HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wildmanx

1,370 karma · joined February 25, 2019

submissionscomments
wildmanx··on Extreme heat, drought will permanently scar California and its social fabric
As long as the price tag on water does not reflect its actual cost on environment and society, they couldn't care less.

Similar to carbon emissions and any other pollution. Once you put an accurate price tag on it, simultaneously avoiding the corruption that usually comes with certificates and that kind of thing, then you'll get somewhere.

wildmanx··on Extreme heat, drought will permanently scar California and its social fabric
You may need to check the orders of magnitude we are talking about here and then re-evaluate your statement. This is not about a few stretches of CA coastline. This is about all of the continental US. A few desal plants won't cut it.
wildmanx··on Extreme heat, drought will permanently scar California and its social fabric
> Well, what are the alternatives?

The same as with any resource that you are overusing: Use less.

You don't need golf courses in the middle of the desert. You don't need broken water access rights regulation that encourages wasting water. You can reduce water use in agriculture to a tiny fraction if you'd start viewing water as a precious resource and do this smarter. There is a lot you can do that's different from "let's keep wasting this resource, we can throw tech at it, ignore the consequences!"

wildmanx··on Extreme heat, drought will permanently scar California and its social fabric
Which is exactly my point.
wildmanx··on Extreme heat, drought will permanently scar California and its social fabric
Oh the typical techie solution to environmental problems. We can solve this with tech!

Wait until the aquifers under North America run dry. That's where most irrigation pump up their ground water from. A few dry rivers and smaller lakes are nothing compared to what's going to happen. Forget your desalination plants.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aquifers_in_the_United...

And it's entirely predictable. In fact, for decades already. But (almost) nobody is doing anything. Cause freedom, I guess. What's a golf course here and there in the desert, for the better off, right? Or what about an artificial lagoon? Freedom!

Edit: Oh, there is a recent John Oliver episode about this one too. Maybe finally somebody will notice. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jtxew5XUVbQ

wildmanx··on Shrugs.app – A native Slack client for macOS
Doesn't your API have a problem if it can be misused that way? In other words, shouldn't your backend by default distrust the client using its API, no matter whether it's the official one or anything else? Even the official client can have bugs that bring down your backend.

That's what the "zero trust" philosophy is about.

wildmanx··on Shrugs.app – A native Slack client for macOS
> If you take more than a few minutes to think out how it works (I know, not popular for the typical HN poster)

Such a condescending remark. This kind of thing is not good PR for your company, product or workplace. Would I want to work with colleagues who publicly disparage a whole community like that? If you communicate like that publicly, how can I expect your internal work atmosphere to be?

I know you're probably an engineer at Slack and not in the PR department, but you may want to re-think your communication strategy. I know that my employer would have been unhappy with me for such a comment, and rightfully so.

Judging by other comments in this thread, folks have apparently thought out how it could work for "more than a few minutes", so not just the style but even the content of your message are clearly off. You are getting community feedback here and competent people are giving suggestions -- for free. Embrace that.

wildmanx··on Controversy continues over whether hot water freezes faster than cold
> such a phenomena

The singular is "phenomenon".

wildmanx··on Ask HN: Can I see your cheatsheet?
Make sure to create a cheatsheet for how to use your cheatsheet manager.
wildmanx··on NeRF: An eventual successor for deepfakes?
> I don't think we'll have the ability to handle this kind of tech responsibly.

Makes you also think whether anybody from the Hacker News crowd working on any contributing tech is acting ethically responsibly. For myself, I have answered this question with "no", which rules out many jobs for me, but at least my kids won't eventually look me in the eye and ask "how could you?"

Sure it's cool tech. But so was what eventually brought us nuclear war heads.

wildmanx··on What happened to the lab-leak hypothesis?
Thanks, Alina. A well-balanced point of view.
wildmanx··on Life is not short
Absolutely! But that's not what I was replying to. That was, roughly, about depriving you of certain joys today in order to increase potential for future joy. Which is what the "Life is not short" article is arguing against.
wildmanx··on Life is not short
> I’d take it one step further and say life also has compounding returns. What you invest today yields returns tomorrow. [...]

> [...] Now I engage with hobbies that yield compounding returns because tomorrow’s happiness is just as important as today’s.

You may not realize it, but this defer-happiness-to-the-future attitude is what the original article is recommending against:

Putting things off for the future is the biggest waste of a life. You deny yourself the present by promising the future. You’re relying on the future, which is outside of your control, and abandoning the present, which is the only thing you can control. The whole future lies in uncertainty – live immediately.

wildmanx··on What happened to the lab-leak hypothesis?
> 1. Are Chan and Ridley selling a book?

