HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

williamcotton

3,613 karma · joined April 16, 2011

submissionscomments
williamcotton··on I'm becoming AI-blind
Most of these arguments are over some metaphysical definition of the word “intelligence”.

As per later era Wittgenstein, I prefer to ignore these engagements and focus more on the meaning-as-use approach.

What is the use of intelligence? What are the concrete outcomes of intelligence?

williamcotton··on And then the men with guns tell you to do it anyway
Pick up a copy of Crime and Punishment ASAP.
williamcotton··on AI Coding Without the Vibes
Vivian, the commercial baker, learned a different set of skills. She might have deskilled with regards to hand-rolling dough but she gained new skills related to industrial production.

I've made a half-dozen or so DSLs with LLM tools over the last couple of years. I've learned a lot about the architecture of parsers, semantic analysis, editor services, LSPs, DAP, etc. I have a new set of skills! I'm able to focus more on the syntax and semantics languages themselves and the overall developer experience. This would have taken literal man-years of development to do otherwise.

For my hand-rolled craft I'd much rather sit down at the piano or pick up my guitar!

williamcotton··on Protobuf has LSP support. You're welcome
Makes sense, thanks for the clarification.
williamcotton··on Protobuf has LSP support. You're welcome
I settled on starting with a CST using rowan, doing semantic analysis, having an agnostic editor services, exposing both an LSP interface with tower, and a WASM interface (for Monaco in the browser [non-LSP!!]) and having the runtime binary doing the interpretation/compilation with the same pathway, with a slight jog, as the editor services. Phew!
williamcotton··on Protobuf has LSP support. You're welcome
Ah, so does the LSP just call out to the Buf binary?
williamcotton··on Protobuf has LSP support
I looked at the dependencies and noticed that it wasn’t using an existing Protobuf parser which means they reimplemented the parser from scratch. Perhaps due to a lack of error recovery in the existing implementations? I don’t have the energy right now for further inspection.

It is definitely best to reuse the parser for the runtime when implementing an LSP but to do so properly means implementing the parser itself as a standalone library. Even better is shipping the semantic analysis as well!

Implementation drift is definitely an issue.

But great project anyways, just wanted to put my thoughts on the matter into the conversation!

williamcotton··on Models Are Getting Dumber on Purpose
At least later-era Wittgenstein would disagree with you.
williamcotton··on Anthropic revenue reportedly jumps to more than $11.5B in second quarter
It is still in their interest to not report "false or misleading statements that you or others on your behalf make regarding your company."

https://www.sec.gov/resources-small-businesses/exempt-offeri...

williamcotton··on Qwen 3.8 27B
Sure. So does this diminish the role of Rembrandt? Or is this some semantic black hole you’re drawing us into?
williamcotton··on Qwen 3.8 27B
There have been plenty of workshops where artists hire assistant painters while maintaining authorship over the works themselves, from Rembrandt to Warhol to Hirst.
williamcotton··on Qwen 3.8 27B
I generally agree and expect this to be the case from a legal perspective.

Legal questions of authorship are going to have to be established in terms of doctrines like SSO [0] and AFC [1]. Currently the incredibly sparse caselaw around this has yet to involve such non-literal notions of copyright.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structure,_sequence_and_organi...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstraction–filtration–compari...

williamcotton··on Choose Boring Technology (2015)
It’s pretty boring at this point.
williamcotton··on Flock updates privacy, accountability, security, and transparency safeguards
Seems like there is some caselaw that supports your theory based on US Supreme Court rulings in Kyllo v. United States (2001) (thermal imaging), United States v. Jones (2012) (GPS tracking) and Carpenter v. United States (2018) (tracking via cell site data).
williamcotton··on Letter to Governor Abbott on responsible AI infrastructure in Texas
I've been to one EA meetup and it wasn't my thing but this seems nothing like the discussions I had. It's where I found out about GiveDirectly.

The biggest issue for me was the AGI/ASI doomerism. But then again, fast-forward five or six years and we've got "unaligned" AI agents blindly following reward functions...

williamcotton··on Mistral Patent for “Code implemented tool calls”
This is markedly better than the USPTO website, FWIW.
williamcotton··on Mistral Patent for "Code implemented tool calls"
> but if it gets past the patent officer that debate happens via lawsuit

Or an Inter Partes Review!

williamcotton··on Denmark Requires Oral Defenses for Students' Written Work to Counter AI Cheating
Are you after learning or an accredited degree?
williamcotton··on U.S. used 'virtually all' of its long-range precision missiles during Iran war
IP at the margin?
williamcotton··on Flint: A Visualization Language for the AI Era
Safari is my default browser and it seems to be working just fine!
williamcotton··on Authorize, don't authenticate
It’s a memorable quote from the movie Kindergarten Cop.
williamcotton··on Flint: A Visualization Language for the AI Era
So a stringly typed JSON-based DSL without a linter or LSP?
williamcotton··on Flint: A Visualization Language for the AI Era
> They even wrote a book about how they went about it (not that it speaks to the quality of the API)

Wilkinson’s Grammar of Graphics inspired ggplot. The textbook doesn’t even mention ggplot.

Shameless plug for my own GoG inspired DSL, Algraf:

https://williamcotton.github.io/algraf/demos

There’s a Minard plot in the demos!

williamcotton··on The lost civic life of movie rental stores
Do you mind sharing which ones?
williamcotton··on AI companies spend record sums on Washington lobbying
Tangentially,

> "Add up all US spending on candidates, PACs, lobbying, think tanks, and advocacy organizations – liberal and conservative combined – and we’re still $2 billion short of what we spend on almonds each year."

https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/09/18/too-much-dark-money-in...

williamcotton··on Measuring developer productivity with the DX Core 4
What about measuring management productivity?
williamcotton··on Launch HN: Bloomy (YC S26) – AI-powered mastery learning for K-12
Article Title: Ed tech is profitable. It is also mostly useless

https://www.economist.com/united-states/2026/01/22/ed-tech-i...

williamcotton··on Show HN: Watch bots interact with an SSH honeypot in real time
So we're getting Rickrolled?
williamcotton··on DSLs Enable Reliable Use of LLMs
I agree. What is missing from the discussion about DSLs are the importance of tooling such as linters, LSPs, etc, to give the LLMs further context.

For example, charts/plots are often stringly typed with regards to column names and a DSL specific to plotting could give immediate feedback to an LLM.

williamcotton··on Control the Ideas, Not the Code
https://williamcotton.github.io/datafarm-studio/

https://williamcotton.github.io/algraf

https://williamcotton.github.io/pdl

https://github.com/williamcotton/algraf

https://github.com/williamcotton/pdl

Check out the /docs dir in the repos for each plan file and the language specs.

They are my 4th and 5th DSLs and I learned quite a bit along the way, most importantly how to separate a WASM runtime wired up to a Monaco editor “lsp” with the same crate for editor-services that works with the actual system binary LSP.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →