF THE PROGRAM IS WITH YOU. SHOULD THE PROGRAM PROVE DEFECTIVE, YOU ASSUME THE COST OF ALL NECESSARY SERVICING, REPAIR OR CORRECTION. ---

See? "The entire risk as to the quality and performance of the program is with you". How can this be more explicit?

Nowhere does it state that the author is obliged to provide support, reply to issue reports, accept merge requests, or is even nice to anybody. It's great if they are, and I appreciate such projects as well, but nobody is entitled to that. So please don't assume it or berate people if you encounter the opposite. This builds false expectations in others who don't know any better. We need to help each other out to build proper understanding within the community.

wildmanx··on Open source is not about you (2018)
It's a typical pattern that I've seen in FOSS projects over the last decades. Somebody writes something cool, publishes it, is initially happy about adoption and positive feedback, and then people start to demand more and more of them. Fix this thing, add that thing, here is my code, when are you finally going to merge it, why are you not responding, you are not respectful of me, etc. etc. Then a mix of burnout and resentment happens and the more bold ones issue such a statement. Others just abandon their project and are never seen again.

It's very sad, and it's rooted in a basic misconception of what FOSS actually is. That's why such posts are important to educate people, even if it sounds drastic.

wildmanx··on Open source is not about you (2018)
What open source means and what different people choose to use it for are different things. Of course as a maintainer you may get more out of it if you put effort in for building a community, which then can help you improve the project, contribute, etc. But that's extra effort, and nobody should assume that everybody commits to that extra effort just because they release source code under a FOSS license.
wildmanx··on Open source is not about you (2018)
> The thing is, that has nothing to do with open source, it's always project-specific, so the full post largely doesn't make any sense as a comment on open source.

That's how I read this article. He argues that it's a misconception that "open source" implies the entitlements that he rejects. There may be projects which offer such entitlements (though it's unlikely phrased like that), but other projects don't, and nobody should assume they are entitled to anything just because of the "open source" label -- beyond the rights guaranteed by the chosen license.

He argues for freedom. The programmers freedom to ignore anything beyond the license, and the users freedom to go choose a different project if they don't like the choices of some project. That's also what you are saying.

wildmanx··on Extreme heat, drought will permanently scar California and its social fabric
> > Energy is not free. No, nuclear isn't either.

> You don't need free energy for desal to be more than worthwhile.

It was a response to that the only byproduct of desalination is sea salt. It's not (or it's a bad-faith misleading statement). You need to account for the energy you put in which has its own byproducts.

> > Want a uranium mine in your backyard?

> If I had a backyard, then sure, why not?

You may want to check out the health implications before you commit.

wildmanx··on Extreme heat, drought will permanently scar California and its social fabric
> The byproducts are sea salt. You might pay less for it at the store.

1. It's not some food-grade "sea salt" that you get. It's brine, which, dumped into the ocean, wreaks havoc in the local ecosystem. It's heavier than sea water, sinks to the ground, etc. Not something you want in your backyard.

2. Energy is not free. No, nuclear isn't either. Want a uranium mine in your backyard? Or a coal mine?

Wasting less water could be the easier solution here.

wildmanx··on Extreme heat, drought will permanently scar California and its social fabric
We humans have a terrible track record when it comes to using tech to try to counter environmental issues that we caused. It has essentially never worked.

What _can_ work is to use tech to address the root cause, which in many cases resource overuse, just like this one. That is, using tech to reduce the use of that resource. Trying to replenish the resource while not curbing its use is doomed to failure.

← PreviousPage 2 of 13Next →