Hej Alina! Thanks for being open with having an economic interest in this topic being dragged out into the open again.

> It is very surprising to me that these feasible routes of inquiry have not been explored more than 2 years into the pandemic.

It's not too surprising to me. International diplomacy works like this. With a more general picture in mind, specific topics often need to be swept under the rug. Otherwise international relations between any two countries would be constantly in shambles and we'd long have seen WW3, WW4 and WW5.

Note that I'm not advocating for any of this hush-hush. I'd also like to know what happened. But that's just not how international diplomacy works. In this particular case, if WHO wants continued support from China, then you need to carefully balance what and how you criticize. Nobody is helped if China leaves the WHO or next time doesn't even tell anybody that a pandemic is coming for fear of being bullied for this kind of thing. I'm sure the responsible bodies (lab people) will learn their lesson and be more careful going forward. That's the only thing we can hope for nonetheless. It's unrealistic to think China would be punished and all their labs shut down. This won't happen.

wildmanx··on New Tolkien book, The Fall of Númenor, to be published
Mind you, A was "If you love Tolkien, or if you love the Amazon series,"

That's not "absurd". And, given time, it's not "generally considered impossible" either, once the series is out and people have watched it.

wildmanx··on New Tolkien book, The Fall of Númenor, to be published
"If A, then B."

This statement does not claim that A is true.

Basic logics, guys.

wildmanx··on Twitter Notes
> I learn a tremendous amount from Twitter and vastly prefer it to needing to buy a book

Is this "learning"? You sure get entertained, quick-and-easy-to-digest facts, good for short attention spans, and 5-10 minutes later you go back to whatever else you were doing. Or hop on the next "educative" twitter thread or somesuch. But have you actually learned something?

If I ask you a week later to summarize your new insights, will you be able to? Will you even remember that you read about this? I sometimes find an old tab in a browser window that I had forgotten to close a while back. I skim through the contents, oh right! That thing! That was interesting! Turns out, a twitter thread, barely a week old, about something interesting, "I really learned something!", but I had already forgotten about it again, and if somebody had asked, I'd mainly have answered "Oh yeah there was this thing, don't remember the details, or the conclusion, or anything really, but I think I read something the other day", which is just hot air.

We should not treat such twitter threads as educational content. They are short-term entertainment, and good at that, but in essence not very different from a tiktok clip of some girl dancing on the beach.

If you really want to learn something, you need to invest time. By reading a book, by discussing with knowledgeable people, by trying something out yourself and/or trying to put your own words down. This takes energy, patience, time and can be frustrating at times. But twitter threads can't solve this for you.

wildmanx··on Does the Tank Have a Future?
If you find out why conflicts and wars have broken out in the past, that could enable you to devise strategies to avoid them in the future.

Just like post-mortems in other areas. A plane crashed? Investigators go find out why, amend protocols and technical safeguards so that root cause won't bring down another plane in the future. Too many bad side effects of some drug? Investigation into why and adjustment of recommendations to doctors. You had a prod network meltdown? The responsible team does an ideally blame-free investigation to find the root cause and re-structures their setup to prevent it next time. Fight with your wife? Find out what caused it and then improve communication or expectations or whatever contributed to it. A war broke out? THOSE GUYS ARE EVIL AND WE NEED MORE SPENDING ON WEAPONS!!!1

Since WW2, all those former world-power countries in western Europe have lived in peace with one another, not because they built weapons for mutually assured destruction, but because they built economic interdependence and mutual understanding. That's a start and proper research into this could take things much further.

wildmanx··on Does the Tank Have a Future?
If you look around in the discussions around here, it's not a surprise. Sadly.

The "best thing against bad guy with a gun is good guy with a gun" mentality runs deep.

wildmanx··on Does the Tank Have a Future?
You seem to have missed the "investment into peace research and conflict prevention" part of my post. Ironically, that's the part that you quoted.
wildmanx··on Does the Tank Have a Future?
It's clear that this is an exciting topic for techies.

But keep in mind what this all is made for: Destroying and killing. We are talking about war machinery, and technical discussions about those tend to romanticize all that technology much too often.

If we'd only pour 10% of the investments that today goes into war machinery into peace research and conflict prevention, then this world would be a much safer place.

There would be less toys to play with and less "fascinating" discussions about tanks and guided missiles and strategy and artillery and infantry and fighter planes, which may sadden the technically inclined, but in the end these are not toys. These are devices to destroy and kill, and designing, building and maintaining them has enormous costs even in peacetime.

wildmanx··on Lilium achieves first main wing transition for all-electric aircraft [video]
Alright, the actual figure is $1,2M for the 90-percentile household net worth. For the individual that's to be divided by 3 (since there are about 120M households in the U.S.). We are at the 96-percentile for $3M household net worth.

So yeah, 4%-ers then. Really makes a big difference to my point. This is totally gonna change everybody's life. (I.e. those who can afford it, while the majority is scraping by from paycheck to paycheck.)

wildmanx··on Lilium achieves first main wing transition for all-electric aircraft [video]
> mono-millionaires

Ah right, moving it from 0.1%-ers to 1%-ers is really going to make a big difference.

wildmanx··on Deluge BitTorrent Client
> Suddenly five thousand voices of open source zealots appear from nowhere

The image that presented itself to me was: An article about an open source project was linked and the two top HN comments were 1. complaints that proxy use doesn't work for 10 years and 2. complaints that there is no official Windows port.

Now, who is the one complaining here? The "open source zealots"?

I find it legitimate to respond to such complaints by pointing out the nature of the criticized project.

wildmanx··on Deluge BitTorrent Client
> When you put something out there, you should strive to do right by your users.

We clearly disagree here.

I also like when some open source author is responsive after they put something out there. And I myself try to be helpful as well. After all, one of the reasons for me publishing things as open source is to attract a community that directly (through patches) or indirectly (through issue reports) helps me to improve the thing I made. Win-win!

But demanding this is actually actively hurtful to the ecosystem. To put it bluntly, would you prefer that somebody just doesn't publish some nice piece of software they wrote to scratch some itch they had just because they have no time/energy/desire to then provide support for users? I don't. I want them to publish it anyway. Maybe somebody else can pick up the maintenance. Or not, but at least it's out there.

> I hate this philosophy of yours with all my might.

"Hate" is a strong word. This is pretty sad.

wildmanx··on Deluge BitTorrent Client
I'm not saying it's an invalid complaint. But it's not particularly helpful or meaningful. It's not like the maintainers are not aware of the issue. It's just that they've so far had other priorities in life. To keep complaining won't change that. (Well, maybe it will, but that would actually be pretty sad.)

It's a different story when some issue is brought up the very first time because somebody wasn't aware who would like to be aware and also willing to do something about it. But to just keep complaining beyond a certain point is just a waste of energy. (Especially for an issue that clearly many people don't care about, including users.)

P.S.: I'm not sure why you need to "learn GUIs" for this. This is clearly an issue in the server part of the client/server model that Deluge has. Which is a very nice design choice, if you ask me. Not just for users, but also for developers -- you don't need to have any clue about GUIs to fiddle with the network-related part of the program. EDIT: Sorry, confused this with the parallel subthread about the proxy issue. Yes, for a Windows port you may need to know some GUI aspects.

wildmanx··on Deluge BitTorrent Client
Sure it's correct.

It's raining outside right now and I don't like it. That's also a correct statement. Just because it comes from the sky doesn't make it "somehow immune from criticism". But that's not a very meaningful complaint. I can complain about the rain all day. Will it change anything? No.

In contrast to the rain, some feature missing in some open source project can be fixed. Put your energy into complaining or into fixing. Your choice.

In a proprietary system, your only option is to complain. Sadly, it's common to see this mentality for open source projects too.

wildmanx··on We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle for freedom (2016)
What keeps things open source / free software in practice is not a philosophical desire for freedom but the very practical desire to be able to get things done. That's why the Linux kernel is so popular and there is an open source ecosystem for systems tooling and web dev libs and all that. Not because people are hippies who want everything to be free (as in gratis) but because it's just so much easier than going through convoluted licensing requirements.

In the end it's just evolution. If there is a free and open tool doing something better than some hard-to-license alternative, or at least well enough, then it will win. Once there isn't then the proprietary alternative will win in the space.

In other words, once the demand for open hackable mobile phone ecosystems is high enough, they will be open and hackable. The demand is just not there. Similar for other areas raised in threads in here.

wildmanx··on Deluge BitTorrent Client
> Deluge still hasn't had an official Windows release for 2.x, and it's been that way since 2019.

This is GPL software made by people in their free time, for free. Apparently, the intersection of "people who want a Windows release", "people who have the skill to do it" and "people who want to do it for free" is empty. If you belong to all 3 groups, then please go ahead and provide a Windows release. If you don't then I'm not sure what you are complaining about. That nobody is providing something to you for free that you need?

wildmanx··on Deluge BitTorrent Client
> It's about a project that silently ignores a privacy-related setting, which then exposes the fact that people download something.

Which means that everybody who either doesn't use a proxy or does not care whether it's exposed what they are downloading can happily use Deluge. Using the term "nobody" you are exaggerating quite a bit, don't you think?

Instead of complaining and demanding that others fix something for you for free who are not affected by it, please consider contributing a fix yourself.

← PreviousPage 3 of 13Next →